• Disclaimer: Hello Guest, Doberman Chat Forums presents the opinions and material on these pages as a service to its membership and to the general public but does not endorse those materials, nor does it guarantee the accuracy of any opinions or information contained therein. The opinions expressed in the materials are strictly the opinion of the writer and do not represent the opinion of, nor are they endorsed by, Doberman Chat Forums. Health and medical articles are intended as an aid to those seeking health information and are not intended to replace the informed opinion of a qualified Veterinarian.”

Doberman Ear Crop Information

  • Thread starter Thread starter FredC
  • Start date Start date

I did see the posting section, thank you! I intend to utilize it as often as I can. Cutting with lasers made sense to me, with the healing process too. As for the boxing, I've entertained the idea going further and doing the MMA style fighting. I watched a video of a man who defended his co-worker with MMA techniques and I was thoroughly impressed. He was of course, a champion in his country so he made it look so easy. Anyway, I don't want to go off topic too much here, so if you want to talk more about the MMA stuff, (and I'd love to) send me a private message.
You and @Tad
Your MMA discussion would be a very nice addition here

https://doberman-chat.com/community/threads/home-defense-for-non-gun-owners.21124/
 
Usually those who say it is barbaric are basing that on the horror stories of some idiot who does it themselves. They have no actual knowledge of what a great crop is and how it is not barbaric at all. My puppies some home just thinking about WHERE our breakfast and we need to get out and play and play they do. That is one of the biggest reasons I feel breeders should do it themselves while the litter is still together with their littermates and in their home they are familiar with. It is a cake walk for them.
 
Usually those who say it is barbaric are basing that on the horror stories of some idiot who does it themselves. They have no actual knowledge of what a great crop is and how it is not barbaric at all. My puppies some home just thinking about WHERE our breakfast and we need to get out and play and play they do. That is one of the biggest reasons I feel breeders should do it themselves while the litter is still together with their littermates and in their home they are familiar with. It is a cake walk for them.
When you say do it themselves I assume you mean the breeder takes them to the vet,has it done,then they return to their home they are familiar and comfortable with?
Not literally do it themselves?
 
Okay, I happened upon this writing tonight. I don't think it was a published article, rather I get the feeling it was a blog post or some other less formal electronic piece of writing. The website where I found it, a respected Doberman breeder's website, said they received permission to share it. Hope it's not a faux pas to share it here, but it's very relevant and backs up one of my stated reasons for supporting cropping. I feel the writer takes it a bit far in how she definitively states the home was protected because the Dobermans were cropped, but I agree with her message.

Below is what was written by Elaine Greenwood:

The public’s reaction to ear cropping has changed over the six decades that I have owned, bred and shown cropped dogs. People, including vets, and most especially young children, are now outright accusatory, asserting that ear cropping is cruel etc. We used to take the time to show them that the cropped ears are completely healed and are not painful. If we had a puppy, we carefully explained that the taping is merely to help the ear to stand, and that cropping is a surgical procedure, done by licensed medical professionals, in a medical setting, with proper anesthesia, pain meds and monitoring, and palliative after care, really not much different than a circumcision, ear piercing, braces, rhinoplasty or other elective cosmetic procedure. But it’s hard to condense all of that into a catchy jingle or 2-second sound bite message. So lately I have a new tack, grounded in the Constitution, with a nod to the NRA.

Most Americans believe in some version of the natural right of self-defense; most believe in the right to bear arms. My choice of self-protection or “arms” is a protective dog. Without question there are breeds that are larger, stronger and more aggressive than a Doberman, breeds that are not necessarily compelling because of how they look, but rather because, if push comes to shove, these breeds can do significant bodily harm. These sorts of breeds are of no interest to me. I do not want a breed that is only a strong deterrent after the fact, after bodily harm has been inflicted. I do not want the litigation resulting from a dog bite, even a provoked dog bite. These fierce breeds are too much responsibility to own and house properly, and some are belligerent, living to please themselves, rather than living to please me.

What I want is an intelligent, loving and devoted breed of dog that does not have to go to the extreme of physical contact in order to be effective protection for me and my property. I want a breed that is protective, with the least risk to me, to the dog and to the general public. I want a dog that comes across as more fierce than he/she actually is. And that dog, that protection, is a cropped Doberman. The intensity of the look of a cropped Doberman, when aroused, is unmistakable. The cropped look, in and of itself, is actually a safe, harmless, extremely effective deterrent. This effective deterrent is not remotely the same with an uncropped Doberman. When an alert cropped Dobe focuses on a threat, you can almost see the pee trickling down the leg of the intruder as they back away. Over the years Arthur (who is active duty United States Air Force, with over 30 years of service to this country), has been deployed overseas, including multiple tours in both Operation Desert Strom and Operation Enduring Freedom. While Arthur has been off fighting for our country, his family and property were safe at home because we own cropped Dobermans. I have never seen a person continue forward in the face of an aroused, alert, cropped Doberman. A cropped Dobe conveys an extremely effective intensity which cuts across language and cultural barriers. A cropped Doberman is our “arms” of choice for self-protection. The cropped look, in and of itself, most effectively conveys “get the frick away from here” better than any other form of self –protection available. We have cropped Dobes that are truly pussycats, but when they are aroused and alert, the message conveyed, because of the ear crop, makes them incredibly effective (yet relatively passive) protection for our home and persons. This, btw, is the reason that cropping is integral to the Doberman breed itself. An uncropped Doberman is no more an effective deterrent than a Black and Tan Coonhound.

Ear cropping is directly related to my fundamental Constitutional rights of self-protection, and of “life, liberty [and] property” … with the very least risk to the general public. -Elaine Greenwood
 
I'm personally not a fan of the notion of having a dog that looks like it will protect but will in fact not, as Ms. Greenwood writes about. I give the bad guy more credit than that. I want be prepared for the fact that the bad guy(s) is someone who is privy to the fact that most dogs are all bark. The deterrent factor though is key.
 
Tad - Elaine knows how important temperament is in our breed. But a Doberman is not all out go get um. The doberman is a thinking breed which is one of the reasons the GSD style training cost many a good Doberman their career as a working dog. Dobermans DO assess the situation NOT just go madly to bite. The Doberman gives his warning as he much prefers to keep it civil but if push comes to shove and the warning is ignored then the picture changes. At this point it is fight or flight and fearless means no flight.

But having trained and watched many dogs train in Schutzhund I can tell you I am not impressed just because a dog stands at alert and barks its head off. That is just the beginning. The end is a whole different story and for that I want a trained dog. The Doberman is smart and wants to win. That is why so much of the training is about building the dog up to the point they feel invincible because there is a clear and present danger.

I always think of it this way - You can train a GSD (they are good foot soldiers and do what they are told) and you can heel that dog right off the cliff BUT you both die. You can train a Doberman (they think for themselves and assess the situation) and you can heel them towards the cliff but at point they are going to stop and say are you nuts that will kill us. Which dog did the best job?? Thinking is one of the biggest reasons the Dobermans lost favor as police dogs. It takes longer to train them and season them and it has to be done right. The doberman will not work for someone who is hard handed or overbearing and they will not succeed if pushed too fast too soon. They want to be an equal partner and you have to appreciate that creative mind that is always thinking.

The image of the Doberman is usually enough to deter anyone and I would much rather avoid a fight as a fight is usually life or death. Humans intent on harm are dangerous and hopefully none of us actually ever have to face that kind of fight up close and personal and neither will our dogs. But when a c/d Doberman stands at full alert and barks that is usually enough for most. No one wants to experience the other. But I can't imagine anyone being intimidated by the hound look. They are not known for aggression.
 
Tad - Elaine knows how important temperament is in our breed. But a Doberman is not all out go get um. The doberman is a thinking breed which is one of the reasons the GSD style training cost many a good Doberman their career as a working dog. Dobermans DO assess the situation NOT just go madly to bite. The Doberman gives his warning as he much prefers to keep it civil but if push comes to shove and the warning is ignored then the picture changes. At this point it is fight or flight and fearless means no flight.

But having trained and watched many dogs train in Schutzhund I can tell you I am not impressed just because a dog stands at alert and barks its head off. That is just the beginning. The end is a whole different story and for that I want a trained dog. The Doberman is smart and wants to win. That is why so much of the training is about building the dog up to the point they feel invincible because there is a clear and present danger.

I always think of it this way - You can train a GSD (they are good foot soldiers and do what they are told) and you can heel that dog right off the cliff BUT you both die. You can train a Doberman (they think for themselves and assess the situation) and you can heel them towards the cliff but at point they are going to stop and say are you nuts that will kill us. Which dog did the best job?? Thinking is one of the biggest reasons the Dobermans lost favor as police dogs. It takes longer to train them and season them and it has to be done right. The doberman will not work for someone who is hard handed or overbearing and they will not succeed if pushed too fast too soon. They want to be an equal partner and you have to appreciate that creative mind that is always thinking.

The image of the Doberman is usually enough to deter anyone and I would much rather avoid a fight as a fight is usually life or death. Humans intent on harm are dangerous and hopefully none of us actually ever have to face that kind of fight up close and personal and neither will our dogs. But when a c/d Doberman stands at full alert and barks that is usually enough for most. No one wants to experience the other. But I can't imagine anyone being intimidated by the hound look. They are not known for aggression.
You had me hovering over the "like" button,until the second to the last sentence.
 
You had me hovering over the "like" button,until the second to the last sentence.
Sometimes I think of this example: Who among us wouldn't be scared of an angry squirrel confronting us? Well, maybe not a perfect example because they're so fast and can be attached to us in a split second, so they really are menacing, not that they're usually confrontational. How about one of the smallest breeds of dogs? I'd be scared of a toy poodle that was really turning it on at me. Well shoot, maybe not a Toy Poodle. Too small. But any decent-sized dog that was truly showing aggression I'd be afraid of.

Now, what if the dog wasn't showing aggression, or even looking alert and assertive? Now, there, an intimidating appearance is key.
 
I do think it's funny that when people think my dogs ears are hurt it's actually just me posting.

I personally prefer the cropped looked because IMO you just have another hound dog/Weimaraner/Rott... Nothing distinguishes the dog for the untrained eye to see. I'm sure people who have uncropped dogs have claims of people thinking they were another breed esp. fawn colors.
 
I do think it's funny that when people think my dogs ears are hurt it's actually just me posting.

I personally prefer the cropped looked because IMO you just have another hound dog/Weimaraner/Rott... Nothing distinguishes the dog for the untrained eye to see. I'm sure people who have uncropped dogs have claims of people thinking they were another breed esp. fawn colors.
Breed misidentification is so common. For one thing people have the innate capability to be pretty clueless about basically everything. Only those things currently popular are known about by a lot of folks.

At the same time, I recognize that the most distinguishing characteristic of a Doberman is the cropped, standing ears. Without them, a Doberman probably looks to the great majority of people like some unknown, nondescript dog, save the markings. This is assuming the person has even ever seen a Doberman, which I feel like a lot of younger people have not (knowingly).

My first Doberman had some physical characteristics that strayed from the standard. He was pretty bulky and tightly-coupled with a big, wide head and shorter snout. His crop was short. Many people asked me if he was a Pitt Bull. Some asked if he was a Pitt/Dobie cross. Some asked if he was a Rottweiler even though he was a Red.

So I understand the notion that to the untrained eye, a natural Doberman might look like a black or brown Visla, GSP, Weimaraner, or just some unknown dog. The hound dog comparison is a bit off to me, although I suppose there are some hounds that are athletic.
 
I found this article in the internet and thought it pertinent to the discussion. I personally like the cropped look but can't help putting myself in the dog's place and would not like to have my ears cropped...

Dogs don’t need ear cropping. There isn't a norm that dictates that certain breeds require ear cropping. Even if show dogs may score higher if they have cropped ears, the procedure is painful and it is not necessary.
The surgery may have complications such as bleeding or the vet may cut too deep into the ear and affect the ear canal. Also, the surgery site can get infected.
A second surgery will be needed if the first surgery is not successful.
The surgery may also have long term side effects such as ear sensitivity and may become very aggressive when the ear area is touched. Seizures may appear post surgery, but only in rare cases. These side effects may occur if the procedure is not performed properly, however none of these can happen if the procedure is not performed in the first place.
Phantom pain may occur after the surgery; the dog may feel pain in the ears, even if the ears are cropped.
Dogs also use their ears to communicate; if the ears are cropped, this can affect the way the dog communicates with other dogs.
There are a lot of vets that refuse to perform the ear cropping or tail docking. A lot of animal rights fighters consider the ear cropping inhumane. Dogs are born with ears and each breed has its uniqueness.
 
I found this article in the internet and thought it pertinent to the discussion. I personally like the cropped look but can't help putting myself in the dog's place and would not like to have my ears cropped...

Dogs don’t need ear cropping. There isn't a norm that dictates that certain breeds require ear cropping. Even if show dogs may score higher if they have cropped ears, the procedure is painful and it is not necessary.
The surgery may have complications such as bleeding or the vet may cut too deep into the ear and affect the ear canal. Also, the surgery site can get infected.
A second surgery will be needed if the first surgery is not successful.
The surgery may also have long term side effects such as ear sensitivity and may become very aggressive when the ear area is touched. Seizures may appear post surgery, but only in rare cases. These side effects may occur if the procedure is not performed properly, however none of these can happen if the procedure is not performed in the first place.
Phantom pain may occur after the surgery; the dog may feel pain in the ears, even if the ears are cropped.
Dogs also use their ears to communicate; if the ears are cropped, this can affect the way the dog communicates with other dogs.
There are a lot of vets that refuse to perform the ear cropping or tail docking. A lot of animal rights fighters consider the ear cropping inhumane. Dogs are born with ears and each breed has its uniqueness.

I honestly don't think you came here for a discussion but rather to have your opinions expressed. Which is fine. But i do not agree with you in the slightest.

Have you ever cropped a dobermans ears before?

My new pup hemi is my second dobe. We was planning on getting her ears cropped by the same vet as we did with my prior dobe Bella. Well unfortunately, her ears had a very slim chance of standing & we did not proceed with the cropping. I honestly wish her ears were cropped to save her the pain of the ear infections that have happened because of the natural ears.

And with your logic, what about circumcision in babies? Is it absolutely necessary? No. Do many still do it? Absolutely. Atleast dogs are under anesthesia during the surgery!! (Not trying to get off topic here)

All in all, it's a personal preference.
 
@Dragonborn you read my mind! Baby boys don't need to be circumcised it most ppl in the US do it!

I think most people love this breed for the look! The fact that they are swayed by AR agenda upsets me. I've even had people tell me "if you wouldn't have had her ears done then she wouldn't look so aggressive" and by aggressive you mean look like a doberman bc I've never found aggressiveness liesin whether an animal is cropped or not!

If it's so devastatingly painful then my does my dog love to have me play with her ears? Why does she ask for butt rubs? Shouldn't she be devastated? Zero issues with surgery, zero complications after and the more vets do it the better the cut so shouldn't we encourage more crops do vets have more experience?
 
I found this article in the internet and thought it pertinent to the discussion. I personally like the cropped look but can't help putting myself in the dog's place and would not like to have my ears cropped...

Dogs don’t need ear cropping. There isn't a norm that dictates that certain breeds require ear cropping. Even if show dogs may score higher if they have cropped ears, the procedure is painful and it is not necessary.
The surgery may have complications such as bleeding or the vet may cut too deep into the ear and affect the ear canal. Also, the surgery site can get infected.
A second surgery will be needed if the first surgery is not successful.
The surgery may also have long term side effects such as ear sensitivity and may become very aggressive when the ear area is touched. Seizures may appear post surgery, but only in rare cases. These side effects may occur if the procedure is not performed properly, however none of these can happen if the procedure is not performed in the first place.
Phantom pain may occur after the surgery; the dog may feel pain in the ears, even if the ears are cropped.
Dogs also use their ears to communicate; if the ears are cropped, this can affect the way the dog communicates with other dogs.
There are a lot of vets that refuse to perform the ear cropping or tail docking. A lot of animal rights fighters consider the ear cropping inhumane. Dogs are born with ears and each breed has its uniqueness.
That "article" is full of untruths and inaccuracies. I'm curious as to the source, and the writer's sources.

I could go through and refute the claims, but I'm not sure it's worth it.

Regarding the circumcision comparison: That's a poignant and appropriate one. Puppies don't have a choice, nor do babies yet we have people crying out about ear cropping but not about the other. Just another example of the lunacy that is elevating animals above humans.
 
My wife and I are getting another doberman puppy. This one has her tail docked already and so we are really considering getting her ears done. I am a little concerned about the posting process after the surgery as we have never done it before. Is it really difficult? One of the vets that we have talked to includes 2 additional aftercare appointments with the cost of surgery. We want the ears to be between a medium and a show crop. We don't want them to be too big. Our new puppy was 3 weeks old yesterday so we will get her in about 4 more weeks and we are very excited!! Any suggestions on ear cropping for a first timer would be great!!! Thanks!
 

Back
Top