My Grim, Fearful Prediction

Your question is a good one. And opens a can of worms. :confused-alt:

I'm not even sure I want to answer it. lol But my stab at an answer is that some people might say they want a Doberman for all the other qualities in a Doberman 'package'. Regardless of C/D being restricted. I've heard it said here on DCF many times over the years.

While that's all well and good and well intended, I come from the 'old school' of Doberman standard. I am appalled that standards on ALL breeds are being torn down and people are letting it happen. I find it a shocking, sad state of affairs and something that I never thought would happen.

As far as I'm concerned, in 20 years there will be no 'breeds' anymore. All dogs will resemble each other. :(

There's your opened can of worms. :biggrin:
[DOUBLEPOST=1422879524,1422879157][/DOUBLEPOST]Oh boy, the next thread I go to really said it all here:
https://doberman-chat.com/community...e-comments-at-the-dog-show.22973/#post-395424
Archer posted my thoughts very well. (post #11)
Yeah, I noticed the discussions in the two threads briefly merged to cover the same topic.
[DOUBLEPOST=1422895999][/DOUBLEPOST]
Sorry, Von. I don't feel they are lepers at all. I just hate the standards are changing for all breeds. What's left if we don't have a standard?
Someone here proffered a pretty fun answer a while ago: Something like a 35 pound brown feral animal.
[DOUBLEPOST=1422896580][/DOUBLEPOST]
Sad to me that some people think a natural Doberman is like a leper and to be avoided at all costs. I believe this attitude is what turned me from pro crop and dock to neutral. It's almost like being natural is worse than being Z factored. I find the vanity personally sad when I know what a fantastic awesome dog the Doberman truly is on the inside.
For me, it's not the thing. It's the implication of the thing. The implication of people wanting and having natural Dobes. I don't automatically dislike a natural Doberman or its owner. It's just part of the picture that I painted in starting this thread.

One more element, though, is appearance. Of course a successfully cropped Doberman always looks better to me, but especially if that Doberman does not have the head to support floppy ears.

A few days ago I posted a pic of two good-looking Dobermanns with natural ears. I can say that when I see some of the more substantial Euro Dobes with natural ears, it looks fine.
 
My concern is that our breed might be heading the direction of some of the other noble breeds such as Great Dane and Boxer.
Again im probably in the minority here but those are both distinctly recognizable and equally beautiful dogs with or without cropped ears. (IMO)..

Gonna go totally to the left field with this one but its just a hypothetical ive pondered and am curious about, But.... The Pit Bull was once also typically seen Cropped. Today however thats not the case and its quite rare to see one Cropped.. And if you do that dog is likely owned by a thug that either fights dogs or envies those that do.. this is a very powerful propaganda tool in the fight to make the practice illegal... Playing on the heart strings of the general public.. What the average Joe doesn't realize is that in general the type of people that want to crop their dobermans vs the type of people that want to crop their pit bulls are very different and they have very different reasons to elect for the same procedure.. Back to my point.. Since Pit Bulls are far more popular in the US then Dobermans it stands to reason the general public relates to Dobermans much the same way as they do Thug owned APBT's and their likes. Now dont ask me how we are supposed to make the distinction for the general public because thats a tall order. I guess i just wonder how much of the animosity towards the PB's as a Cropped breed spills over into the realm of the Dobermans perception?
[DOUBLEPOST=1422896865][/DOUBLEPOST]
Yeah, I noticed the discussions in the two threads briefly merged to cover the same topic.
[DOUBLEPOST=1422895999][/DOUBLEPOST]
Someone here proffered a pretty fun answer a while ago: Something like a 35 pound brown feral animal.
[DOUBLEPOST=1422896580][/DOUBLEPOST]
For me, it's not the thing. It's the implication of the thing. The implication of people wanting and having natural Dobes. I don't automatically dislike a natural Doberman or its owner. It's just part of the picture that I painted in starting this thread.

One more element, though, is appearance. Of course a successfully cropped Doberman always looks better to me, but especially if that Doberman does not have the head to support floppy ears.

A few days ago I posted a pic of two good-looking Dobermanns with natural ears. I can say that when I see some of the more substantial Euro Dobes with natural ears, it looks fine.
I didnt mean for my post to point any fingers at anybody in particular.. I try very hard to be very general. its never been my intention (except for a few rare cases) to go after any individual opinions. we are all entitled to them.. Although i kind of believe thats were the problems begin, that word entitlement.. It would seem a good % of the population feels entitled to far more than an opinion..
 
@Gretchen_Red wrote: "I do know that my trainer says they've been seeing more and more Dobermans, they're making a come back and most of them are unC/unD. ."

Now, that strikes at the core of the issue for me. The rest of your post as well, really.
 
And then there's all the information on the Internet and books,things are painted with a different brush depending on where and what you read.Here's a for instance....

The Doberman Pinscher is a medium sized, squarely built dog with a compact, muscular body. The head is long and when viewed from the side, looks like a blunt wedge. The top of the skull is flat, and turns into the muzzle with a slight stop. The color of the nose depends on the color of the dog's coat; black on black dogs, dark brown on red dogs, dark gray on blue dogs, dark tan on fawn dogs and pink on white dogs. The teeth meet in a scissors bite. The color of the almond-shaped eyes is various shades of brown, depending on the coat color of the dog. In the USA ears are usually cropped to stand erect (cut at the age of about 12 weeks). The pup's ears have to be taped for a couple of months to make them stand up. A lot of breeders are starting to leave the pup's ears natural. If left natural they develop ears somewhat like a hound. The tail is usually docked at the age of 3 days. If the tail is not docked it grows a tail somewhat like a hound. Note: cropping ears and docking tails is illegal in a lot of countries and we are starting to see more and more dogs with their body parts left in tact. The chest is broad and the legs are perfectly straight. Dewclaws are sometimes removed. The short, hard, thick coat lies flat. Sometimes there is an invisible gray undercoat on the neck. The coat comes in black, black with tan markings, blue-gray, red, fawn and white. When markings appear they are above each eye, on the muzzle, throat, forechest, legs, feet and on the tail. There is also a solid white color. While white markings are considered a fault in some clubs, in others they are accepted.
 
I wonder how the other 3/4 of the worlds population feels about their natural Dobermanns being called crap bred dogs. People tend to forget the world isnt comprised of the USA solely.. as a matter of fact the C/D standard will be the Minority Defecto Doberman standard, if it isnt already.
That brings up a point: Isn't it strange that in the birthplace of the breed, C/D is now outlawed? All because of the notion of animal rights. What a spineless world we are becoming in many ways. The founders of the breed back in Germany weren't so silly.
 
That brings up a point: Isn't it strange that in the birthplace of the breed, C/D is now outlawed? All because of the notion of animal rights. What a spineless world we are becoming in many ways. The founders of the breed back in Germany weren't so silly.
Yes.It's strange.
Sissification of the country.
 
@Gretchen_Red wrote: "I wasn't saying they all were crap bred. I was saying the ones in the rescues, most of who were natural, appeared to be crap bred. There are some very good breeders who will allow for natural."

As I mentioned yesterday, the breeder of my current puppy isn't into C/D, and in fact, seems to be quite a fan of natural – loving the look of the ears and citing that the tail acts as a rudder and even that the dewclaws can help them in turning in the field and climbing trees. The tree part was, I think, mostly said in jest.

They are a very good breeder it seems to me. So the issue is not specifically C/D. It just plays a role in the larger issue about which I'm wondering.
[DOUBLEPOST=1422899488,1422898289][/DOUBLEPOST]@Gelcoater wrote: "The old saying good fences make good neighbors is amplified by good fence with pointy eared dog behind it.;)"

That's funny. See? :spit:

I was going to mention regarding C/D two experiences I've had recently (though it's not the only thing we're discussing here).

1.) My neighbor's car was stolen out of his open garage the other night. He's a nice older man. He brings guys over to his house, or has them come over, and they do some work for him. I've seen guys walking up our dead-end street that (hey, I don't discriminate) look down on their luck. It's like he offers work to the homeless or something.

We have full view of his house from our back porch which sits up pretty high. The other day I had my pup out on the back porch. I went to get him and saw him just staring at one of these friends of the old man down there. I was struck by the fact, as I looked down there between the goalposts that are his ears. A cropped Doberman says, like nothing else can, I AM WATCHING YOU.

2.) I've mentioned that one reason I believe docking is a benefit is that it does not allow an adversary to as readily see a wagging tail. I also hear advocates of non C/D say they can read their Dobes better by having the tail there.

I was setting out on a walk with our daughter and our pup, but I saw a man walking up the sidewalk who lives at the end of the street. He always walks on our side of the road in front of our house, so I knew he'd be coming right at us on the sidewalk. So I backed us up onto our front lawn. (I was having him heel and knew it would turn to chaos if we passed on the sidewalk). The man walks by and my pup goes nuts lunging and looking aggressive. Not that I wanted him too. I had commanded him not to bark in fact. He's only 7 months. But he looked aggressive to the guy.

The guy's comment? "I can't tell if his tail is wagging or not!"
[DOUBLEPOST=1422899992][/DOUBLEPOST]
Again im probably in the minority here but those are both distinctly recognizable and equally beautiful dogs with or without cropped ears. (IMO)..

Gonna go totally to the left field with this one but its just a hypothetical ive pondered and am curious about, But.... The Pit Bull was once also typically seen Cropped. Today however thats not the case and its quite rare to see one Cropped.. And if you do that dog is likely owned by a thug that either fights dogs or envies those that do.. this is a very powerful propaganda tool in the fight to make the practice illegal... Playing on the heart strings of the general public.. What the average Joe doesn't realize is that in general the type of people that want to crop their dobermans vs the type of people that want to crop their pit bulls are very different and they have very different reasons to elect for the same procedure.. Back to my point.. Since Pit Bulls are far more popular in the US then Dobermans it stands to reason the general public relates to Dobermans much the same way as they do Thug owned APBT's and their likes. Now dont ask me how we are supposed to make the distinction for the general public because thats a tall order. I guess i just wonder how much of the animosity towards the PB's as a Cropped breed spills over into the realm of the Dobermans perception?
[DOUBLEPOST=1422896865][/DOUBLEPOST]
I didnt mean for my post to point any fingers at anybody in particular.. I try very hard to be very general. its never been my intention (except for a few rare cases) to go after any individual opinions. we are all entitled to them.. Although i kind of believe thats were the problems begin, that word entitlement.. It would seem a good % of the population feels entitled to far more than an opinion..
Good question. I think there is a lot of spill-over. I've pretty much always felt that people view me as some sort of tough guy walking down the street with my cropped Dobe. I remember one neighbor years ago who was real nosy, judgmental and uncomfortable with newcomers. She had a real problem that I had my Dobe walk on the deck railing to learn control and balance.

After we had a confrontation, and we later had a discussion to try to reach a tolerable place, one thing she told me is that she always sees me walking down the street looking all mean and angry. I told her that most times she sees me I have just come back from a run and I have an intense look on my face, and that's how I feel. Anyway, I do think people make judgements upon seeing cropped ears.
 
I have had several GD's in the 80's, both cropped and uncropped. The cropped GD's look is very imposing and strikes fear in the heart of many people, while the uncropped dogs just look like overgrown dogs to me. With the crop going out of style for the breed over the last two decades, all the dogs I see nowadays look like very poor breedings of the GD. The only ones I see that have that Regal look are from quality breeders, have their ears cropped, and they are not easy to come by.

This is sad to me, and what I feel may happen to the Doberman as C/D is faded out. The ear quality of most GD's today can hardly take a crop, and many Dobermans are the same way. That is one aspect that is lost when the standard is not followed. The Dobermann in Europe will change in head appearance and ear shape and size, to follow the new standard. Also the popularity in the breed is waning, and I expect to see this trend continue.

Again it is a choice, but not at the expense of quality breeding!

RIP...Chief and Jazz image.webp
 
And to some of us, no preference either way. See the two "freebies" I have here. Bentley C/D and the other, sport docked only. In my opinion Bidgie's sport dock looks sillier than putty, as is how I see the new tall eared crop. They are worthy pets no matter their appearance. In my final opinion, they're all good. Whatever floats your boat and doesn't rock mine.

The freebies in quotes cause everyone knows free dogs are not free, Been pretty steady at 53 dollars each per month over the passed several years. I recall in times gone by spending 19 dollars per dog, per month. Those numbers are all inclusive.

Both2001.webp
 
And to some of us, no preference either way. See the two "freebies" I have here. Bentley C/D and the other, sport docked only. In my opinion Bidgie's sport dock looks sillier than putty, as is how I see the new tall eared crop. They are worthy pets no matter their appearance. In my final opinion, they're all good. Whatever floats your boat and doesn't rock mine.

The freebies in quotes cause everyone knows free dogs are not free, Been pretty steady at 53 dollars each per month over the passed several years. I recall in times gone by spending 19 dollars per dog, per month. Those numbers are all inclusive.

View attachment 39690
Good looking friends you have there! I agree on the longer tail dock, though I didn't know there was a name for it - "sport dock."

My last Dobe's tail was cut too long. The only benefit I found to it is that when the leash would get fouled between his hind legs, I could clear it by simply picking his back end up by the tail a few inches and swinging the leash free.
 
Good looking friends you have there! I agree on the longer tail dock, though I didn't know there was a name for it - "sport dock."

My last Dobe's tail was cut too long. The only benefit I found to it is that when the leash would get fouled between his hind legs, I could clear it by simply picking his back end up by the tail a few inches and swinging the leash free.

A Dober-handle! Who'd a thought you'd become a "Doberman handler" that way.
 
A Dober-handle! Who'd a thought you'd become a "Doberman handler" that way.
And now to go even further into the weeds: Years ago a friend of mine thought of an idea. We'd make a video of the Dobeerman. We'd somehow dispense some beer into a glass but have my Dobie between the beer and the camera. We'd pull the tail down, and out would come the beer!
 
Well, some people say beer tastes like dog piss. :shock::woot2::eek::wacky::wtf3: :D
[DOUBLEPOST=1422911136,1422910315][/DOUBLEPOST]
And to some of us, no preference either way. See the two "freebies" I have here. Bentley C/D and the other, sport docked only. In my opinion Bidgie's sport dock looks sillier than putty, as is how I see the new tall eared crop. They are worthy pets no matter their appearance. In my final opinion, they're all good. Whatever floats your boat and doesn't rock mine.

The freebies in quotes cause everyone knows free dogs are not free, Been pretty steady at 53 dollars each per month over the passed several years. I recall in times gone by spending 19 dollars per dog, per month. Those numbers are all inclusive.

View attachment 39690


Nothing personal, but a problem that I see is that what floats the boat of some people is a total ban of C/D. And these boat floaters are very powerful, which is why I take the position that I do that it must remain a choice, and I state it plainly. Like the lyric from the Rush song Freewill states, "If you choose not to decide you still have made a choice". I do not want anyone rocking my boat either which is why C/D should never be banned, for any reason.

But I must admit, that even if it is never banned there may one day be no vets that can perform it, as only a few learn how to do this anymore. It could possibly become just a lost art and function in veterinary school. Thus the PTB win by default.
 
I believe form follows function. Natural Dobermans work well with families. Cropped work very well as working dogs.

Form folllows function has nothing to do with neighbors perception. Form (structure) follows function (working breed) It means the dogs structure must support and enhance the function for which the dog was bred to do. It is misconceptions that have gone a long way to changing people's ideas all based on lack of knowledge.

So, if the breed is evolving, my point is I hope it doesn't wind up like what I perceive to be the state of the most commonly seen Boxer – a goofy, awkward ineffectual shell of what it once was.

A breed does not evolve backwards it adapts to what is needed. For example Most dobermans have already lost their back dew claws which tells me there were really useless ..........and I can only hope the front follow suit as they are ugly and easy to get hung up on blankets etc. They have no control over them so they just hang there to get caught on things.
I so agree. I have seen some very ugly boxers that do not come close to resembling the finer examples in the show ring. DG and I were just talking about that at the show this weekend.

I believe this attitude is what turned me from pro crop and dock to neutral. It's almost like being natural is worse than being Z factored. I find the vanity personally sad when I know what a fantastic awesome dog the Doberman truly is on the inside.

I have never heard anyone refer to anyone's dog as worse than a leper. DPCA rescue has more uncropped than cropped and most are poorly bred. They are much harder to place. But because it is an emotionally charged issue people project the fact we abhor the destruction of our standard onto someone beloved pet. That is not what any one intends in reality. The dogs can't help it just as the albino dogs did not ask to be born. It is the disregard for the standard and breeding against the standard that is the problem. Without a breed standard what do you think would have happened to Herr Dobermann's dogs??? Everyone would have gone their own direction with different purposes and visions til there were not more "true dobermann's as Herr Dobermann bred. The breed (all breeds) would be lost in the change. I have no problem with someone going out and breeding a new breed that is meant to be left uncropped and undocked. So whether it is breeding albino's or or not cropping/docking it is still changing the breed and not for the better.

I am very very sorry for those who have lost their rights, but I live in America and still have the right. Just as I do not believe in gun control, I do not believe in government intervention in the breeding of our animals. I joined two breed clubs who had COE and adopted the standard to follow and as a member of that club I agreed to follow their standard. I don't see that as entitlement. Because I love this breed just as it is, I therefore agreed to be bound by that standard and do my best to follow it. In every instance when the tried the "choice" route it led to the LOSS of the right to c/d. Everyone is looking to US to see if we will fall under the AR pressure. I don't see standing up and standing strong on your believes as entitlement.

A natural born Doberman is fine to own as a personal choice, but the C/D Doberman will always stand out in the crowd and should remain a choice of those that wish to choose to continue with the standard. Thus, the standard should not be changed for any reason.

How I wish this was the case but look around - look at the countries that opened their standard to include the description of the undone and now they have NO CHOICE. Give them an inch and they will take our dogs and destroy them.

There is also a solid white color. While white markings are considered a fault in some clubs, in others they are accepted.

You can tell whoever wrote that knows nothing about the purebred dog fancy and what it is about. I doubt they even know there is a standard and that "white" is a non allowed color. For me it is one of AKC's biggest hyprocrisies. They are for breed quality clears state that you are not to breed know defects yet allow a mutant gene that is known to be harmful all along promoting a million dollar health foundation to eliminate defects. Now go figure that one out.

And these boat floaters are very powerful, which is why I take the position that I do that it must remain a choice, and I state it plainly. Like the lyric from the Rush song Freewill states, "If you choose not to decide you still have made a choice". I do not want anyone rocking my boat either which is why C/D should never be banned, for any reason.

In fact it is not a choice per the standard - Ears normally cropped and carried erect - the uncropped ear will not stand erect - so the standard calls for cropped and docked. It actually does not allow for choice and it is a deviation from the standard so what breeder would intentionally breed to promote a deviation??? Just something to think about. Yes I stand by the standard that I joined DPCA and UDC to support our breed and to do my best to breed to adhere to that standard. I never considered not doing so an option.
 
How I wish this was the case but look around - look at the countries that opened their standard to include the description of the undone and now they have NO CHOICE. Give them an inch and they will take our dogs and destroy them.
Please show me where anyone is asking for the standard to be opened? You are seriously so blinded by fear that you can't even see that we are agreeing with you on the standard.. this is what frustrates so many people here..
 
Please show me where anyone is asking for the standard to be opened? You are seriously so blinded by fear that you can't even see that we are agreeing with you on the standard.. this is what frustrates so many people here..

I agree all I've asked for is choice. I've had both cropped and not cropped Dobermans.

When you have children cropped dogs (this could be any breed that's traditionally cropped) can cause problems with perceptions. Defined more clearly sometimes your childrens friends parents won't let their kids play at your house if they fear the dog. Also neighbors might fear you for no apparent reason. Irrationality is not something you can control. Since cropping is purely cosmetic and has no bearing on how the dog will perform this is a situation where I would want a not cropped dog.

On the other hand if I didn't have children and was looking for a dog that looked imposing before even becoming an aggressor I'd want a cropped dog.

I'm compelled to wonder, then, what are the desires and motivations of those who seek out uncropped Dobermans. I understand yours, or at least I understand what is your stated position. I'm not saying I agree with it.

You're not giving dog owners enough credit. People know that a cropped dog looks more imposing than a non cropped dog. Just like they know that a Doberman will be more protective than a Lab. As I've stated there's always a reason for cropping or not cropping. It depend on what you're looking for.

I like how Dobermans act, the velcroness, the protectiveness, the intelligence, etc. However right now I don't need a dog that looks imposing.
 
Please show me where anyone is asking for the standard to be opened? You are seriously so blinded by fear that you can't even see that we are agreeing with you on the standard.. this is what frustrates so many people here..

First I am not blind by fear or I would follow suit and be wishy washy claiming to support the standard but also supporting choice. Believe you me I would have more "friends" but I can't sacrifice my believes for those who don't care about a standard or understand how it protects our breed....any breed.

It is hard to explain to those who are not part of the culture but I will try to explain my position. First I CHOSE to join both DPCA and UDC because I believed in the Doberman, believed in those who created the standard to protect and preserve the standard, and who agree to be held to a higher calling in breeding.

The others have the CHOICE to not join the club, not be held to a standard, not be held to any COE's and to do their own thing. So you can see exactly where that leads us - oversized, albino's, poorly constructed, z - factored - uncropped and now we are facing undocked. What would the doberman look like today without these dedicated breeders who fight daily to preserve and protect our rich heritage and our rich traditions? With over 300 AKC reg breeder what direction, how many different directions would the dogs go and could you find any today who still are true dobermans without this standard and elite groups of folks who are sworn to protect it???? Once the stud books close and it becomes a recognized breed then all experimentation stops and we have a breed that breeds true to form and function. Breed clubs say we should breed to improve not go backwards destroying a look that defined our dogs as no other.

For those who do not choose to join and support those elite breeders who want to stay on course, they have the freedom to do their own thing and have it their way. The problem is today they feel entitled to change the breed to satisfy their own personal whims. I am not for stopping them right up and to the point it begins to infringe on my rights to follow a standard and a higher calling to breed quality. It is a double edged sword and we all struggle with it and the outcomes. But those who profess to love the breed should not be divided. We have a strong place to stand and that is in support of the standard. If the others become vocal and accepted then it will force the opening and changing of the standard so to say no one wants the standard opened with every single doberman who is not presented as close to the standard moves people in a different direction away from that standard. So what will dogs look like and act like when the standard falls under the "choice banner"???? I think we have to use some intelligence and consider that course. We have plenty of examples of poorly bred dogs to look at and we have the examples of Europe to see where choice led them. JMHO

You're not giving dog owners enough credit. People know that a cropped dog looks more imposing than a non cropped dog. Just like they know that a Doberman will be more protective than a Lab.

For me the answer is not to hide the breed or be deceptive. Personally I prefer they know exactly what the breed is because the safety of my children is or primary concern and few would dare to challenge a doberman if they knew it was a doberman. For me it is like lying and saying no it is not a "REAL" doberman. Hope that makes sense.
 

Back
Top