• Disclaimer: Hello Guest, Doberman Chat Forums presents the opinions and material on these pages as a service to its membership and to the general public but does not endorse those materials, nor does it guarantee the accuracy of any opinions or information contained therein. The opinions expressed in the materials are strictly the opinion of the writer and do not represent the opinion of, nor are they endorsed by, Doberman Chat Forums. Health and medical articles are intended as an aid to those seeking health information and are not intended to replace the informed opinion of a qualified Veterinarian.”

Doberman Ear Crop Information

  • Thread starter Thread starter FredC
  • Start date Start date

Love the cropped ears... If I have it my way, I'll always crop. Question: Why are some people soooo against cropped ears, but you don't hear as much "hype" when it comes to docking?
 
I know its a personal choice etc but the reasoning behind it makes no sense. You either do it because you like the way it looks end of story there are no real benefits to the dog except that you will feel better about it. I really don't mind if you crop and dock your dog as long as you look after it well and dont BS me on everything else.
 
kashi:

I disagree that "it is truly cosmetic when it comes down to it."

You seemed to miss most or all of my points.

I actually wrote that the ears themselves are not going to make your dog more capable of defending you (except for the less to grab onto part).

I am fully aware that a good guard dog only does so much and isn't of much use against poisoning or firearms unless they undergo very specific training. And even at that it's a big if.
 
No I read your points but most dog breeds were bred with form as well as function in mind. Meaning looks and confirmation were often more important then the dogs ability to preform its task. This tradition continues, just look at the ridiculous modern show GSDs with their slanting top lines and useless back legs.

The Black russian terrier is a good case in point it was bred as Stalin's military dog and confirmation was not important at all as long as it had the right temperament and build to do its job only when it had to registered with the kennel clubs that and effort was made to make the dog conform to a standard.

All I am saying is that temperament seems to escape most discussions on workablity but some how cropped ears are more important. Its crazy how shallow us humans are.
 
Which reminds me that while yes the most popular military/working dog at the moment, the belgian malinois, may have naturally erect ears it does have its full tail. I have read and spoken to K9 Trainers and for them cropping docking etc is nowhere near important as temperament. Weight and agility is a close second.

All I am saying is crop your dogs ears if it makes you feel better but don't expect to do much for the dog.
 
Kashi:

That's a good point re the Malinois and its tail.

I recognize that when you look at the whole picture, ear cropping is relatively unimportant in terms of your dog's working ability.

But that's what the thread is about.

Probably the point of most importance is the cropped Dobe's appearance being a deterrent. Now when it comes to the types of attacks you're talking about, no it cropping doesn't matter.

For a lot of people with evil intent or potential, the appearance of a dog does matter. Many people still believe/feel the stigma and legend regarding Dobermans. If they see a tough-looking Dobe, they're going to be all the more hesitant to try anything.

We had an American Bulldog / Pittbull. That dog got a lot of respect around the city in which I currently live. She basically looks like a big Pitt. That type of dog is feared around here. My dog's appearance added to her deterrent factor. We're talking muggings, robberies, or home invasions by someone who has been observing your home. Not someone gassing your home.
 
I can somewhat related to what Tad said. My dog is a big goof. But I've had people go out of their way to avoid him. And I have a had a few folks comment on how "mean" looking he is. I just laugh.

And on the flip side, when I'm out with my friend and her natural ear girl it is very opposite. We take her out in public and people come up from all over. Is this a ....lab, mix, hound dog, etc and then they hear no it is a doberman their jaw drops.

So looks can be a detterant and I understand that was one of the functions as well as loyal protector this breed originated because of.

I personally have only grown up around C/D Dobies. I prefer the C/D look.

However I love the breed and could never own anything else. If it became illegal to have a C/D, then I would have a natural over having no dobie at all.
 
Which reminds me that while yes the most popular military/working dog at the moment, the belgian malinois, may have naturally erect ears it does have its full tail. I have read and spoken to K9 Trainers and for them cropping docking etc is nowhere near important as temperament. Weight and agility is a close second.

All I am saying is crop your dogs ears if it makes you feel better but don't expect to do much for the dog.
What about the dogs ability to "aim" it's ear at a sound?I believe a cropped dog has an edge over a non cropped dog.
As to military dogs..why weren't Kurt or any of the other Doberman dogs of the Pacific theater WWII natural ears?image.webp
 
What about the dogs ability to "aim" it's ear at a sound?I believe a cropped dog has an edge over a non cropped dog.
As to military dogs..why weren't Kurt or any of the other Doberman dogs of the Pacific theater WWII natural ears?View attachment 36464
Honestly, I think there are two answers to your question. First people were less sissified back then. There wasn't all of this AR bull crap to deal with in the 1940s. Second, they were more into withholding to regulations in general back in those days, esp in the military. Breed standards are regulations. Also The Doberman was only accepted as a breed in the AKC in 1908, so it was fairly new back then.
 
Honestly, I think there are two answers to your question. First people were less sissified back then. There wasn't all of this AR bull crap to deal with in the 1940s. Second, they were more into withholding to regulations in general back in those days, esp in the military. Breed standards are regulations. Also The Doberman was only accepted as a breed in the AKC in 1908, so it was fairly new back then.
Forgot to add that the increased hearing ability due to "ear aiming" probably factored in there too ;)
 
All I am saying is that temperament seems to escape most discussions on workablity but some how cropped ears are more important. Its crazy how shallow us humans are.
Mostly just spoiled first world country citizens who have no real idea of hardships.Once upon a time Americans took great pride in combining form and function in every single aspect of our Made in USA product lines.. Weather it be a car or a dog.. Today we are happy just making everything look pretty nothing works longer then a few months to a cpl years.. Everything is designed to be replaced with new.. It would be hard for me to believe that this phenomena did not strike the Kennel clubs and the fanciers also.. Even the Auto industry is doing this.. Take the Corvette as an example.. a 200 mph car with a governor that doesn't allow you do ever do over 125.. I know stupid analogy but thats kind of the point.. People are stupid and dont know what they want.. A watered down dog of any breed is good for vanity not much good for anything else.

What about the dogs ability to "aim" it's ear at a sound?I believe a cropped dog has an edge over a non cropped dog.
As to military dogs..why weren't Kurt or any of the other Doberman dogs of the Pacific theater WWII natural ears?View attachment 36464
I bet it was easy as punch to find a crop vet back in the day.. Probably dirt cheep to. (as far as surgeries go) and of course the sissy thing Archer brings up..
 
That must have been a very sneaky burgler ! this May be a stupid question , but for the American translation, did he literally gas you or does that mean surprised? Because you were talking about poisoning and stuff? (and that is horrible too, I would probably kill someone if they did that to my dogs!) my mom had a burglar in her house once and the half pit/ half cattle dog and mini pin didn't wake up before my mom, scary!
 
Or cutting off their balls! Lol... I think it just has been a big controversy and some people just fall into the hype, I read a quote from a trainer and they said "before I got into training I thought cropping was so cruel but I learned that it is really not that bad, is almost painless if done properly, and can benefit the dog and training in some cases". I personally think is pretty much just cosmetic but they look so regal and gorgeous with the cropped ears!
 
Anyone who truly believe the procedure is purly cosmetic should go Bear hunting with a one of those Alaskan winter hats i was talking about earlier and then when you think you hear a bear approaching tell me what you do next? I can tell you for a fact your not going to pull those flaps down closer and tighter to your ears..
815h1GXbfPL._SY355_.webp

Thats not to say that everyone who crops their dogs ears are using them for utility but no doubt a cropped ear has function.. If im not mistaken all wild k-9 type species (Wolves, Fox, Coyote, Etc) have natural prick ears. the Evolutionary process is not designed to make animals less functional over the centuries. I understand the argument in today's society is that its just not necessary anymore, but i take offence to that statement because no one knows for what purpose we intend for our own dogs.
 
I don't get offended by anything someone believes or wants to do to their own dog as long as the dog is happy healthy and well taken care of. I have literally heard from three different vets and read accredited resources that it is purely cosmetic. But what do I know, if it helps in whomever's case then great! I don't know why Mr. Doberman would breed them to be the ultimate guard and sport dog with floppy ears if it was of such grave importance? Along with the breeders of pits, boxers, viszlas hounds, weimaraners, etc... I want to crop my dogs ears, so I guess I will see for myself
 
. the Evolutionary process is not designed to make animals less functional over the centuries.
I whole heatedly agree with the entirety of your post.You do realize though you have opened up an avenue of an entirely different debate,right?;)
 
Cropping can't add to evolution because it is not bred in, it is a cosmetic surgery done after birth. Dobbies have been cropped for nearly 100 years and they keeping popping out with those floppy ears! Lol
 
I don't know why Mr. Doberman would breed them to be the ultimate guard and sport dog with floppy ears if it was of such grave importance?
At some point before the Doberman was a recognized breed it did have natural prick ears however somewhere along the lines another breed was introduced into the gene pool and the prick ears were lost..

However to answer your question specifically.. 100 years ago Mr Doberman could easily C/D his own dogs with no questions asked.. A vet wast even required.. Breeders did this on their own regularly.. So i'm thinking considering the ease of availability less importance was put on ears when designing a new breed and purpose.
 
At some point before the Doberman was a recognized breed it did have natural prick ears however somewhere along the lines another breed was introduced into the gene pool and the prick ears were lost..
.
i would speculate that the dog introduced later,losing the prick ears had far less to do with form and more to do with temperament/sharpness.
 

Back
Top