@Gretchen_Red wrote: "I wasn't saying they all were crap bred. I was saying the ones in the rescues, most of who were natural, appeared to be crap bred. There are some very good breeders who will allow for natural."
As I mentioned yesterday, the breeder of my current puppy isn't into C/D, and in fact, seems to be quite a fan of natural – loving the look of the ears and citing that the tail acts as a rudder and even that the dewclaws can help them in turning in the field and climbing trees. The tree part was, I think, mostly said in jest.
They are a very good breeder it seems to me. So the issue is not specifically C/D. It just plays a role in the larger issue about which I'm wondering.
[DOUBLEPOST=1422899488,1422898289][/DOUBLEPOST]
@Gelcoater wrote: "The old saying good fences make good neighbors is amplified by good fence with pointy eared dog behind it.

"
That's funny. See?
I was going to mention regarding C/D two experiences I've had recently (though it's not the only thing we're discussing here).
1.) My neighbor's car was stolen out of his open garage the other night. He's a nice older man. He brings guys over to his house, or has them come over, and they do some work for him. I've seen guys walking up our dead-end street that (hey, I don't discriminate) look down on their luck. It's like he offers work to the homeless or something.
We have full view of his house from our back porch which sits up pretty high. The other day I had my pup out on the back porch. I went to get him and saw him just staring at one of these friends of the old man down there. I was struck by the fact, as I looked down there between the goalposts that are his ears. A cropped Doberman says, like nothing else can, I AM WATCHING YOU.
2.) I've mentioned that one reason I believe docking is a benefit is that it does not allow an adversary to as readily see a wagging tail. I also hear advocates of non C/D say they can read their Dobes better by having the tail there.
I was setting out on a walk with our daughter and our pup, but I saw a man walking up the sidewalk who lives at the end of the street. He always walks on our side of the road in front of our house, so I knew he'd be coming right at us on the sidewalk. So I backed us up onto our front lawn. (I was having him heel and knew it would turn to chaos if we passed on the sidewalk). The man walks by and my pup goes nuts lunging and looking aggressive. Not that I wanted him too. I had commanded him not to bark in fact. He's only 7 months. But he looked aggressive to the guy.
The guy's comment? "I can't tell if his tail is wagging or not!"
[DOUBLEPOST=1422899992][/DOUBLEPOST]
Again im probably in the minority here but those are both distinctly recognizable and equally beautiful dogs with or without cropped ears. (IMO)..
Gonna go totally to the left field with this one but its just a hypothetical ive pondered and am curious about, But.... The Pit Bull was once also typically seen Cropped. Today however thats not the case and its quite rare to see one Cropped.. And if you do that dog is likely owned by a thug that either fights dogs or envies those that do.. this is a very powerful propaganda tool in the fight to make the practice illegal... Playing on the heart strings of the general public.. What the average Joe doesn't realize is that in general the type of people that want to crop their dobermans vs the type of people that want to crop their pit bulls are very different and they have very different reasons to elect for the same procedure.. Back to my point.. Since Pit Bulls are far more popular in the US then Dobermans it stands to reason the general public relates to Dobermans much the same way as they do Thug owned APBT's and their likes. Now dont ask me how we are supposed to make the distinction for the general public because thats a tall order. I guess i just wonder how much of the animosity towards the PB's as a Cropped breed spills over into the realm of the Dobermans perception?
[DOUBLEPOST=1422896865][/DOUBLEPOST]
I didnt mean for my post to point any fingers at anybody in particular.. I try very hard to be very general. its never been my intention (except for a few rare cases) to go after any individual opinions. we are all entitled to them.. Although i kind of believe thats were the problems begin, that word entitlement.. It would seem a good % of the population feels entitled to far more than an opinion..
Good question. I think there is a lot of spill-over. I've pretty much always felt that people view me as some sort of tough guy walking down the street with my cropped Dobe. I remember one neighbor years ago who was real nosy, judgmental and uncomfortable with newcomers. She had a real problem that I had my Dobe walk on the deck railing to learn control and balance.
After we had a confrontation, and we later had a discussion to try to reach a tolerable place, one thing she told me is that she always sees me walking down the street looking all mean and angry. I told her that most times she sees me I have just come back from a run and I have an intense look on my face, and that's how I feel. Anyway, I do think people make judgements upon seeing cropped ears.