• Disclaimer: Hello Guest, Doberman Chat Forums presents the opinions and material on these pages as a service to its membership and to the general public but does not endorse those materials, nor does it guarantee the accuracy of any opinions or information contained therein. The opinions expressed in the materials are strictly the opinion of the writer and do not represent the opinion of, nor are they endorsed by, Doberman Chat Forums. Health and medical articles are intended as an aid to those seeking health information and are not intended to replace the informed opinion of a qualified Veterinarian.”

Are More US Doberowners Leaving Their Dobes Uncropped and Undocked?

I think most people on this board can agree with the following statement:
I will try to say it one more time. It is not about cropping and docking ONLY. I am not against some leaving their dogs uncropped and docked. I am 100% solidly for following the standard and NOT LOOSING the right to crop and dock.

This statement is confusing:
If any of you can guarantee me that by you leaving your dogs uncropped we will NOT LOOSE our right to crop [\quote]
Regardless of what we do with our dogs, we can't guarantee the preservation or loss of the right. Think about it - continuing to crop dogs does not necessarily guarantee, one way or another, that the right to crop would remain, does it? Whether we keep that right [and this applies to any right] is more up to how passionate the people are and how willing they are to fight the courts/AR groups/etc. Not cropping the dog does not guarantee, one way or another, that we would lose or keep the right; nor would cropping the dogs guarantee, one way or another, that we would lose or keep the right.

Once that standard is chopped away there are no more purebred dogs.
No more purebred dogs? :confused2: Like Swift and DV, I fail to see how the "purebred" is gone if you don't crop the ears. Whether a dog gets their ears cropped, they are still from a line of DOBERMANS - you are not breeding in or breeding out a cropped ear. The cropped ear is a cosmetic change made to the dog after birth so that it conforms to the standard. But it does not mean that without the crop, the dog is not purebred and that the purebred goes away. How do you make that conclusion? Am I missing something? :scratch:
 
Good points and that is where most miss the point. The purebred dog fancy rest solidly on their individual standards. IF there is no standard to describe the correct ideal of a breed then how do you know what is good or not???

So if our standards become up to the whims of the public then there will be no more point in having purebred dogs because it won't matter everyone - just does what they want. So if everyone does what they want then how will be be able to tell what a breed is suppose to look liek at its best and have a guide to follow?? We can't have it both ways and that is the danger in this fight.

Every single thing about the purebred dog fancy is against everyone just doing what they want - If everyone does that then we have nutts and soon you would not be able to identify one breed from many others. At that point there are no pureberd dogs to speak of. The standard makes it possible for a dog be be recognized as a particular breed and as breeders we must uphold that standard and therefore, protect our breed.

Once a standard is changed because of government intervention then the govt has just said we do not honor breed clubs or their standard so everyone is free to breed what ever they want. Soon because everyone is different and has different views some breeders like the look of the greyhound better so they start breeding their Dobermans to more resemble greyhounds then someone else says well we need to have more colors so let try to breed for a brindle Doberman, Someone else says no I think they should look like mastiffs with much heavier bone and so then we have the mastiff dobermans. Where does it stop? I can tell you where it starts - with c/d. If they win that then the entire foundation that the purebred dog world stands on and for is on very shakey ground.
 
While it is well and good for those that have C/D choice to say they disagree with the AKC breed standard.....it is now time to state some facts of the CKC standards, in all matters, relating to the purebred dog world in Canada.

The CKC studbook recognizes the AKC studbook.As such,the AKC standard is correct as per the CKC standard.Nobody can disagree with them.As are the sanctioned standards of numerous international studbooks for all the breeds the CKC registers.

Why would anyone make an anti-crop statement using that logic?That logic is not based on anything the CKC stands for in Canada or the world of purebred dogs.

The CKC is our studbook and it's purpose is to register purebred dogs and promote purebred dogs through sanctioned sporting events.There by, the CKC advocates for the purebred dog and educates the public about purebred dogs.That IS their logic.Crop and dock is allowable and will remain ever so.

The CKC will NEVER ban cropping in their standards because we have the federal legislated Animal Prdigree Act.The federal government will never waste their time keeping out cropped registered dogs.Crops will always be allowable by the CKC standards.If it's a registered purebred anything....it is IN by our federal governments standards.

Cropped dogs will always show and win in Canada.Natural ear dogs will be dogs without crops regardless of their breed.We have all hit on the disreputable reasons for not cropping.The CKC is well aware of the same points also. They are also well aware what it takes to continue to exist.They will NEVER officially take any stand on the issue.It is not in their best interests and they are legally obligated by federal law to register purebred dogs.The federal laws will not ban cropping.

Cropping is not going away in Canada because a CKC registered dog owner disagrees with it and thinks they have choice.Natural ears will not become the norm for a reputably bred CKC Dobe in Canada.Most certainly not for conformation titles.

I blame the vets,AR and the disreputable for the C/D debate in Canada.I will use our federal laws and have dogs cropped in America, if out vets continue to not perform the procedure.I do not use vets that are against cropping.I won't support any animal being the collateral damage of the disreputable.Including vets and AR.
 
Good points and that is where most miss the point. The purebred dog fancy rest solidly on their individual standards. IF there is no standard to describe the correct ideal of a breed then how do you know what is good or not???

So do you breed for a specific shape natural ear so you can cut sections off? This logic makes no sense...

One cannot breed to the standard, they can only create the standard.

So many ways to determine what's good and what's not...
 
Natural ears will not become the norm for a reputably bred CKC Dobe in Canada.Most certainly not for conformation titles.

It sounds like your dream :)
Yes it's much harder to finish natural Doberman in Canada... but there are more and more natural dogs in the CKC show ring.
Public and judges are getting used to the look. None of dog handlers I met refused to show my girl.... and they were confident they could finish her.
I don't have statistics how many natural Dobermans got titles in CKC but I am sure the number is growing at least from what I see locally.

Susan I won't vote for the cropping/docking ban. I respect your rights to c/d your dog but I want the equal rights for owners of natural and cropped Dobermans in the show ring and breeding programs.
 
I agree with Swift that it is very interesting how most of the natural supporters are not against the ban, but the people who crop are against the floppy ears. You want the choice but you don't want us to have the choose because you think it's the wrong choice!

I really annoys me, Suzan, when you keep brining up what Hr. Dobermann wanted. First of all, if it was all about Hr. Dobermann why do the Americans not spell the breed with the double n? Also someone posted a picture of the Dobie as it looked back in the day and it sure as hell does not look like that anymore. So we are allowed to change the Dobermann into something else conformationally, temperament etc, but we better crop the dam ears because the is what Hr. Dobermann wanted? Seriously?

Suzan, you also come across quite condescending whenever this topic is brought up. You say to Swift not to be upset, but you feel it acceptable to speak down to people as if you have all the right answers. Noone is saying that there should be a c/d ban, but that the natural eared Dobie is the exact same dog as it would be if it had the ears cut off.

In regards to all of you saying that your dog is in no discomfort after being cropped. I somehow have a hard time believing that. I know what my girls were like after being spayed, and I know what it feels like when I have been cut into in some way. There is discomfort, but dogs are programmed to not show weakness as that will mean death in the wild. Have any of you ever seen a dog with an embedded collar? They wag their tails and look happy when someone pays them attention and takes care of them. That doesn't mean that they aren't in severe pain. I am not saying it's the same thing, just giving an example. I think we humans justify what we do by saying they are feeling no pain etc, but how do we know, really? I have seen dogs being very stoic even though being sick and being in pain. They are not human and they do not act like humans. I am not interested in telling anyone what to do, so I wish people would stop their double standards and try and tell me that my preference is causing the death of the Doberman. Bad breeding causes the death of the breed, not a lack of cosmetic surgery!
 
I agree with Swift that it is very interesting how most of the natural supporters are not against the ban, but the people who crop are against the floppy ears. You want the choice but you don't want us to have the choose because you think it's the wrong choice!

I bolded part of your statement above, I don't think it's a fair statement. You say MOST that have natural ears aren't against the ban, then the way you word the second part, is like you're putting ALL people who are for cropping and docking are against natural. This should state most people in both situations. I think it should be each owners choice and I don't think someone should take that choice away from us.
 
So many ways to determine what's good and what's not...

You have hit the nail on the head for everything that Mary Rogers Dexter represents to our breed.

Changing any studbooks breed standards does not make reputably bred dogs.Respecting the standards of the studbook by breeding reputably to the standard does.That is always what's good for the Doberman in any time.If you want titled Doberman in the AKC.....crop and dock.

It has always been of a keen interest to me that Herr Dobermann used the dogs at the pound to breed.He was already cleaning up the mess made by the disreputable.
 
This is an argument that will never go away i'm afraid , but do you not think we have to move on, Herr Dobermann would not recognise this breed if he were to come back as the confirmation has changed so much, he was more interested in the character and temperament than what it looked like , and the tail was only docked so he would not have to pay tax on it as in those days you paid tax on any dog with a tail , and on some of his dogs the ears were just about none existent ,now every dog looks different with no two crops looking alike, if all the crops were the same it might make more sense to me, here is an extract from the history of Herr Dobermann and the development of the breed.

Herr Karl Friedrich Louis Dobermann (1834-1891) was a tax collector & dogcatcher /skinner for the state of Thuringia, Germany and had a second job as night watchman. As a dogcatcher, he could choose the best dogs for his purpose. He was concerned with character rather than conformation. His requirement was to create a watchful, sharp, brave and intelligent dog. He wanted a guard dog with a strong mouth, a good nose, courage, hardness nd a highly developed protective instinct. We know he succeeded. From the beginning, his dogs were known regionally as "Dobermann's Hunde". They gained a solid reputation for harsh strength of character and an ability to hunt, bite and kill vermin. Herr Dobermann crossed several types of dogs but did not keep records (there were no pure bred dogs at that time) and there is little agreement on the origins of the Dobermann.
In 1890 the Standard for the breed was written and approved by the German Kennel Club and remains basically the same - although judges today are accepting much larger dobermann than the standard calls for.

history%20prinz%20strick%20&%20prinzessin%20schlippche.jpg

Around the time of Herr Dobermann's death in 1891, came the Breeders: Goswin Tischler & Otto Goeller (photos left), who were very influential in the development of the Dobermann breed.
 
The Association of Veterinarians for Animal Rights is opposed to various surgeries done to meet "breed standards" or to correct so-called vices. Procedures such as ear cropping, tail docking, or debarking in dogs, or declawing in cats are unacceptable because of the suffering and disfigurement they cause an animal are not offset by any benefits to the animal. If such a procedure can be shown to be necessary for medical or humane reasons, then it is permissible. The "breed standards" for dogs must be altered to allow the animals to be shown without being surgically mutilated.

To me the above says it all - The vets for Animal RIGHTS - The AR groups are the Aniaml Rights groups and vets have joined hands with them.

It goes on to say it must be done humanely so how can you outlaw something that can be done humanely and correctly.

While I might believe that 11 Rotties died I would find it hard to believe that all 11 died specifically because of tail docking. Being dirty and uncared for yes but having attended the docking of hundereds of tails by my vet with never a single infected tail I have to ask why am I so darn lucky??? Surely through the years I should have at least one infection - I know numerous other breeders who have never had a tail infection either and some of them dock their own puppies. Don't forget this also includes the removal of dew claws with not a single infection.

I can now see why England lost their rights so long ago - The AR groups were not really widely know for al their nuttiness at that time and by the above statement they obviously infiltrated the vet community and pushed their agenda. I know the AVMA here has adopted their policy and tried to push it here but got resistence.

There is a BIG differenct between Animal Rights and The Animal Welfare policies. We must study the differences and understand that they are not both for the welfare of animals. The AR group campaigned about 2 years ago for the humane catch and release program for the common house fly and then they campaigned for mice. They are so far out in left field that they would not even recognise common snese. They believe animals should have the same rights as humans. - As soon as it passses I can retire Gunner and he will draw SS as it is his right.

The AR groups are slowly strangling the world economy with their philosophy.

Animal welfard on the other hand is for the fair and humane treatment of our animals but we are still allowed to use them for food. They do not want animals abused but they are not out there destroying factory farms and illegally releaseing animals in captivity.

Ingrid Newkirk co-founder of PETA was born in Surrey, England -
Instead of seeing all the other species on Earth as ours to convert into hamburgers, handbags, living burglar alarms, amusements, test tubes with whiskers, and so on, we need to respect them as fellow beings, as other individuals and families and tribes who have the same basic interests in experiencing joy and love and living without needless pain and harassment as we do.
She is vegan and believes you should be too.

Some other things to consider is verbage - the articles uses severaly inflammatory words which are used for the sole purpose of painting a picture that just might not be realistic - For example "crushing" the bone in the tail is one. Even the first year medical student should know that bones and cartilage are not hard but softer and bendable during birth. Tails are often clamped to keep them from bleeding during the proceedure. If instruments are clean no other antibiotics are required and puppies immediately squirem back to momma to nurse. It is over in a flash and no way an amputation at that point - It is a TAIL Dock and dew claw removal.. Dew clawas just flick off with your finger and neither is invasive. No newborn should ever be put under for such a minor proceedure and in fact I believe that it helps the puppies to stiumulate them and help them become stronger.

I can't tell you how many calves I have helped my dad ban through the years. While I have never banned a tail because I think it would be to hard to get it in exactly the right place I now people who do and love the results of the tail. In fact I have assisted my vet with so many tail docking and dew claw removal thorugh the years I could easily do it. I just like the vet to see the puppies and know that all is going well at this critical time in their lives and their little systems become alive and active.

Guys this is one of the biggest reasons we are loosing - Very good - loving caring people are misguided by their very jaded philosophy. Go to the PETA and HSUS web sites and read what all they have in store for you. The world will not survive if they succeed in putting every single business that uses animals for food out of business and make no mistake that is there goal.

To ADD: On the confusing statement - the issues is not about c/d in reality - they have a far bigger agenda - they want to win this issue and get breed standards thrown out the window because the want to do away with purebred dogs. That is the real issue and why we can't let them win on this one. They knew they could not win if they just came out with their real agenda so they broke it down into thinks they know they can win and have already done so in some areas.
 
This is an argument that will never go away i'm afraid , but do you not think we have to move on, Herr Dobermann would not recognise this breed if he were to come back as the confirmation has changed so much, he was more interested in the character and temperament than what it looked like , and the tail was only docked so he would not have to pay tax on it as in those days you paid tax on any dog with a tail , and on some of his dogs the ears were just about none existent ,now every dog looks different with no two crops looking alike, if all the crops were the same it might make more sense to me, here is an extract from the history of Herr Dobermann and the development of the breed.

Herr Karl Friedrich Louis Dobermann (1834-1891) was a tax collector & dogcatcher /skinner for the state of Thuringia, Germany and had a second job as night watchman. As a dogcatcher, he could choose the best dogs for his purpose. He was concerned with character rather than conformation. His requirement was to create a watchful, sharp, brave and intelligent dog. He wanted a guard dog with a strong mouth, a good nose, courage, hardness nd a highly developed protective instinct. We know he succeeded. From the beginning, his dogs were known regionally as "Dobermann's Hunde". They gained a solid reputation for harsh strength of character and an ability to hunt, bite and kill vermin. Herr Dobermann crossed several types of dogs but did not keep records (there were no pure bred dogs at that time) and there is little agreement on the origins of the Dobermann.
In 1890 the Standard for the breed was written and approved by the German Kennel Club and remains basically the same - although judges today are accepting much larger dobermann than the standard calls for.

history%20prinz%20strick%20&%20prinzessin%20schlippche.jpg

Around the time of Herr Dobermann's death in 1891, came the Breeders: Goswin Tischler & Otto Goeller (photos left), who were very influential in the development of the Dobermann breed.

I think he would be proud to see how far the breed he started has come. You have to remember he was breeding many different dogs to come up with his Dobermann. It is the refinement of successfully breeding the same breed that has shaped the look we have today. As for the length of the crop, he may or may not like it, but one thing is for sure he would not like to see his dog with natural ears and a tail.
 
Guys this is one of the biggest reasons we are loosing - Very good - loving caring people are misguided by their very jaded philosophy. Go to the PETA and HSUS web sites and read what all they have in store for you. The world will not survive if they succeed in putting every single business that uses animals for food out of business and make no mistake that is there goal.

To ADD: On the confusing statement - the issues is not about c/d in reality - they have a far bigger agenda - they want to win this issue and get breed standards thrown out the window because the want to do away with purebred dogs. That is the real issue and why we can't let them win on this one. They knew they could not win if they just came out with their real agenda so they broke it down into thinks they know they can win and have already done so in some areas.
I think just like a lesson in school, sometimes it takes going over and over and over something, for it to sink in or to open ones eyes. I am a prime example. I donated to HSUS for years! All those sad, sick animals that came in the mail broke my heart and I wanted to help.....until little by little I became enlightened that those sad, sick animals were getting VERY little of my money! :stomp: They don't tell you that! :thumbdown: You have to find that out for yourself or listen to others like on DCF! :thumbsup: Giving to a local shelter is much more rewarding and helpful!

Now PETA is different story. I thought those people were freaks right from the beginning! Their agenda was so off the wall half the time that I was always amazed at the celebrities that flocked to them. :scratch: Wasn't it the President who swatted a fly and PETA protested? Give me an effing break!

Did you see the stunt they pulled in Chicago here?
http://www.wgntv.com/blogs/leshock-...cagos-michigan-avenue-20111215,0,849947.story
 
I hate to ignite a riot, but I was browsing the Internet and happened to look up 'tail docking' and found the following information on this site (http://www.petplace.com/dogs/tail-docking/page1.aspx):
​
How Long Is the Hospital Stay?The typical stay following a tail docking is 2 to 3 hours but will vary depending on the overall health of the pet and the underlying reason for the surgery. Most puppies are docked without anesthesia and are typically taken home shortly after the procedure.​
​
While I don't have a problem with docking of dogs in general, I find it extraordinarily cruel that any dog would be docked or otherwise cut on without anesthesia, no matter what the age. If this is a normal standard I can understand why PETA and others are looking to outlaw it. Why on earth would anyone vivisect an animal? How would they like it if their newborn baby had a finger or an ear removed without anesthesia? Is the theory that because they're so young they don't feel pain, or aren't strong enough to cause any damage to the 'surgeon' so it's ok? If this is the standard practice we're living in the dark ages, and really this needs to be outlawed. I really don't care that anesthesia is expensive, or risky to the animal, cutting off an appendage without anesthesia is an absolutely vile practice that is cruel and unnecessary, and in my opinion should be a punishable offense.

Here is another site that discusses the effects of docking on puppies:

http://www.projectspayneuter.com/petowner/ear&tail.htm

I'm not suggesting that docking or cropping be outlawed, just the cruel and vicious process of doing so without anesthesia. Sorry for reviving this discussion, but I'm outraged at this finding and wonder what others think.
 
With all due respect, I don't how in the world people can presume to speak for Mr. Dobermann...to know what he would or wouldn't like in todays Doberman(n).
 
I think he would be proud to see how far the breed he started has come. You have to remember he was breeding many different dogs to come up with his Dobermann. It is the refinement of successfully breeding the same breed that has shaped the look we have today. As for the length of the crop, he may or may not like it, but one thing is for sure he would not like to see his dog with natural ears and a tail.

I think he would be more disappointed seeing what a couch potato softies a good percentage of these dogs have become rather than seeing my dog with ears and a tail.
 
I hate to ignite a riot, but I was browsing the Internet and happened to look up 'tail docking' and found the following information on this site (http://www.petplace.com/dogs/tail-docking/page1.aspx):
​
How Long Is the Hospital Stay?The typical stay following a tail docking is 2 to 3 hours but will vary depending on the overall health of the pet and the underlying reason for the surgery. Most puppies are docked without anesthesia and are typically taken home shortly after the procedure.​
​
While I don't have a problem with docking of dogs in general, I find it extraordinarily cruel that any dog would be docked or otherwise cut on without anesthesia, no matter what the age. If this is a normal standard I can understand why PETA and others are looking to outlaw it. Why on earth would anyone vivisect an animal? How would they like it if their newborn baby had a finger or an ear removed without anesthesia? Is the theory that because they're so young they don't feel pain, or aren't strong enough to cause any damage to the 'surgeon' so it's ok? If this is the standard practice we're living in the dark ages, and really this needs to be outlawed. I really don't care that anesthesia is expensive, or risky to the animal, cutting off an appendage without anesthesia is an absolutely vile practice that is cruel and unnecessary, and in my opinion should be a punishable offense.

Here is another site that discusses the effects of docking on puppies:

http://www.projectspayneuter.com/petowner/ear&tail.htm

I'm not suggesting that docking or cropping be outlawed, just the cruel and vicious process of doing so without anesthesia. Sorry for reviving this discussion, but I'm outraged at this finding and wonder what others think.


Yes it is right , they say they don't feel the pain but it has been proven the do feel it , here is an article for you Quee to read

  • The whimpering and the 'escape response' (continual movements) exhibited by most puppies
    following tail docking, are evidence that they are feeling substantial pain. Animals tend to be
    more stoic than humans due to an inherent preservation instinct.
  • Because some puppies do not show signs of intense suffering, it does not mean that the pain
    inflicted on them has not registered in their central nervous system.
Cosmetic tail docking is most often performed without any anaesthesia or analgesia and only manual restraint
is used. General anaesthesia, if used, produces unconsciousness and muscle relaxation but does not affect the
sensory nerves and will not necessarily prevent 'dorsal horn wind' up or the development of pathological pain.
Movement of the patient may be controlled, but sensory stimuli will still register in the higher centres of the
central nervous system. On recovery from anaesthesia peripheral and central sensitisation, the mechanisms
underlying the generation of pathological pain will still he present.
 
While the puppies are under anesthesia and do not feel pain during the procedure, the healing process is long and painful. The ears must be kept taped up for several weeks or months and the sutures and tape used are very itchy and irritating to the pet. Seen from the irritation, the tape will have to be replaced repeatedly. Not to mention the pet is very uncomfortable and in pain.
Frequent visits to the vet to changes the tape and bandages are necessary. Owners often find the time and money required problematic. Failure to provide the diligent aftercare often leads to complications. Infections and/or failure of ears to stand are common, even after all the haste in preparation.

See this is how people who have fallen into the AR agenda really get to you - First what is LONG AND PAINFUL - If you cut your finger like a paper cut how long and painful is it? It gets better with each day and by day 3 when stitches come out there is no pain because the ears have healed. So if the sutures come out on day 7 and I know because I remove the stitches myself then how irritating is it? The sutures are not in when the ears are posted.

By this statement then we had better not put braces on children because that is long and painful for sure sometimes lasting a couple years and it is mostly cosmetic. My gosh they put children in those chairs and hold them down while they crank away on those braces to thighten them up - The teeth as they are jammed into a new position are sore and painful. Sometimes even forcing the poor child to have to eat a liquid diet.

See it is all about how you want to describe it - the above is no more an accurate picture of the brecing process than the tail docking and ear cropping. DO NOT FORGET dew claws which are removed at 3 days also.

Again have first hand knowledge of this after the stitches are out and the ears are healed a 7 day process the soreness is over and after the first week of posting if done correctly the complications are over. Every single puppy i s on antibiotics so very seldom are their complications.

You can't give a newborn anesthesia - for gosh sakes that would be dangerous at that age. See above. By the time the puppy is 10 lbs they are able to be put to sleep and that is about 7 weeks when ears are done. If a tail is cropped on a puppy 10 lbs or more then YES it is put to sleep.

As far as the study in Sweden on tail injuries I would say they are very very lucky - I was watching Dr. Pol on Nat Geo Wild last night and guess what - I about fell over - he had a pit bull come in who go their tail slammed in the door so he docked it AFTER putting the dog to sleep . My vet says he does quite a few tail dockings due to injuries so I guess we are wilder here in America than Sweden.

With ear posting instructions very few have to have the vet tape the ears and YES I would agree that vets are not good at taping. They think it has to be a major taping session and completely close up the ear - If they knew how to tape correctly it is a minimum. After the second taping puppies will come lay their head in your lap while you clean and massage the ears before reposting.

Quee - there are always people who can't even stand the sight of a needle does that mean it is curel to give shots? Shots hurt??? Or does it mean they probably should not become a nurse or doctor??? There are people who can't stand the sight of blood but thank goodness for those who are not squeemish. We do not need the squeemish making the decisions for others. They are over sensitve to the point of unrealistic visual images of what is happening just like on the other end you have those that abuse animals. Breeders and vets should fall in the middle ground where the utmost care is given with a minimum of pain.

BTW EVERY single puppy that is cropped comes home with a pain shot - after the first 24 hours they could care less. My puppies who might be the exception and extremely healthy come home dying to eat since they did not get to eat that morning. The first signs of stress is when a dog will not eat or take a yummy treat.
 

Back
Top