Honeslty this is way too far out for normal comprhension. Dog breeding is considered very different because the our dogs are considered man's best friend and we have a far more intimate relationship living inside with them. We frown on "dog auctions" while some of the highest auctions in te country are for example the Keenland horse sale. Dog people (good dog breeders) would never put their dogs in an autcion.
I would beg to differ, humans have every bit the enchanted relationship with horses as with dogs. The primary difference is just that owning a horse is out of reach for most folks, but most folks who want to can have a dog. While some of the quality youngsters and breeding stock do well in auction, the thought that older and lame horses might wind-up in auctions, being sold by the pound for their flesh, is horrifying to Americans. Seems we're more concerned with the fate of unwanted horses than unwanted pets.
But my point is still that the goals and techniques should be the same. Just because the consequences don't seem as heavy doesn't mean that it's a pass to slack-off and be sloppy.
You have contracts with dogs and usually you don't with horses, cattle or hay unless it is a contract to deliever XXX.
And why is that?
Again, this is my point. You shouldn't
need a health contract that essentially protects a buyer from the breeder's incompetence, which is just assumed with purebred dogs. Producing animals that are diseased, not completely capable of meeting breed standards, or to be able to do the work they were engineered to do should be the extremely rare exceptions.
As for breeding-related contracts, that's more a matter of the assumed lack of competence in purchasers, which is somewhat appropriate, but another matter altogether.
The principles of the actual breeding and genetics are the same but from there it goes an entirely different direction. with the exception horses are bred right back and kept in foal while dogs rest a year.
Best practices based on purely physiological difference aren't really part of the issue...
We test for Vwd so we know what we are breeding and it is very easy to breed now without producing any affected dogs. But in the betinning that was not so. I iwll say this as it is much like the Impressive gene - that gen while it produces a big problem also produces some of the best muscled for showing gentics out there. Does that mean we should continue to breed for it NO but that is a known fact among horse people.
So as horse breeders they try to find a way to keep the go while eliminating the bad which you seem to think can just be thrown out the window on a whim.
Form over function... Color-horse breeders, halter show breeders, dog breeders, all are typically cut from the same cloth. It takes some sort of willful and stubborn ineptitude to think that way. That's why you see all the worst diseases in those animals.
What good is muscle when it can't be exercised to a good lather without the horse collapsing from non-cerebral seizures? There is no good whatsoever in that, and I don't think I'm alone in thinking what halter horses were looking like by the 90s were pretty hideous...extreme bodybuilder types of hideous. There's having a nice, ripped physique, and then there's grotesque hypertrophy. That's a matter of personal opinion though. The reason Impressive's genes were so popular was because of the sheer laziness in the halter show crowd, who wanted huge muscles in their horses without having to put in the work to build them. It's essentially juicing-by-proxy.
Even in the best quality performance horses, you don't see the sort of absurd linebreeding that you see the halter showing idiots performing. Three Bars himself appeared in Impressive's pedigree no fewer than 3 times, in that one of his grand-daughters (who also one of his great-grand-daughters) was bred to one of his sons to produce Impressive. Good Lord, I've seen worse inbreeding in a pedigree, but I can't remember when, probably in a Dobe pedigree that I rejected. And just think of all the subsequent halter pedigrees in which Impressive himself appeared over and over and over such that homozygous descendants for his one defective gene were dropping dead frequently enough that people noticed a correlation. Should it come as any surprise that halter horses, even in a plain breed like AQHA, would turn out to be a disease-infested genetic cesspool in an otherwise exceptionally healthy breed?
I say this as someone who has horses from popular performance lines. IMHO, there has never been a finer Quarter Horse than Leo. Three Bars was super fine too, as were many of his descendants. Then you have your Moons, Larks, and Jets as well. All of my horses have had pedigrees filled with these names, some have up to two different "Bars" descendants in the third rows of their pedigrees, usually on opposite sides, and that's all the more inbreeding they've had-- the closest the same name might be appearing would be 5 or 6 generations back and not on the same side of the tree. Competent breeders know that it takes a bit more effort to locate non-closely-related breeding stock that will further a specific goal, but they do the work and try their best, knowing that even if they don't get what they wanted, at least what they do get is still going to be good. Lazy, amateur breeders go for breeding close relatives to get fast and easy results, with all the predictable failures and complete disasters that come with doing so, but they rationalize the latter all away.
Of course I would breed a carrier or affected as long as it was bred to a clear if the pedigree carried something I really wanted to keep. In fact I did one such breeding 3 years ago and keep a carrier puppy that will be bred to a clear to get back to clear. Do you think if a bloodline is really strong it would be smart to just throw it out because you have to start with affected but know you can get to clear withing 2 generations???? Depth of a breeding program is very important and Vwd is important but not a ruling factor when we have a proven way to avoid producing affecteds.
So, you are planning only one breeding, and your plans are to test every puppy to make sure that carriers without any other redeeming qualities were genetic dead-ends? If so, that's a more-or-less right way of doing it, but if you're not clear after two generations, then what? More rationalizations? If not only one breeding, how many carriers are you willing to produce, and will they all be screened and prevented from propagating the defect, or will you keep making exceptions and selling carriers as breeding/show stock if they're good enough, because hey, as long as you breed them to clear, it's all okay?
Most dog breeders apparently wouldn't care to make sure the defect didn't leave their program to continue to propagate, which is why there are still z-factors floating around. It's also why HyPP will be lingering around in AQHA halter show pedigrees for decades to come, too.
Personally, yes. I would likely throw out a line based on a defect unless I was being overly sentimental, and even then, I would only keep it if I was absolutely certain I could make the defect go away and not propagate it at all. There are too many better choices out there to be so caught-up in the notion that an unproven youngster who's a carrier of a genetic disease is important enough to be considered future breeding stock. Poor choices almost always beget more regrettable choices.
Just because something looks good on paper or in a test tube does not mean it always works out the way you think not if you have a true understanding of genetics and throwbacks to something way back in a pedigree.
I really don't know if you're just caught-up in magical thinking, but it's obvious from the state of most dog breeds that you're not alone in it. There's a world of difference between an unfortunate genetic fluke, and just recklessly flailing about and causing calamities in a gene cesspool. As someone with the more conventional understanding of how animal husbandry is done, looking at the state of dog breeds, the way breeders generally do things, and all the problems they struggle with, it's kind of like watching someone who is thoroughly incompetent making repeated mistakes and then blaming chance for the predictable failure. No, the genetic disasters in the Doberman are not flukes, they're just due to egregious incompetence on the part of thousands of breeders over the course of a century. It's not going to get any better unless Doberman breeders start taking animal husbandry seriously & behave like professionals.