So bad new on mischas potty issues update...

She goes out around 230-3 usually. I'm going to start having him do 230 then I'll set my alarm for 5. He has a hard time sleeping so usually tries to settle in and do nothing but relax for almost 2 hours before bed. Even as simple as walking the dog wakes him up too much to the point he has to start over. It's so bad he tries not to use the bathroom after he's come to bed because that will wake him up. He's one of those, once he's up, he's up no matter how little sleep he gets. :-(

Sent from my LG-D850 using Tapatalk
 
She goes out around 230-3 usually. I'm going to start having him do 230 then I'll set my alarm for 5. He has a hard time sleeping so usually tries to settle in and do nothing but relax for almost 2 hours before bed. Even as simple as walking the dog wakes him up too much to the point he has to start over. It's so bad he tries not to use the bathroom after he's come to bed because that will wake him up. He's one of those, once he's up, he's up no matter how little sleep he gets. :-(

Sent from my LG-D850 using Tapatalk
I am like that too. When I am stirred awake I am up for good.
 
I disagree. I think it makes it harder to house train.
I agree with you- it makes sense to me that it would make it more difficult but I've had several people (on here and otherwise) say that should make it easier. I felt like it would make her used to going wherever she is and not have to tell anyone she needs to go out.

I plan to try to use the "speak" command and associate that with outside to try to get her to verbally tell us. She's not a fan of the bell, so that was $40 wasted on 2 bells in the house lol

Sent from my LG-D850 using Tapatalk
 
The dogs had free roam of quite a large area and were housed in a large barn, so even if they couldn't "go out" per se they still had more than enough room to not lay in their mess. This has baffled several people as when this is the case it's often easier to house train.

I disagree. I think it makes it harder to house train.

That's my opinion too. Harder to train. I actually have no experience with it so I don't know where I've come up with that over the years. :scratch: I know I used to think that of a feral cat especially. Keeping one 'in house' can be difficult because they are so used to going anywhere they please. I guess I would simply assume the same for a dog.

Now, that said, the man I bought my horses from always said that keeping them in groups outdoors teaches them the same as what your trainer said....to go in one spot. Even when eventually put in a stall. Cheyenne is perfect that way. :) And when all three are out in the pasture, most of it IS in one area.

But I still would think that a dog allowed to 'go wherever', is going to be harder to housebreak.

Are most of her accidents early in the morning? I understand you work and are away from home....what happens then? Does she hold it all day or is your fiance there with her?

Her natural instinct to stay clean just doesn't seem to be there I have observed her walking through and sitting in urine from another dog as well which is very abnormal. She has shown me that she has bladder control but I think she lacks self-control if that makes any sense.
This is baffling to me. I certainly can understand your frustration. :( With three children and a job to go to, this is going to be quite trying. She sounds like a project that will take every ounce of your attention, patience and training! lol Like Archer, I feel this can be done but it will take a drill sergeant! Too bad you couldn't take a weeks vacation or something lol and be there constantly to praise and :nono:. Somehow it's got to be made very clear to her what's good and whats bad. No in between.
He's one of those, once he's up, he's up no matter how little sleep he gets. :-(
Ugh, I can be like that too. Not every time but there are times I am awake and cannot fall back to sleep. If it's after 3am, sometimes, I'm up! :(

But having a puppy is like having a baby. That first year, you get little sleep because you are in training. Ok, THEY are in training. lol But, hate to say it, you are in training too. ;)

Has your fiance gone through the baby stages with your children? If not, I could see this being an eye opener! :spit: I think having children gives you a bit of experience under your belt for having a puppy. There are a lot of similarities. ;)
 
This just seems so weird to me. I get that she's quite happy in her own mess, to me that's whatever but training is training. Even if she's ok in her own mess she should know it's not ok to go in the house by now so it baffles me as to why she hasn't caught onto that.
 
That's my opinion too. Harder to train. I actually have no experience with it so I don't know where I've come up with that over the years. :scratch: I know I used to think that of a feral cat especially. Keeping one 'in house' can be difficult because they are so used to going anywhere they please. I guess I would simply assume the same for a dog.

Now, that said, the man I bought my horses from always said that keeping them in groups outdoors teaches them the same as what your trainer said....to go in one spot. Even when eventually put in a stall. Cheyenne is perfect that way. :) And when all three are out in the pasture, most of it IS in one area.

But I still would think that a dog allowed to 'go wherever', is going to be harder to housebreak.

Are most of her accidents early in the morning? I understand you work and are away from home....what happens then? Does she hold it all day or is your fiance there with her?


This is baffling to me. I certainly can understand your frustration. :( With three children and a job to go to, this is going to be quite trying. She sounds like a project that will take every ounce of your attention, patience and training! lol Like Archer, I feel this can be done but it will take a drill sergeant! Too bad you couldn't take a weeks vacation or something lol and be there constantly to praise and :nono:. Somehow it's got to be made very clear to her what's good and whats bad. No in between.

Ugh, I can be like that too. Not every time but there are times I am awake and cannot fall back to sleep. If it's after 3am, sometimes, I'm up! :(

But having a puppy is like having a baby. That first year, you get little sleep because you are in training. Ok, THEY are in training. lol But, hate to say it, you are in training too. ;)

Has your fiance gone through the baby stages with your children? If not, I could see this being an eye opener! :spit: I think having children gives you a bit of experience under your belt for having a puppy. There are a lot of similarities. ;)
I used up my last vacation week the week we got her back in May. (lesson learned don't take all your vaca at the beginning of the year!)

He did not go through any baby stages with my kids, and doesn't have any of his own either. My youngest was just about 3 when we got together and even though toddler years are bad, it's no where near the sleep deprivation of having an infant. He has however said, thanks to the puppy experience lol, that we will not be having a baby (we had talked about having one, since I would like a daughter- I have all boys, and he doesn't have any of his own)

It baffles me that she seems to "get it" in the house, just definitely not the crate, and will be absolutely perfect for almost a week then bam she'll pee on the floor after no accidents for awhile. And that she'll do it after having just been outside to potty and play.

Sent from my LG-D850 using Tapatalk
 
What does she do when she's in her crate typically? Do you notice a difference in her behaviour before an accident? Does she stand there, pace, whine, doesn't lay down much? I again wonder if it is some anxiety creeping in. Just because she behaves well at night doesn't necassrily mean she is entirely comfortable or lacks any anxiety issues in her crate. Any escapes out of tie outs, collars, leashes, crates, etc would point towards some sep. anxiety even more.

I'm wondering if going back as if she were a puppy and reintroducing the crate with small sessions when you are actually home will make her more comfortable in case her issues are due to anxiety of being left alone. Increase the session time and increase your distance slowly. Definitely make sure when you let her out there is no touch, talk or eye contact (just a quick way to say no doting, you have a task to do!)...straight to outside for potty.

I too agree she needs to be taken out before your fiance goes back to sleep. Anytime we are going to be out or sleeping or w/e it is where we cannot let the dogs out it is always a good idea to let them potty, even if they were just out. :)
 
Oh definitely will do. It's so frustrating to also know that growing up having free roam often means easier house breaking and that's not the case lol I was hoping that meant harder time house breaking because of being used to going wherever they were that would make me feel a little better (understand the why a little better maybe?) It's going to be a long road. I'm sad that my fiances first impression of the breed is this though. He's not impressed and doesn't particularly want another one in years to come.

Sent from my LG-D850 using Tapatalk
Maybe you can persuade your fiancé to take the word of all of us here on DCF that Dobermans are one of the most intelligent breeds out there and are not normally a problem to potty train.
 
She doesn't even have any bedding. She eats it so she lost blankets/towels/beds several months ago lol she seems to do it early morning though so I may start there. She usually ok around 4 when my fiance comes to bed but when I get up by 8 she has a mess.

Sent from my LG-D850 using Tapatalk
I hear you. Oji lost bedding of any kind in his crate too. Guaranteed destruction and possible ingestion.
 
She doesn't mind a bath anymore. She's gotten them so often I think she's used to it. Wendy (the trainer) had to bathe her this morning and said she has never seen a doberman so good for a bath and nail trim... Gave her an "A" for that haha!

Sent from my LG-D850 using Tapatalk
Well, I guess Mischa and Oji are not litter mates after all then.
 
I'm sorry you don't have better news. We feed TOTW and buy a 30 pound bag from Amazon.com. I pay $45


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk
Sheesh. I may have to start buying my food from Amazon. I think it's about 55 or 57 bucks from my nearby pet food store.
 
Sheesh. I may have to start buying my food from Amazon. I think it's about 55 or 57 bucks from my nearby pet food store.
If you're switching foods you may want to check out local specialty pet stores also. Sometimes they carry or can get specialty foods and will sell them cheaper to get you in the door. It seems counterintuitive, and sometimes they cost more, but my local one is consistently $5-$10 less per bag than chewy.com or petflow.com depending on the variety (Amazon doesn't have the food that I feed). The local store is also really good about letting me call in orders since I move between Orijen Six Fish/Tundra/Regional Red.


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk
 
I used up my last vacation week the week we got her back in May. (lesson learned don't take all your vaca at the beginning of the year!)

He did not go through any baby stages with my kids, and doesn't have any of his own either. My youngest was just about 3 when we got together and even though toddler years are bad, it's no where near the sleep deprivation of having an infant. He has however said, thanks to the puppy experience lol, that we will not be having a baby (we had talked about having one, since I would like a daughter- I have all boys, and he doesn't have any of his own)

It baffles me that she seems to "get it" in the house, just definitely not the crate, and will be absolutely perfect for almost a week then bam she'll pee on the floor after no accidents for awhile. And that she'll do it after having just been outside to potty and play.

Sent from my LG-D850 using Tapatalk
Her peeing on the floor means she doesn't get it, especially if she just went outside. The fact that she pees in her crate, in the house and outside just tells me she has no idea what she is supposed to be doing. I know you are doing everything you can, but I just feel there is something that you are missing. I know because I was there 9 years ago with my Miniature Pinscher. I was missing his tell. He had a very weird way to ask to go outside and I discovered it simply by accident. Once I figured out what it was, we had no issues potty training him. Faith peed in her kennel and laid in it when we first brought her home. She didn't care about laying in it either (eww) and so it took patience, persistance and much diligence, hard work and sleepless nights to break her of that habit. We took her out every hour. if she didn't pee, we tried again in 15 minute incriments until she pottied. She was never left to her own devices and was constantly under our supervision. When she was in her kennel (we have to work, lol) , she was robbed of her blankets and she would only pee when she couldn't hold it, but oddly enough, would not lay in it if she didn't have anything to absorb it. It took waking up every two hours through the night consistantly to help her PLUS taking her out every two hours during the day. My BFF who is a Veterinary behaviorist says that once they have a duration of time that they don't pee in their crate or the house that it increases your chance for success. I REALLY think that she needs to have a strict potty training schedule. Puppies and young dogs do best with schedules. She needs to go out immediately after eating, drinking and upon waking up from sleeping. Then she needs to go out on a schedule in addition to those times. When I am potty training I personally never let them play in the backyard. I want them to know that going out into the back yard means doing their buisness. We go out, they potty, I praise them and then we go back in and play. This is why I think it is good that she tends to potty in one area. Use it to your advantage. She still thinks that the world is her bathroom. Your fiance needs to be a part of this too. If he is up, he needs to be taking her out so you can sleep and vice versa. Good practice for him, lol.
 
Will do. What about during the day potty breaks when no one's home? I am able to run home at lunch and let her out but it certainly don't be able to be every 2 hours. Another difference, she will walk, sit and lay in it. She was stripped of all bedding months ago so it just sits in the plastic tray and she acts as though nothing's different. She often a damp, stinky dog lol waiting on skin issues from getting a bath 4x a week. I was trying to just wipe her down but she stinks so bad without a full bath.

Sent from my LG-D850 using Tapatalk
 
Wow, I've never experienced something like this so it is baffling on what to do... :(
 
Wow, I've never experienced something like this so it is baffling on what to do... :(
That's what's frustrating. Everyone is baffled lol! She spent the weekend last week with our trainer (the one who has 30+ years experience breeding showing and training dobes?) and she got sent home a day early because she made such a mess in the crate daily, Wendy wasn't going to be able to bathe her Monday morning if she had another mess and didn't want to send her home stinky. Worked for me... I figured there wouldn't be much more she could have done in another 24 hours and it saved me some money. But when she has so much strictly doberman experience and she's completely baffled as well, it frustrates me even more. I'm almost at a loss because I certainly don't have near the training experience she does (or that many of you here do!) good news though, no accidents in the crate or house in 48 hours now! I even slept through my alarm last night so didn't take her out in the middle of the night and she was still dry in the crate this morning!

Sent from my LG-D850 using Tapatalk
 
good news though, no accidents in the crate or house in 48 hours now! I even slept through my alarm last night so didn't take her out in the middle of the night and she was still dry in the crate this morning!
Well this is encouraging! I think your consistency and persistence is going to pay off in the long run.
 
I hope so. I always jinx myself when I post good updates lol she pooped on the floor about an hour ago in the midst of company coming over so I didn't catch her. She had "that look" when she saw that I saw it though and then she was extra lovey and sucking up so I think she knows she wasn't supposed to go in the house. She even went to bed quicker and quieter than normal tonight lol

Sent from my LG-D850 using Tapatalk
 
Just a question, and I may have missed something previously in the thread since I'm kind of playing catch-up (I apologize if so)--your trainer email mentioned that it seemed to be anxiety related? Do you know what kind of anxiety? Could it be possible that tensions are so high for her that normal dog nature to be clean just slips by? It would certainly be understandable--you're keeping amazingly high spirits given the situation--but the anxiety may be something to look into and perhaps treat medically if possible until the situation resolves. If less anxiety=ability to potty train=lower tensions=less anxiety naturally then everyone wins.


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk
 

Back
Top