• Disclaimer: Hello Guest, Doberman Chat Forums presents the opinions and material on these pages as a service to its membership and to the general public but does not endorse those materials, nor does it guarantee the accuracy of any opinions or information contained therein. The opinions expressed in the materials are strictly the opinion of the writer and do not represent the opinion of, nor are they endorsed by, Doberman Chat Forums. Health and medical articles are intended as an aid to those seeking health information and are not intended to replace the informed opinion of a qualified Veterinarian.”

Backyard Breeder vs Reputable Breeder

  • Thread starter Thread starter FredC
  • Start date Start date

Anytime you post something on a public forum you are opening yourself up to judgement. So if you don't like to be judged, don't post.
Not every disease is fatal or means suffering and some can be managed with medication. I will do what I have to do to manage my dogs health and pray I know when it is time to give up that fight.
I am not opposed in the least to euthanasia. Actually, when my dad was sick with end stage Parkinson's my family as a whole took a look at it because he was suffering so much. We anguished over several options because we wanted nothing but the best and least painful thing for him. In the end, it was my dad's decision not to go that way because the ones left behind would pay the price. It is still illegal and not a decision to take lightly because we are humans trying to play God. Who would not prefer to see their loved one have a peaceful passing and not suffer any longer. But something that just requires an expensive medication does not call for death.
As far as any posting you have done, I get the impression you are looking for the perfect puppy from the perfect breeder. All I can say is good luck finding that.

I can tell you don't like me, but that's okay. I was actually referring to the fact that you have chosen to ignore everything else I posted and instead twist my words to fit your own fantasies of cruelty and bad ownership, when that couldn't be further from the truth. And you still continue to do this, despite having been presented with the facts. I have stated my opinion very clearly, and if you had read it you would not be going on about diseases being all fatal or whatever. I'm not judging you for what you choose to do with your dog or how much you choose to spend - that is your business, and not mine - you might do well to do the same.

One thing that I don't appreciate is when people start trying to talk for me, ignoring what I have said and then act smug and tell me not to post if I don't like to be judged. If you're not reading and taking in what I am saying anyway, then there's really nothing I can do to change your opinion or impression. And to be honest, seeing as you are some random person over the internet who has had up until now zilch to do with me, I don't see why I should even care. Paint me in as negative a light as you like, if that makes you feel good, but an ill-informed opinion holds very little weight in the scheme of things.

And as for the puppy, wow, you really are bitter... First of all, I have already found a puppy, twice actually, from a good breeder. I find comments like "if I were a breeder I would cross you off the list" etc. to be completely irrelevant to the discussion, not at all constructive and just intended to insult. Maybe it is actually a good thing that you aren't a breeder, because you seem to easily let your emotions get the best of you and cloud your judgement.
 
People come from different perspectives and it is more eveident when poeple are from different parts of the world. Values and opinions are just different. Does notmean one is right and one is wrong. I did not read that Ataro was ready to throw out any dog for a minor illness.

I know Paint has more heart and because of rescuing and has a very special soft spot in her heart for all dogs. I think we just misunderstood what was being said.

Having said that I think too many are focused on the negative and just slamming everyone while having some very unrealistic expectations. First what does health testing really guarantee???

We can guarantee two things right now VWD status and PDK4 status because we have DNA test for those things. Those two things do not guarantee a healthy dog or an unhealthy dog.

So as a breeder it is like being dumped in a big maze with hundreds of twist and turns with most being dead ends. But to be true to our passion we persist and carry on inspite of all the crap thrown at us on a daily basis. We try to take it, assemble it, respond to it and continue to struggle to produce the dog call the Doberman.

If we did not have a registry where do you think Dobermans would be today??? If we did not have a breed standard what do you think Dobermans would look like??? How would it work with purebred dogs if everyone just bred what they liked???

I will tell you we have come a long way from Herr Dobermann's dogs and I feel most of it is for the best. I would not be interested in his dog which was butt ugly and quite the scrapper. So both looks and temperament had to be changed for the dog to emerge, become popular and that fit society as it changed. Once we hit that mark then it is just the continual struggle to breed the perfect dog or a dog tha most closely fits the standard.

I do feel in some areas we have gone too far and some things have suffered but we also have the opportuntiy to stop and work to bring it back. But I think all would agree that changes needed to be made from the original dog if it was to survive and

Then you have someone who feels pets are genetic failures and all I can say to that is you need to look at brothers and sisters - aunts uncles etc and see the genetic diversity and not all are perfect but they all have value and if you are not breeding for the perfect dog then those "pet puppies" make it possible for you to have a Doberman. To the inexperience untrained eye 95% of you would not even recognize any big difference as there are so many facets that separate the pet puppy from the show puppy (speaking of well bred dogs not poorly bred examples of the breed) and none are related to major defective faults except the z factor and albinos.

I think we can clearly see that people have evolved to the point of stupidity. They have been raised in cities, with a text book understanding of how life works and have made some very poor judgements based on their total lack of understanding of real life which does not grow in a test tube. If you believe you have all the answers to breed a perfect dog then I suggest you go do it and please report back here, we will on be on pins and needles awaiting your results.
 
Anytime you post something on a public forum you are opening yourself up to judgement.
Thats not entirely the premise this forum was built on.. The players in this thread (and another that recently popped up) really need to bring it down a notch b4 action is taken. This forum has a fantastic ignore feature i suggest a few people in this thread use it b4 its to late. Doberman Chat is the friendly Doberman Community and i intend to keep it that way. There is already a very popular doberman forum dedicated to member bashing and a multitude of other aggressive tendencies.. Its our goal to be different and always has been.. Love me or hate me it is my job and i take it seriously..
 
You are missing a vital point. It isn't about the money. A good breeder will sell a pup at a reasonable price, not too much not too little. Just enough to offset the expense of health testing the parents, training the parents, and creating and raising the litter. None of that is cheap, that is why the pups from a good breeder are over $1000. You forget that it isn't really a business as it isn't about making money. It is about bettering the breed.

Does not breed dogs younger than age 2. Has breeding stock x-rayed to check for hip dysplasia, echo/doppler run for SAS, holtered within the last year for boxer cardiomyopathy (also known as ARVC) and thyroid screened. Can produce certification to prove claims.
I agree what you said after all if i were to breed my dogs all their shots are going to run $200 at least ears $600 at my vet, feeding them $100 ish till they are old enough to go to home. so really for $1000 pup i wouldnt even make anything. oh and i forgot to add the tests for everything haha so id be in the hole
 
This reminds me of a time last year when my close friend was looking for a cattle dog. She is an avid trail rider and cattle dogs are very popular around here. We looked at a few nice litters and she placed a deposit on a lovely female puppy from a reputable and notable local working line breeder. (AKC reg and participation in agility, plus health cert and great temps). I don't know what bug crawled up her behind, she thought it would be a good idea to look at a BYB for comparison. I like to rescue, so it has been a matter of keeping a sharp eye out for the breed and making sure that the temperament is going to fit with our family. Anyways... I came along and OMG I can tell you that I wanted to knock the "breeder" out and take all of her dogs with me.

First off... her sire was obviously not purebred, although she advertised the pups as being so. I suspected a heeler crossed with lab or pit bull by the way his head was shaped. He was in a makeshift kennel on the side of the building and spent the entire two minutes we stood looking at him lunging, growling and barking his head off. The BYB offered to let him loose... we declined :)

The bitch and the pups were housed in a small dirt floor kennel on the other side of the building. She had the bottom portion of a plastic dog house and a ratty old pillow as a bed. The pups were about 4 weeks old and were crawling around in the dirt and were completely filthy. God only knows what is in that dirt, as the lady proudly told us that she had last winter built two horse stalls out of field fencing in that very location.

We obliged and talked with the breeder for a good 30 minutes. She was loose with telling her life story and how she breeds this pair a "few times a year" in order to help support her horses (she had 13 at that time). She was also breeding her 4 mares...

It was a very educational experience and I have since seen three litters out of that very same pair on ebay classifieds! Although the lure of a less expensive dog will drive people to buy from a BYB, the consequences of purchasing a pup with an aggressive sire, living in unsanitary conditions and having god knows what health issues... is most certainly not worth whatever you save in a purchase price. Ultimately, my friend kept her hold on the female puppy and they have had many happy trail rides this summer.

As far as Doberman pups are concerned... a BYbred pup will run you between $500 - $900 here in the Willamette Valley.
 
Please don't forget the cost of ear crops as that is a major factor with each puppy. BYB put all that money into their pocket insteady of decent ear crops. I have seen numberos With the things we are facing today we must present this breed per the standard and that is c/d so breeders need to do their WHOLE job not just the breeding part but also all other stuff that makes up the complete package.
 
If it weren't for backyard breeders no one would have any dog worth having. Seems most doberman owners wanna show dog...in reality most pet owners just want a companion. This is my experience in a "ghetto" location of San Diego.

For example I got Maze from an animal shelter. Don't know if she was backyard bred or reputable breeder. Point is I got my dream dog and it didn't cost me a used car or a new bike or a mortgage or months of groceries.

At the end of the day everyone in this forum got a doberman they love and care for.
 
Seems most doberman owners wanna show dog...in reality most pet owners just want a companion.
It's a good thing then that reputable breeders create great companion dogs first and that 100% of their dogs make great pets. ;) Not all puppies from a litter out of a reputable breeder are show quality. Im sorry, I truly understand that there are people that cannot afford the money that it takes to pay for a breeder that puts the time, research, and health testing behind a litter but if it weren't for BYBs we wouldn't have to euthanize dogs because of overcrowded shelters. It's not cheap to own a dog, free or not. It's a lifetime commitment of health care, food, and training costs. The price tag won't change any of that. Fortunately, there are breeds that don't need as much health testing and are a bit more affordable with a bit of money set aside each month.
 
Hello, I'm new to this chat board and I'm just curious. I belong to a couple of Doberman groups on FB, boy was it a mistake. You talk about backyard breeders, damn. They are actually breeding Z factor dogs! They brag about the color assortments they have, "cream"? Why are they breeding for cream dogs?! They are Z factor dogs. Am I getting too old and not with the times anymore or is this acceptable?
 
Hello, I'm new to this chat board and I'm just curious. I belong to a couple of Doberman groups on FB, boy was it a mistake. You talk about backyard breeders, damn. They are actually breeding Z factor dogs! They brag about the color assortments they have, "cream"? Why are they breeding for cream dogs?! They are Z factor dogs. Am I getting too old and not with the times anymore or is this acceptable?

They breed them because they can sell them for more $$$ and that's what it's all about with BYB. It is wildly unacceptable and most of these dogs have several health issues.
 
I hear ya! Greeders know that most everyone wants a puppy, it’s all about supply and demand. They lack integrity, compassion and the love needed to breed. It's all about the money and only about the money. They're irresponsible and heartless.
The only way BYB’s will stop is with buyers educating themselves, putting in the time and effort and doing their homework. Unfortunately society are enabling back yard breeders, it’s very sad.

If you’ve come from a rant, you’re in the right place. Welcome to DCF!
 
Here I go... I am poking the bear...

What would you classify a breeder that health tests, keeps the dogs and pups in good conditions and is willing to take the puppies back... but has had no interest or even time for shows/events? Their spouse works and they stay home taking care of kids/dogs. Is this still a BYB?
 
What would you classify a breeder that health tests, keeps the dogs and pups in good conditions and is willing to take the puppies back... but has had no interest or even time for shows/events? Their spouse works and they stay home taking care of kids/dogs. Is this still a BYB?
My personal idea of reputable is they do all you describe plus are involved in sports or show, and have a goal in mind of producing better puppies of that breed. If you don't show or trial (which is the opinion of a neutral 3rd party observing your dog) how else would a breeder know they are producing better puppies and continuing the breeds reputation for what it represents? Clearly there are companion dogs for homes that have no interest in show or sports and I can see people breeding "just for pets, so no show/sport is needed to prove them". This is where it can go south in a hurry depending on the size of the kennel. You have one litter a year from your old favorite girl who is a stable sweetheart and a nice looking dog - that's one thing. If you have 3 or 4 bitches and 1 or 2 dogs and have litters several times a year? Even if the physical testing is done, DNA and OFA, how are you helping the breed? How do you choose dams and sires if you don't know what they excel at? And how do you match temperaments if parents aren't tested in public around strangers? How do you find out what the puppies are looking like as 2 & 3 year olds?

I know that the price of puppies from reputable breeders is completely out of range for many people. Training, trialing & showing is incredibly expensive. Not everyone can, not everyone wants to, but it does help shape the breed and your puppies will answer whether, as a breeder, if you are doing things right.
 

Back
Top