What is Registration and What Registery is best?

Funny that a well bred dog many times has a contract attached to it that it may never be bred and even go as far as demanding a mandatory spay neuter at some point.. All the while BYB bred dogs get bred wildly unchecked.. And then we wonder why the breed is going to hell in a hand basket.. its certainly a catch 22 situation where you really are damned if you do and damned if you dont..

The common conception is that only the best of the best should ever be bred.. This leaves a HUGE market open to anyone with a vague interest in breeding regardless of experience, education or ethics. Dobermans are especially attractive to undesirables because puppies are not cheap regardless of who bred them. And it gets even better because the gene pool is so small everyone can claim great genetics. :shakinghead:
 
To better illustrate my point.. This Bitch cant be bred per her contract.. (assuming)
Doberman1.webp


All the while there are no safeguards in place (besides the breeders good intentions with a contract a generation or 2 back that someone eventually cheated on) to prevent the owner of this Doberman to be bred without discretion..

doberman2.webp

Now assuming for the purpose of this discussion that the dog with the white patch is a purebred AKC registered doberman.. With a obvious fault. Guess what? he comes with the same papers our well bred dogs have except their is no contract and anyone with a desire can breed it.. All the while im sure their would be a better candidate except he has a contract stating he cannot be bred ever.. Leaving the Doberman gene pool i gigantic mess that good breeders get the pleasure of trying to fix with their hands tied behind their backs, Even though the mess may have been self inflicted to some degree.



Disclaimer i have zero idea as to the identities of either dog.. Im just playing devils advocate to make a point and contribute to the discussion.
 
While indi is contracted not to be bred from, I believe if I were to title her, health check her, show a real interest in learning about the breed, prove I've got what it takes and take advice or direction from her breeder on suitable males, her breeder would allow me to breed her.
Im not a fan of the.mandatory spay/neuter though. Breeders should be selling to people they believe will stick to a no breeding contract and/or return the dog to them should they need it rehomed.

Sent from my LT15i using Tapatalk 2
 
Please dont get me wrong i am not knocking contracts.. I know they serve a purpose and i know the breeders intentions of said contracts are in most cases noble.. But the end result in the big picture is bad news for our dogs in general.. Im not knocking the intentions of contracts.. but i dont think its working and i personally believe its showing an adverse effect and some time or another dialog needs to open up and more common ground needs to be found b4 its to late..
 
I guess I understand both sides. A breeder would not want their dogs, with their name and reputation attached to be bred by anyone to anything. And really, that is a lovely bitch, who should be bred by someone who knows what they're doing, not the average pet owner.

A mandatory spay neuter at the time of sale as a pup won't really help either as a breeder won't know how the pup will turn out.

I guess its back to the same discussion on bybs and people breeding for money. An impossible thing to overcome.

Sent from my LT15i using Tapatalk 2
 
I guess I understand both sides. A breeder would not want their dogs, with their name and reputation attached to be bred by anyone to anything. And really, that is a lovely bitch, who should be bred by someone who knows what they're doing, not the average pet owner.

A mandatory spay neuter at the time of sale as a pup won't really help either as a breeder won't know how the pup will turn out.

I guess its back to the same discussion on bybs and people breeding for money. An impossible thing to overcome.

Sent from my LT15i using Tapatalk 2

Sadly i concur even though the solution is so simple it cant be grasped by most unless your a little insane. ;)
But seriously i agree.. the doberman world is already splintered in to so many different groups (Pro C/D, Anti C/D, Show/Work, Na/EU, Etc, Etc.. the likelihood of any solutions will prove impossible.
 
Besides all the emphasis just on appearance, I would like to see a lot more breeders focusing on temperament after what I've witnessed in Germany. And by that I mean correct temperament, not just temperament defined as stable enough to live in a family (almost any dog can do that, purebred or not).

I guess I'm a little tired of seeing breeders who focus entirely on show and do absolutely nothing else with their "working breed" dogs, then justify their dog's suitability for breeding based on one conformation title. But the irony is, if a non-breeder titles their dog in exactly the same way, their dog is more harshly criticized before being deemed worthy because they are not a breeder? They are essentially doing the exact same thing!
 
The self proclaimed experts call this watering down the breed. Some will say its been tried in the USA and the enthusiasts claim it as a shell of the Dog as it was intended.. Others blame it on to much emphasis on conformation the list just goes on and on everyone on every side in every argument is making excuses to protect themselves from personal slander and libel, Breeders are some of the worst offenders. its called self preservation. Same with the C/D debate.. It will rage on until one side or the other is declared a winner and beyond.. There is no room for common ground or common sense anymore.. Its become a dog eat dog world and be damned anyone that gets in our way.. Thats just the world we live in today.. Sad it takes tragedy to bring people together in most cases.
 
Leaving the Doberman gene pool i gigantic mess that good breeders get the pleasure of trying to fix with their hands tied behind their backs, Even though the mess may have been self inflicted to some degree.

Von I agree with purebred dogs and by the very thing that makes them possible it can also be their downfall. But the option is no Doberman and that I am not good with. Reg was meant to maintain parentage and bloodlines to know where you wanted to go to breed but back in the beginning it was an add on to field trails. As conformation grew - and we were at the beginning, the total dog was pretty much there - conformation, temperament, working ability and health.

We have to have a system to track these dogs and AKC reg is the method we have. We need shows to because it is a way to have your dog evaluated by someone other than yourself (generic yourself) and hopefully avoid kennel blindness. It is a form of advertising and in today world of instant communication it is a way to expand and reach a targeted market.

It is one reason though that I like the Euro way of judging better - Think about it - in 50 years how many Doberman's can win Westminister - at best 50 - That in itself creates a big bottleneck. You have read some of my articles on this very subject and so I know you know where I stand. I believe we need showing and trails but I do not believe it is the only way to judge a dog - BUT to eliminate a lot of the BYB, showing does give one a foot up - Because of the Standard I am not for just anyone willy nilly getting two dobermans and breeding them.

Look at the problems that have been created because of that - The albino's should have and could have easily been eliminated from the beginning had the people who bred the litter said these are not allowed and done the right thing. Breeding dogs under 2 years of age - and untested. I believe a minimum of Vwd and hips - now I would add PDK4 to that minimum list As far as I am concerned anything else is a crap shoot anyway but it is info at the time.

You I know that after working hard to establish your bloodlines and accomplishment you would not want to see one of your dogs bred to and Albino or an unregistered dog or to any of the dogs reg through the fly by night registeries. How do you avoid some new BYB from cropping up with one of your dogs???

Certainly today JQP is far less equipped to even handle or correctly understand a dog let alone breed it which usually happens due to a OOOOOPS litter.

Breeders are pretty darn good at evaluating and grading a litter at 8 weeks and the pet puppies go with limited reg and spay/neuter - this is prudent IMHO. People who want pets usually don't want the bother of heat seasons etc.

Look at what happened when breeders lost control of the standard - that is why we have a c/d issue - JQP doesn't understand anything about the show ring, trails, or even how they got a dog that looks a certain way. They are so innudated with horror stories they can't think straight and it will cost us our breed.

When people join a club or a forum there are rules you agree to abide by and for Dobermans the Breed standard and DPCA COE is that guideline. If you (my you's are all generic) don't want to follow the rules get out or get banned!!!!

It is a double edged sword and it cuts deep. Breeding is not for the faint of heart.
 
Von I agree with purebred dogs and by the very thing that makes them possible it can also be their downfall. But the option is no Doberman and that I am not good with. Reg was meant to maintain parentage and bloodlines to know where you wanted to go to breed but back in the beginning it was an add on to field trails. As conformation grew - and we were at the beginning, the total dog was pretty much there - conformation, temperament, working ability and health.

We have to have a system to track these dogs and AKC reg is the method we have. We need shows to because it is a way to have your dog evaluated by someone other than yourself (generic yourself) and hopefully avoid kennel blindness. It is a form of advertising and in today world of instant communication it is a way to expand and reach a targeted market.

It is one reason though that I like the Euro way of judging better - Think about it - in 50 years how many Doberman's can win Westminister - at best 50 - That in itself creates a big bottleneck. You have read some of my articles on this very subject and so I know you know where I stand. I believe we need showing and trails but I do not believe it is the only way to judge a dog - BUT to eliminate a lot of the BYB, showing does give one a foot up - Because of the Standard I am not for just anyone willy nilly getting two dobermans and breeding them.

Look at the problems that have been created because of that - The albino's should have and could have easily been eliminated from the beginning had the people who bred the litter said these are not allowed and done the right thing. Breeding dogs under 2 years of age - and untested. I believe a minimum of Vwd and hips - now I would add PDK4 to that minimum list As far as I am concerned anything else is a crap shoot anyway but it is info at the time.

You I know that after working hard to establish your bloodlines and accomplishment you would not want to see one of your dogs bred to and Albino or an unregistered dog or to any of the dogs reg through the fly by night registeries. How do you avoid some new BYB from cropping up with one of your dogs???

Certainly today JQP is far less equipped to even handle or correctly understand a dog let alone breed it which usually happens due to a OOOOOPS litter.

Breeders are pretty darn good at evaluating and grading a litter at 8 weeks and the pet puppies go with limited reg and spay/neuter - this is prudent IMHO. People who want pets usually don't want the bother of heat seasons etc.

Look at what happened when breeders lost control of the standard - that is why we have a c/d issue - JQP doesn't understand anything about the show ring, trails, or even how they got a dog that looks a certain way. They are so innudated with horror stories they can't think straight and it will cost us our breed.

When people join a club or a forum there are rules you agree to abide by and for Dobermans the Breed standard and DPCA COE is that guideline. If you (my you's are all generic) don't want to follow the rules get out or get banned!!!!

It is a double edged sword and it cuts deep. Breeding is not for the faint of heart.
Understood, i believe there is some confusion as i did go off topic and on the subject of registries and i jumped on the contracts bit.. I know they are a valuable tool but to borrow your phrase Thay are also a "double edged sword" when the rest of the world is breeding indiscriminately.. My point was that its far easier to breed to an ugly out of standard dog then it is to breed a quality dog.

Its understood by anyone that has even attempted a serious breeding program that the task isnt even remotely easy.. 5 years in and im still at ground zero and just cant get to where i am supposed be by now.. Setbacks are far more common then successes.. there is no such thing as a set back when your in it for the wrong reasons..

bla ive got a DR apt to make.. But i look forward to continuing this conversation a little later. lol you know i have plenty to say on the subject of registries to.. I dont hate them but a makeover is certainly in order.
 
I know they are a valuable tool but to borrow your phrase Thay are also a "double edged sword" when the rest of the world is breeding indiscriminately.. My point was that its far easier to breed to an ugly out of standard dog then it is to breed a quality dog.

A big Amen to that and I would love to hear their sales pictch because they often get more for them than our well bred dogs. But why??? Because good breeders care about where their dogs go and who gets to breed them - the poorly bred dog breeders don't care. How do we solve that???

Until we come up with solid solutions to the challenges we can only deal with what we have. I don't know the answers but in no way believe any government should step in and make decisions. NO WAY -

It takes 10 years to begin to establish your own bloodlines - The first 5 years you are breeding from someone else's stock as you build dogs you have bred - then in the next 5 years you are breeding from dogs you produced and then you can evaluate what you produce and begin to make tweaks and adjustments as you study what happend in the first generations and where you want to go from there. Breeding is a lifelong study.

Just look at all the misconceptions that JQP has on purbred dogs

I know we have to have guidelines but they can't choke the creativity of breeders. So while the guidelines cut both ways we have to find the way to adjust and make something that works. I am not for the things we see here way too often - people breeding young untested dogs, Z factored, Fly by night registries etc. To me these are far bigger problems than any health issue we have. If we really put our heads together and work on it I am sure positive adjustments can be made. But as long a JQP thinks they should have a say I fear all is lost.
 
There is, and has ever always been one purpose to a studbook-- logging of lineage. There have been purebred dogs for millennia, but registry-maintained studbooks for only the relatively recent past. Until they came on the scene, people had to evaluate each individual animal on its merits, determining with their own eyes if it had the ability and met the accepted standards.

Registration has become a crutch that allows people to be lazy and incompetent. They no longer need to be even a little good at judging animals, they have a piece of paper that tells them that it's probably what it's claimed to be based on its ancestry.

Registration allows breeders to ignore best practices. There's no need to actually demonstrate the ability, health, or temperament of their breeding stock, that little piece of paper allows them to breed completely unproven youngsters and the registry takes simple parentage as merit. VonDoom has illustrated that problem quite aptly with the photos above. BYBs do this every day, it has to be a particularly lazy and inept BYB to not be able to procure a couple of registered animals to produce puppies with papers.

There are all too many unhealthy, untrained, untested, unproven animals with poor conformation and unsuitable temperaments who are not worthy of the registration papers they received only for the event of being born, much less potential breeding stock status that the papers confer on them at birth. Until registries get their act together, their papers mean nothing more than what I stated in my first sentence. It is the pinnacle of ignorance to conflate "AKC (or other) Registered" with "quality".

Another thing. Until such an absurd amount of value was placed on studbooks, breeders had to be extremely competent, working with their eyes, their hands, and their knowledge. Conformation shows, if they existed for dogs in a remotely similar sense they did for horses ("the market"/auction pens), would have some diversity within a breed, with the folks not judging a bunch of fine points on extremely similar animals, but rather whether an animal fit a particular type. For example, the "quarter horse" has been around since the 17th century. The primary fancy-pants registry, the AQHA, was founded in 1940. In those intervening few hundred years, people knew what a "quarter horse" was based on whether it fit the mold, not who its parents were.

That is not only largely gone (as evidenced by the short-lived, disease-prone wrecks a lot of breeds are becoming), but the emphasis on these papers discourages any sort of discretion when it comes to plying the animal husbandry trade to clean-up the stagnant or bad blood in the gene pool. This notion that "pure=good" is relatively recent, professional breeders used to perform a lot more outcrosses when necessary to fit their specific breeding programs.

Perhaps people should color outside the lines like K.F.L. Dobermann did, his efforts helped to design one of the best working breeds, one I think we all can agree is close to the pinnacle of canine artificial selection for nearly all of the traits that make dogs so special to us humans. Would he and those other folks who ran with his dream approve of what the refined, Registered Doberman has become today? They probably would be impressed with the better examples, but I can guarantee that they would also be the first people to throw this notion of registration being important out the window in the pursuit of making the Doberman more able and healthier. They took educated risks, doing their best to borrow and combine traits they wanted from other breeds, and they had to put in the work. There was no notion of "to make a great dog, you just lounge in the hammock of a breed registry and you can't go (too) wrong!" which is largely what the AKC and its legion of BYBs and commercial breeders has become.
 
In light of all the new puppies we have I felt perhaps we needed to revive this post as people still have a problem deciphering a good breeder from a not so good breeder.

  1. If you paid a cheaper price but then couldn't get AKC reg papers - did you win???
  2. If you paid a cheaper price and then spend $2,000 on vet bills and cropping - did you win???
  3. If you went to a BYB and then had a problem but they quit responding to you because they did not care - did you win???
  4. If you paid the same price as what you could have gotten from a good breeder - did you win???
Guys the internet affords a wealth of info at our fingertips - when I read some of the threads I know there was precious little research done.
When I read that a "breeder" using the term loosely let someone have a puppy that had very small children I have to wonder.

There is so much that goes behind a good pedigree and AKC registration along with a breeder who brees to better the breed not just proudce puppies.

How do we get the word out?? Why is it not working??? Whose responsibility is it to educate themselves first???

  1. I suppose that would depend on the reasons someone gets a purebred puppy. Id be willing to guess that its probably 50/50. People that sign up for lists similar to DC are a bit different then the general population.. I have no real way of knowing but i would venture a guess and say more people pay for AKC registrable dogs then actually spend the extra few bucks to make it official. I know as a hardcore enthusiast this doesn't sit well with you but most people in the real world could care less about that piece of paper (the application to many people is as good as the registration itself). A pedigree for example has no meaning to someone who has no clue therefore not worth the paper its printed on.
  2. If you only have to spent a couple G's on your dog in its lifetime id say your fortunate.. However i know what you are trying to say so ill address the question without the humor. This question can and will be answered differently by different people depending on their personal experience, luck or whatever you want to call it.. Facts are facts and you cannot dispute that good breeders can produce bad puppies and some clueless breeders can produce some very healthy dogs I personally attribute this to a number of things but a good example would be Scatter bred dogs vs Line bred dogs. (id go in to more detail but since im preaching to the choir i doubt i need to)
  3. Does the general population even know that this is how authentic breeders do things? Ive personally never needed breeder support in relation to my dogs making this pretty low on my personal list of priorities when looking for a puppy...
  4. See answer 2.
Now heres my question.. The internet has been around for the masses for a good 20 years now so with this wealth of information now available to us is the Doberman any healthier as a whole today then it was 20 years ago?

Sincerely
Devils advocate
 
Registration has become a crutch that allows people to be lazy and incompetent. They no longer need to be even a little good at judging animals, they have a piece of paper that tells them that it's probably what it's claimed to be based on its ancestry.

Kaloric you are so bitter I have to ask why the hell did you get a Doberman if you feel registraion and purebred dogs are such gargage?

For those that don't know - why don't you spell out K. F. L. as not everyone is as knowledgable as some of us.

FYI quarter horses come from specific lines and we have Arabians, Morgans, Thoroughbreds, Paints, Mustangs so we needed a registry and guess what we still have to evaluate our breeding stock. You post your disdain for the breeders who brought you the Doberman is like biting the hand that feeds you.

What AQHA did was to bring the quarter horse to the forefront for it specific qualities and give JQP the info needed to find the right quarter horse. EX - Hancock quarter horse were very good at calf roping and barrel racing. Doc bar horses excelled at calf roping and cutting horses. The registry gave people a place they could to research info that otherwise would be very difficult to see let alone promote and evaluate what might be a good cross to add in etc.

Breeders now had a tool to assist them. They did not stop with their passion and study to always strive to improve on what they had. You are so blinded by your misinformation that you could not see ground zero if it jumped up and bit you.

Today the registry gives people a convenient way to research our Dobermans for show lines, working lines etc.
Registration has become a crutch that allows people to be lazy and incompetent. They no longer need to be even a little good at judging animals, they have a piece of paper that tells them that it's probably what it's claimed to be based on its ancestry.

You obviously are not in touch with reality. And certainly have no clue what a pedigree through registration tells you. No one has ever said it is the end all end all but it is a darn good place to start. I have spent hours and hours and days and weeks researching pedigrees to see what lines produce what on both sides of the world while you spout your disdain for anything purebred. Registration is not a crutch and is exactly why we have shows, trails etc to compete and test our stock. Lazy and Incompetent - go get a mutt we dont need morans in our breed especially ones so filled with hate and venom. No one forced you to get a Doberman but if you feel they are such bad examples then go get a snake - cold and bloodless not to mention heartless.
 
There are all too many unhealthy, untrained, untested, unproven animals with poor conformation and unsuitable temperaments who are not worthy of the registration papers they received only for the event of being born, much less potential breeding stock status that the papers confer on them at birth. Until registries get their act together, their papers mean nothing more than what I stated in my first sentence. It is the pinnacle of ignorance to conflate "AKC (or other) Registered" with "quality".

Another thing. Until such an absurd amount of value was placed on studbooks, breeders had to be extremely competent, working with their eyes, their hands, and their knowledge. Conformation shows, if they existed for dogs in a remotely similar sense they did for horses ("the market"/auction pens), would have some diversity within a breed, with the folks not judging a bunch of fine points on extremely similar animals, but rather whether an animal fit a particular type. For example, the "quarter horse" has been around since the 17th century. The primary fancy-pants registry, the AQHA, was founded in 1940. In those intervening few hundred years, people knew what a "quarter horse" was based on whether it fit the mold, not who its parents were.

That is not only largely gone (as evidenced by the short-lived, disease-prone wrecks a lot of breeds are becoming), but the emphasis on these papers discourages any sort of discretion when it comes to plying the animal husbandry trade to clean-up the stagnant or bad blood in the gene pool. This notion that "pure=good" is relatively recent, professional breeders used to perform a lot more outcrosses when necessary to fit their specific breeding programs.

Perhaps people should color outside the lines like K.F.L. Dobermann did, his efforts helped to design one of the best working breeds, one I think we all can agree is close to the pinnacle of canine artificial selection for nearly all of the traits that make dogs so special to us humans. Would he and those other folks who ran with his dream approve of what the refined, Registered Doberman has become today? They probably would be impressed with the better examples, but I can guarantee that they would also be the first people to throw this notion of registration being important out the window in the pursuit of making the Doberman more able and healthier. They took educated risks, doing their best to borrow and combine traits they wanted from other breeds, and they had to put in the work. There was no notion of "to make a great dog, you just lounge in the hammock of a breed registry and you can't go (too) wrong!" which is largely what the AKC and its legion of BYBs and commercial breeders has become.

I don't believe that registries are completely useless in that they can hold important information about the parents' health, working or conformation titles and so on. But I do think that they should be more discriminating in practice. For example, in order to register a litter of Dobermanns in Europe, depending on the country the parents must have passed temperament tests, have received three grades of excellent in shows (or a number of CACs), and a breed warden comes to inspect the puppies at the age of 7 weeks to make sure they really are what the breeder claims, and to make the registrations invalid for breeding of any puppy with obvious disqualifying faults like improper markings (white chest, lack of tan marking etc.). If that were the case with the AKC, the albino gene would not still be floating around among registered Dobes.
 
depending on the country the parents must have passed temperament tests, have received three grades of excellent in shows (or a number of CACs), and a breed warden comes to inspect the puppies at the age of 7 weeks to make sure they really are what the breeder claims, and to make the registrations invalid for breeding of any puppy with obvious disqualifying faults like improper markings (white chest, lack of tan marking etc.).

According to what you have found in Germany I would say it isn't working so well.
 
According to what you have found in Germany I would say it isn't working so well.

I wasn't referring to just Germany in my post, which, if you have read anything about the history of the DV club, you would know has much more complex reasons as to why it is where it is now than the enforcement of the ZTP. Many other countries such as the Czech Republic, Luxembourg, Bulgaria etc. have similar systems and requirements, and seem to be doing just fine.
 
Breeders now had a tool to assist them. They did not stop with their passion and study to always strive to improve on what they had. You are so blinded by your misinformation that you could not see ground zero if it jumped up and bit you.

A tool. That's precisely what a pedigree is, nothing less, nothing more. It is not the be-all, end-all that so many hacks have made it. Or would you care to dispute the point I'm making, that the ignorant BYBs and commercial breeders that make up the overwhelming majority of any purebred dog on the market these days, whether advertised in the newspaper or available in a pet shop, are using the fact that a dog has registration papers to make something of that animal which simply isn't there, wasn't there in its parents, and they should frankly be ashamed of themselves? Or, how about that buyers get burned because they see "AKC Reg." and wind-up with a pup that might be a completely unworthy representative of the breed in nearly every respect, and they thought that line in the advertisement had overwhelming significance?

I will definitely grant that "DPCA" means quite a bit more because there's at least a little peer-review and they focus a lot more on spreading the knowledge.

It used to be that one could pick up a copy of any big-city newspaper, flip to the "dogs" section of the classifieds, and easily find 80-100 listings for various "AKC Reg. _insert_breed-here_" dogs. This is part of the chaos that registries help to create when the existence of a studbook is confused with being more important than knowledge and evaluation of the animal you see right in front of you.

I would compare the way a lot of people throw around the importance of registration as being a lot like the people who drive into fields or canals because they were mindlessly obeying the GPS device rather than paying attention to where they're actually going.

Today the registry gives people a convenient way to research our Dobermans for show lines, working lines etc

A tool. And as Ataro noted, also a great way to research health testing that's been done, it empowers people if they care to be knowledgeable. For those who don't want to do their homework, the registry only serves to provide an illusion of quality when there is no substance to be found.

Registration is not a crutch and is exactly why we have shows, trails etc to compete and test our stock.

It most definitely is a crutch for those who might as well be selling mutts for all they know or care about selective breeding. When a breeder's primary motivation is money, and they know that including the "AKC Reg." text in the listing means a few hundred $$$ as opposed to practically giving away unremarkable puppies in front of Wal*Mart, there's no other way to describe it. It's a situation where perhaps everyone either needs to be MUCH better at communicating that "having papers doesn't mean you're getting a good example of the breed, do the rest of your homework", or the registries need to clamp-down and curtail the free-for-all, making breeders and their breeding stock have to work just a little to qualify for studbook eligibility.

I don't believe that registries are completely useless in that they can hold important information about the parents' health, working or conformation titles and so on. But I do think that they should be more discriminating in practice. For example, in order to register a litter of Dobermanns in Europe, depending on the country the parents must have passed temperament tests, have received three grades of excellent in shows (or a number of CACs), and a breed warden comes to inspect the puppies at the age of 7 weeks to make sure they really are what the breeder claims, and to make the registrations invalid for breeding of any puppy with obvious disqualifying faults like improper markings (white chest, lack of tan marking etc.). If that were the case with the AKC, the albino gene would not still be floating around among registered Dobes.

While D4E also has a great point that it doesn't sound like the system is working quite as intended in Germany from your observations there, this is along the lines of what I'm getting at, and it's certainly better than the "all of absolutely nothing" that the AKC does to screen breeding stock and breeders. Their most heroic effort seems to be to simply flag z-factor animals with cryptic reg numbers that mean nothing to people who are not in-the-know (do they even have explanation or disclosure on "what z means" on the certificate?), when they should be banned outright. They could do even more, like imposing limited registrations on homozygous affected animals for known genetic defects or less-than-good hips, but they won't do that, either.

Folks, it's not at all that I don't like purebreds or pedigrees. But I also am hard-pressed to give too much of a crap about them. While all of my animals (except for the little grey cat) are purebreds with registrations, I looked over the animals themselves, looked over their parents when possible, and for all I care, I could've tossed their papers in the file cabinet without even reading them. The registration was little more than something to get me in the ballpark of what I was looking for. I would be extremely hard-pressed to ever buy an animal sight-unseen, or seen only through photos on the Internet.

When I picked-out Kira from the choice of female pups I had before me, I made that choice based on things that I never would've seen in a photo, such as how she reacted and behaved. Honestly, I probably would've chosen one of the others had I been going by photos alone, her markings are not as light and crisp as the others had. Even as a puppy, she had a tenacious, bold temperament, not shy or anxious in the least. The others gave me a little pause because they did seem more anxious, which isn't too surprising considering they were not in their comfort zone, but isn't a huge part of this breed being able to assess an unfamiliar challenge head-on without backing-down or even flinching? There is absolutely no substitute for knowing what you're looking for and having the opportunity to choose it. If I could've found another perfect opportunity that consisted of a completely unpapered Doberman who looked like a Doberman, moved like a Doberman, and behaved like a Doberman, just like the variety of Doberman you usually find in shelters and rescues, I would've gone that route too. My requirements and distaste for dealing with controlling people & organizations caused me to look to a breeder instead.
 
A tool. That's precisely what a pedigree is, nothing less, nothing more. It is not the be-all, end-all that so many hacks have made it. Or would you care to dispute the point I'm making, that the ignorant BYBs and commercial breeders that make up the overwhelming majority of any purebred dog on the market these days, whether advertised in the newspaper or available in a pet shop, are using the fact that a dog has registration papers to make something of that animal which simply isn't there, wasn't there in its parents, and they should frankly be ashamed of themselves? Or, how about that buyers get burned because they see "AKC Reg." and wind-up with a pup that might be a completely unworthy representative of the breed in nearly every respect, and they thought that line in the advertisement had overwhelming significance?

I did not say it was a perfect tool - since humans designed it it has flaws but is still better than nothing and you can clearly see how important people feel it is becasue as you point out all the BYB's try to ride on the coat tails of others. Good breeders dont' have the majority of problems of you speak of "unworthy representative" of the breed because they use the genetics to produce consistency in their breeding program. I have seen what you speak of in many BYB dogs. Just read the form
.
You say the majority of the pups you visited appeared anxious only one was not so what does that say about good representatives of the breed. Why were those puppies anxious because someone came to visit??? Untrained, unsocialized and poor breeding tactics.

Exactly how would you have even found the ball park without a registry??? It has far more importance than what you want to admit and it appers you use it yourself if all your animals are registered. If it had no meaning then you would have bought some CKC reg (using the term loosely or non reg)
I would've gone that route too. My requirements and distaste for dealing with controlling people & organizations caused me to look to a breeder instead.

Everything to do with the purebred dog worlds is about standards and the registry that protects the breeds. If breeders did not set some guidelines then any johny come lately would be off and running and destroying all we have worked to create and preserve.
 

Back
Top