I think that the statement of a Kc registration being a window of opportunity for idiots to churn out fake dobermans is valid. I have an odd way of looking at KC registration. I used to regularly bin mine pretty much as soon as I got home. As I wasn't going to breed from my dog or show it, it was superfluous to my needs. It's a breed registry and nothing more. There is no motivation within the system for people to breed 'good dobermans' or even dobermans to standard at all.
It takes into account in no way any kind of character test, it's impossible to police, it's essentially a farce. Well thats a bit harsh really it isn't a farce because it does what it says on the tin, it is a registry of lineage. Now the problem with the KC system is it pretends to be something other than what it is. It has breed standards within it yet makes no attempt to only register dogs which live up to or very close to that standard or even ensure the standards wording is in the best interests of the dogs themselves.
Conversely if you find an unregistered dog that is perfect to the standard there is no way of registering that dog into the system, as far as I know, which means that dogs genetics are forever exiled from the registry, unless something underhanded is done, which again makes a farce of the original intent.
It hosts shows and declares champions and such like yet the dogs that didn't cut it are not taken off the register never to produce a registrable pup again. They have openly admitted that they will not make changes that are in the best interests of the dogs themselves because they will loose members (read revenue)
It has become in the eyes of the public something it it is not. That of a guaranty that you are buying a doberman that lives up to the standard.
This sorta sums it pretty much up in an odd way:
Now the KC, in the uk anyway has been shown up as substandard as far as control of breeding, you can see this just by looking at Bulldogs, GSD'd, Pugs and others winning shows yet they are nearly crippled with various problems.
From wikipedia:
The original purpose of a kennel club, however, was the breeding and showing of conformation bench purebreds, and this remains the most widely accepted definition.
In reality, it should go back to it's original purpose that of a registry of lineage for showing and conformation and nothing else. There needs to be an independent breed club that decides which dogs go on the KC registry and which don't and maintains the standard for that particular breed, such as the dpca and I mean REALLY maintains it. This would increase the likelyhood that only quality dogs that are bred can be called 'standard dobemans' but there is way too much wonga involved in the KC now for that to happen.
This is why the KC's are basically obliged to register z factored dogs, because their lineage is unquestionable.
On a related (ish) topic. The docking ban could be a blessing in disguise in the uk, although working dobermans should have been included on the 'working dog exception list' (I still can't believe they are not) because now 'Joe Public' don't want dobermans anymore, bybers are losing interest. People in general are losing interest in the breed. This way if the standard had been left as requiring a docked tail, they could have been left to the working dog breeders and as such pups would go to working families. If show breeders had wanted to show their dogs they would HAVE to work them also, either themselves or someone else. Some semblance of the original doberman would have emerged again. People who love dobermans would put the effort in to work their dogs (or have them worked). Some show breeders would get an eye-opener as to exactly what they have done to the dobermans temperament for work and maybe understand it more and why we complain so much.
Equally unless a dog has been shown it should not have automatic registration rights of any pups produced. Both would be easy to police, no title, no registration, no show results, no registration.
I'm not trying to offend anyone with this post, it is just my opinion just as everyone else's is theirs.
I have two bitches, neither of them live up to standard, either temperamentally or physically. I will be amazed and I mean truly amazed if I can title either of them, yet there is NOTHING at all stopping me from going out and finding some random stud or buying my own male and getting them knocked up except my conscience. The pups would be eligible for KC registration and I could advertise them as such. That would not mean in the real word that they are 'true dobermans' at all but Joe bloggs that phones me up after seeing my advert in pre-loved would swallow it hook line and stinker.
Note: In the UK (unless it has been changed) a dogs tail can still be docked if it appears on the exception list and can be proved that the PUP ITSELF is going to be a real life working dog. Dobermans, sadly along with rotties did not make that list, yet all manner of hounds did. Hmmmm, I wonder which demographic keep and breed loads of hounds.........
Personally I like their tails natural but I don't like the concept of the government sticking their noses into affairs that are not their business, such as tail docking, breeding of dogs, abortion and whether a church should allow gay marriages (not because I am for or against any of the above, rather it is none of their business)
Sorry if none of that makes any sense, I think it's the worst bit of english I have ever written Please don't ban me, please don't ban me......