These are all some very good arguments for and against cropping! I do have a question though as the original post did not say how the ears are cropped. I was doing some research on cropping in my state and learned that one of the vets here uses a laser to cut. Is this the usual way it is done now? I like the idea of using a laser to do it for sure, but I wasn't clear on if that's a common method. Also, here is my two cents worth on why I chose the cropped look. Before we bought our house, it had been broken in to twice, with the previous owners being home and tied up in the basement during one of the incidents (nobody was hurt). My husband may also be starting a new job that requires him to be out of town often. I have other means of protection but no "deterrent". I would have gone with a German Shepard but the coat is just too thick for the summers here and I intend to train my future doberman to be a service dog. A doberman with cropped ears is more intimidating, and I am relying on that factor. As a doberman person, you may be able to tell that the big friendly looking dog with floppy ears is a doberman, but to most of the general population, we see a hound, until you tell us otherwise. It is absolutely about the look for me, but it isn't because I think they look better with cropped ears, but I do want that working dog association as soon as you see him. People take a Doberman with cropped ears a little more seriously that natural. I need him to be taken seriously.
Edit: I feel like I over explained a lot lol