So bad new on mischas potty issues update...

MischasMomma

Site Sponsor
Hot Topics Subscriber
$ Forum Donor $
Not sure if this should be here or I'm health and behavior... @JanS please move it if needed!!
Here's the message I got this morning from the trainer (who has had her since Friday morning)
5:52am sat:
No accidents during the day at all! However Friday night is a different story, she and the crate were a mess. I'll let you know about today.
9:32am sat:
Unfortunately she had a huge mess in her crate again. Do you know if she was born and raised in a house? I'm starting to suspect she was not raised in a very clean environment. Her natural instinct to stay clean just doesn't seem to be there I have observed her walking through and sitting in urine from another dog as well which is very abnormal. She has shown me that she has bladder control but I think she lacks self-control if that makes any sense.

I honestly think there's only two ways to get her past this. One is to keep her totally clean and avoid these accidents at all costs! Which may mean getting up once or twice in the middle of the night to take her out. It will mean going out with her every time and making sure that she potties outside. It will mean tracking when she goes so you can learn her natural patterns and then gradually helping her to extend that length of time. It will be hard work and you may or may not be successful. The other option which I know is not an option for you Is a dog door to a fenced yard and teaching her to take her self out and no longer crating her but that too would have a lot of difficulties and involve time.
I would also strongly recommend taking her off of puppy food. And I strongly recommend the food that doesn't have corn. This food has corn is one of its meaning gradient and I strongly recommend a food that doesn't have corn. This food has corn as one of its main ingredients. I've noticed she poops a lot she's basically not utilizing the nutrients in this food which is probably why you have to feed her so much of it. I realize that budget may be an issue but honestly you're probably feeding her 2 cups of food more a day than you would on a different food and most of it's just coming out the other end anyway. His food is primarily carbohydrates rather than high-quality protein. While that may or may not have an impact on Peeing in the crate it Will impact her overall behavior and health.
Check if this brand has an adult food that doesn't have corn in it. And consider switching to that.
By the way I do think the urination problem is in part and anxiety issue and an overall combination of her temperament and other factors.

(my response) And sorry, I missed the first message. She was not raised in a house. The pups were born in the house since it was February, however the "breeder" moved them outside to the barn as soon as she was able to keep it warm enough with heat lamps. They had free roam of a very large fenced farm area.

(her response) Oh that's odd...I mean not being in the house is one thing but having a large area to roam and potty usually results in cleaner puppies.

I do have a concern...I'm going to have to bathe her today, but I have no doubt she will potty again tonight in her crate and will be covered. She just isn't a "neat" dog. I've tried her in our large crate and our small...she smears stuff everywhere. My morning person won't be able to bathe her and I won't be in until late afternoon. Did you want to consider picking her up later today? I hate to send her home dirty. Maybe she will be fine tonight but given the last two nights I don't think she will.


So that being said, Mischa is coming home a day early and sounds like without any change. I am looking into switching her food and see if that helps, but it doesn't sound like she thinks it will make a huge difference in the urination, if at all. *sigh*

Sent from my LG-D850 using Tapatalk
 
Sorry you received bad news, but this is fixable. I suggested the same thing your trainer did in your last thread (starting from scratch taking her out more etc) and I still think it will work. It will just be a lot of work on your end and will take some time. You will have to be very diligent and your whole family will have to be on the same page. No doubt though that you can get through this! Keep us posted on her progress
 
Oh definitely will do. It's so frustrating to also know that growing up having free roam often means easier house breaking and that's not the case lol I was hoping that meant harder time house breaking because of being used to going wherever they were that would make me feel a little better (understand the why a little better maybe?) It's going to be a long road. I'm sad that my fiances first impression of the breed is this though. He's not impressed and doesn't particularly want another one in years to come.

Sent from my LG-D850 using Tapatalk
 
Do you have kids? Perhaps use kids as an example for him to better understand. Not every kid is alike, just like not every dog is alike. I have three Dobies. Although they share similar traits, they are all very different.
 
Yes, I have 3. His "problem" I believe is the cost. I know you get what you pay for now... Thought we got a really good deal getting Mischa for $400... And he wasn't happy we spent that much. He has always done rescues, even puppies, but his most expensive dog was $300 and the pup was already neutered too. He sticks to mixed breeds, which obviously are cheaper than pure bred too.

Sent from my LG-D850 using Tapatalk
 
Sorry it wasn't the news you wanted to her. :( I'm not sure what you feed but it certainly wouldn't hurt to gradually switch to a higher quality grain free food to make for less poop. Honestly a more expensive food really isn't that expensive when you have to figure how much less you have to feed them to give the nutrients they need.

My other thought is that she's getting UTI's if she's laying in her mess, so the food change might help on both parts. And as stated, starting from scratch might and taking her out at night might also help.
 
We feed authority from Petsmart. TOTW isn't much more than what I pay now (about $10 more for the same size bag) so I think I may try to switch to that. UTIs have been ruled out several times and she doesn't seem to go frequently it's just she doesn't let us know when she does need to go. Normally her night routine is to go out to potty when I go to bed at 10 then she goes out again around 2-230, then I'm up at 8 for her to go out before I go to work.

Sent from my LG-D850 using Tapatalk
 
I love TOTW and it really is a good food for a reasonable price.

Another thought would be to sleep near her crate for a night or two so you could see if there's a pattern on what time she messes the crate. Or if you had a monitor that would tell you that it would be easier yet.
 
That is bed news... :( I wonder how much of the mess was related to being in a strange place? The trainer's advice about accident prevention seems solid even if it means two potty breaks every night. Most people advise those with housebreaking issues to treat the dog like a puppy that has no physical control. I took Hans out so much that I was starting to wonder if he was housebroken or just empty all the time :) It was exhausting!
 
I'm sorry you don't have better news. We feed TOTW and buy a 30 pound bag from Amazon.com. I pay $45


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk

I do the same. I actually have to order a new bag!

I am sorry that there wasn't better news. I have had many of the same thoughts in regards to TD's crate peeing. The home he came from was a disaster (it was the reason why I actually bought him. I wasn't going to leave him there, but at the same time I hate having funded that breeder. Off topic though), so I question if he was allowed to lay in his messes. I am anal about immediately taking him out of the crate and cleaning him (he gets his paws wiped down and his body if it was caught in the act and he just stepped in it, but he goes straight to the tub if he has splashed). He does not like bathes or having his paws messed with, so over time his crate peeing has dropped drastically.

In fact the only real times it happens now is if we are bone heads and stick him in there without walking him first.


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk
 
That is bed news... :( I wonder how much of the mess was related to being in a strange place? The trainer's advice about accident prevention seems solid even if it means two potty breaks every night. Most people advise those with housebreaking issues to treat the dog like a puppy that has no physical control. I took Hans out so much that I was starting to wonder if he was housebroken or just empty all the time :) It was exhausting!

It's no worse or better than at home though. I'm going to start setting an alarm and do an extra potty break over night I suppose. :-(

Sent from my LG-D850 using Tapatalk
 
She doesn't even have any bedding. She eats it so she lost blankets/towels/beds several months ago lol she seems to do it early morning though so I may start there. She usually ok around 4 when my fiance comes to bed but when I get up by 8 she has a mess.

Sent from my LG-D850 using Tapatalk
 
I do the same. I actually have to order a new bag!

I am sorry that there wasn't better news. I have had many of the same thoughts in regards to TD's crate peeing. The home he came from was a disaster (it was the reason why I actually bought him. I wasn't going to leave him there, but at the same time I hate having funded that breeder. Off topic though), so I question if he was allowed to lay in his messes. I am anal about immediately taking him out of the crate and cleaning him (he gets his paws wiped down and his body if it was caught in the act and he just stepped in it, but he goes straight to the tub if he has splashed). He does not like bathes or having his paws messed with, so over time his crate peeing has dropped drastically.

In fact the only real times it happens now is if we are bone heads and stick him in there without walking him first.


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk
Same here... Except upon first impression our "breeder" seemed very nice and knowledgeable. It was me that was not, or I would have known to run the other direction from a z factor puppy and a breeder intentionally breeding a white dobe. But what throws a wrench in it, Mischa was not left to lay in her own messes. The dogs had free roam of quite a large area and were housed in a large barn, so even if they couldn't "go out" per se they still had more than enough room to not lay in their mess. This has baffled several people as when this is the case it's often easier to house train.

Sent from my LG-D850 using Tapatalk
 
She doesn't mind a bath anymore. She's gotten them so often I think she's used to it. Wendy (the trainer) had to bathe her this morning and said she has never seen a doberman so good for a bath and nail trim... Gave her an "A" for that haha!

Sent from my LG-D850 using Tapatalk
 
Since she performed the same at the trainer's. I guess you can rule out any environmental factors.
Yep. She also tried an x pen instead of a crate which had wanted to try. Only difference was she had a bigger mess (bigger space to make a mess!) so that was no help either.

Sent from my LG-D850 using Tapatalk
 
She doesn't even have any bedding. She eats it so she lost blankets/towels/beds several months ago lol she seems to do it early morning though so I may start there. She usually ok around 4 when my fiance comes to bed but when I get up by 8 she has a mess.

Sent from my LG-D850 using Tapatalk
Then he needs to put her out at 4. Prevent the accident before it happens :)
 

Back
Top