Breeders now had a tool to assist them. They did not stop with their passion and study to always strive to improve on what they had. You are so blinded by your misinformation that you could not see ground zero if it jumped up and bit you.
A tool. That's precisely what a pedigree is, nothing less, nothing more. It is not the be-all, end-all that so many hacks have made it. Or would you care to dispute the point I'm making, that the ignorant BYBs and commercial breeders that make up the overwhelming majority of any purebred dog on the market these days, whether advertised in the newspaper or available in a pet shop, are using the fact that a dog has registration papers to make something of that animal which simply isn't there, wasn't there in its parents, and they should frankly be ashamed of themselves? Or, how about that buyers get burned because they see "AKC Reg." and wind-up with a pup that might be a completely unworthy representative of the breed in nearly every respect, and they thought that line in the advertisement had overwhelming significance?
I will definitely grant that "DPCA" means quite a bit more because there's at least a little peer-review and they focus a lot more on spreading the knowledge.
It used to be that one could pick up a copy of any big-city newspaper, flip to the "dogs" section of the classifieds, and easily find 80-100 listings for various "AKC Reg. _insert_breed-here_" dogs. This is part of the chaos that registries help to create when the existence of a studbook is confused with being more important than knowledge and evaluation of the animal you see right in front of you.
I would compare the way a lot of people throw around the importance of registration as being a lot like the people who drive into fields or canals because they were mindlessly obeying the GPS device rather than paying attention to where they're actually going.
Today the registry gives people a convenient way to research our Dobermans for show lines, working lines etc
A tool. And as Ataro noted, also a great way to research health testing that's been done, it empowers people if they care to be knowledgeable. For those who don't want to do their homework, the registry only serves to provide an illusion of quality when there is no substance to be found.
Registration is not a crutch and is exactly why we have shows, trails etc to compete and test our stock.
It most definitely is a crutch for those who might as well be selling mutts for all they know or care about selective breeding. When a breeder's primary motivation is money, and they know that including the "AKC Reg." text in the listing means a few hundred $$$ as opposed to practically giving away unremarkable puppies in front of Wal*Mart, there's no other way to describe it. It's a situation where perhaps everyone either needs to be MUCH better at communicating that "having papers doesn't mean you're getting a good example of the breed, do the rest of your homework", or the registries need to clamp-down and curtail the free-for-all, making breeders and their breeding stock have to work just a little to qualify for studbook eligibility.
I don't believe that registries are completely useless in that they can hold important information about the parents' health, working or conformation titles and so on. But I do think that they should be more discriminating in practice. For example, in order to register a litter of Dobermanns in Europe, depending on the country the parents must have passed temperament tests, have received three grades of excellent in shows (or a number of CACs), and a breed warden comes to inspect the puppies at the age of 7 weeks to make sure they really are what the breeder claims, and to make the registrations invalid for breeding of any puppy with obvious disqualifying faults like improper markings (white chest, lack of tan marking etc.). If that were the case with the AKC, the albino gene would not still be floating around among registered Dobes.
While D4E also has a great point that it doesn't sound like the system is working quite as intended in Germany from your observations there, this is along the lines of what I'm getting at, and it's certainly better than the "all of absolutely nothing" that the AKC does to screen breeding stock and breeders. Their most heroic effort seems to be to simply flag z-factor animals with cryptic reg numbers that mean nothing to people who are not in-the-know (do they even have explanation or disclosure on "what z means" on the certificate?), when they should be banned outright. They could do even more, like imposing limited registrations on homozygous affected animals for known genetic defects or less-than-good hips, but they won't do that, either.
Folks, it's not at all that I don't like purebreds or pedigrees. But I also am hard-pressed to give too much of a crap about them. While all of my animals (except for the little grey cat) are purebreds with registrations, I looked over the animals themselves, looked over their parents when possible, and for all I care, I could've tossed their papers in the file cabinet without even reading them. The registration was little more than something to get me in the ballpark of what I was looking for. I would be extremely hard-pressed to ever buy an animal sight-unseen, or seen only through photos on the Internet.
When I picked-out Kira from the choice of female pups I had before me, I made that choice based on things that I never would've seen in a photo, such as how she reacted and behaved. Honestly, I probably would've chosen one of the others had I been going by photos alone, her markings are not as light and crisp as the others had. Even as a puppy, she had a tenacious, bold temperament, not shy or anxious in the least. The others gave me a little pause because they did seem more anxious, which isn't too surprising considering they were not in their comfort zone, but isn't a huge part of this breed being able to assess an unfamiliar challenge head-on without backing-down or even flinching? There is absolutely no substitute for knowing what you're looking for and having the opportunity to choose it. If I could've found another perfect opportunity that consisted of a completely unpapered Doberman who looked like a Doberman, moved like a Doberman, and behaved like a Doberman, just like the variety of Doberman you usually find in shelters and rescues, I would've gone that route too. My requirements and distaste for dealing with controlling people & organizations caused me to look to a breeder instead.