• Disclaimer: Hello Guest, Doberman Chat Forums presents the opinions and material on these pages as a service to its membership and to the general public but does not endorse those materials, nor does it guarantee the accuracy of any opinions or information contained therein. The opinions expressed in the materials are strictly the opinion of the writer and do not represent the opinion of, nor are they endorsed by, Doberman Chat Forums. Health and medical articles are intended as an aid to those seeking health information and are not intended to replace the informed opinion of a qualified Veterinarian.”

Aloof vs Fear

Curing

Member
I thought this might be an interesting discussion that may help people understand the difference and be able to pick up on whether a dog is aloof or lacks nerve.
But also whether a dogs lack of nerve is due to its genetics or due to poor upbringing and training.

I’m sure we’ve all run into someone with a reactive dog who blames the dogs reactivity on abuse. The ones who say “he was abused by a man so he snaps at men”

Or the people who excuse fearful behaviors due to the dog being “aloof”

So I’d love to hear all YOUR thoughts.

How do you tell between and aloof vs a weak nerved dog.

How do you tell between a dog that is weak nerved due to genetics vs one who is weak nerved due to improper training and upbringing?

My thoughts below!
 
So I’m still learning about animal behavior everyday. It really intrigues me, I was once told that a dog who is genetically weak nerved can only ever be managed and won’t really “change”
Meaning despite all the training in the world, they will always struggle with certain things.
Whereas a dog with stronger nerves that maybe wasn’t raised correctly CAN change with proper training to show their true self.

So those are my thoughts!
 
Rubie is aloof. If she wants someones attention, she will initiate it. Moo is still a puppy so he's usually confident but there are situations in which we will appear fearful (unsure) and we work through them to build his confidence.

I think in an aloof dog is approached, they basically ignore you but their body language is still confident (straight, upright, proud looking). If they become uncomfortable, they go all rigid and may growl.

If a fearful dog is approached, they appear submissive (trying to make themselves look smaller, tail tucked, whites of the eyes showing, licking or panting).

Both aloof and fearful dogs will resort to biting if their body language is ignored and their boundaries are pushed. Pictures of people putting their dogs and children in 'cute' poses but where the dog clearly looks rigid, is panting, showing the whites of their eyes... that's all body language to say "back off" that people ignore for the sake of social media.

As for genetics vs environment, I think that's getting into nature vs nurture which can be very difficult to determine.

There was a very interesting and disturbing documentary on Netflix, Three Identical Strangers, that discusses nature vs nurture in an unorthodox (and probably unethical) way. I think reputable breeders certainly breed for the temperament they want but a litter of puppies can certainly vary in their 'nerve' as much as a couple of kids from the same family can differ in personalities.

I think it's more difficult to find a dog that is weak nerved because of training. I have an uncle who trains his dogs in a way that I don't necessarily agree with (a little heavy handed for my liking and just generally uneducated in the matter). His dogs are obedient but not confident which I guess could be seen as lacking nerve.

Our friends adopted a pit who has scars all over from, presumably, being a bait dog. She LOOOOVES people but does not like other dogs. It's hard to tell if she doesn't like other dogs because of her experience prior to their adopting her or because she was bred to not like other dogs with the intent of fighting them.

Interesting topic!
 
My two are totally different in personality. My female is a social butterfly and will eagerly accept attention from most people but especially ones she knows. She is also one that has a bit of sharpness to her, as in she will defend her ground and me when a situation warrants it. She is confident but friendly. She does not like being overwhelmed with more than two people approaching her at the same time but does remain stable. I remove her from those situations.

My male is confident and totally aloof with strangers and people he knows. He is all about me and my movements around people. He doesn’t tense up or display stressed behavior, he is confident and chooses to ignore advances to him. He prefers attention to come from me or my husband. The one exception is little blond haired girls. He goes absolutely all mushy over them. He acts like he hates other dogs when he is in the vehicle or behind the fence, but is accepting of them in a controlled environment. If they both had their preference they would only play with me and each other. They are not keen on romping with other dogs. They want to work, train and play. That’s where their focus is. I heeded @Doberman Gang advice and made myself the most exciting thing in their world and it shows how well it works when they are off lead with me. Bogie did break command once and allowed his prey drive to take over to chase a sprinting deer. I did use a stim to get his focus back on me and he returned immediately. I allow them to free run off lead but they will go 100’ then immediately come back and check in with me, then run again. I have tried hiding from them and they will go crazy trying to find me, which is only moments for them to locate me.
I think both nature and nurture go hand in hand with training a stable dog.
Geez, hope I did not veer off topic in my tangent. Lol
 
I wish I could take some time off and truly observe all the different mentalities of dogs. I understand what high/low drive is but the different levels of sharpness and if a dog has nerve and of what kind is very interesting to me.
 
I believe nerve is genetic but confidence can be built or destroyed. So a dog with poor genetics nerve wise can be taught to gave some confidence and improve slightly just as a strong nerve dog can be broken through bad training and abuse.

This is so true and something I think too many people forget!!
Like I think this really hits the nail on the head for me!
Thank you!
 
I wish I could take some time off and truly observe all the different mentalities of dogs. I understand what high/low drive is but the different levels of sharpness and if a dog has nerve and of what kind is very interesting to me.

Me too!
I feel like this is what really sets a lot of handlers and trainers apart. I’ve met too many trainers and handlers who were only focused on one aspect of the dog such as drive and didn’t focus on the whole of them and miss out on a lot because of that!
 
My two are totally different in personality. My female is a social butterfly and will eagerly accept attention from most people but especially ones she knows. She is also one that has a bit of sharpness to her, as in she will defend her ground and me when a situation warrants it. She is confident but friendly. She does not like being overwhelmed with more than two people approaching her at the same time but does remain stable. I remove her from those situations.

My male is confident and totally aloof with strangers and people he knows. He is all about me and my movements around people. He doesn’t tense up or display stressed behavior, he is confident and chooses to ignore advances to him. He prefers attention to come from me or my husband. The one exception is little blond haired girls. He goes absolutely all mushy over them. He acts like he hates other dogs when he is in the vehicle or behind the fence, but is accepting of them in a controlled environment. If they both had their preference they would only play with me and each other. They are not keen on romping with other dogs. They want to work, train and play. That’s where their focus is. I heeded @Doberman Gang advice and made myself the most exciting thing in their world and it shows how well it works when they are off lead with me. Bogie did break command once and allowed his prey drive to take over to chase a sprinting deer. I did use a stim to get his focus back on me and he returned immediately. I allow them to free run off lead but they will go 100’ then immediately come back and check in with me, then run again. I have tried hiding from them and they will go crazy trying to find me, which is only moments for them to locate me.
I think both nature and nurture go hand in hand with training a stable dog.
Geez, hope I did not veer off topic in my tangent. Lol

not at all! Hearing about varying personalities and how people work with their dogs is awesome and really helps me learn just how intricate it all is. Like how amazing is it how different each dog is!
 
I wish I could take some time off and truly observe all the different mentalities of dogs. I understand what high/low drive is but the different levels of sharpness and if a dog has nerve and of what kind is very interesting to me.
After close to 3 yrs with my two, it’s amazing to watch the body language of them. I am with them almost constantly and have learned their ‘tells’ to the point of almost predicting their next move. Of course they learned that about me very early on.:D
They seem to know what I am going to do even before I do. A simple gesture never goes unobserved by them and I am the same way with them. A flinch or twitch, tilt of the head, their eyes all lead to an action that they are anticipating or ready to perform. Many times verbal commands are not necessary with these two. They will look at my face and posture and seem to know what I am asking of them. Hand signals are a snap for them and I truly think they prefer signing over verbal. They seem to respond more readily with hand signals. Verbals bore them. Lol
Their capacity for motion memory is incredible. I will sit and watch my birds body language as well. They seem to have bad days like us and prefer not to be bothered and it shows in their body language.
Reading an animal’s body language correctly will certainly help prevent a bite or full on attack. I don’t approach strange dogs, they have to come to me if they want attention. Working in a vet clinic certainly helps you in reading an animal. They are at their most vulnerable with the sights, sounds and smells of an animal hospital. Just watching their body language as they are walking into a clinic is helpful in knowing how to proceed with them to prevent further stress.
 
For instance, the first time I/Ragnar went to do some Schutzhund training, I was warned by two members not to walk behind their trucks because their GS would absolutely go off and to also not look into their dogs eyes when walking around us. Somebody did walk behind their trucks (not me) and the dogs went fricking beserk and took a while to calm down- owners were pissed.

During their time training on the field, I could tell that these dogs were at a another whole level of intensity than I am use too. Ragnar is high drive and can be intense at times but he is not like so jacked up that he scares folks around him. These owners stated these were protection only dogs and no one was allowed to approach or pet their dogs; they were super proud of the intense persona their dogs emit. I even made the comment that maybe Ragnar did not belong there if he was not as dangerous and intense. The head person and assistant heard me and said no, that Ragnar was very much well rounded and felt as if he would be successful at Schutzhund training- he may not reach IPO3 but we would both greatly enjoy it.

Anyways....
As said, I have no experience with nerve and sharpness so I would like to know the thoughts of an objective mind on these different mentalities. I guess it all depends on what you want, to have a dog so sharp and intense that it’s public beware or is the dog crazy and owners just hide it through obedience??
 
After close to 3 yrs with my two, it’s amazing to watch the body language of them. I am with them almost constantly and have learned their ‘tells’ to the point of almost predicting their next move. Of course they learned that about me very early on.:D
They seem to know what I am going to do even before I do. A simple gesture never goes unobserved by them and I am the same way with them. A flinch or twitch, tilt of the head, their eyes all lead to an action that they are anticipating or ready to perform. Many times verbal commands are not necessary with these two. They will look at my face and posture and seem to know what I am asking of them. Hand signals are a snap for them and I truly think they prefer signing over verbal. They seem to respond more readily with hand signals. Verbals bore them. Lol
Their capacity for motion memory is incredible. I will sit and watch my birds body language as well. They seem to have bad days like us and prefer not to be bothered and it shows in their body language.
Reading an animal’s body language correctly will certainly help prevent a bite or full on attack. I don’t approach strange dogs, they have to come to me if they want attention. Working in a vet clinic certainly helps you in reading an animal. They are at their most vulnerable with the sights, sounds and smells of an animal hospital. Just watching their body language as they are walking into a clinic is helpful in knowing how to proceed with them to prevent further stress.

I found my 2 dogs are more responsive to hand signs too which is cool but also can be a bigger especially during long distance commands lol! So we spend a lot of time work just voice commands, but dang it’s amazing how well they can pick up small things and know exactly what you’re gonna ask!
 
For instance, the first time I/Ragnar went to do some Schutzhund training, I was warned by two members not to walk behind their trucks because their GS would absolutely go off and to also not look into their dogs eyes when walking around us. Somebody did walk behind their trucks (not me) and the dogs went fricking beserk and took a while to calm down- owners were pissed.

During their time training on the field, I could tell that these dogs were at a another whole level of intensity than I am use too. Ragnar is high drive and can be intense at times but he is not like so jacked up that he scares folks around him. These owners stated these were protection only dogs and no one was allowed to approach or pet their dogs; they were super proud of the intense persona their dogs emit. I even made the comment that maybe Ragnar did not belong there if he was not as dangerous and intense. The head person and assistant heard me and said no, that Ragnar was very much well rounded and felt as if he would be successful at Schutzhund training- he may not reach IPO3 but we would both greatly enjoy it.

Anyways....
As said, I have no experience with nerve and sharpness so I would like to know the thoughts of an objective mind on these different mentalities. I guess it all depends on what you want, to have a dog so sharp and intense that it’s public beware or is the dog crazy and owners just hide it through obedience??
I know just what you’re talking about and also wonder the same.
I don’t think I’d personally would want a dog like that. I was always told that the best dogs for the sport were dogs that knew when to turn on and when to turn off. Calm confident assured dogs etc. but I see a lot of those very high intensity dogs and I wonder if it’s just personal preference or truly those are the dogs people feel has what it takes to really take them too the top!
 
For instance, the first time I/Ragnar went to do some Schutzhund training, I was warned by two members not to walk behind their trucks because their GS would absolutely go off and to also not look into their dogs eyes when walking around us. Somebody did walk behind their trucks (not me) and the dogs went fricking beserk and took a while to calm down- owners were pissed.

During their time training on the field, I could tell that these dogs were at a another whole level of intensity than I am use too. Ragnar is high drive and can be intense at times but he is not like so jacked up that he scares folks around him. These owners stated these were protection only dogs and no one was allowed to approach or pet their dogs; they were super proud of the intense persona their dogs emit. I even made the comment that maybe Ragnar did not belong there if he was not as dangerous and intense. The head person and assistant heard me and said no, that Ragnar was very much well rounded and felt as if he would be successful at Schutzhund training- he may not reach IPO3 but we would both greatly enjoy it.

Anyways....
As said, I have no experience with nerve and sharpness so I would like to know the thoughts of an objective mind on these different mentalities. I guess it all depends on what you want, to have a dog so sharp and intense that it’s public beware or is the dog crazy and owners just hide it through obedience??
There are a lot of people out there that train their dogs in the old school way of thinking. They are kennel dogs, they only get out when they are getting trained, they owners don’t want anyone touching them or petting them, the dogs have never had that picture so would probably lash out at a stranger. It is poor dysfunctional training in my opinion. Not saying that is the case with those dogs but it sounds similar to what I have seen many times. I also have met the people who will say “My dogs only train in civil work” (Personal Protection) and make some negative response about my dogs being sport dogs. Then once protection training is over, I will offer them the opportunity to put on some gear and take bites from my dogs. So far none have taken me up on it.
I say go have fun, train the way you feel is the best and most fun for you and your dog. I have trained and competed with some of the top competitors and most of them will tell you their dogs are house dogs that hang out with them in the house. This is the true bond, train together live together. That doesn’t mean they want you petting their dogs though. Blaze doesn’t seek out people for petting. I don’t specifically tell people they can’t pet him but most people just let him be. This is what I prefer, I am his bond, the one that is going to play with him, everyone else is just a part of the environment.
 
I'm having to deal with a fearful puppy that I visit for an hour every day for my neighbors (they both work and the 6 mo old pit bull mix pup and their 11 year old GSD are left alone all day, & it's my job to go over and let them out for an hour). She's a shelter adopted mix breed and so shy and so timid I almost don't know how to deal with it. The first time I went to let her out of her crate she wet herself and I had to coax her out of the crate with treats (I was told in advance that's probably what would happen). This fearfulness and timid behavior is genetic, she was never abused or beaten. The couple have had her for 4 months now and she's better (doesn't wet herself and bounds out of the crate when I open it) but still so shy it's sad. I've tried to entertain her, play gently, talk silly to her etc etc. She did go to basic obedience class once a week for 6 weeks with the owners, and that helped, but still. So glad this is not my dog!!! It's a helpless feeling to try to create fun with the dog and she doesn't want to reciprocate. She will tug with her owners but not with strangers, or even me who she's known for a couple of months now. So yeah, you can help with confidence, but inborn personality is not going to go away. Plus I feel terribly sorry for her growing up in a crate, even if it's xtra large.
 
I'm having to deal with a fearful puppy that I visit for an hour every day for my neighbors (they both work and the 6 mo old pit bull mix pup and their 11 year old GSD are left alone all day, & it's my job to go over and let them out for an hour). She's a shelter adopted mix breed and so shy and so timid I almost don't know how to deal with it. The first time I went to let her out of her crate she wet herself and I had to coax her out of the crate with treats (I was told in advance that's probably what would happen). This fearfulness and timid behavior is genetic, she was never abused or beaten. The couple have had her for 4 months now and she's better (doesn't wet herself and bounds out of the crate when I open it) but still so shy it's sad. I've tried to entertain her, play gently, talk silly to her etc etc. She did go to basic obedience class once a week for 6 weeks with the owners, and that helped, but still. So glad this is not my dog!!! It's a helpless feeling to try to create fun with the dog and she doesn't want to reciprocate. She will tug with her owners but not with strangers, or even me who she's known for a couple of months now. So yeah, you can help with confidence, but inborn personality is not going to go away. Plus I feel terribly sorry for her growing up in a crate, even if it's xtra large.
The crate is a god send, don’t feel sorry for her. The kennel is a safe place for her, itvis where she will feel safe. If left loose all day would make her neurotic and probably worse. Remember they are not human, we too often humanize our dogs but that is a mistake. Let her out but don’t talk to her or try to get contact from her. Let her seek you out then reward her for accomplishing that on her own. This will help her build confidence on doing things on her own.
 
Interesting topic. Jazz is my first experience with Dobe genetics and I'm still being surprised at how sensitive she is to some things. While she isn't purebred she has a really good dose of the Dobie! :rofl: By nature she is fearless and fronts up to anything and has from a small pup so she has a solid temperament I think, but if anything happens that leaves a negative impression, she remembers it well and reacts to the same circumstance with anxiety. One almightly flash of lightning and the huge thunder clap when a tree was hit close in the first spring storm meant that it took quite a while to have her calm again. She takes her cues from me and I had flinched! I have to be so careful not to give wrong cues as she watches like a hawk, and I think this is what makes her so different from any other dog I have had and why the bond with a Dobe is so solid.

My take on things is that even with a really good temperament due too genetics it would be really easy to cause a Dobe to have issues, either fear or aggression. On the other hand if you have a dog who isn't as confident, then this same sensitivity should mean that you can instill trust and confidence with careful training. Just my :2cents worth.
 
Interesting topic. Jazz is my first experience with Dobe genetics and I'm still being surprised at how sensitive she is to some things. While she isn't purebred she has a really good dose of the Dobie! :rofl: By nature she is fearless and fronts up to anything and has from a small pup so she has a solid temperament I think, but if anything happens that leaves a negative impression, she remembers it well and reacts to the same circumstance with anxiety. One almightly flash of lightning and the huge thunder clap when a tree was hit close in the first spring storm meant that it took quite a while to have her calm again. She takes her cues from me and I had flinched! I have to be so careful not to give wrong cues as she watches like a hawk, and I think this is what makes her so different from any other dog I have had and why the bond with a Dobe is so solid.

My take on things is that even with a really good temperament due too genetics it would be really easy to cause a Dobe to have issues, either fear or aggression. On the other hand if you have a dog who isn't as confident, then this same sensitivity should mean that you can instill trust and confidence with careful training. Just my :2cents worth.

Totally agree! they are definitely a more sensitive dog and I think alot of people who don't own them or haven't worked with them don't realize that. I for one learned that after I actually got mine and had to adjust my training methods to fit that, since I had been working with German Shepherds which are a bit more mmm id say "hard" breed. meaning they can take corrections a bit better (in my own experiences of course)
The thing I've notice with that too though, is that like in sports like protection alot of the handlers/trainers who only work breeds like Malinois or GSD's see that sensitivity as a fault and often either disregard the breed/dog or believe that somehow the dog is lesser.
Personally in my own experience i'v had someone flat out tell me after a doberman has been "ruined" they'll never be able to be fixed. And I stuck on that pretty heavy because I didn't know any better at the time. It wasn't until I met trainers/handlers who actually worked with Doberman such as @Doberman Gang did I realize that's a load of shit thats said by people who don't care for or understand the breed.

I mean just as was said above, you can make or break confidence in a dog simply by using poor training tactics, and I think that Doberman may just be a bit more prone to breaking if the methods of training aren't targeted for that breed. But I DON'T believe for a second that this sensitivity makes them any less capable or lack the tenacity for the sport.

My dog right now that I got back in September, I believe is a prime example of improper training methods breaking the confidence of a dog. Just from September to now I've seen a MASSIVE change in demeanor, temperament, and confidence just by focusing on working engagement and focus and positive training methods. And while I still wonder what exactly is genetic and what exactly was due to improper training or upbringing, I think just watching him progress in the way I have has really taught me alot about how both nature and nurture truly effect a dog.
 
I'm also finding nowadays that people (especially in the working world) are less likely to take into consideration that something may actually be due to training and not due to genetics.
Which is crazy that I even mention that because the first thing I EVER think about whenever I see a dog with an issue is "were they bred right?" "is this genetics?" "are they weak nerved" etc. So I whole heartedly believe that alot does have to do with genetics, but just the fact that any time someone says "my dog is having X problem" alot of those people will immediately jump to "BAD NERVES, POOR GENETICS" without even ever seeing the dog or assessing them their self.

But then again, those also are the people I'd never trust even outside of the internet because of how quick they jump to conclusions. So ya know.
 
how quick they jump to conclusions.
This is one thing that upsets me with anything whether it’s the temperament of a dog, kids, cats, birds etc. unless you spend time evaluating an animal, child, adult etc. and understanding reactions, impulses and environment of those animals and people, it’s unfair to make a rash judgement because what you are seeing may not actually be what you are seeing.
 

Back
Top