• Disclaimer: Hello Guest, Doberman Chat Forums presents the opinions and material on these pages as a service to its membership and to the general public but does not endorse those materials, nor does it guarantee the accuracy of any opinions or information contained therein. The opinions expressed in the materials are strictly the opinion of the writer and do not represent the opinion of, nor are they endorsed by, Doberman Chat Forums. Health and medical articles are intended as an aid to those seeking health information and are not intended to replace the informed opinion of a qualified Veterinarian.”

Backyard Breeder vs Reputable Breeder

  • Thread starter Thread starter FredC
  • Start date Start date

Nothing serious and no big deal.. I just had to delete a page of unrelated beer chat.. I feel this thread has good educational merit and should stay that way.. Nothing wrong with a little off topic chit chat here and there but this particular one went way off in to left field and needed to be cleaned up to keep the thread relevant.
----
edit: I suppose anyone is free to start a BYB Beer vs Reputable Beer thread in the off topic forum. ;)

:lmao:
 
First we were talking about dogs not horses and the two are very very different- haivng bred AQHA and APHA horses and campaigned our stallion to Reserve World Champion as a 2 years old winning many jackpot ropings I do know a little of which I speak. But you can't suddenly throw in livestock like horses and cows and compare it to dogs. They are vastly different.

I really see more similarities than differences. Sure, large animals require an amount of basic competence and resources that smaller animals like dogs don't need, but animal husbandry for working animals is really about the same no matter what species you're discussing. The entire point is to apply the principles that humanity has refined over thousands upon thousands of years to take a feral animal and selectively shape it into a new type of specialized creature that can make us faster, stronger, or tougher than we would be by ourselves, and in return for making us better, we offer them affection and resources to make their lives better, too.

I have no problem speaking of the things that did not work out quite like I wanted but I don't take myself outback and beat myself over the head as you imply one should. I use it as a tool to learn from and try to figure out why it did not work like planned. Unlike some who just want to throw around a lot of blame when they have never been down in the trenches and don't know of wht they speak because they are sadly lacking in some very vital information.

I'm pretty sure I didn't say anything like that. What I will say is that, if you make the choice to claim superiority and disparage those who do not adhere to your vision of breed standard, you are sticking your head up and making a target of yourself.

If you can demonstrate that you have a significantly higher success rate along with a lower rate of failure than someone who is not so focused, congratulations, you have clearly earned the cred to say you're improving the breed through your efforts. I believe some breeders are in this place, but a number aren't.

If you have a small percentage of exceptional successes, but that comes at the cost of a higher-than-normal incidence of failure, then there's a real problem worthy of critique. I'm not saying this is the case, of course, just that it's clearly the case with some programs.

I'd compare such a program to a hay supplier I bought from only once. Their good hay was incredible, nice and green, I can give them credit for that. But their bad hay was downright dangerous, some bales were so hot inside after a month that, had I given them a few more weeks, they would've burned my barn down because it was baled with too high of a moisture content. I lost easily 15% of the bales to mold and heavier heating than cattle hay is usually permitted to ferment. They were flirting with disaster, baling right on the edge of curing, and when you get down to it, I really must have hay that's consistently cured safely rather than super hay that has a few bales that are composting or on the verge of combustion.

This is all I'm saying, it seems like some breeders are playing on a razor's edge. Not so much in the Doberman breed as seems to be the case in the GSD breed, and consistent "good" quality beats a program that produces heightened extremes of quality and failure.

So you have no passions or things you truly care about and strive to accomplish in life - truly sad. It may be trying to fly on the wings of wax but at least I try and therefore work to fulfil my job on this earth as a productive, honorable citizen and human being. Too many today suffer from depression or tunr to drugs or alcohol because they have never learned to strive for better things but hope someone will come and take care of them. They have no passion in their lives.

I see what your problem is, you're confusing "passion" with "risk-taking" and "hubris". If I was to choose the sort of breeding program I'd run (or buy from), I'd go more for the lasting legacy than the glory. That's just who I am. People with too much ambition and hubris are prone to being impatient and taking stupid risks that not only have a chance of resulting in failure, but are prone to catastrophic failures.

Quite honestly, the people who truly "better the breed" are the ones who build the foundation with good, solid stock, not the ones trying to build the highest tower on that foundation.
 
I am not confusing anything with anything else. This is about doberman breeders, not hores not hay and not any other thing. the horse industury is far far different from dog breeding. While both have standards and there is certainly the same genetic rules that apply you can't compare then as the similarity stops right there.

I'm pretty sure I didn't say anything like that. What I will say is that, if you make the choice to claim superiority and disparage those who do not adhere to your vision of breed standard, you are sticking your head up and making a target of yourself.

When one deviates from THE standard they are wrong. What you don't understand about Vwd is it is not the big scare everyone claims. There is absolutely nothing wrong with breeding carriers or affecteds as long as they are bred to clears. The gene pool remains too small to make a drastic leap. Even Vet Gen has mde this statement. Dobermans have the type ! which is not a severe type of Vwd. But as science often does to generate dollars for more research they put out the big bad scare and freaked everyone out to make everyone seem bad if they did not DNA test their dogs. The biggest problem with all this mass genocide people promote to eliminate even a single bad gene could bring us to the brink of extinction and then with no place to go.
 
I am not confusing anything with anything else. This is about doberman breeders, not hores not hay and not any other thing. the horse industury is far far different from dog breeding. While both have standards and there is certainly the same genetic rules that apply you can't compare then as the similarity stops right there.



When one deviates from THE standard they are wrong. What you don't understand about Vwd is it is not the big scare everyone claims. There is absolutely nothing wrong with breeding carriers or affecteds as long as they are bred to clears. The gene pool remains too small to make a drastic leap. Even Vet Gen has mde this statement. Dobermans have the type ! which is not a severe type of Vwd. But as science often does to generate dollars for more research they put out the big bad scare and freaked everyone out to make everyone seem bad if they did not DNA test their dogs. The biggest problem with all this mass genocide people promote to eliminate even a single bad gene could bring us to the brink of extinction and then with no place to go.
very well said! There is no health concerns with a Doberman that is a carrier of VW! There are so many more health concerns that need attention in this breed. Dilated Cardiomyopathy is at the top of my list. We have a small gene pool in Dobermans and with knowledge and health testing we might be able to improve the overall health of this breed.
 
I am not confusing anything with anything else. This is about doberman breeders, not hores not hay and not any other thing. the horse industury is far far different from dog breeding. While both have standards and there is certainly the same genetic rules that apply you can't compare then as the similarity stops right there.

And this attitude is why folks with a real understanding of animal husbandry tend to hold dog breeders and color-horse breeders in contempt. You just don't think the rules apply to you.

So could you please explain how "dog breeding" is different than "horse breeding" or "cattle breeding" or "haying"?

Is it because you don't think you have to have a rate of to-standard breeding that approaches 100%, because you can pawn your failures to meet standard off on well-meaning families as "pet grade"? Yeah, there's a very similar mentality in the color-horse breeds, too. So what if that pretty Paint or Appy has godawful conformation or is developing moonblindness? Someone will still pay thousands to put 'em in the backyard and ride 'em on weekends, they won't even notice the serious faults because of all that CHROME! :rolleyes:

Or is dog breeding different because dogs rarely do meaningful "real world" work, they only practice choreographed maneuvers under controlled circumstances, whereas titles mean very little in other livestock that are always expected to live-up to breed standards? That's also a terrible attitude to differentiate based on. The breed standard is a means to an end, not an end in and of itself. If "reputable kennels" are approaching animal husbandry in this manner, then it explains a lot about why so many AKC breeds are so faulty in health matters. If breeders are not looking past the standard to understand what it means, it amounts to focusing on the letter of the law but ignoring the spirit of it.

Or is dog breeding different because breeders don't do an appreciable amount of "eating their own (proverbial) dog food", but instead breed to sell in excess of 90% of the animals they produce? Yes, most places that breed livestock keep a lot more animals for themselves to build out their herds and have those animals working for them, just as they keep a good bit of the hay they produce to feed their own animals. I'd agree that it would be pretty impractical to maintain a large herd of closely-related dogs. However, if one of their typical puppies is not what a "reputable breeder" would consider suitable for the basic things they would do with the pick-of-the-litter, it's substandard and that breeder is not doing things correctly.

The culture I've been involved with takes compliance with the functional requirements that underlie the breed standards a whole lot more seriously. A plain brown horse that can't do what it was bred to do as a result of faults is more likely than not to have a terrible and hard life, passed-around through auctions to the lowest-end buyers like dude ranches, until it gets dumped in a pasture somewhere to fend for itself or sent to slaughter. When there is not much of a "pet grade" market to fall back on, where a failure means that the breeder is going to lose money & valuable time, where that failure has serious repercussions for the animal's well-being, where you're breeding to make your own herd larger, achieving consistent success is an absolute must.

When one deviates from THE standard they are wrong. What you don't understand about Vwd is it is not the big scare everyone claims. There is absolutely nothing wrong with breeding carriers or affecteds as long as they are bred to clears. The gene pool remains too small to make a drastic leap. Even Vet Gen has mde this statement. Dobermans have the type ! which is not a severe type of Vwd. But as science often does to generate dollars for more research they put out the big bad scare and freaked everyone out to make everyone seem bad if they did not DNA test their dogs. The biggest problem with all this mass genocide people promote to eliminate even a single bad gene could bring us to the brink of extinction and then with no place to go.

What you don't understand is that I KNOW vWD isn't terribly critical, but it's just one of those things...one of those little things that sometimes rears its ugly head. Dismissing a condition like this as being trivial unimportant is doing the breed a disservice. Being at the point where you're advertising the lack of a list of diseases, rather than advertising the good traits, is a sad, sad place to be.

It doesn't require massive culls or removing every carrier of a condition from the gene pool overnight. It does require that breeders stop this apathetic attitude towards "trivial" health issues, where genetic faults are just accepted rather than having folks striving to eradicate them. Something like vWD could be all-but eradicated over the course of a decade or two if reputable breeders focused on a small, incremental goal of reducing the incidence of it by setting personal goals rather than passing the buck. Then it would be one fewer thing to worry about or need to test for.

Kudos to those who don't breed carriers as I seem to recall you do, D4E. But even for those who do breed carriers, if they handle the puppy sales properly, it's not going to diminish the gene pool appreciably. Test all the puppies if a parent is a carrier, the additional cost shouldn't be a problem if the carrier parent is just so incredible & perfect that the good traits outweigh the faulty allele. If the carrier isn't awesome otherwise, why the heck would anyone breed it? There's no excuse for such incompetence.

On to evaluating the puppies, those with carrier status would have to be perfect otherwise to be considered breeding quality. Any fault or other lack of being absolutely outstanding in a carrier? Pet grade, limited-registration, no-breed/spay/neuter contract. Let the best of the non-carriers be considered breeding/show stock as long as they are still fully-compliant with the breed standard. That's the area where I absolutely support adherence to breed standard & the proper use of limited registration that wouldn't be left up to the buyer's discretion.

Even something like a reversible-limited registration at registry level, which would require all breeding stock be tested, all the progeny of carriers to either be tested or having mandatory limited registration imposed until such testing was done. Tested carriers could only have the limited registration reversed if they had some compelling reason to be considered as breeding stock, probably being highly distinguished in competition. This is competent, bloodless culling of animals that are diseased and have defects. It doesn't require any killing, only not breeding carriers unless there's a really good reason that balances out perpetuating the condition.

This is an attainable goal with negligible fallout. How is this practice somehow not something that should be done? Similar approaches (albeit more bloody) have been used in animal husbandry for thousands of years, long before breed registry pedigrees, hobby competition, genetic testing, or Gregor Mendel's research into inheritance conclusively explained why these techniques work. Since there is a market for pets, it's that much easier to fix the faults in a kinder, gentler approach as I described above. Dogs are not an exception, not by a longshot. Early-onset DCM would be a bit more difficult to breed-out, but it's also entirely possible to do so through the time-tested methods that have worked on every other species, and even the more ancient breeds of dogs. These health debacles are really a rather modern problem because people didn't tolerate this sort of foolishness when dogs had jobs that they were expected to do just like other livestock.
 
And this attitude is why folks with a real understanding of animal husbandry tend to hold dog breeders and color-horse breeders in contempt. You just don't think the rules apply to you.

Honeslty this is way too far out for normal comprhension. Dog breeding is considered very different because the our dogs are considered man's best friend and we have a far more intimate relationship living inside with them. We frown on "dog auctions" while some of the highest auctions in te country are for example the Keenland horse sale. Dog people (good dog breeders) would never put their dogs in an autcion.

You have contracts with dogs and usually you don't with horses, cattle or hay unless it is a contract to deliever XXX.

The principles of the actual breeding and genetics are the same but from there it goes an entirely different direction. with the exception horses are bred right back and kept in foal while dogs rest a year.

We test for Vwd so we know what we are breeding and it is very easy to breed now without producing any affected dogs. But in the betinning that was not so. I iwll say this as it is much like the Impressive gene - that gen while it produces a big problem also produces some of the best muscled for showing gentics out there. Does that mean we should continue to breed for it NO but that is a known fact among horse people.

So as horse breeders they try to find a way to keep the go while eliminating the bad which you seem to think can just be thrown out the window on a whim.

Of course I would breed a carrier or affected as long as it was bred to a clear if the pedigree carried something I really wanted to keep. In fact I did one such breeding 3 years ago and keep a carrier puppy that will be bred to a clear to get back to clear. Do you think if a bloodline is really strong it would be smart to just throw it out because you have to start with affected but know you can get to clear withing 2 generations???? Depth of a breeding program is very important and Vwd is important but not a ruling factor when we have a proven way to avoid producing affecteds.

Just because something looks good on paper or in a test tube does not mean it always works out the way you think not if you have a true understanding of genetics and throwbacks to something way back in a pedigree.
 
Honeslty this is way too far out for normal comprhension. Dog breeding is considered very different because the our dogs are considered man's best friend and we have a far more intimate relationship living inside with them. We frown on "dog auctions" while some of the highest auctions in te country are for example the Keenland horse sale. Dog people (good dog breeders) would never put their dogs in an autcion.

You have contracts with dogs and usually you don't with horses, cattle or hay unless it is a contract to deliever XXX.

The principles of the actual breeding and genetics are the same but from there it goes an entirely different direction. with the exception horses are bred right back and kept in foal while dogs rest a year.

We test for Vwd so we know what we are breeding and it is very easy to breed now without producing any affected dogs. But in the betinning that was not so. I iwll say this as it is much like the Impressive gene - that gen while it produces a big problem also produces some of the best muscled for showing gentics out there. Does that mean we should continue to breed for it NO but that is a known fact among horse people.

So as horse breeders they try to find a way to keep the go while eliminating the bad which you seem to think can just be thrown out the window on a whim.

Of course I would breed a carrier or affected as long as it was bred to a clear if the pedigree carried something I really wanted to keep. In fact I did one such breeding 3 years ago and keep a carrier puppy that will be bred to a clear to get back to clear. Do you think if a bloodline is really strong it would be smart to just throw it out because you have to start with affected but know you can get to clear withing 2 generations???? Depth of a breeding program is very important and Vwd is important but not a ruling factor when we have a proven way to avoid producing affecteds.

Just because something looks good on paper or in a test tube does not mean it always works out the way you think not if you have a true understanding of genetics and throwbacks to something way back in a pedigree.

I remember Impressive very well. Impressive was what Michael Angelo's dream horse would be in looks . As I recall he couldn't scatter his own scats, but his semen was worth thousands. No offense meant, but I always considered Halter Class as a woman's thing and we in the cutting and cattle business never wanted chrome at work, but in the arena was a different matter. Chrome, color and good halter conformation were selling points, but they did not contribute to the cutting ability of the horse. For dogs too, give me the working ability over looks any day.
 
Honeslty this is way too far out for normal comprhension. Dog breeding is considered very different because the our dogs are considered man's best friend and we have a far more intimate relationship living inside with them. We frown on "dog auctions" while some of the highest auctions in te country are for example the Keenland horse sale. Dog people (good dog breeders) would never put their dogs in an autcion.

I would beg to differ, humans have every bit the enchanted relationship with horses as with dogs. The primary difference is just that owning a horse is out of reach for most folks, but most folks who want to can have a dog. While some of the quality youngsters and breeding stock do well in auction, the thought that older and lame horses might wind-up in auctions, being sold by the pound for their flesh, is horrifying to Americans. Seems we're more concerned with the fate of unwanted horses than unwanted pets.

But my point is still that the goals and techniques should be the same. Just because the consequences don't seem as heavy doesn't mean that it's a pass to slack-off and be sloppy.

You have contracts with dogs and usually you don't with horses, cattle or hay unless it is a contract to deliever XXX.

And why is that?

Again, this is my point. You shouldn't need a health contract that essentially protects a buyer from the breeder's incompetence, which is just assumed with purebred dogs. Producing animals that are diseased, not completely capable of meeting breed standards, or to be able to do the work they were engineered to do should be the extremely rare exceptions.

As for breeding-related contracts, that's more a matter of the assumed lack of competence in purchasers, which is somewhat appropriate, but another matter altogether.

The principles of the actual breeding and genetics are the same but from there it goes an entirely different direction. with the exception horses are bred right back and kept in foal while dogs rest a year.

Best practices based on purely physiological difference aren't really part of the issue...

We test for Vwd so we know what we are breeding and it is very easy to breed now without producing any affected dogs. But in the betinning that was not so. I iwll say this as it is much like the Impressive gene - that gen while it produces a big problem also produces some of the best muscled for showing gentics out there. Does that mean we should continue to breed for it NO but that is a known fact among horse people.

So as horse breeders they try to find a way to keep the go while eliminating the bad which you seem to think can just be thrown out the window on a whim.

Form over function... Color-horse breeders, halter show breeders, dog breeders, all are typically cut from the same cloth. It takes some sort of willful and stubborn ineptitude to think that way. That's why you see all the worst diseases in those animals.

What good is muscle when it can't be exercised to a good lather without the horse collapsing from non-cerebral seizures? There is no good whatsoever in that, and I don't think I'm alone in thinking what halter horses were looking like by the 90s were pretty hideous...extreme bodybuilder types of hideous. There's having a nice, ripped physique, and then there's grotesque hypertrophy. That's a matter of personal opinion though. The reason Impressive's genes were so popular was because of the sheer laziness in the halter show crowd, who wanted huge muscles in their horses without having to put in the work to build them. It's essentially juicing-by-proxy.

Even in the best quality performance horses, you don't see the sort of absurd linebreeding that you see the halter showing idiots performing. Three Bars himself appeared in Impressive's pedigree no fewer than 3 times, in that one of his grand-daughters (who also one of his great-grand-daughters) was bred to one of his sons to produce Impressive. Good Lord, I've seen worse inbreeding in a pedigree, but I can't remember when, probably in a Dobe pedigree that I rejected. And just think of all the subsequent halter pedigrees in which Impressive himself appeared over and over and over such that homozygous descendants for his one defective gene were dropping dead frequently enough that people noticed a correlation. Should it come as any surprise that halter horses, even in a plain breed like AQHA, would turn out to be a disease-infested genetic cesspool in an otherwise exceptionally healthy breed?

I say this as someone who has horses from popular performance lines. IMHO, there has never been a finer Quarter Horse than Leo. Three Bars was super fine too, as were many of his descendants. Then you have your Moons, Larks, and Jets as well. All of my horses have had pedigrees filled with these names, some have up to two different "Bars" descendants in the third rows of their pedigrees, usually on opposite sides, and that's all the more inbreeding they've had-- the closest the same name might be appearing would be 5 or 6 generations back and not on the same side of the tree. Competent breeders know that it takes a bit more effort to locate non-closely-related breeding stock that will further a specific goal, but they do the work and try their best, knowing that even if they don't get what they wanted, at least what they do get is still going to be good. Lazy, amateur breeders go for breeding close relatives to get fast and easy results, with all the predictable failures and complete disasters that come with doing so, but they rationalize the latter all away.

Of course I would breed a carrier or affected as long as it was bred to a clear if the pedigree carried something I really wanted to keep. In fact I did one such breeding 3 years ago and keep a carrier puppy that will be bred to a clear to get back to clear. Do you think if a bloodline is really strong it would be smart to just throw it out because you have to start with affected but know you can get to clear withing 2 generations???? Depth of a breeding program is very important and Vwd is important but not a ruling factor when we have a proven way to avoid producing affecteds.

So, you are planning only one breeding, and your plans are to test every puppy to make sure that carriers without any other redeeming qualities were genetic dead-ends? If so, that's a more-or-less right way of doing it, but if you're not clear after two generations, then what? More rationalizations? If not only one breeding, how many carriers are you willing to produce, and will they all be screened and prevented from propagating the defect, or will you keep making exceptions and selling carriers as breeding/show stock if they're good enough, because hey, as long as you breed them to clear, it's all okay?

Most dog breeders apparently wouldn't care to make sure the defect didn't leave their program to continue to propagate, which is why there are still z-factors floating around. It's also why HyPP will be lingering around in AQHA halter show pedigrees for decades to come, too.

Personally, yes. I would likely throw out a line based on a defect unless I was being overly sentimental, and even then, I would only keep it if I was absolutely certain I could make the defect go away and not propagate it at all. There are too many better choices out there to be so caught-up in the notion that an unproven youngster who's a carrier of a genetic disease is important enough to be considered future breeding stock. Poor choices almost always beget more regrettable choices.

Just because something looks good on paper or in a test tube does not mean it always works out the way you think not if you have a true understanding of genetics and throwbacks to something way back in a pedigree.

I really don't know if you're just caught-up in magical thinking, but it's obvious from the state of most dog breeds that you're not alone in it. There's a world of difference between an unfortunate genetic fluke, and just recklessly flailing about and causing calamities in a gene cesspool. As someone with the more conventional understanding of how animal husbandry is done, looking at the state of dog breeds, the way breeders generally do things, and all the problems they struggle with, it's kind of like watching someone who is thoroughly incompetent making repeated mistakes and then blaming chance for the predictable failure. No, the genetic disasters in the Doberman are not flukes, they're just due to egregious incompetence on the part of thousands of breeders over the course of a century. It's not going to get any better unless Doberman breeders start taking animal husbandry seriously & behave like professionals.
 
I'm not going to elaborate on all off your topics but I would like to address the VW. Yes as Doberman breeders we will breed a carrier to a clear
 
I'm going to elaborate on one of several topics you have brought up in this last thread Breeders will breed carriers to clears and affected to clears. What would you have us do? Stop breeding, let the BYB just have litter after litter with no clue to genetics or the future of their cash cow puppies? I will be breeding a carrier to a clear and I stand tall doing that! I know that the puppies that are carriers will be co owned with me if they are show prospect and they will breed to clear or carriers. This genetic disease is not going away tomorrow and certainly not with BYB just sticking two dogs together and multiplying the gene pool. It's not a failure if there are carrier puppies, some of these puppies will go to pet homes and be spayed and nurtured. And OMG it's not a big deal now!! One of the easiest genictic faults to deal with so let's talk about Dilated Cardiomyopathy. Let's talk about Wobblers, cancer, liver problems, thyroid, eyes, hips. FORGET ABOUT VW DIEASE!
I'll use my personal experience experience looking for a sire. Juno is a carrier and red, wanna look for a clear black male, then wanna know if his echo and 24 holter matchs Junos tests. Then need to know about his liver results, thyroid and eye tests. Then I have to look at his pedigree to see if both pedigrees fit, not too closely line breed, looking at all the dogs in the pedigree as i want to know how they died. Then I want to look at the conformation of this male and see if it's a match. DO YOU HAVE ANY IDEA HOW SMALL MY CHOICE IS after I have considered all health tests, contacted the sires breeder then decided if we can work together. After about ten thousand dollars, showing and health testing then I choose the stud dog. Then the money comes out with progesterone testing artificial insemination, having Semen shipped and sent over the border. The monetary steps don't stop. I'm not going to ramble but OMG lay off the VW and breeders breeding carriers.
 
I would beg to differ, humans have every bit the enchanted relationship with horses as with dogs. The primary difference is just that owning a horse is out of reach for most folks, but most folks who want to can have a dog. While some of the quality youngsters and breeding stock do well in auction, the thought that older and lame horses might wind-up in auctions, being sold by the pound for their flesh, is horrifying to Americans. Seems we're more concerned with the fate of unwanted horses than unwanted pets.

But my point is still that the goals and techniques should be the same. Just because the consequences don't seem as heavy doesn't mean that it's a pass to slack-off and be sloppy.



And why is that?

Again, this is my point. You shouldn't need a health contract that essentially protects a buyer from the breeder's incompetence, which is just assumed with purebred dogs. Producing animals that are diseased, not completely capable of meeting breed standards, or to be able to do the work they were engineered to do should be the extremely rare exceptions.

As for breeding-related contracts, that's more a matter of the assumed lack of competence in purchasers, which is somewhat appropriate, but another matter altogether.



Best practices based on purely physiological difference aren't really part of the issue...



Form over function... Color-horse breeders, halter show breeders, dog breeders, all are typically cut from the same cloth. It takes some sort of willful and stubborn ineptitude to think that way. That's why you see all the worst diseases in those animals.

What good is muscle when it can't be exercised to a good lather without the horse collapsing from non-cerebral seizures? There is no good whatsoever in that, and I don't think I'm alone in thinking what halter horses were looking like by the 90s were pretty hideous...extreme bodybuilder types of hideous. There's having a nice, ripped physique, and then there's grotesque hypertrophy. That's a matter of personal opinion though. The reason Impressive's genes were so popular was because of the sheer laziness in the halter show crowd, who wanted huge muscles in their horses without having to put in the work to build them. It's essentially juicing-by-proxy.

Even in the best quality performance horses, you don't see the sort of absurd linebreeding that you see the halter showing idiots performing. Three Bars himself appeared in Impressive's pedigree no fewer than 3 times, in that one of his grand-daughters (who also one of his great-grand-daughters) was bred to one of his sons to produce Impressive. Good Lord, I've seen worse inbreeding in a pedigree, but I can't remember when, probably in a Dobe pedigree that I rejected. And just think of all the subsequent halter pedigrees in which Impressive himself appeared over and over and over such that homozygous descendants for his one defective gene were dropping dead frequently enough that people noticed a correlation. Should it come as any surprise that halter horses, even in a plain breed like AQHA, would turn out to be a disease-infested genetic cesspool in an otherwise exceptionally healthy breed?

I say this as someone who has horses from popular performance lines. IMHO, there has never been a finer Quarter Horse than Leo. Three Bars was super fine too, as were many of his descendants. Then you have your Moons, Larks, and Jets as well. All of my horses have had pedigrees filled with these names, some have up to two different "Bars" descendants in the third rows of their pedigrees, usually on opposite sides, and that's all the more inbreeding they've had-- the closest the same name might be appearing would be 5 or 6 generations back and not on the same side of the tree. Competent breeders know that it takes a bit more effort to locate non-closely-related breeding stock that will further a specific goal, but they do the work and try their best, knowing that even if they don't get what they wanted, at least what they do get is still going to be good. Lazy, amateur breeders go for breeding close relatives to get fast and easy results, with all the predictable failures and complete disasters that come with doing so, but they rationalize the latter all away.



So, you are planning only one breeding, and your plans are to test every puppy to make sure that carriers without any other redeeming qualities were genetic dead-ends? If so, that's a more-or-less right way of doing it, but if you're not clear after two generations, then what? More rationalizations? If not only one breeding, how many carriers are you willing to produce, and will they all be screened and prevented from propagating the defect, or will you keep making exceptions and selling carriers as breeding/show stock if they're good enough, because hey, as long as you breed them to clear, it's all okay?

Most dog breeders apparently wouldn't care to make sure the defect didn't leave their program to continue to propagate, which is why there are still z-factors floating around. It's also why HyPP will be lingering around in AQHA halter show pedigrees for decades to come, too.

Personally, yes. I would likely throw out a line based on a defect unless I was being overly sentimental, and even then, I would only keep it if I was absolutely certain I could make the defect go away and not propagate it at all. There are too many better choices out there to be so caught-up in the notion that an unproven youngster who's a carrier of a genetic disease is important enough to be considered future breeding stock. Poor choices almost always beget more regrettable choices.



I really don't know if you're just caught-up in magical thinking, but it's obvious from the state of most dog breeds that you're not alone in it. There's a world of difference between an unfortunate genetic fluke, and just recklessly flailing about and causing calamities in a gene cesspool. As someone with the more conventional understanding of how animal husbandry is done, looking at the state of dog breeds, the way breeders generally do things, and all the problems they struggle with, it's kind of like watching someone who is thoroughly incompetent making repeated mistakes and then blaming chance for the predictable failure. No, the genetic disasters in the Doberman are not flukes, they're just due to egregious incompetence on the part of thousands of breeders over the course of a century. It's not going to get any better unless Doberman breeders start taking animal husbandry seriously & behave like professionals.
How many Dobermans have you had in your life time and what were there VW results from Vet gen?? What other health testings has been done on them? You seem to be very anti breeder but you must of got at least one Doberman to be as spoken as you are in this forum. I would love to know what health tests results you have on your dog or dogs you have had
 
Michele = we need to put him in charge of breeding and all animals would go extinct faster than even PETA and HSUS plan.

So, you are planning only one breeding, and your plans are to test every puppy to make sure that carriers without any other redeeming qualities were genetic dead-ends? If so, that's a more-or-less right way of doing it, but if you're not clear after two generations, then what?

It is obvious some just don't get it. Question for the great one - Why would you test every puppy if only two meet all other requirements for show quality why would you test the pet puppies and for what reason???? They would be either clear or carrier and going on limited reg so breeding would not be a concern.
 
I'm going to elaborate on one of several topics you have brought up in this last thread Breeders will breed carriers to clears and affected to clears. What would you have us do? Stop breeding, let the BYB just have litter after litter with no clue to genetics or the future of their cash cow puppies? I will be breeding a carrier to a clear and I stand tall doing that! I know that the puppies that are carriers will be co owned with me if they are show prospect and they will breed to clear or carriers. This genetic disease is not going away tomorrow and certainly not with BYB just sticking two dogs together and multiplying the gene pool. It's not a failure if there are carrier puppies, some of these puppies will go to pet homes and be spayed and nurtured. And OMG it's not a big deal now!!

The disease certainly won't go away tomorrow with a couple of self-proclaimed "reputable breeders" sticking two dogs together, one of which they know carries the defect, either. Just saying.

One of the easiest genictic faults to deal with so let's talk about Dilated Cardiomyopathy. Let's talk about Wobblers, cancer, liver problems, thyroid, eyes, hips.

Clearly, you haven't made any meaningful progress against vWD, one of, in your own words, "the easiest genetic faults to deal with", as there are still so many carriers floating around and both you and D4E are breeding carriers. Why should anyone trust you to be able to even begin to tackle one of the major diseases? I wouldn't. I only bring it up because it is such a classic textbook example of a genetic defect that is easy to deal with. But of course you and D4E are trivializing the defect, rationalizing, and don't want to talk about it anymore, because you're both contributing to the problem.

However, if you have evidence that your research into pedigrees and health-testing has achieved improvement against a major disease, I'd like to hear about those results.

I'll use my personal experience experience looking for a sire. Juno is a carrier and red, wanna look for a clear black male, then wanna know if his echo and 24 holter matchs Junos tests. Then need to know about his liver results, thyroid and eye tests. Then I have to look at his pedigree to see if both pedigrees fit, not too closely line breed, looking at all the dogs in the pedigree as i want to know how they died. Then I want to look at the conformation of this male and see if it's a match. DO YOU HAVE ANY IDEA HOW SMALL MY CHOICE IS after I have considered all health tests, contacted the sires breeder then decided if we can work together. After about ten thousand dollars, showing and health testing then I choose the stud dog. Then the money comes out with progesterone testing artificial insemination, having Semen shipped and sent over the border. The monetary steps don't stop. I'm not going to ramble but OMG lay off the VW and breeders breeding carriers.

I really don't have much sympathy over all the efforts you'll have to go through because you have painted yourself into a difficult corner by choosing to breed a carrier. That is a problem of your own making. I will reiterate my statement that there are clearly better choices than breeding known or suspected carriers of any genetic defect.

Imagine a day when you don't have to be sad about how small your choice of sires is, because you don't have to worry about vWD prevalence decimating the range of semi-responsible choices you could make. I believe something around 70% of the population are carriers? If you all want to join the big leagues and enjoy a robust registry that isn't infested with diseases, you're going to have to play like the big leagues, which starts by taking a bite out of what you can, not kicking the can down the road.

It is obvious some just don't get it. Question for the great one - Why would you test every puppy if only two meet all other requirements for show quality why would you test the pet puppies and for what reason???? They would be either clear or carrier and going on limited reg so breeding would not be a concern.

There would obviously be no need to test "pet grade" animals, I must've forgotten momentarily that you're dealing with such a high failure rate that you would only have to test a couple out of each litter that live up to expectations such as conforming to competition quality & breed standards.

Nah, you folks don't need my "help" wrecking the breed, the collective efforts of apparently nearly every breeder, BYB or otherwise, are getting there just fine on your own. I'm no expert, I just have a pretty good idea of how things are done. I would suggest you try to play like the professionals who don't have disease-infested registries, follow their practices. They clearly are doing a far superior job bettering their breeds, something which Doberman breeders are failing miserably at.

Anyway, this thread has been far more enlightening than I could've ever hoped, considering I just chimed-in to speak to the reasons I had for choosing a rural, non-showing breeder. If I ever had doubts over how I sourced my puppy a year ago, they're pretty much gone at this point. But as always, I'm going to be constantly evaluating my outcome with Kira and keeping an eye on any new developments in disease or attitude when it comes to making the choice to bring another Dobe into my life, which will hopefully be pretty far down the road.
 
I must've forgotten momentarily that you're dealing with such a high failure rate that you would only have to test a couple out of each litter that live up to expectations such as conforming to competition quality & breed standards.

So you consider pet puppies a "failure rate""???

But of course you and D4E are trivializing the defect, rationalizing, and don't want to talk about it anymore, because you're both contributing to the problem.

The problem is Vwd affected who are clinical affected. Since I have not breed a single affected puppy in over 10 years I guess I did consider it important enough to take some steps. And please don't generalize and say I don't want to talk about it anymore as I have never leaft a hot topic thread because I wanted to skate on issues. We have had a couple take that approach however but it won't be me.

So with your Kira ws the litter DNA tested prior to you getting her or were the parents both clear?
 
Another note, so let's breed only Vw clear dogs and forget about DCM and every other health issue. So now we have clear Dobermans but they are dropping dead everywhere! Let's breed two clear VW dogs together but both of them have cardio problems?? Ignorance is bliss


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk
 
I understand what Vwd is and why it is a concern. Is it a cross over from human to dog or the other way around?
 
That is a big problem M&M - If we had eradicated the Vwd gene immediately and not studied more we could have ended up with exactly what you claim - All dying of soemthing else and then we have shot ourselve s in the foot. Being a Vwd carrier certainly does not make the dog inferior and neither does Vwd affected in any way. Just gives you info to use when making a breeding decision.

Wouldn't it have been tragic had we eliminated it and destroy the breed only to find out that Dobermans have type 1 which is not considered life threatening the vast majority of the time. I was fortunate in that in testing I had several clear by accident to start with so went to clear quckly but when I had the opportuntiy to breed an affected bitch to my clear male and get pick puppy I was thrilled as it took me back to some old bloodlines I consider very valuable.

That carrier bitch is Rayna and I would challenge anyone to claim she is inferior or a failure. So I am interested to see if he has a clear bitch or if the parents were even tested. It will be interesting to see how open and up front one is.

We certainly cant throw out excellent genes to avoid Vwd now PDK4 ????? who knows yet. We are still waiting to see exactly how it plays out but we have another tool in our arsenal.
 
It is a different from dogs as they have not been crossed with humans - Most of the diseasesdogs have are similar to humans but not identical. But we use them to study and make iprovements for humans through research.

There are some illnesses that humans can catch from dogs but only one way to share DNA problems.
 

Back
Top