What is Registration and What Registery is best?

Putting the whole question of whether a national registry like the ANKC or the VDH etc. is good or not aside, what I would like to know is why is it so damn easy for all of these unofficial registries to pop up? I don't think such things exist in Australia or Mexico, at least not from what I have seen or heard but I have recently discovered that they do, in fact, also exist in Germany.
 
Putting the whole question of whether a national registry like the ANKC or the VDH etc. is good or not aside, what I would like to know is why is it so damn easy for all of these unofficial registries to pop up? I don't think such things exist in Australia or Mexico, at least not from what I have seen or heard but I have recently discovered that they do, in fact, also exist in Germany.
Its a business that generates revenue.. Making it more difficult to do would probably come with unexpected consequences.. Its up the us as individuals to gives those registries credibility or not. If a new registry popped up tomorrow they would have to have a solid foundation and something fresh and exciting to offer b4 people buy into these things.. CKC (Continental) is in essence a total fraud in many regards but it didnt have to be that way if they had offered up something better and legitimate.. Its hard to take a business seriously when all you need is a check, a persons word and a cpl pictures to declare your dog a purebred without any other records to prove such a thing.. Wait till they and others get into the business of /recognizing/declaring new breeds. (or maybe they already do) ugh :(
 
I forgot to add, here's a prime example of an advertised and "highly decorated" stud without VDH papers: Inouk von Klein Sibirien

fotogalerie_1_inouk_von_klein_sibirien_14_20091014_1930971897.webp

He is 75cm (29.5" ... the FCI allows for only a 2cm deviation ie. max 74cm tall for a male, which would result in a lower quality grading) and yet he somehow has a ZTP V1A which was handed out to him by the "West German Breed Club".

The irony doesn't stop there though, his owner has actually bothered to have him tested for HD & ED, has had him holtered, and he has his BH. Um... so, why didn't she bother with the proper papers? It's things like this which make me go hmmm...
 
How accurate are the DNA tests to determine a dogs breed? You would think they'd at least ask for something like that, if not proof from a credible registry. Of course the DNA test wouldn't tell you the lineage or anything, but it would be more proof than a couple of pictures. :confused:
 
How accurate are the DNA tests to determine a dogs breed? You would think they'd at least ask for something like that, if not proof from a credible registry. Of course the DNA test wouldn't tell you the lineage or anything, but it would be more proof than a couple of pictures. :confused:
That would decrease the CKC's ability to cash your check.. There is a reason its so simple.. Its just not legitimate.

The CKS is a haven for breeders that have broken AKC limited registrations rules and breeder contracts.. This is where you go to get papers on dogs that otherwise cant be registered.. This allows real BYB's to sell their Dogs as CKC registered, giving any novice in the dog world some odd piece of mind.. Because they have a papered purebred for a fraction of the price of and AKC registered dog.. I dont support this group but that is what they are in the business of doing.
 
Do you know if his parents were properly registered??? If not that is probably why she did not get him papered.

As far as why do the registries pop up - Becasue people don't udnerstand the entire purebred dog world and how it works. They like a few here seem to think reg has no meaning and not worth the paper it is written on. BUT low and behold they get a dog and then someone tells them what a beautiful dog it is and it feeds their ego and suddenly they want to breed this "magnificent aniamal that has been judged by a NO NOTHING as beautiful - compared to what would be my question. Thye can't get legit papers so they find someone who will reg them just as they found someone with unpaperd dogs that would let them have a puppy with no restrictions and controls and another BYB is created!!! Oh the joy.

Since a registry sets its own rules as far as business goes they don't have to support a standard so they don't. For them it is about satisfying a need and making money off of ignorance.
 
Do you know if his parents were properly registered??? If not that is probably why she did not get him papered.

She has "WDV" papers on him, that's what I'm getting at. And so do the dog's parents. Apparently you can get kennel names with these unofficial registries here, too.

So basically, you can get unofficial pedigrees, ZTPs, and titles for your dog. And most people here have no idea about the difference between the FCI recognized VDH and any number of these unofficial registries that also allow people to register kennel names.

My amazement comes from the fact that she bothered to health test him and "title" him, so why did she not get a dog with VDH papers instead?

The woman I met with the illegally docked Dobe got him from one of these unofficially registered kennels. This is what is worrying: she found out about the unofficial kennel, but had no idea that there were official registered kennels near Berlin or where to get info on them.
 
She has "WDV" papers on him, that's what I'm getting at. And so do the dog's parents. Apparently you can get kennel names with these unofficial registries here, too.

So basically, you can get unofficial pedigrees, ZTPs, and titles for your dog. And most people here have no idea about the difference between the FCI recognized VDH and any number of these unofficial registries that also allow people to register kennel names.

My amazement comes from the fact that she bothered to health test him and "title" him, so why did she not get a dog with VDH papers instead?

The woman I met with the illegally docked Dobe got him from one of these unofficially registered kennels. This is what is worrying: she found out about the unofficial kennel, but had no idea that there were official registered kennels near Berlin or where to get info on them.
CKC has the lovely bonus of riding on the coattails of the real CKC in Canada.. Some people dont even realize they are being ripped off until its to late.. It is of my opinion that the CKC only exists to fraud people intentionally and by design.. Others may pop up here and there and be far more legitimate out of the gate.. The UKC pops in to mind for me.. Of course others dont even see the UKC as legit.. I myself believe competition is important so i do not have a problem with another registry as long as it wasn't started with the intention of scamming people out of their hard earned money..
 
I myself believe competition is important so i do not have a problem with another registry as long as it wasn't started with the intention of scamming people out of their hard earned money..

Ditto - Any venue you choose to work or show in has value as you oearn someting about your dog and about yourself. It is not necessarily that one is better than the other but you know the one that came first set the standard so people tend to follow it more.

I personally like the Euro way of judging - because you get a written critique and the judges seem much more approachable than in the AKC ring where they are busy to get to the next class. But ALL are good and all give valid info. Since several of the venues use AKC judges I don't think they go stupid just because it is a different club holding the event.

Back 4 or 5 years ago when AKC tried to make their judges exclusive to AKC and the big stink that ensued since they are considered independent contractors AKC backed down but UKC said hey we are the 2nd oldest registry and we can rain our own judges and so now they have some judges that are started in UKC don't know if they ever cross trained with AKC or not as I have not heard anthing about it so would think not.

All valid registries required AKC, FCI or CKC registration to qualify to reg with their reg. UKC does have a set of dogs that are only UKC reg but they go a long ways back and have established their onw credibility for those breeds.
 
I did not say it was a perfect tool - since humans designed it it has flaws but is still better than nothing and you can clearly see how important people feel it is becasue as you point out all the BYB's try to ride on the coat tails of others. Good breeders dont' have the majority of problems of you speak of "unworthy representative" of the breed because they use the genetics to produce consistency in their breeding program. I have seen what you speak of in many BYB dogs. Just read the form
.
You say the majority of the pups you visited appeared anxious only one was not so what does that say about good representatives of the breed. Why were those puppies anxious because someone came to visit??? Untrained, unsocialized and poor breeding tactics.

It's all relative. Kira-puppy was interested in checking-out me and her future "big Dobe sister". I'm sure the others have reasonable temperaments wherever they are, but Kira definitely had a distinct natural edge, and she's held onto it. The others may have needed a little more guidance in becoming what they should be.

As far as breeders go these days, especially those breeding within the constraints of a registry, they're just riding on the coattails of the people who really applied the theory and took the risks. This applies to all AKC (or other registry) breeders. It's feasible to breed towards a phenotype

Everything to do with the purebred dog worlds is about standards and the registry that protects the breeds. If breeders did not set some guidelines then any johny come lately would be off and running and destroying all we have worked to create and preserve.

I'm not talking about the registries, it's obvious the guidelines are just taken more as suggestions and registries are very hesitant to turn-away those registration fees. Animals with registered parents have to be pretty diseased or just plain wrong to be denied.

I was referring to the several-page contracts that rescue organizations generally have-- the context was that I would gladly have adopted a paperless dog that I could identify to be Doberman, but I didn't want to deal with all the BS and mandatory spay, etc.

I have no fears when it comes to identifying animals by sight to be sufficiently of a breed type. I don't need a registry to identify a Doberman or Quarter Horse, or any other breed I take an interest in. Most people really shouldn't have any problem either, and I think it's just a little silly to not register animals who meet the physical and mental specifications of a breed, even if their parentage is not known or recorded in a studbook. Sure, make them pass more rigorous conformation judging and earn working titles to prove that they're worthy of being accepted for registration.
 
I think that the statement of a Kc registration being a window of opportunity for idiots to churn out fake dobermans is valid. I have an odd way of looking at KC registration. I used to regularly bin mine pretty much as soon as I got home. As I wasn't going to breed from my dog or show it, it was superfluous to my needs. It's a breed registry and nothing more. There is no motivation within the system for people to breed 'good dobermans' or even dobermans to standard at all.
It takes into account in no way any kind of character test, it's impossible to police, it's essentially a farce. Well thats a bit harsh really it isn't a farce because it does what it says on the tin, it is a registry of lineage. Now the problem with the KC system is it pretends to be something other than what it is. It has breed standards within it yet makes no attempt to only register dogs which live up to or very close to that standard or even ensure the standards wording is in the best interests of the dogs themselves.
Conversely if you find an unregistered dog that is perfect to the standard there is no way of registering that dog into the system, as far as I know, which means that dogs genetics are forever exiled from the registry, unless something underhanded is done, which again makes a farce of the original intent.
It hosts shows and declares champions and such like yet the dogs that didn't cut it are not taken off the register never to produce a registrable pup again. They have openly admitted that they will not make changes that are in the best interests of the dogs themselves because they will loose members (read revenue)
It has become in the eyes of the public something it it is not. That of a guaranty that you are buying a doberman that lives up to the standard.
This sorta sums it pretty much up in an odd way:


Now the KC, in the uk anyway has been shown up as substandard as far as control of breeding, you can see this just by looking at Bulldogs, GSD'd, Pugs and others winning shows yet they are nearly crippled with various problems.
From wikipedia:
The original purpose of a kennel club, however, was the breeding and showing of conformation bench purebreds, and this remains the most widely accepted definition.

In reality, it should go back to it's original purpose that of a registry of lineage for showing and conformation and nothing else. There needs to be an independent breed club that decides which dogs go on the KC registry and which don't and maintains the standard for that particular breed, such as the dpca and I mean REALLY maintains it. This would increase the likelyhood that only quality dogs that are bred can be called 'standard dobemans' but there is way too much wonga involved in the KC now for that to happen.

This is why the KC's are basically obliged to register z factored dogs, because their lineage is unquestionable.

On a related (ish) topic. The docking ban could be a blessing in disguise in the uk, although working dobermans should have been included on the 'working dog exception list' (I still can't believe they are not) because now 'Joe Public' don't want dobermans anymore, bybers are losing interest. People in general are losing interest in the breed. This way if the standard had been left as requiring a docked tail, they could have been left to the working dog breeders and as such pups would go to working families. If show breeders had wanted to show their dogs they would HAVE to work them also, either themselves or someone else. Some semblance of the original doberman would have emerged again. People who love dobermans would put the effort in to work their dogs (or have them worked). Some show breeders would get an eye-opener as to exactly what they have done to the dobermans temperament for work and maybe understand it more and why we complain so much.
Equally unless a dog has been shown it should not have automatic registration rights of any pups produced. Both would be easy to police, no title, no registration, no show results, no registration.

I'm not trying to offend anyone with this post, it is just my opinion just as everyone else's is theirs.

I have two bitches, neither of them live up to standard, either temperamentally or physically. I will be amazed and I mean truly amazed if I can title either of them, yet there is NOTHING at all stopping me from going out and finding some random stud or buying my own male and getting them knocked up except my conscience. The pups would be eligible for KC registration and I could advertise them as such. That would not mean in the real word that they are 'true dobermans' at all but Joe bloggs that phones me up after seeing my advert in pre-loved would swallow it hook line and stinker.



Note: In the UK (unless it has been changed) a dogs tail can still be docked if it appears on the exception list and can be proved that the PUP ITSELF is going to be a real life working dog. Dobermans, sadly along with rotties did not make that list, yet all manner of hounds did. Hmmmm, I wonder which demographic keep and breed loads of hounds.........

Personally I like their tails natural but I don't like the concept of the government sticking their noses into affairs that are not their business, such as tail docking, breeding of dogs, abortion and whether a church should allow gay marriages (not because I am for or against any of the above, rather it is none of their business)

Sorry if none of that makes any sense, I think it's the worst bit of english I have ever written Please don't ban me, please don't ban me......
 
I'm quite sure that show breeders bred down the temperament in many countries because they wanted they wanted to supply the demand. People want pets, not working dogs. Nevermind the fact that the Dobermann IS a working breed and shouldn't be for everyone. Some still tout this, but I'm quite sure these "family pet" goal breedings have created a dog that anyone can have, or that can be comparable to any large energetic breed. Let's face it, many breeds of dog will alert and to me expecting a Dobermann to do nothing more than that is contrary to the original function that the dog was bred for.

I recently gave someone advice on breeders in Europe including several which I consider to be breeding dogs with poor temperament. The guy said temperament was really important to him, and that he was initially drawn to the Dobermann by its "friendly demeanor and trainability". Huh?

By the way, Matt Vandart - according to statistics in Australia, people are not losing interest in the breed, it has been going up in the last 10 years (although they are still nowhere near as popular as they were in the 70s and 80s).

I think most of the problems that arise with poorly bred Dobes or dogs of other breeds showing up with full papers is that the breed club has very little if any control over the breeding process. For example, in many countries you need to be a member of the Dobermann club, you need to register a kennel name, and you need to follow their procedure in order to be able to register a litter (i.e. minimum show rating, temperament test, HD results etc.).

In Australia the Dobermann club does not regulate breedings, but in order to register a kennel name (and litters), you have to do a course on breeding practices and pass an exam (based on the materials they provided you with, which cover ethics, methods etc.). And while I think this does nothing to improve the standard of Dobes being produced, it weeds out the flaky people and improves the quality of care that the puppies receive before going to their new homes.
 
In Australia there is no such Dobermann club which regulates breedings, but in order to register a kennel name (and litters), you have to do a course on breeding practices and pass an exam (based on the materials they provided you with, which cover ethics, methods etc.). And while I think this does nothing to improve the standard of Dobes being produced, it weeds out the flaky people and improves the quality of care that the puppies receive before going to their new homes.

That is cool, I like that, did the Govmnt do that?
 
That is cool, I like that, did the Govmnt do that?
No, the kennel club did it. They also publish a lot of information for breeders concerning genetics and how to improve the health of their stock. I'm guessing some of this information is probably a part of the course as well (it's a home study course that you take the exam for at a designated government office).
 
Yep, as I said... the breed club self-regulation just isn't happening actively in many places, unfortunately. That's not even touching on the show vs working crowds that for the most part don't have much to do with each other.
 
There needs to be an independent breed club that decides which dogs go on the KC registry and which don't and maintains the standard for that particular breed, such as the dpca and I mean REALLY maintains it. This would increase the likelyhood that only quality dogs that are bred can be called 'standard dobemans' but there is way too much wonga involved in the KC now for that to happen.

You complain about popular sire syndrome - you complain about inbreeding, line breeding and now you want to limit registrations. Just how do you see that helping in a small closed gene pool???
 
That is a separate problem to whether registration is anything other than a pedigree registration.

Although the gene pool could in fact be increased by introducing non registered but 'in standard' dobermans, for example ones from a country other than the accepted KC ones, obviously with the relevant 5-8 degrees of generation documented.
Either one wants to be able to get a doberman to a standard or not. KC registration in it's current form does not in any way guaranty this.

It would only make the gene pool smaller if people remain lazy and don't show or title their dogs before breeding.

Consideration could be taken into a judges score sheet from a show, so even if the dog isn't the best there, an acceptable level of conformation (scored) could entitle the dog for breeding (along with a working title/s) this would help deal with popular sire syndrome.
Line breeding is fine, if it is for a purpose that betters the breed without compromising the health of the line.
For example to 'fix' an appropriate temperament (as in set it, not repair it) but if those dogs are both carriers or affected of a genetic problem then, well you know what happens then.

Fact of the matter is, the KC system has been around a long time in a virtually unchanged format and genetic issues persist, in many breeds. If something isn't working you need change.
The old system of if a dog can do the job it is intended to is far superior, for any breed IMO
 
New That is a separate problem to whether registration is anything other than a pedigree registration.

Although the gene pool could in fact be increased by introducing non registered but 'in standard' dobermans, for example ones from a country other than the accepted KC ones, obviously with the relevant 5-8 degrees of generation documented.
Either one wants to be able to get a doberman to a standard or not. KC registration in it's current form does not in any way guaranty this.

So you think opening it to the wind and unknowns would guarantee anything or something??? How if you think it is so poor now with guidelines do you see opening the guidelines to the whims of whomever would help?
 

Back
Top