• Disclaimer: Hello Guest, Doberman Chat Forums presents the opinions and material on these pages as a service to its membership and to the general public but does not endorse those materials, nor does it guarantee the accuracy of any opinions or information contained therein. The opinions expressed in the materials are strictly the opinion of the writer and do not represent the opinion of, nor are they endorsed by, Doberman Chat Forums. Health and medical articles are intended as an aid to those seeking health information and are not intended to replace the informed opinion of a qualified Veterinarian.”

DCM Due to Diet - FDA UPDATE 6/27/19

Just got this email today from Lotus Pet Food.

mail
Grain-Free Recipes and Canine Dilated Cardiomyopathy
There has been quite a bit of concern about a possible correlation between grain-free diets for dogs and canine dilated cardiomyopathy. The first topic that should be addressed is that the heart issue is likely caused by a food having a high percentage (over 30%) of legume seeds (peas, chick peas, lentils) in the food not that a food is grain-free or that a diet has potato (potatoes are not legumes). A diet high in legume seeds can block the absorption of amino acids which could result in a taurine deficiency. The other factor is most likely a lower percentage of fresh meats and or organ meats that supply the amino acids methionine and cysteine. The fact that some grain-free diets may be high in legume seeds and low in fresh meat is what could be causing the cases of canine dilated cardiomyopathy in dogs.
 
Just got this email today from Lotus Pet Food.

mail
Grain-Free Recipes and Canine Dilated Cardiomyopathy
There has been quite a bit of concern about a possible correlation between grain-free diets for dogs and canine dilated cardiomyopathy. The first topic that should be addressed is that the heart issue is likely caused by a food having a high percentage (over 30%) of legume seeds (peas, chick peas, lentils) in the food not that a food is grain-free or that a diet has potato (potatoes are not legumes). A diet high in legume seeds can block the absorption of amino acids which could result in a taurine deficiency. The other factor is most likely a lower percentage of fresh meats and or organ meats that supply the amino acids methionine and cysteine. The fact that some grain-free diets may be high in legume seeds and low in fresh meat is what could be causing the cases of canine dilated cardiomyopathy in dogs.
So is that saying that it's mostly the legume seeds and not potatoes?
 
I know its still confusing.
Other things that have come out saying potatoes also!
This is still in the beginning stages.

As I've said before that these pet food companies are putting in toooooooo much plant (cheaper than meat) ingredients to boost protein levels and NOT putting in enough meat! Also putting in less meat!
Dogs need meat proteins and not plants!

Now its biting them in the ASS! Which is great for pet owners but it sucks because of the pets suffering! And pet owners pocket books!
 
Forgot this was also part of the Lotus email

What makes Lotus better:
1. 3 out of our 4 diets grain-free foods have been formulated to keep the legume seed content at levels around 20% or lower (the lamb has a legume content that is in the high 20% but it also has a high fresh meat content of 38% with no rendered protein meals so the amino availability is very high).
mail

2. We use a lot fresh meat, up to 40%. Fresh meat amino acids are more bio-available than the amino acids from protein meals. Our Lotus Oven-Baked Grain-Free Lamb, Lotus Oven-Baked Grain-Free Sardine and Herring, and our Lotus Oven-Baked Grain-Free Turkey all use fresh meat only (no rendered proteins).
3. Our dog foods are oven-baked which means the amino acids in the meat don’t get denatured like they would in an extruded food. Typically, extruded lose about 20% of the bio availability of the amino in the food. In third party testing of amino acids Lotus showed that there was very little to no loss of most of the amino acids during baking - 90% to 100% retention. Our tests showed that Lotus is meeting the required amount for Methionine-cystine at .70% for growth and reproduction even after baking. These are the two amino acid building blocks that will produce the taurine the dog needs.
 
Yes, but since TOTW has all the not so good ingredients, I was going to change anyway. Why keep him on it if it’s not a big deal to change him over? And then, now TOTW has a class action law suit starting against them. I don’t think it’s worth the risk to stay on and test him if I am going to change kibble?.?..

Then use the new kibble for a while and test him then.
 
@Ddski5 i think they are requesting tests be done before a change over so that it can be submitted for the research that is being done with grain free food and low taurine. If you could schedule the blood draw for Tues. or Wed. when your vet opens back up after the holiday. They could easily fit you in for the blood draw.
Some labs require frozen blood sample and others want a vial of whole blood and a vial of plasma.
If your vet is using Antech or IDEXX labs they are charging $203. for the test with a 15 day turn around time. That cost is what the vet pays so expect a higher cost once the clinic adds their costs onto it.
UC Davis labs are offering a 24 to 48hr turnaround time at a cost of $74.
 
If the offending ingredients are in Totw, you would want to test before changing food. FDA also is asking those that come back low to save the food and lot number so they can pinpoint better.

Just left my vets office and they said they do Taurine testing.

I will start transitioning off of TOTW today with new kibble.

I wonder how long to be on new kibble before going in for the blood draw for Taurine test?

Edit: I believe I read it should be over 6 months on the food. This is why you would want to test now. Changing diet helps, but if the dog were to be low enough, a vet or cardiologist would probably want to supplement in addition to diet change. An echo may be ordered too.

The test results should not take long to come back from what I've seen in the FB group, Bri is right.

UC Davis labs are offering a 24 to 48hr turnaround time at a cost of $74.
 
So is that saying that it's mostly the legume seeds and not potatoes?
I would follow science and advisories given out by UC Davis only for right now. Not sure I could trust a dog food company at this moment, sorry. A lot of them are giving canned responses that because the FDA hasn't contacted them, their food is perfectly ok. Okay...
 
I think about what they pay these advertising execs, that most likely don’t own a dog or cat and would not know anything about nutritional values and health requirements.

Think of them as true wordsmiths. They grab your attention with the photographs and videos of the wolf and a dog running together, through beautiful landscape. This conjures up a true natural vision in your brain of what a dog should be.
The photographer is very skilled at getting the right pictures of real meat for the diet.
Now the creative ad team repeatedly use the words, natural, trusted sources, superior ingredients, carefully cultivated relationships with their sources, no bid contracts, the very finest of ingredients available.
Bingo... now they have you hooked. The average person is going to buy that product because they believe the words of the advertising team and manufacturers. Who doesn’t want to have their dog eating like their ancestors and living a healthy long life?
The average person doesn’t realize you need to research the ingredients because there is no such thing as “truth in advertising” anymore, especially when it comes to pet food. It’s all about the money.
Most likely the advertising budget is far greater than the production and sourced products combined.
If your pet gets extremely ill or dies as a result of their product ingredients they are nothing more than collateral damage of doing business and trust me that cost is factored into “just doing business as normal.”
Now you have people speaking up and learning about nutrition, what is good and what is toxic, not to mention you now have veterinary research teams exposing the causes of animals becoming ill and dying.
Hopefully this will put a spotlight on the FDA and AAFCO to do what they were hired and paid to do instead of allowing their pockets to be lined to look the other way.
Ok rant over.
 
Edit: I believe I read it should be over 6 months on the food. This is why you would want to test now. Changing diet helps, but if the dog were to be low enough, a vet or cardiologist would probably want to supplement in addition to diet change. An echo may be ordered too.
Just checked, it is 3 months on the diet to get an accurate reading. I'm sure your vet could confirm.
 
I think about what they pay these advertising execs, that most likely don’t own a dog or cat and would not know anything about nutritional values and health requirements.

Think of them as true wordsmiths. They grab your attention with the photographs and videos of the wolf and a dog running together, through beautiful landscape. This conjures up a true natural vision in your brain of what a dog should be.
The photographer is very skilled at getting the right pictures of real meat for the diet.
Now the creative ad team repeatedly use the words, natural, trusted sources, superior ingredients, carefully cultivated relationships with their sources, no bid contracts, the very finest of ingredients available.
Bingo... now they have you hooked. The average person is going to buy that product because they believe the words of the advertising team and manufacturers. Who doesn’t want to have their dog eating like their ancestors and living a healthy long life?
The average person doesn’t realize you need to research the ingredients because there is no such thing as “truth in advertising” anymore, especially when it comes to pet food. It’s all about the money.
Most likely the advertising budget is far greater than the production and sourced products combined.
If your pet gets extremely ill or dies as a result of their product ingredients they are nothing more than collateral damage of doing business and trust me that cost is factored into “just doing business as normal.”
Now you have people speaking up and learning about nutrition, what is good and what is toxic, not to mention you now have veterinary research teams exposing the causes of animals becoming ill and dying.
Hopefully this will put a spotlight on the FDA and AAFCO to do what they were hired and paid to do instead of allowing their pockets to be lined to look the other way.
Ok rant over.


Yuuuup
Pets don't care what the package looks like! Its all to grab the attention of pet owners. Lots of these pics on pet food I think are false advertising. But for the uniformed pet owner they work.
The pet food industry makes Billions $$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$
 
Think of them as true wordsmiths. They grab your attention with the photographs and videos of the wolf and a dog running together, through beautiful landscape. This conjures up a true natural vision in your brain of what a dog should be.
The photographer is very skilled at getting the right pictures of real meat for the diet.
Now the creative ad team repeatedly use the words, natural, trusted sources, superior ingredients, carefully cultivated relationships with their sources, no bid contracts, the very finest of ingredients available.
Exactly. My sister told me this exact thing years ago when she was telling me about Beneful. She said they put all these beautifully colored vegetables and meats on the bag to draw people in when in fact there's nothing good in that bag.

I was discussing some of this with my husband yesterday, who really just trusts me with all the animals care and doesn't have a clue about all the things we talked about here regarding food companies and they're deceptive practices. He says to me, don't the food companies know when they're putting stuff in their food that's bad for dogs? Oh my sweet, naive, husband. No! They don't give a shit what they put in! It's all about money.
 
Oliver's Story
by Julie Carter


Today has been a rough day. Exactly one month ago, we lost our beloved Oliver to Dilated Cardiomyopathy (DCM). He had just turned 4 years old and was a proud study enrolled Hero in the Golden Retriever Lifetime Study (GRLS). Oliver collapsed and died on my kitchen floor from a fatal arrhythmia. Something I now understand goes hand in hand with DCM.

Although I’m thankful that Oliver didn’t suffer, the manner in which he died was excruciatingly painful for us. Despite being less than 5 feet away when he dropped to the floor, there was nothing my husband or I could do to save him. He was gone in a matter of seconds, leaving us no time to say goodbye or accept what was happening.

DCM is a cruel and deceptive disease. From the day he was diagnosed to the day he died, Oliver looked and acted like the picture of health. He was strong, playful, energetic and completely asymptomatic. Our only clue there was a problem came when a heart murmur was detected during a GRLS vet visit. Within days, Oliver was at the cardiologist having blood work for a Taurine test (which came back at 209) and an echocardiogram. He was diagnosed with Dilated Cardiomyopathy that day and our lives were turned upside down. His cardiologist prescribed multiple cardiac medications and supplements while advising an immediate diet change. By his next meal, we began switching him to a grain inclusive, legume-free dog food and started giving him the prescribed medications and supplements.

For almost 3 years, Oliver was fed a grain-free limited ingredient kibble. The brand and type of food I chose was based on several pet store employee recommendations, as opposed to what my Veterinarian had suggested. I trusted the wrong people with my dog’s nutrition and he paid the price for my ignorance.

Oliver had his last echocardiogram the day before he died. Although his heart was still enlarged, the strength with which it was contracting had improved, leading his Cardiology team and our family to be cautiously optimistic. His heart gave us no indication of what was going to happen in less than 24 hours.

Although additional time and research is needed to determine the exact correlation between certain diets and DCM, there is no doubt dogs are now being diagnosed at an alarming rate. And, while some dogs have shown improvement with proper treatment, others like Oliver, Jax, Bruin and Harley have died, leaving their heartbroken families completely shattered.

If you believe your dog looks too healthy to have heart disease, think again. If you think your dog can’t have Taurine Deficient DCM because they aren’t acting ill, please think again. Oliver looked and acted perfectly normal until the moment he died.

Please be your dog’s advocate and spare your family the grief my family is suffering from. Educate yourself by reading everything in the FILES section on this Facebook page. Then, spread awareness wherever you go in order to help educate others. TAKE it, SHARE it and RUN with it! Together, we can be the change that will save lives.

Screenshot_20180903-180542~2.webp
 
Despite being less than 5 feet away when he dropped to the floor, there was nothing my husband or I could do to save him. He was gone in a matter of seconds, leaving us no time to say goodbye or accept what was happening.


My heart breaks for them. I experienced this very thing with my Chaos. :( It's devastating.



DCM is a cruel and deceptive disease. From the day he was diagnosed to the day he died, Oliver looked and acted like the picture of health. He was strong, playful, energetic and completely asymptomatic. Our only clue there was a problem came when a heart murmur was detected during a GRLS vet visit.


^^^^ This is the hard part for me. Drake looks and acts so healthy. So hard to watch him run and play because of my fear of him dropping right in front of me. That is my heart talking, I'm not ready to lose him. My brain knows that it's about the quality. Sitting on the couch is no life for a dog like Drake. My head and heart have this argument every single day. So far my head wins, it only takes watching him wrestle with Rue or to see him stand there so majestic waiting for me to throw the ball. I love a happy dog!
 

The most recent FDA Betrayal
upload_2018-9-5_23-12-23.webp
It’s so much worse than the fox guarding the hen house…
http://truthaboutpetfood.com/the-most-recent-fda-betrayal/
upload_2018-9-5_23-12-23.webp
Wishing you and your pet(s) the best,
Susan Thixton
Pet Food Safety Advocate
Author Buyer Beware, Co-Author Dinner PAWsible
TruthaboutPetFood.com
Association for Truth in Pet Food

Become a member of our pet food consumer Association. Association for Truth in Pet Food is a a stakeholder organization representing the voice of pet food consumers at AAFCO and with FDA. Your membership helps representatives attend meetings and voice consumer concerns with regulatory authorities. Click Here to learn more.
What’s in Your Pet’s Food?
Is your dog or cat eating risk ingredients? Chinese imports? Petsumer Report tells the ‘rest of the story’ on over 5,000 cat foods, dog foods, and pet treats. 30 Day Satisfaction Guarantee. Click Here to preview Petsumer Report. www.PetsumerReport.com

The most recent FDA Betrayal
By Susan Thixton
- September 5, 2018
FDAFoxHen-765x383.jpg


It’s so much worse than the fox guarding the hen house…

Imagine if your pet got sick, and the illness led to your beloved pet’s death. You learn your pet died because of heart disease somehow linked to the “complete and balanced” grain-free pet food you trusted. The FDA announces an investigation. You and thousands of other pet owners are slightly comforted that perhaps FDA will stop other pets from dying like your pet did. But will that FDA investigation be in the best interests of pets?

Maybe not. Some very concerning information has been graciously provided to TruthaboutPetFood.com by a concerned anonymous source.

What the FDA told pet owners is not exactly true…

The FDA’s original announcement of the agency’s investigation into the “Potential Connection Between Diet and Cases of Canine Heart Disease” was published on July 12, 2018. In this announcement FDA told consumers the agency was collaborating with veterinary laboratories in their investigation: “The FDA’s Center for Veterinary Medicine and the Veterinary Laboratory Investigation and Response Network, a collaboration of government and veterinary diagnostic laboratories, are investigating this potential association.”

In that first FDA announcement, the FDA directly lied to consumers. The truth is – at the time FDA told consumers they were working with “veterinary diagnostic laboratories” – they were actually working with the trade association representing the VERY PET FOOD MANUFACTURERS linked to perhaps thousands of dog illnesses and deaths. Provided to TruthaboutPetFood.com by an anonymous source is the following letter the Pet Food Institute sent out on June 12, 2018 – one month prior to the date FDA told the public they were collaborating with “veterinary diagnostic laboratories”…

PFIFDAnotice.png


Dr. Martine Hartogensis – of FDA’s Center for Veterinary Medicine Office of Surveillance and Compliance – contacted the trade association that represents the majority of the pet food manufacturers whose pet foods are linked to the DCM illnesses and deaths ONE MONTH PRIOR to FDA telling consumers.

The companies who manufacture the pet foods were MORE IMPORTANT to FDA than the people whose dogs were sick and dying.
And…one month prior to alerting consumers to the pet food problem – the agency had provided the Pet Food Institute a slide presentation on the issue. This slide presentation has NEVER been provided to consumers by FDA – FDA ONLY considered industry important enough to be provided with investigation details.

You need to clink on the link The most recent FDA Betrayal
to see this 15 Page document
Grain Free Versus Non Grain Free Foods


Not only is the fox guarding the hen house, but now the fox has been enlisted to help determine why there was a security breach in the hen house.

And unfortunately, there is more bad news about this FDA investigation.

FDA is also directly working with (these are what we know of)…

Both Natural Balance and Nutrish manufacture a grain-free dog food.

  • Pet Nutrition Alliance, an organization that offers (somewhat biased) pet food ‘education’ to veterinarians. Pet Nutrition Alliance is “generously” supported by…
PNASponsor-500x216.png


In their ‘attempt’ to help FDA in this investigation, Pet Nutrition Alliance sent out a questionnaire to small pet food manufacturers, that appears to be threatening them to respond (in my opinion). The questions were not science based – they were asking these small manufacturers questions if they employ a “nutrition expert” to formulate their diets and if these small manufacturers own their manufacturing facilities.

These two questions will sound familiar to most pet owners – it’s very common marketing of Big Pet Feed (we make our own food, we employ board certified nutritionists). And they are interesting questions because it WAS NOT a board certified nutritionist that caught this problem in pet food – it was Dr. Joshua Stern that found it, associate professor and residency program director for cardiology at the University of California, Davis. Click Here to view the Pet Nutrition Alliance questionnaire (graciously provided by an anonymous source).

How can pet owners depend on the proper outcome of this FDA investigation?
In my opinion, this is one of the worst displays of FDA bias in recent years. Why the agency is ‘working with’ (and only with) the very pet food manufacturers responsible for the illnesses and deaths is beyond me. If the agency truly wanted to act in the best interest of pets, they would have reached out to all pet food manufacturers – to get both sides of the story. If they wanted to perform an unbiased investigation, the FDA would have reached out to Dr. Karen Becker, Dr. Barbara Royal, Steve Brown and other great modern minds of pet nutrition for opinion. If the FDA was truly performing an investigation to protect pets (and not protect industry), the agency would have kept pet owners more informed (AND not lied to them).

But that’s not what happened.

This is a very serious issue that can ONLY begin to be resolved if the FDA is completely transparent with pet owners from this moment forward.

The following email was sent to FDA 9/5/2018…

Dr. Patrick McDermott
Acting Director
Office of Surveillance and Compliance
Center for Veterinary Medicine, Food & Drug Administration

Dr. McDermott –

I write you sharing great frustration. It appears that once again, FDA is considering the interests of industry over the interests of pets/pet owners. On July 12, FDA published a notice to their investigation into the “Potential Connection between Diet and cases of Canine Heart Disease”. The FDA specifically told consumers the agency was collaborating with “the Veterinary Laboratory Investigation and Response Network” in this announcement. But..as evidence has been provided to TruthaboutPetFood.com – we have learned this statement was not true. Evidence provided to us shows that FDA was beginning to collaborate with the Pet Food Institute one month prior to alerting consumers of an FDA investigation. Evidence provided to us shows that FDA provided PFI a slide presentation prior to June 12, 2018.

Your July 12 announcement did NOT tell consumers the entire story, the agency conveniently forgot to tell consumers they had been working with a pet food manufacturer stakeholder group – the VERY group that represents most of the suspect pet foods. With all due respect, the fact is the agency lied to thousands of grieving and worried pet food consumers.

It is with great regret that we learned FDA reached out to ONLY one stakeholder organization (the Pet Food Institute) but the agency did not reach out to TruthaboutPetFood.com and/or AssociationforTruthinPetFood.com for assistance in this investigation. The FDA also did not reach out to the other pet food manufacturer stakeholder organization Next Generation Pet Food Manufacturers Association who represents human grade ingredient pet foods. Unless the FDA is open and willing to work with all stakeholder organizations to resolve a serious issue, this displays certain bias of the agency.

With all due respect, how can any consumer trust the resolve the FDA determines in the grain-free/DCM connection? The agency’s actions thus far are clearly in the best interest of pet food manufacturers. How can we trust FDA to find a resolve that is solely in the best interest of pets?

For the best interest of all pet food consumers, we are requesting immediate change to how FDA handles this investigation. We request the agency make public on the FDA website 100% of the investigation thus far – and every step throughout the investigation. We request every email, notes from every phone conversation, every meeting, every document, laboratory results and every email between FDA and who ever the agency has or will speak to in the future. We request daily updates on the FDA website – live (or close to it) updates for pet food consumers.

The FDA betrayed pet food consumers by speaking with industry first. And if law were enforced, this situation might not have ever happened. If you recall – ALL regulatory authorities – each State Department of Agriculture and FDA sat back and did nothing for YEARS while pet food manufacturers were using pea protein, pea fiber, and pea starch when these ingredients were not defined by AAFCO, not legal. As well, Section 1002 of the Food and Drug Administration Amendments Act required FDA to develop “Ingredient Standards and Definitions; (2) Processing Standards; and (3) Labeling Standards Including nutritional and ingredient information”. This legal requirement of FDA was supposed to be completed by September 2009. Unfortunately for ALL pet food consumers, FDA has never completed this work. Considering just ingredient standards AND processing standards – had FDA completed this work as required -perhaps, this could have prevented these illnesses and deaths.

So here we are again, with a serious situation that is costing many pets their lives. Unfortunately we cannot turn back time. BUT, we can change the future.

Please put pet health as priority over industry interests. Please post every single bit of information on the FDA website – daily. Please be transparent with your investigation. Please work with pet food consumers.

Representing Pet Food Consumer Members of Association for Truth in Pet Food –

Susan Thixton

If any pet owner would like to express their opinion on the grain-free/DCM investigation to FDA, you can send your comments to Center for Veterinary Management – [email protected].

Example email:

As a pet owner and consumer, I am very concerned at the FDA bias in the investigation of “Potential Connection between Diet and cases of Canine Heart Disease”. The FDA has not been transparent with consumers, and is directly working with the very companies being investigated in this issue. With all due respect, how can I trust the resolve the FDA determines in the grain-free/DCM connection? The agency’s actions thus far are clearly in the best interest of pet food manufacturers. How can I trust FDA to find a resolve that is solely in the best interest of pets?

For the best interest of all pet food consumers, I am requesting immediate change to how FDA handles this investigation. I am requesting the agency make public on the FDA website 100% of the investigation thus far – and every step throughout the investigation. I am requesting every email, notes from every phone conversation, every meeting, every document, laboratory results and every email between FDA and who ever the agency has or will speak to in the future. I am requesting daily updates on the FDA website – live (or close to it) updates for pet food consumers.

Please put pet health as priority over industry interests. Please post every single bit of information on the FDA website – daily. Please be transparent with your investigation. Please work with pet food consumers.

[Your Name]



My sincere apologies to the thousands of pet owners that are directly involved in this FDA investigation. The FDA did you wrong. I’m sorry this happened to you. Let us hope they see the error of their ways and correct that HUGE ERROR.

Big Thank You to Anonymous. Without you, FDA would still be misleading consumers.



Wishing you and your pet(s) the best,

Susan Thixton
Pet Food Safety Advocate
Author Buyer Beware, Co-Author Dinner PAWsible
TruthaboutPetFood.com
Association for Truth in Pet Food

atpfbannersmall-295x120.jpg

Become a member of our pet food consumer Association. Association for Truth in Pet Food is a a stakeholder organization representing the voice of pet food consumers at AAFCO and with FDA. Your membership helps representatives attend meetings and voice consumer concerns with regulatory authorities. Click Here to learn more.

What’s in Your Pet’s Food?
Is your dog or cat eating risk ingredients? Chinese imports? Petsumer Report tells the ‘rest of the story’ on over 5,000 cat foods, dog foods, and pet treats. 30 Day Satisfaction Guarantee. Click Here to preview Petsumer Report. www.PetsumerReport.com

2018listseal_B-small.png




The 2018 List
Susan’s List of trusted pet foods. Click Here to learn more.



Have you read Buyer Beware? Click Here

Cooking pet food made easy, Dinner PAWsible

Find Healthy Pet Foods in Your Area Click Here
 
Has anyone done the taurine testing with UC Davis? I know we posted the information on here somewhere but I want I get Nero tested and have his echocardiogram done before switching his food. I likely will stay with the same brand, just switch to a non-grain free alternative. It was really hard picking up more food today and sticking with the same thing, knowing it's best to to get the testing done first, then switch. :( But I made sure to grab the flavor that didn't have sweet potato second or peas third!
 

Back
Top