• Disclaimer: Hello Guest, Doberman Chat Forums presents the opinions and material on these pages as a service to its membership and to the general public but does not endorse those materials, nor does it guarantee the accuracy of any opinions or information contained therein. The opinions expressed in the materials are strictly the opinion of the writer and do not represent the opinion of, nor are they endorsed by, Doberman Chat Forums. Health and medical articles are intended as an aid to those seeking health information and are not intended to replace the informed opinion of a qualified Veterinarian.”

Are More US Doberowners Leaving Their Dobes Uncropped and Undocked?

Wow we are spinning in circles! But this is a good debate thread. I do not think anyone on either side should talk down to anyone, as we all have the right to an opinion. Both cropped and natural ear dobes are beautiful and I do not believe any of our dogs are what they were meant to be by H. Dobermann. However at one point there was a standard developed to help protect our breed (as any other) and the standard should not change. I am NOT suggesting that all dogs must be cropped, however to take this "right" and change our "standard" will open up a bigger can f worms then what we ALL want to see. It's bad enough that we are on most BSL lists...we have to fight for our loves our Dobes and our rights. I believe the standard should remain,as well as the choice to crop or not. If we stop cropping does that mean a doberman won't be a doberman, No. But to change the standard opens doors to our already endangered breed and will alllow them to change what our breed standard is. THEY want our dogs GONE.

If nothing else can be agreed on here, its that we should ALL have a CHOICE in how we want our pups ears or tail. Its not important to make someone understand your point of view, as in most cases that will not happen, we feel what feel. The thing is...we all should agree on CHOICE .Period. And to not agree on that, well that i think is putting our breed in more danger. You can agree and disagree on standard or pain or whatever, but we should all have a choice..of course that is my opinion. Oh and one last thing....none of these things we are throwing around here are facts, they are ether theories or opinions. If there were facts...we would not be having this conversation. So please stop attacking other peoples views. We are a great community and should communicate as so! HUGS!
 
Wow we are spinning in circles! But this is a good debate thread. I do not think anyone on either side should talk down to anyone, as we all have the right to an opinion. Both cropped and natural ear dobes are beautiful and I do not believe any of our dogs are what they were meant to be by H. Dobermann. However at one point there was a standard developed to help protect our breed (as any other) and the standard should not change. I am NOT suggesting that all dogs must be cropped, however to take this "right" and change our "standard" will open up a bigger can f worms then what we ALL want to see. It's bad enough that we are on most BSL lists...we have to fight for our loves our Dobes and our rights. I believe the standard should remain,as well as the choice to crop or not. If we stop cropping does that mean a doberman won't be a doberman, No. But to change the standard opens doors to our already endangered breed and will alllow them to change what our breed standard is. THEY want our dogs GONE.

If nothing else can be agreed on here, its that we should ALL have a CHOICE in how we want our pups ears or tail. Its not important to make someone understand your point of view, as in most cases that will not happen, we feel what feel. The thing is...we all should agree on CHOICE .Period. And to not agree on that, well that i think is putting our breed in more danger. You can agree and disagree on standard or pain or whatever, but we should all have a choice..of course that is my opinion. Oh and one last thing....none of these things we are throwing around here are facts, they are ether theories or opinions. If there were facts...we would not be having this conversation. So please stop attacking other peoples views. We are a great community and should communicate as so! HUGS!



Very well said. One thing my dad always said to us growing up was "Without choice, there is no freedom". I always remember that when I come across a disagreement. Although we cannot be completely free to do as we please, we should celebrate the freedoms we do have, and that includes everyones freedom, not just the ones we agree with. I hope to have the the freedom to own dobermans for the rest of my life as well as have the right to c/d them.
I would also like to add something. I wish everyone would do research on AR groups to find out the truth about them. They may have started as a good thing, but money and power have changed things. Would an organization that believes in the rights of animals really put them down because they do not have room for them?
To understand the risk to our breed you must do your homework. The odds are stacked against them.
 
Hi Dobs4Ever,

I appreciate your response, however when it comes to tail docking I have to respectfully disagree. It's one thing to have a paper cut, to get blood drawn or an injection, and quite another to remove an appendage with a full complement of nerves and pain receptors without any anesthesia. I've had blood drawn and injections and paper cuts as an adult, and while it's not a fun process it certainly isn't one that warrants painkillers. On the other hand, if you told me you were going to remove a toe, finger, hand or leg, I'd want to be put out completely, and can only imagine how tortuously painful it would be without them. To do the equivalent to a puppy doesn't minimize the excruciating pain it experiences during and after the procedure.

In my reading and research it seems that veterinarians, breeders and owners make the choice of docking and cropping without anesthesia either because of the cost involved, or because of the anticipated risks of death and complications. Those risks don't seem to have been researched in a measurable way, in part because it appears that the standard is to crop and dock without anesthesia and this hasn't been measured statistically (complications with anesthesia for puppies). The pain that the dogs go through does not seem to be a consideration, and this seems to be a common practice.

As I said earlier, I don't have a problem when these procedures are administered humanely, but if they're done without painkillers or anesthesia to me this is not humane - this is torture. With all of the money that is spent on dogs as a whole, effort should be put into finding a way to do these procedures without torturing our dogs in the process.

P.S. I'm normally anything but a PETA supporter as I hunt, eat meat, and wear fur and leather all the time. PETA rants and ravings have nothing to do with my position on this - I believe that any torturing of animals is wrong and should be illegal, and to me docking and cropping without anesthesia falls into that category. And PETA would see these practices banned entirely, which I disagree with - I just don't believe cutting off a limb or appendage, or operating on any creature without anesthesia and pain management is an appropriate practice, and to put it another way - it's not OK to do to me, so it's not OK to do to my dog either!
 
I just want to point out that operations/procedures are in fact preformed on infants without anesthesia, namely circumcision. If you Google it there are some very good articles and video ( forewarned they are very graphic ).

Unfortunately anesthesia is not safe at the time of tail docking but that doesn't deter me from wanting tails docked. A friend has a un-docked dog who I cannot stand to be around because this dog has left bruises up and down my legs from her tail beating me! She is really a sweet dog but I avoid being near her because of her tail.

My 2 bits on this topic is always choice, to me choice taken away from either side causes problems! The groups that are after total control in fact do start small as to not alarm foks, small choices are removed first, tiny privileges revoked until you become complacent and you forget that there is an agenda. As an example "the patriot act" comes to mind. In a moment of public fear, sorrow, terror we allowed the government to infringe on basic rights before most folks even had the good sense to question. Now the fight to get those rights given back will be a lot harder than fighting against their removal to begin with!

Myself I prefer c/d. While I think that all the dobermans on this site are beautiful, the imposing look of a crop is what I personally want. Uncropped they remind me of hound dogs. Nothing against hound dogs but I just don't think they are intimidating at all. I understand it's still the same breed and the reaction of the dog will be the same in most cases but I want people to know it from a distance! I don't want them realizing it once they are up close and personal to me and my dog.
 
Unfortunately anesthesia is not safe at the time of tail docking but that doesn't deter me from wanting tails docked. A friend has a un-docked dog who I cannot stand to be around because this dog has left bruises up and down my legs from her tail beating me! She is really a sweet dog but I avoid being near her because of her tail.



So this is the reason to dock a dog, I think not, not a good enough argument my friend, I have had Bella over 4 years and never once had a bruise off her tail , how soft are you?:rolleyes:
 
On the other hand, if you told me you were going to remove a toe, finger, hand or leg, I'd want to be put out completely, and can only imagine how tortuously painful it would be without them. To do the equivalent to a puppy doesn't minimize the excruciating pain it experiences during and after the procedure.

You guys have fallen prey to the baloney - Please understand that cropping as I have clearly stated at 7 weeks every single puppy is put to sleep and every single puppy is put on antibiotics and pain med when they come home so you are not listening to what is being said.

Three is a vast difference in amputating a finger of a human (and we don't do that to babies so it is usually caused by a severe injury later after the bones have hardened and all the nerves fully developed. What you are missing clearly because the AR gropus have made it sound gruesome believe you me I could not stand it if were anywhere close to what you describe. But as soon as the deed is done they are right back to normal and I personally over the years of docking hunderds of puppy not ever seen anything at all like you describe. The moment it is over it is over. The do not whimper or fret or worry - But I will tell you this clearly back during the war adult humans have had limbs amputated on the battle field without pain killlers and that is truly gruesome but at the time it was save their life or let them die anyway.

I would far far prefer to have tails and dews done at 3 days as opposed to wait til they are 7 weeks and have ears done and then have to have tails and dews done also. They are much more active so much more susceptible to an infections on the feet and tail since they sit them right down in the the dirt.

It might surprise you t know that actually it was God you taught us this when HE instituted circumcision for baby boys. HE said the never ending and blood flow were minimal at that age so safe. So if it is good enough for GOD it is good enough for me. After all He created all creatures big and small.
 
It's interesting to note how the standard has changed over the years since 1900, how the Dobermann has changed in appearance and size from approx 23 inches to the 27.5 ideal we have now, it's also interested to note that the first standard was drawn up after Louis Dobermanns death...

Here's a link to the many changes/clarifications there has been over the last century LINKY.
Cant copy n paste it here, there's a big Copyright notice in the document...

I'd love a cropped/docked Dobe but I live in a country that bans these practices. Is my all natural Dobe any less of a Dobermann than one c/d'd? No I don't think so... In this country this is now the norm, my dog conforms to the standard in my country.

Should I abandon the breed because the Dobermann here is not as pleasing on the eye as he could be? again, I don't think so...

My point is is that the standard has moved on with the breed as the breed has developed and changed over the last 113 years, the Dobe of 1900 is a lot different from the Dobe of 2010 and no doubt it will be different again in another 50/100 years. We need to accept the fact that the standard can, has and will change. I agree, fight those changes all the way, try with all your might to keep it the way it is but it's not going to be the end of the breed when/if those changes occur in the US. Even if it is something as huge as a c/d ban, it's not going to be a Dobermann Armageddon, there are enough people around the world that love the breed whatever the changes, the breed is smaller in Europe in numbers but is that such a bad thing? maybe bad for the puppy mills but not for the quality of the breed...
 
I am wide awake in dreamland.

If your CKC Doberman can be titled in conformation.....do it!:D

Would you agree to have your titled Doberman used as foundation for a reputably bred CKC litter that was C/D?

I am going to show my natural girl. If it takes too much time and effort I may not finish her. I have no plans to breed her.
 
LOL! Not soft at all I assure you. Many medical procedures endured, the same bones repeatedly broken not to mention the things I have done voluntarily like cosmetic tattooing (lipstick and eyeliner) and a full sleeve tattoo.
I will repeat again that I clearly said "choice" I voiced only why it matters to me not what I believe others should do. I am 5'1 so my friends dogs tail hits me higher up than most people (upper thigh and groin). Just because you feel differently about it and would make a different choice than me gives you no right to insult me by calling me "soft" but thanks for sharing your opinion. After all throwing insults is such a great way to get people to listen.....:thumbdown:
 
LOL! Not soft at all I assure you. Many medical procedures endured, the same bones repeatedly broken not to mention the things I have done voluntarily like cosmetic tattooing (lipstick and eyeliner) and a full sleeve tattoo.
I will repeat again that I clearly said "choice" I voiced only why it matters to me not what I believe others should do. I am 5'1 so my friends dogs tail hits me higher up than most people (upper thigh and groin). Just because you feel differently about it and would make a different choice than me gives you no right to insult me by calling me "soft" but thanks for sharing your opinion. After all throwing insults is such a great way to get people to listen.....:thumbdown:

I'm 5'2" so maybe it's because i am much taller that i have not been bruised :pokeeyes:
Still not the right reason to dock a dog:scratch:
 
It sounds to me as if you don't believe that there is a "right" reason to dock a tail period. I am secure enough to allow anyone to have their own opinion and confident enough to feel no shame in expressing mine. Have a nice day!

Well that's why we having this debate, to put the right reason forward, but so far the only reason put forward is cosmetic which just does not justify docking , as you say we are all allowed our personal opinion ;)
 
Then you need to go back and re read because there were other reasons for docking some just choose to ignore them or listen to the scewed numbers presented by the AR groups to push their agenda.

PLus if you have a good breeder it was done long before you got your puppy and is something that most of you never even come close to experienceing so you can thank your breeder for having the courage to stand up for a cropped and docked dog so you don't have to endure the problems that tails pose for many of us.
 
Wow! Everyone has a very strong opinion about crop and dock. My first dobie was cropped and docked. I watched the Vet do the surgery, very interesting. My current 2 are docked but not cropped due to a form I had to sign @ the adoption stating I would not crop ears. Although, I love the cropped look and understand that it is the breed standard, I also love the natural ears. Billy only has 1 ear due to the original "breeder" cuting it off and 1 from another male puppy at birth. This is where cropping gets a bad name, home crop jobs gone wrong. I have also seen many crops go bad for lack of knowledge about proper taping techniques and length of committment to taping and it is a committment.
I am for everyone being able to make their own informed choice about cropping/docking. I also understand a breeders POV as the breeder of my current show puppy takes all of his pups to California for cropping. All the owners return with their pups and they go to California for surgery. This breeder will also tape the pups ears for owners, too, so no excuse for bad tape jobs!
As for the people that think it is cruel to crop and dock, you are just being judgemental about something that is not a cruelty when done by a professional under anesthesia. There are many more horrific cruelties done to animals at the hands of their "loving" owners than a proper crop and dock!
 
PLus if you have a good breeder it was done long before you got your puppy and is something that most of you never even come close to experienceing so you can thank your breeder for having the courage to stand up for a cropped and docked dog so you don't have to endure the problems that tails pose for many of us.

I followed Gino and Asha from the beginning of their life. Both of my breeders felt down after docking and then cropping puppies. They told me they would prefer not to do it. I assume it's not an easy procedure for breeders either.
Why do most breeders stand strong on cropping/docking? ... Confusing... :confused2:
 
I think this has been one of the best debates of the issue of d/c AND honorable usage of a breed standard I've run across in a very long time.Too long!

You know why this forum is fantastic?.....because we, go where others fear to tread.They have the wrong breed for it.

Don't think for a moment they are not watching us closely from their own breed forums.We have one of the most important breeds ever bred in history and few ever as beloved,fixed,respected...yet evolving.The Doberman standard is never static because it was never written to be so.We have it 'made',so to speak, as compared to other breeds and we have the breed that needed ALL the other breeds the most.It sure does go 'round and 'round because it CAN! It is now time for the Doberman to give back to All the other breeds we have raided.The Doberman can save them all.

On every principle that other breeds can be dismissed by society on, our breed still possesses.We can no longer give an inch on anything.In the dog world there is far to much at stake for that.

Our breed 'icons' collectively brought that forward for us when they created our foundation.We got lucky like none others on the modern studbooks of today.Look at what IS happening to the breeds that are 'unemployable'.Dumbed down isn't the word for it.They are going extict!They are so undervalued in modern society that people care no0thing for them,thus they have become redundant.They are more than unemployed.....their breed standards,even collectively. are for everything few people do today.Not so for the Doberman.

Someone hit on 'studbooks' and their development.FANTASTIC input to this debate.

They have evolved from a 'personal' bloodline studbook into a community based ' breed club' studbook, and onward into what they are today.It is a myth that one was for looks and the other was for fuction and then they all came together into what they are today.Performance vs. Looks........fairytale!Form follows function.Any way you cut it..... the Doberman must be correct to the standard to function!It does not need to be 'corrected' by society's wim and leisure to exist because the Doberman was bred to standard can serve whatever we asked of the dog.

Herr Doberman used the underclass of the dog world in his own time to create the most iconic breed of the dog world today.A modern dog for every man.We have to fight anything that is against 'good Doberman' the hardest because our breed needs a 'little of this and a little of that' from all the other breeds to be good.

Watch that movie Marley and Me.What was there to laugh about?Retriever acting like a retriever....HELP.....what should we do with him? Soooooo funny,but not to me.Most popular dog on the studbook in any time,including today, and the public thinks it's funny because it's 'useless'!Makes me barf a little.
 
To ADD: On the confusing statement - the issues is not about c/d in reality - they have a far bigger agenda - they want to win this issue and get breed standards thrown out the window because the want to do away with purebred dogs. That is the real issue and why we can't let them win on this one. They knew they could not win if they just came out with their real agenda so they broke it down into thinks they know they can win and have already done so in some areas.


AR are the most vile 'greeders' the dog world has ever endured.
 
Well that's why we having this debate, to put the right reason forward, but so far the only reason put forward is cosmetic which just does not justify docking , as you say we are all allowed our personal opinion ;)

Judith, I am unsure there is a "right reason" because both sides are based on opinion, not facts. Both sides can put up evidence and neither is more wavering than the other. I think we can simply state that the most important thing here is choice. All dobes are beautiful, no one is stating there is anything wrong with a natural dog, it's just not the standard here and we feel we should have the choice to c/d.
 
If the reason to dock the tail is because the dog clears the table, bruises our legs, bodies etc, and break them because of their vicious wagging, how come all dogs don't get docked? I would think all breeds would have the same problem. Also I would say that if you have the above mentioned problems with the dogs tail, maybe you should get a cat or a parrot instead. Why is it that humans think it's OK to amputate body parts because they are inconvenient for them? This also applies to when cats are declawed! I think that is a vile thing to do. Humans think it's OK to make everyone and everything else conform to us. We wouldn't want to be considerate to any of the other living creatures that we share this earth with.

I do agree that everyone should have a choice, but to me it sounds like we should not have a choice to keep the dogs natural as it's the death/downfall or the breed?! Also I don't see the Dobies in Europe declining in quality just because of the d/c ban there.
 

Back
Top