• Disclaimer: Hello Guest, Doberman Chat Forums presents the opinions and material on these pages as a service to its membership and to the general public but does not endorse those materials, nor does it guarantee the accuracy of any opinions or information contained therein. The opinions expressed in the materials are strictly the opinion of the writer and do not represent the opinion of, nor are they endorsed by, Doberman Chat Forums. Health and medical articles are intended as an aid to those seeking health information and are not intended to replace the informed opinion of a qualified Veterinarian.”

Backyard Breeder vs Reputable Breeder

  • Thread starter Thread starter FredC
  • Start date Start date

Absolutely and I am a Cadillac girl all the way. They are just so much more car so much more comfortable and lots of bells and whistles - When workng I always drove an Cadillac Eldorado - surround sound moon roof leather interior YUM. I still miss them. I think I had a love affair with everyone I drove. Same with my Dobermans. That's why we have pedigree dogs - We don't want just any old mutt. It goes against the very prinicple of what a purebred dog is all about - it is for the discriminateing.

Dobermans are the Cadillac of dogs so they are not cheap and they are not for the chinzy.

I too am a Cadillac driver and was most of my adult life. My wife would tell you that I miss my Caddys very much, but I can no longer get into one of them due to my disability. I now drive a Dodge Durango because it is a perfect fit for my needs and that is where the value lays. I too have leather, moon roof, Bose surround sound, everything electric including the mirrors and seats with heaters and 100k miles without a hitch. Only replaced a water pump, tires and the usual fluids. The Durango is also a purebred and I am all for purebred dogs, cats, mules and horses. You talk to me as if I am against reputable breeders and the truth is...I am all for them as long as they represent themselves honestly. I will assure you that I am not against making lots of money and great profits. I sold Real Estate in Washington, Nevada, California and Arizona. I worked out of an independent office because we refused to be dictated to by Corporate Offices that knew little to nothing about our business. We excelled in both the housing industry and the commercial markets. My father and I purchased and trained AQHA cutting horses & reining prospects. So I understand purebreds and good pedigrees. We even had a few Arabians on the property. Yep, I do understand the need for high quality pedigrees and I appreciate the work you and others in this Forum do. Yeah....I miss my Caddys too.
 
Absolutely and I am a Cadillac girl all the way. They are just so much more car so much more comfortable and lots of bells and whistles - When workng I always drove an Cadillac Eldorado - surround sound moon roof leather interior YUM. I still miss them. I think I had a love affair with everyone I drove. Same with my Dobermans. That's why we have pedigree dogs - We don't want just any old mutt. It goes against the very prinicple of what a purebred dog is all about - it is for the discriminateing.

Dobermans are the Cadillac of dogs so they are not cheap and they are not for the chinzy.
While I see your point and agree about Caddy,but this isn't always the case.Dealers often include something they call "added market value"
Case in point,the PT Cruizer.When they came out there was much press,but I hadn't seen one in person.I was expecting something bigger I guess.All the adds etc reported a 15,500-16,000 dollar car.We go check them out and sticker is 25-27K! I read down the list,and ask the sales rep WTF is this? "Added market value",he says. "It's what people are willing to pay for this car right now." I said maybe but I sure as hell aint paying that.Paying that much more didn't make the car any better.
Go look at a new Challenger, Camaro,or Mustang with all the options,and special packages today,you will find the same deal.
Laughed my ass off a few years later when people were trying to dump that pos PT and asking 17K when,after the newness of the model wore off,and you could go to any dealer and get a brand new one for......17Ksticker:)

And uh,less the leather I didn't want anyways,my Dodge ram has all the stuff your caddy did,and could tow 3 caddys on a trailer to boot:D:DYes that was a jab,Tiger;):D
 
And,D4E,you would love my Father in law,Caddy every couple years.He's 84? now,a couple years back he had an XLR,and was saying how some punk on the freeway was messing with him in his "Jap car":Dand he spanked the kid.My wife and a couple of her sisters were like:eek:Dad!

He says "What? I kept it under 140":DShoulda seen their faces after that,there is no emoticon to describe it:D
He's rolling a CTS now:cool:
 
While I see your point and agree about Caddy,but this isn't always the case.Dealers often include something they call "added market value"
Case in point,the PT Cruizer.When they came out there was much press,but I hadn't seen one in person.I was expecting something bigger I guess.All the adds etc reported a 15,500-16,000 dollar car.We go check them out and sticker is 25-27K! I read down the list,and ask the sales rep WTF is this? "Added market value",he says. "It's what people are willing to pay for this car right now." I said maybe but I sure as hell aint paying that.Paying that much more didn't make the car any better.
Go look at a new Challenger, Camaro,or Mustang with all the options,and special packages today,you will find the same deal.
Laughed my ass off a few years later when people were trying to dump that pos PT and asking 17K when,after the newness of the model wore off,and you could go to any dealer and get a brand new one for......17Ksticker:)

And uh,less the leather I didn't want anyways,my Dodge ram has all the stuff your caddy did,and could tow 3 caddys on a trailer to boot:D:DYes that was a jab,Tiger;):D

:lmao: I'm sure she loved it.:D
 
I'd tend to regard Dobermans more as the Mercedes-Benz of dogs, with 25+ year old MB cars in mind. The luxury of a MB was understated, they're easily recognizable but they never needed outrageous body styles or gargantuan size to make a statement. You knew the beauty was more than skin deep; those cars could handle taxi service in 3rd world countries. It may sound kind of silly, but I have never come across another make of vehicle that has such a solid, precise, and satisfying click when you open or close the doors. It's the little things that tell you the elegance of those cars is in their pragmatism, and at their heart they were made to work. That's why I still have my 29 year old 300D, even though I haven't driven it in years because it's "not a motorcycle" and "not cargo or 4x4 snow vehicle". It's a shame that the current MB lineup doesn't really seem to live-up to their old standard of quality.

Those Germans, they know how to engineer dogs and cars. :D

More on-topic, though...

I tend to trust farmer/rancher types more than any other type of breeder. The good ones are priceless.

They know what quality looks like and what is superficial, and don't get too hung-up on things that don't matter.
They have a good understanding of animal husbandry, usually thanks to the experience of their ancestors, an upbringing around animals, and involvement with 4-H & state fairs.
They know that competitive titles aren't everything, and they don't spend vast amounts of time earning titles. They possess an understanding of the relevance of competition.
They do understand that an animal that isn't completely up-to-spec in terms of being able to do what it was bred to & capable of competing for those titles is a failure on their part.
Their animals are their livelihood, so they treat them right.
Their animals do know how to work because they all have jobs.
They aren't out to make a name for themselves or change the world, just to produce high-quality animals and/or produce to the best of their abilities.
They know how to run a business, providing a fair price for the level of quality, they understand the value of their work and they don't work for free, but they don't gouge either.
Their customers are their livelihood too, so they treat them ethically and honestly.
They don't treat their customers like stupid children by telling you what you can and can't do with the animals you purchase from them, but they will turn away idiots who don't have their heads on straight.
They don't try to dazzle you with signs of luxury or refinement, what you see is good, solid, and functional, but without many frills. They have no problem showing you around their facilities, but also don't trip over themselves to brag and show them off, either.

Those are mostly ideals, and not everyone lives up to all those things all the time. The more characteristics along these lines I observe, though, the more likely someone is to pass my screening.
 
God, I would rather spend the money on a puppy from a reputable breeder that has studied pedigrees, have done the health testing and will be supportive and be their when I need them. Spend the money for a puppy and YES no guarantees but I know as a puppy owner I have a
Puppy that has been socialized, healthy and the best chance of life.

Buy a puppy from a BYB and ya, got a deal, NOT! It's amazing how the vet bills and heartache add up quickly and where is the breeder, not there for you!

I disagree with every reputable breeder started out as a BYB. Not true! I have had Dobermans for over twenty years, belong to the Doberman Pinscher club of Canada, the Doberman Pinscher club of British Columbia, the Canadian Kennel Club and the Prince George Kennel Club. I have shown my dogs for fifteen years and have a passion for Dobermans and this is a big part of my life. I am planning a breeding with one of my girls in the near future and have spent the time and money to do it correctly. I'm a registered breeder and have spent thousands of dollars health testing and showing.

I can't stop anybody from buying a cute puppy from some BYB but maybe somebody will read this and think the five hundred dollar puppy in the newspaper isn't really such a good deal. It's heartbreaking when something happens and their is no support from your breeder. I'm talking about DCM, Cancer, wobblers, etc.

If you can't afford to pay 1000 to 2500 dollars for a puppy then it might be a wake up call when something goes wrong and you have the vet bills to deal with. Having a puppy is a responsibility and you need to have finances put away for emergencies. They are part of your family.
 
They know what quality looks like and what is superficial, and don't get too hung-up on things that don't matter. Beauty only is sueprficial and so good breeders know you have to study the standard to breed to the total dog - conformation,, temperament, working ability and health. So it all matters.


They have a good understanding of animal husbandry, usually thanks to the experience of their ancestors, an upbringing around animals, and involvement with 4-H & state fairs. OK

They know that competitive titles aren't everything, and they don't spend vast amounts of time earning titles. They possess an understanding of the relevance of competition.
Competitive titles aren't everything but it is how you compete and prove what you have learned. Anyone who has not earned titles is sadly lacking in some very vital informaiton about our breed. You don't learn it by osmosis.


They do understand that an animal that isn't completely up-to-spec in terms of being able to do what it was bred to & capable of competing for those titles is a failure on their part.
Really??? Mother nature can sure throw you some curves and you must understand genetic to have a hope of even coming out good. If you feel it a failure then breeding is not for you. Even the best dogs do no always resproduce themselves. That one made me luagh.

Their animals are their livelihood, so they treat them right. Sorry we treat them right because we love them and have a great passion for a particular breed. We treasure all that they teach us and bring into our lives.

Their animals do know how to work because they all have jobs. UGH you mean they compete???

They aren't out to make a name for themselves or change the world, just to produce high-quality animals and/or produce to the best of their abilities.
You are kidding right??? Of course we want to make a name and change the world. It goes far far beyond just producing high-quality animals. Its a passion.
They know how to run a business, providing a fair price for the level of quality, they understand the value of their work and they don't work for free, but they don't gouge either.
I don't know many who could survive or make their livelyhood out of their animals. For that you would have to throw quality out the window and breed in mass.
Their customers are their livelihood too, so they treat them ethically and honestly.
My clients become my friends and extended family, but regardless all should be treated ethically and honestly.


They don't treat their customers like stupid children by telling you what you can and can't do with the animals you purchase from them, but they will turn away idiots who don't have their heads on straight.
We have strigient contract to protect our dogs and their future as best we can from the idiots who think they should tell us how to do our own business and 90% of JQP do not have their heads on straight. They have bought into to much misinformation.

They don't try to dazzle you with signs of luxury or refinement, what you see is good, solid, and functional, but without many frills. They have no problem showing you around their facilities, but also don't trip over themselves to brag and show them off, either.
I swear I don't know where folks come up with this stuff.
 
brag and show off?? I think we or they have the right to be proud of the hard work and accomplishments. I don't consider that bragging! I have every ribbon
and award hanging in my house.
 
They know what quality looks like and what is superficial, and don't get too hung-up on things that don't matter.
Beauty only is sueprficial and so good breeders know you have to study the standard to breed to the total dog - conformation,, temperament, working ability and health. So it all matters.

Beauty? Who said anything about that? Quality. It's all those things, the whole dog, and nothing looks better quality than a clean health report, proper conformation, or a working dog or horse doing its work.

I think that's why you almost never see farmer/rancher types breeding goofy designer dog crosses, because nobody even knows what they're supposed to be good for or how they should look.

They know that competitive titles aren't everything, and they don't spend vast amounts of time earning titles. They possess an understanding of the relevance of competition.
Competitive titles aren't everything but it is how you compete and prove what you have learned. Anyone who has not earned titles is sadly lacking in some very vital informaiton about our breed. You don't learn it by osmosis.


Would you extend that to saying someone who hasn't competed in rodeo, halter, or performance events with their horses have no understanding in what makes a good working horse? Titles...many AQHA registered horses earned western pleasure riding ribbons when it was all about peanut-rolling. I'm sure those contenders learned so very much about the breed as a result of their efforts, too!

All conformation showing tells you is what the current conformation fad is in the region. Performance events are more useful, but the most useful ones are absolute certifications of ability, not just being relatively faster or better than the other animals that happened to show up that day. That's why I would think ScH titles are desirable, and think that any Doberman should be fundamentally capable of completing at least the lower tiers of those certs if sufficient effort was put into training.

They do understand that an animal that isn't completely up-to-spec in terms of being able to do what it was bred to & capable of competing for those titles is a failure on their part.
Really??? Mother nature can sure throw you some curves and you must understand genetic to have a hope of even coming out good. If you feel it a failure then breeding is not for you. Even the best dogs do no always resproduce themselves. That one made me luagh.

You don't seem to be very comfortable when it comes to owning failures. Only a hack blames the tools, in this case, breeders use "mother nature" as the primary tool in their trade. It won't always go as planned, but that doesn't mean it's not a failing of yours if you orchestrated it. That's not to say that you're a failure (gotta differentiate between "experiencing a failure" and "being a failure") or that you don't have an excellent success rate in what you do; folks on here who have purchased puppies from you appear to be quite satisfied. I'm saying that owning the occasional failure and scrutinizing yourself is how you learn and improve.

Also, I simply said "competition", not "winning the title". Being able to compete means that an animal, with competent training, could do its intended work well enough to succeed at it. Not every contender can be the best, but if it's not basically up-to-par, it's a failure at some level.

Their animals are their livelihood, so they treat them right.
Sorry we treat them right because we love them and have a great passion for a particular breed. We treasure all that they teach us and bring into our lives.

I see nearly every BYB speaking of those things, that's a red flag to me. I'm much more confident in folks who are a little dependent on their animals in addition to valuing their companionship. The latter is a given, if I don't see signs that someone loves their animals, I'm walking the other way.

Their animals do know how to work because they all have jobs.
UGH you mean they compete???

I mean that cattle dogs are heeling. I mean that retrievers hunt. Dobes may not have a lot of protecting to do, but they would still be trained to do it. The horses have a variety of horsey jobs. Just because someone does real work with an animal rather than contrived, choreographed work in a ring for prizes doesn't mean it's any less work.

They aren't out to make a name for themselves or change the world, just to produce high-quality animals and/or produce to the best of their abilities.
You are kidding right??? Of course we want to make a name and change the world. It goes far far beyond just producing high-quality animals. Its a passion.

Obviously, I must not be speaking of the sort of breeder that you are. That's not to disparage what you do or what your ambitions are, but I see these grand ambitions as trying to fly to the sun on wings of wax. I, personally, prefer more down-to-Earth folks in my dealings.

They know how to run a business, providing a fair price for the level of quality, they understand the value of their work and they don't work for free, but they don't gouge either.
I don't know many who could survive or make their livelyhood out of their animals. For that you would have to throw quality out the window and breed in mass.


A lot of modest profits from a variety of agricultural sources is a livelihood. A deliberately unprofitable endeavor is, by definition, a hobby, and the person doing it, an amateur. A great hay supplier I had up to about 20 years ago (when the brothers, who were rather elderly at that point, retired from farming) had a name synonymous with top quality cattle dogs. I didn't even know that until folks I referred their way mentioned they, and their extended family around the area, were known for the dogs. I think the crops were the biggest source of income, but the dogs and cattle were what kept things going in the years that weren't so great for planted crops.

Their customers are their livelihood too, so they treat them ethically and honestly.
My clients become my friends and extended family, but regardless all should be treated ethically and honestly.

Then that would be something you have in common with my preferred type of breeder. BYBs and Greeders (love that term) don't seem to care about things like this, and that's what makes them bad.

They don't treat their customers like stupid children by telling you what you can and can't do with the animals you purchase from them, but they will turn away idiots who don't have their heads on straight.
We have strigient contract to protect our dogs and their future as best we can from the idiots who think they should tell us how to do our own business and 90% of JQP do not have their heads on straight. They have bought into to much misinformation.

The concept of contracts and limited registrations is foreign to me. Then again, I don't understand the majority of dog owners either. It's obviously up to you to do what you think you need to in order to protect people from their own stupidity, or protect your own interests, or whatever is going on. Must be the sorts of farm types I'm used to, I find it hard to fathom people breeding & raising dogs without a compelling motive to do so, or doing it haphazardly. It's too much work and investment to take such things lightly, and failures (i.e., the out-of-spec working animals that can't do their fundamental jobs) are not only a drain on resources, but they damage reputations.

They don't try to dazzle you with signs of luxury or refinement, what you see is good, solid, and functional, but without many frills. They have no problem showing you around their facilities, but also don't trip over themselves to brag and show them off, either.
I swear I don't know where folks come up with this stuff.

I've seen a few of the websites from fancier kennels with the manicured lawns, wrought-iron fences, fine concrete runs, and heated kennel facilities. There were also those hilarious "glamour" shots of that Lana woman a couple of weeks ago, and those silly people who were showing off their big powerboat on their puppy-sales website. I'm obviously not referring to you, just those bad examples that are extremely commercial or extremely bling.
 
brag and show off?? I think we or they have the right to be proud of the hard work and accomplishments. I don't consider that bragging! I have every ribbon
and award hanging in my house.

...the facilities. Not accomplishments. Would you buy a puppy from someone because they had an $80,000 kennel building that the animals all lived in? Or it had a full-time gardener to manicure the lawns? I just don't see such things as selling-points, maybe just the opposite, because I'd rather see a dog that is part of a family than kept in a kennel. Living conditions are important, but I find too much flaunting of wealth to be extremely off-putting.
 
Omg, no unless I liked the breeding and approved of the sire and dam and the health testing that has been documented. And yes the way the puppies have been raised

I have see byb Doberman puppies kept in an open face horse shelter in -20 c so I know what the other side of the spectrum entails

Most of us don't have the grand houses and are not rolling around in dollar bills but have a nice clean home to raise puppies. I consider myself middle class if I have to be judged financially.

I'm trying to figure out what is making you so judgmental.
I celebrate reputable breeders for working blood sweat and tears to finally have the opportunity to have a healthy litter of puppies.

I also question your statement on conformation and the flavor of the day. There is a standard in what a judge looks at judging in conformation. To an outsider or someone that has not experienced showing it seem very easy to do. You need to train your dog at a very young age and work hard to be a success in the ring.

I have a house where my dogs live with me. They take up all the space on the couch and constantly under foot and I can't remember the last time I had a bath without faces staring at me.

My best advice is not to judge breeders by one experience or think we are all the same. There are good reputable breeders that actually care about what they produce.



Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk
 
I'd tend to regard Dobermans more as the Mercedes-Benz of dogs, with 25+ year old MB cars in mind. The luxury of a MB was understated, they're easily recognizable but they never needed outrageous body styles or gargantuan size to make a statement. You knew the beauty was more than skin deep; those cars could handle taxi service in 3rd world countries. It may sound kind of silly, but I have never come across another make of vehicle that has such a solid, precise, and satisfying click when you open or close the doors. It's the little things that tell you the elegance of those cars is in their pragmatism, and at their heart they were made to work. That's why I still have my 29 year old 300D, even though I haven't driven it in years because it's "not a motorcycle" and "not cargo or 4x4 snow vehicle". It's a shame that the current MB lineup doesn't really seem to live-up to their old standard of quality.

Those Germans, they know how to engineer dogs and cars. :D

More on-topic, though...

I tend to trust farmer/rancher types more than any other type of breeder. The good ones are priceless.

They know what quality looks like and what is superficial, and don't get too hung-up on things that don't matter.
They have a good understanding of animal husbandry, usually thanks to the experience of their ancestors, an upbringing around animals, and involvement with 4-H & state fairs.
They know that competitive titles aren't everything, and they don't spend vast amounts of time earning titles. They possess an understanding of the relevance of competition.
They do understand that an animal that isn't completely up-to-spec in terms of being able to do what it was bred to & capable of competing for those titles is a failure on their part.
Their animals are their livelihood, so they treat them right.
Their animals do know how to work because they all have jobs.
They aren't out to make a name for themselves or change the world, just to produce high-quality animals and/or produce to the best of their abilities.
They know how to run a business, providing a fair price for the level of quality, they understand the value of their work and they don't work for free, but they don't gouge either.
Their customers are their livelihood too, so they treat them ethically and honestly.
They don't treat their customers like stupid children by telling you what you can and can't do with the animals you purchase from them, but they will turn away idiots who don't have their heads on straight.
They don't try to dazzle you with signs of luxury or refinement, what you see is good, solid, and functional, but without many frills. They have no problem showing you around their facilities, but also don't trip over themselves to brag and show them off, either.

Those are mostly ideals, and not everyone lives up to all those things all the time. The more characteristics along these lines I observe, though, the more likely someone is to pass my screening.

A very good post. May I add that they risk more than money...they risk their lives every day. The cattle business and breeding and training horses to work cattle is dangerous stuff. Everyone in the business accepts the risks or gets out.
 
To me the dogs are worth it. I'm middle class, and I'll be honest saving 1500-2500 for a quality dog does not take that long. I agree with others if you can not afford the initial cost, how can you afford proper health care, food, toys, bedding... In my short time with my puppies I can guarantee you I have already spent more than my purchase price making sure they have every luxury I can afford. Just don't tell my girlfriend that. She already thinks I'm crazy for what all I do with my dogs.
 
First we were talking about dogs not horses and the two are very very different- haivng bred AQHA and APHA horses and campaigned our stallion to Reserve World Champion as a 2 years old winning many jackpot ropings I do know a little of which I speak. But you can't suddenly throw in livestock like horses and cows and compare it to dogs. They are vastly different.

I have no problem speaking of the things that did not work out quite like I wanted but I don't take myself outback and beat myself over the head as you imply one should. I use it as a tool to learn from and try to figure out why it did not work like planned. Unlike some who just want to throw around a lot of blame when they have never been down in the trenches and don't know of wht they speak because they are sadly lacking in some very vital information.

The concept of contracts and limited registrations is foreign to me. Then again, I don't understand the majority of dog owners either. It's obviously up to you to do what you think you need to in order to protect people from their own stupidity, or protect your own interests, or whatever is going on. Must be the sorts of farm types I'm used to, I find it hard to fathom people breeding & raising dogs without a compelling motive to do so, or doing it haphazardly. It's too much work and investment to take such things lightly, and failures (i.e., the out-of-spec working animals that can't do their fundamental jobs) are not only a drain on resources, but they damage reputations.

That is clear that you do not have a solid understanding of how or what the purebred dog world is really all about, hence the misconceptions. The compelling motive is passion for a breed and the desire to strive to produce the perfect example of that breed.

As good breeder we don't have to shoult from the roof tops about how great our dogs are - they prove themselves everyday in the field and I find it ridiculous that you say Dobermans don't "display" their work everday as there is not always a threat for them to step up to. So little understanding of this breed - sad

but I see these grand ambitions as trying to fly to the sun on wings of wax.

So you have no passions or things you truly care about and strive to accomplish in life - truly sad. It may be trying to fly on the wings of wax but at least I try and therefore work to fulfil my job on this earth as a productive, honorable citizen and human being. Too many today suffer from depression or tunr to drugs or alcohol because they have never learned to strive for better things but hope someone will come and take care of them. They have no passion in their lives.
 
Omg, no unless I liked the breeding and approved of the sire and dam and the health testing that has been documented. And yes the way the puppies have been raised

I have see byb Doberman puppies kept in an open face horse shelter in -20 c so I know what the other side of the spectrum entails

Most of us don't have the grand houses and are not rolling around in dollar bills but have a nice clean home to raise puppies. I consider myself middle class if I have to be judged financially.

I'm trying to figure out what is making you so judgmental.
I celebrate reputable breeders for working blood sweat and tears to finally have the opportunity to have a healthy litter of puppies.

I also question your statement on conformation and the flavor of the day. There is a standard in what a judge looks at judging in conformation. To an outsider or someone that has not experienced showing it seem very easy to do. You need to train your dog at a very young age and work hard to be a success in the ring.

I have a house where my dogs live with me. They take up all the space on the couch and constantly under foot and I can't remember the last time I had a bath without faces staring at me.

My best advice is not to judge breeders by one experience or think we are all the same. There are good reputable breeders that actually care about what they produce.

Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk

I'm only judgemental when it comes to people who don't seem to have their priorities straight-- everyone has their motivations and skill levels, not everyone is made of money.

I just have more trust in the middle-class or established folks who are anchored to their land than someone who flaunts wealth. All breeders are not the same, I'm just kind of drawing a distinction that not every breeder is the worst BYB, nor are they the ones with lofty aspirations who may linebreed and focus primarily on competitions. It's my personal preference to look to folks who know the value of hard work and how priceless a working animal is. Reputable breeders are definitely in the ballpark.

Re: conformation-- well, there wouldn't be "Mexican Dobes" and "European Dobes" and "American Dobes" which are all fairly distinct styles if there wasn't a flavor-of-the-year/region when it comes to judging. That's why I made a reference to the peanut-rolling fad in western pleasure show horses. It's awkward, stupid, and ultimately probably detrimental, but there was a span of time when that's what judges thought was somehow ideal. Judges project their ideas on the competitors, especially if everything isn't spelled-out precisely.
 
I must have missed something


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk
Nothing serious and no big deal.. I just had to delete a page of unrelated beer chat.. I feel this thread has good educational merit and should stay that way.. Nothing wrong with a little off topic chit chat here and there but this particular one went way off in to left field and needed to be cleaned up to keep the thread relevant.
----
edit: I suppose anyone is free to start a BYB Beer vs Reputable Beer thread in the off topic forum. ;)
 

Back
Top