kaloric
Well-Known Member
So you consider pet puppies a "failure rate""???
If they fail to meet the breed standard or can't do what they were bred to do as the result of a disease or other fault, I would indeed. If they are up to standard and capable, then it would seem that you may be artificially constraining the gene pool when they could be leveraged through your own breeding program to combat these diseases. Just a thought.
The problem is Vwd affected who are clinical affected. Since I have not breed a single affected puppy in over 10 years I guess I did consider it important enough to take some steps. And please don't generalize and say I don't want to talk about it anymore as I have never leaft a hot topic thread because I wanted to skate on issues. We have had a couple take that approach however but it won't be me.
Progress is progress, and I respect your forthrightness. That's at least some form of accountability. I still am wondering at what point it's not enough to just not breed affected animals, but not breed any positive ones at all. No crystal balls, I know, but past a point, it does seem there should be an absolute goal beyond which no more compromises will be made.
So with your Kira ws the litter DNA tested prior to you getting her or were the parents both clear?
Her parents are purportedly clear, as I recall. As others have unfortunately learned, it's still important to verify to make sure you didn't get a bill of goods. Not that it would particularly even matter if she's a carrier, it's hardly going to derail my plans to not breed her.
That is a big problem M&M - If we had eradicated the Vwd gene immediately and not studied more we could have ended up with exactly what you claim - All dying of soemthing else and then we have shot ourselve s in the foot. Being a Vwd carrier certainly does not make the dog inferior and neither does Vwd affected in any way. Just gives you info to use when making a breeding decision.
Wouldn't it have been tragic had we eliminated it and destroy the breed only to find out that Dobermans have type 1 which is not considered life threatening the vast majority of the time. I was fortunate in that in testing I had several clear by accident to start with so went to clear quckly but when I had the opportuntiy to breed an affected bitch to my clear male and get pick puppy I was thrilled as it took me back to some old bloodlines I consider very valuable.
There is negligible chance of such a catastrophe if folks are making extremely calculated decisions to drop the affected dogs from programs, avoid breeding more by pairing carriers, and then ceasing to breed carriers. That last step is the most important, while it is easy to reduce the incidence of affected animals, having many carriers in circulation will guarantee it will continue to cost everyone who is conscientious about the health of their Dobermans a bit of money and that there will continue to be an unnecessary component in the minefield of diseases.
That carrier bitch is Rayna and I would challenge anyone to claim she is inferior or a failure.
Inferior? Perhaps, when compared to a comparable animal that doesn't carry a genetic defect. Failure? I'd kind of assume she's up-to-standard, otherwise you wouldn't care so much to keep her in your program. If she has proven to be extremely healthy otherwise and her parents/grandparents weren't overly predisposed to serious health issues, especially in the area of cardio health, then yes, I would tend to agree that vWD carrier status is probably not worth worrying about. But it's one of those situations where, if you start with a known defect and then toss in the potential for an unknown predisposition or two, you'd be firmly in "not bettering the breed" territory. Again, I know you don't have a crystal ball, but there are usually better choices than starting out with the odds slightly against you and the betterment of the breed's health.

See ya there.