My little man is growing up!

I love that your dogs you are breeding have so many titles. I wish I could find a local breeder that had all of that and the health testing. I would like to have puppies available to buy and train for service dogs, but no such luck :( My friend is going to start breeding, but she wants to wait till her male is a bit older. Did you teach him the retrieve with the "ear pinch", motivational retrieve, or does he just enjoy doing it?

James loves retrieving just about anything, but has just recently started grabbing the things he is supposed to retrieve and running off with them, so back on the leash he goes for training and we are also two weeks into a motivational retrieve class....he loves it. The teacher is very knowledgeable, but I don't really like her.....oh well.

Nice work :)
 
Purlfrog you don't teach a young puppy the retireve with an ear pinch. They are babies and usually if you present things at a young age they will do it naturatlly because everything is new to them so one more things doesn't matter PLUS you have their natural desire to bite things working for you.

You won't find a young dog with all the health testing and titles because some test require the dog to be older and usually they are not trained til a little older. Most very young dogs and puppies appear to be healthy as most problems don't show up til later. That is why it is not recommended that you breed them too young. Your friend appears to have some common sense and concern for doing things correctly.
 
I think we all need to have a dobe reunion somewhere in the middle of the country!!!!! Wouldn't it be fun for evryone to actually meet all the kids we hear soooo mch about???/ I vote yes!!!!! I am up for a roadtrip!!!!!!!:beer::bump:
Absolutely, and it's definitely something we want to try to seriously coordinate to make it an event worth going to for at least a weekend getaway. I'd be in too! :thumbsup:
 
Purlfrog you don't teach a young puppy the retireve with an ear pinch. They are babies and usually if you present things at a young age they will do it naturatlly because everything is new to them so one more things doesn't matter PLUS you have their natural desire to bite things working for you.

You won't find a young dog with all the health testing and titles because some test require the dog to be older and usually they are not trained til a little older. Most very young dogs and puppies appear to be healthy as most problems don't show up til later. That is why it is not recommended that you breed them too young. Your friend appears to have some common sense and concern for doing things correctly.

Yes I understand this, there is a debate going on with a couple of trainers I know that only will do the ear pinch rearguards. So I am collecting some info on people teaching the retrieve. I have always taught the motivational retrieve or just taught during play sessions and put a command to it later. I know about the health testing too, most breeders wait till at least two to have the health testing and such done till then. I am not looking for a young dog with all the health testing, I am just looking for a breeder that does it with the dogs he/she breeds.
 
That is a super good looking puppy. :) Wowsers. :D

In regards to retrieving, in my opinion, there should not be force involved. Some dogs have the drive to work and some don't. If you have to force them with ear pinching or e-collar it will never be because the dog enjoys it and want's to please you, but because they don't want the punishment. Not the way I want to train. I think people just need to accept that their dog doesn't have the drive or that they aren't teaching it in a fun way.
 
Some dogs do retreive natuaraly and some don't like it but one of the ways a breeder test their dogs is are they willing to accept the training and work. So it is not as much about they don't like the work but if they are not exposed to the dumbbell as a young dog it is foreign to them and they resist. It has nothing to do with the drive, if they retrieve the tuggy etc then they can retrieve the dumbbell. They just have to get used to it and be trained to accept it. Willingness to train and learn is one thing a breeder wants in their dogs and is why titles are important.

As a breeder and trainer if we let our dogs decide what they will or won't do the dogs would be lost and spoiled so rotten that a lot of folks would be complaining about their out of control dogs. Training and each new thing a dog learns builds their self esteem and confidence. All dogs are far better off learning something than nothing.

Kids don't like to go to school a lot of the time I don't think you would recommend them to skip school.
 
What an amazing puppy, Immortal! Love the ear crop too! I'm sure it will look wonderful on him!

For fear of going too far off topic on this, what is this 'ear pinch'?? Yikes, it doesn't sound like anything I would want to do!
 
What an amazing puppy, Immortal! Love the ear crop too! I'm sure it will look wonderful on him!

For fear of going too far off topic on this, what is this 'ear pinch'?? Yikes, it doesn't sound like anything I would want to do!

I've heard it being used for Gundogs...this video should show you what they do to teach a forced retrieve. I haven't ever had to go this route myself so I do not have an opinion on it. I've always been able to either have a dog that was eager to retrieve or was able to make the retrieve a game and fun enough where the dog would retrieve for me.

Skip to 2:33 into the video below...

 
Folks, a forced retrieve is supposed to be a last resort. It is not ideal, its not pleasant but neither are a lot of other methods. The trainer just has to decide if it is worth it to go this route vs not getting a title. For breeding stock there may not be an option of not getting a title.
 
Suzan I must disagree with you on that. It sounds like you are saying that any dog can learn how to retrieve and be good at (or at least do) what the handler wants it to do. So why is it that some puppies in a litter are picked for working, some for showing and some for pets. Would you not agree that some dogs just don't have it in them to work regardless of what you do?

It's not just a matter of getting them to retrieve the dumbbell, they also have to want to work, have drive and be able to stay focused. It is not just a matter of the breeder doing the right work from the beginning. If that was the case any dog could be a schutzhund star regardless of breeding etc.

I have heard the reasoning before that to compete the dog needs to retrieve the dumbbell etc etc. But have none thought about that maybe they should get a dog with the right workability instead of trying to force a dog to do it that just doesn't have it in them?

It's the same with horses. If I just forced a horse to do the work I wanted it to do it certainly wouldn't be pretty. It would be a very unhappy horse. I had to sell one of my horses because he just wasn't able to do the job that I wanted him to do. He was sold as a hunter/jumper and has been very very successful at that. Just because a dog isn't going to be great at schutzhund doesn't mean it can't be great at other things. If it's so important to be competitive then it should also be important to have the right dog for the job.
 
Suzan I must disagree with you on that. It sounds like you are saying that any dog can learn how to retrieve and be good at (or at least do) what the handler wants it to do. So why is it that some puppies in a litter are picked for working, some for showing and some for pets. Would you not agree that some dogs just don't have it in them to work regardless of what you do?

It's not just a matter of getting them to retrieve the dumbbell, they also have to want to work, have drive and be able to stay focused. It is not just a matter of the breeder doing the right work from the beginning. If that was the case any dog could be a schutzhund star regardless of breeding etc.
Katja, this is done to dogs that show drive and workability in all the other venues up to that point. Some dogs just find the retrieve uncomfortable or strange. Suzan is saying that if you start with the dumbell while the puppy is young you are more likely to get the retrieve without having to resort to this method because it will not be strange or uncomfortable. It isn't about whether or not the dog have the drive because they will have already shown that or not before getting to this point.
 
Katja, this is done to dogs that show drive and workability in all the other venues up to that point. Some dogs just find the retrieve uncomfortable or strange. Suzan is saying that if you start with the dumbell while the puppy is young you are more likely to get the retrieve without having to resort to this method because it will not be strange or uncomfortable. It isn't about whether or not the dog have the drive because they will have already shown that or not before getting to this point.

I agree with this completely. Miles and Arianna love the obedience work and doing bite work. But they thought the retrieve was some weird way to torture them LOL They both hated it, even when I tried as a puppy to play with it and make it a game. Some dogs just don't like the dumbbell- AKC or Schutzhund -- until they get used to it, then it can be fun, Miles and Ari both get really excited when they see the dumbbell now- but boy it wasn't short work to get them there. But I also was not going to give up on them because it was a lot of work. I am just ecstatic that Khaos is taking to it so well and so young.
 
I've heard it being used for Gundogs...this video should show you what they do to teach a forced retrieve. I haven't ever had to go this route myself so I do not have an opinion on it. I've always been able to either have a dog that was eager to retrieve or was able to make the retrieve a game and fun enough where the dog would retrieve for me.

Skip to 2:33 into the video below...


Sorry, but that is bullS%*&. If u cant teach your dog to fetch the normal way, too bad for you...just an opinion..lol. Axl wouldnt go and get a ball or toy and retrieve for love or money..but I kept up trying to show him and now..WOW..he loves to fetch!
 
Absolutely, and it's definitely something we want to try to seriously coordinate to make it an event worth going to for at least a weekend getaway. I'd be in too! :thumbsup:

Sounds like fun...but I'd never be able to make it happen. I'll be so jealous.:groan:
 

Back
Top