• Disclaimer: Hello Guest, Doberman Chat Forums presents the opinions and material on these pages as a service to its membership and to the general public but does not endorse those materials, nor does it guarantee the accuracy of any opinions or information contained therein. The opinions expressed in the materials are strictly the opinion of the writer and do not represent the opinion of, nor are they endorsed by, Doberman Chat Forums. Health and medical articles are intended as an aid to those seeking health information and are not intended to replace the informed opinion of a qualified Veterinarian.”

Aloof vs Fear

This is one thing that upsets me with anything whether it’s the temperament of a dog, kids, cats, birds etc. unless you spend time evaluating an animal, child, adult etc. and understanding reactions, impulses and environment of those animals and people, it’s unfair to make a rash judgement because what you are seeing may not actually be what you are seeing.
Yes exactly! and if you're not even seeing it and just reading what someone has typed then its even more unfair to make those sort of judgments.

My thought is, you should at first offer a few different opinions like "Oh it may be due to lack of nerve, but it could also be due to poor desensitizing" and then offer ways to fix whatever problem it may be. instead of being matter of fact on something you haven't even assessed in person or even seen at all.

Because that attitude doesn't make the person asking want to ask questions anymore, it makes them feel attacked and then they end up never asking again and their dog, cat, bird, child suffers.

I see this so freaking often in groups I manage on FB and it really hurts me to see. But thats also one thing I love about this forum. Everyone is so helpful, honest, but also offer a variety of possibilities to give the OP a rounded outlook. Love it!
 
This is one thing that upsets me with anything whether it’s the temperament of a dog, kids, cats, birds etc. unless you spend time evaluating an animal, child, adult etc. and understanding reactions, impulses and environment of those animals and people, it’s unfair to make a rash judgement because what you are seeing may not actually be what you are seeing.
I really think this should be one of those things that go on the fridge at eye level for daily reminders! Quick judgments are too easy to make and too hard to change when made! Getting off topic. :bag:
 
What a great thread and topic! I look forward to reading all the entries in detail, sharing my thoughts and maybe learning something!

I'm glad you mentioned this very familiar thing:

"I’m sure we’ve all run into someone with a reactive dog who blames the dogs reactivity on abuse. The ones who say “he was abused by a man so he snaps at men”

I tell ya', when I hear someone talk about their adopted dog, the majority of time I hear this tried and true refrain. I imagine it's true in probably only 10 - 15 % of the cases. I do feel that a lot of dogs are just naturally more uncomfortable/less confident around men. So this is just one of the many cases where we should look at nature-vs.-nurture.

So much more to be said. Thanks again for the thought-provoking.
 
The crate is a god send, don’t feel sorry for her. The kennel is a safe place for her, itvis where she will feel safe. If left loose all day would make her neurotic and probably worse. Remember they are not human, we too often humanize our dogs but that is a mistake. Let her out but don’t talk to her or try to get contact from her. Let her seek you out then reward her for accomplishing that on her own. This will help her build confidence on doing things on her own.
Oh, I definitely believe in crates, didn't mean it that way. I just meant she is at that stage of puppyhood where she could be socializing with her new family and learning stuff, but no one is home. I also used the ignore technique for the first 2 months, but now I'm gently trying to engage a little. Now over 3 months, she engages for just a few minutes. I roll a ball and she will bound after it, then sniff around and walk off. I do chores around the house and the puppy will watch me, if I make eye contact or silly-talk to her she will wag her tail, but she stays laying on the floor, doesn't run around or get into mischief. It's just weird to witness a zero drive dog! I only felt bad about the crating because it is about 9 - 10 hours a day, 4 - 5 days/week, (with her hour out mid-day). And this in line with @Curing original question - I use this dog as an example of genetics, I think confidence can be helped with this puppy, but her basic bottom line will not change much.
 
A timid or nervous dog would probably not do well in our home because our home is a noisy one.
With 4 large parrots, 2 cats and all the barking dogs on our street, it gets loud and can be intense when the birds crank up with ear piercing screeching and their constant talking and mimicking sounds.
When I got the pups and brought them home they did not react to the birds screeching once they learned where it came from.
If the power goes off, which it frequently does, Bacall (my female) gets a little antsy trying to figure out why the fans are not turning and there is no tv or music playing. The first power outage occurred when they were around 9mo old and she looked up at the fan standing still and got spooked. It took a bit to overcome that but now after Hurricane Irma without power for several weeks and with the winds pounding us, they handled it like champs and do not react to much to noises except for close lightning strikes with thunder immediately following. I have to get Bacall out and walking when we get thunderstorms to desensitize to the loud booms. Fireworks get her nervous and we are working on that. I had to give her Sileo on New Years. Bogie handles noises with zero issues. Yay!
 
A timid or nervous dog would probably not do well in our home because our home is a noisy one.
With 4 large parrots, 2 cats and all the barking dogs on our street, it gets loud and can be intense when the birds crank up with ear piercing screeching and their constant talking and mimicking sounds.
When I got the pups and brought them home they did not react to the birds screeching once they learned where it came from.
If the power goes off, which it frequently does, Bacall (my female) gets a little antsy trying to figure out why the fans are not turning and there is no tv or music playing. The first power outage occurred when they were around 9mo old and she looked up at the fan standing still and got spooked. It took a bit to overcome that but now after Hurricane Irma without power for several weeks and with the winds pounding us, they handled it like champs and do not react to much to noises except for close lightning strikes with thunder immediately following. I have to get Bacall out and walking when we get thunderstorms to desensitize to the loud booms. Fireworks get her nervous and we are working on that. I had to give her Sileo on New Years. Bogie handles noises with zero issues. Yay!
We have a cockatoo (want it? LOL jk) and i don’t think our dogs even care that she’s there. I don’t think I’ve ever seen them notice her lol. But maybe they’re just all deaf from her scream :rofl:
 
they are definitely a more sensitive dog and I think alot of people who don't own them or haven't worked with them don't realize that. I for one learned that after I actually got mine and had to adjust my training methods to fit that, since I had been working with German Shepherds which are a bit more mmm id say "hard" breed. meaning they can take corrections a bit better (in my own experiences of course)
The ‘hardness’ certainly seems very different to me. I’ve been watching working line GSDs work and get corrected but they keep on going like it’s nothing. They do learn from the correction too so it is at least effective. Initially I would wince seeing the corrections because I’m not sure my dog would tolerate that, and this is despite the statement about Euros that “they stay confident through correction”. While I don’t know how confident the dogs were before their training started, they sure exude confidence now. There is a Euro Doberman there and the corrections are certainly not the same. I agree that the dogs are definitely intended to be pets in the home. I can walk by nearly everyone’s car and the only dogs that react are the ones that live more rural. Re the judgemental nature of working dog people, the GSD people kind of do have a reason for it haha.
 

Back
Top