My Grim, Fearful Prediction

Oppression leads to conditioning which leads to mindset which leads to normal.

Do the math. ;)



Personally I think the root of the problem is summed up by them above quote. Who wants rights taken away? In the good ole USA talk of banning c/ding is just beginning and the passionate are not going down without a fight. I have no doubt it was the same way in the UK when talk of banning first started.
I always find it interesting that the ones that shout the loudest about it being cruel are the ones that know the least about it. I have witnessed both procedures and can tell you from beginning to end there in nothing cruel about it. I guess I should preference that with "when done correctly" because there is and always will be irresponsible people.
Yes, there are differences in the UK and the USA and in the 2 dogs. But to imply that one is better than the other is simply wrong. They are just different and a matter of taste. Everyone knows my taste in the dogs. I made that perfectly clear in my search for a pup. They are the same dog with a slightly different look. Both looks suffer from the same serious health problems and IMHO, we as dobe lovers should be coming together and working on that vs fighting over what the dog should look like or which side of the world is better.
 
I got a glimpse this afternoon in to the what the image of a barking, cropped Doberman seems like to the uninitiated.

A couple of women came walking up my street, one of them taking a video. Well, it turns out she was Facetiming someone who might be interested in buying the new-build house across the street. She then pointed the phone toward Oji who was behind our aluminum (wrought iron-look) fence. That's when I came out and looked at the women because I took issue with them recording my house/Dobe etc.

Then one speaks up and says they like our garage, and did we build it? That's what she was videoing. So I cordially answer. Then they ask if they can walk down toward the garage (which would bring them closer to Oji behind the fence). I say okay, but just don't get too close to the fence.

By this time, Oji is barking. One asks, as she is backing away even farther than she already was, if he would bite them or something. I kinda' said Nah. Then she said this: "I see he's pointing his ears up, like he's saying Intruder!"
 
I'm compelled to wonder, then, what are the desires and motivations of those who seek out uncropped Dobermans. I understand yours, or at least I understand what is your stated position. I'm not saying I agree with it, but at least you seem like a good Doberman owner. Not that I'm setting myself up as judge; I just love the breed and want it preserved.

So, if the breed is evolving, my point is I hope it doesn't wind up like what I perceive to be the state of the most commonly seen Boxer – a goofy, awkward ineffectual shell of what it once was.

I continue to ask why people want a Doberman if they don't want what it was intended to be.

I suspect I am not understanding your post very well so let me ask a couple of questions.

Uncropped Dobermans are the natural order of things. Cropped or uncropped, its still the same dog. What is the motivation for spending lots of money, fussing with the problems associated with cropping and causing the dog significant discomfort? Just to satisfy some notion of what a Doberman should look like?

Do you really think a Doberman was 'intended' to have cropped ears? Intended by who?

I find this whole line of reasoning to be odd at best.
 
What is the motivation for spending lots of money, fussing with the problems associated with cropping




First, done properly there shouldn't be any problems. Second, a quality Doberman from a reputable breeder should come already c/d, healed and ready to post. It is included in the purchase price. Third the motivation is the result.....simply stunning!


causing the dog significant discomfort?



I have witnessed the process from the crop all the way through the day you are finished posting. The pups came home ready to eat and play like nothing happened. As far as posting, again done properly there is no discomfort.
 
I won't get into it, but a little research into the breed might give you all the answers to you question above....:googleit:

BTW I love cropped ears, however my Dobe is a Floppy, only cuz I'm cheap:).

Last year I got my third Dobe. None have had cropped ears. Not giving intruders ears to grab on to is a joke.
 
First, done properly there shouldn't be any problems. Second, a quality Doberman from a reputable breeder should come already c/d, healed and ready to post. It is included in the purchase price. Third the motivation is the result.....simply stunning!

I have witnessed the process from the crop all the way through the day you are finished posting. The pups came home ready to eat and play like nothing happened. As far as posting, again done properly there is no discomfort.

There must be very few 'quality' breeders around because I see very few dobe pups being sold at 10 weeks or so with ears cropped. The job and the expense are left to the new owner. I've seen more than a few with bad laser cuts, infections, repeated bandaging with sticks and none of the dogs seemed to enjoy it.

I submit 'stunning' is in the eye of the beholder. I think all my dogs have looked just fine with floppy ears. Would you consider cropping your kid's ears to make them more attractive?

No discomfort? Just how would you know?
 
So, what's your definition of 'the natural order'? I'm assuming that you are, at least, aware that the Doberman is a man-made breed?

I thought they were a dog made breed! I'm pretty sure they come out of their mamas with floppy ears. When you can breed them so they come out of mama dog with cropped ears you can say that's the natural order. Until then, floppy ears are natural.
 
Oh I almost forgot....






Yes.










The first to say so was Herr Dobermenn, the creator of the breed, followed by breed clubs all over world.


People used to believe a lot of things, 'way back when'. I would hope our thinking has evolved somewhat since then.
 
Friend, welcome. It's clear you're on a mission to promote non-crop. At this point, I would just suggest you read much of what has been laid out and discussed here and in other threads and to research the topic further. Of course you are free to leave your Dobes "natural" (those quotation marks are very purposeful); but most of your statements and questions are misguided.
 
There must be very few 'quality' breeders around


That's VERY true. Every breed is Chuck full BYB pooling to make a quick buck. Really sad when it comes to the dobie. They are a breed riddled with serious health problems. Breeding should be left to the knowledgeable that are interested in the betterment of the breed.





I see very few dobe pups being sold at 10 weeks or so with ears cropped.
,



Hmm.....interesting. I know very few that will well pups left natural. The ones I do know breed working lines that may compete internationally. Sad to me so many countries have bought into the AR whacko agenda.




Would you consider cropping your kid's ears to make them more attractive?



I do have a friend who altered her son's ears. He was born with very large ears that stuck out. After years of being bullied (absolutely tormented) by other kids she opted to have it fixed.


No discomfort? Just how would you know?





Einstein I'm not, but I am smart enough to know when a dog is in pain. Like I said earlier I have seen the procedure performed. I watched as the pups ran around and played with each other shortly afterwards. I am on my 4th cropped dobe and have yet to deal with an infection or any problems. Again, a crop performed and cared for properly should heal just fine with no problems.


You wish to leave your dogs natural, I'm fine with that. Everyone should be free to make whatever decision that works for them. I am a very responsible owner that researches my decisions. I am also tiring quickly of people that jump on board with the AR movement and not know what they are talking about judging me. I'm done with rehashing the same old thing. Time to move on to much more important things. Dobermans have much bigger problems than the look of their ears.
 
^^Amen.

Respect! Don't place guilt or judgement on others for their choices. If you dont want to crop the ears thats fine, just dont tell me its wrong. It’s really that simple.

One thing I admire about this wonderful forum, I’ve had both cropped and “natural” and NEVER have I felt judged by members. We are all here for the same reason, the love of the Dobermanns.

I’ll respect your right to choose if you respect mine! :)
 
It is sad to realize that all the controversy over C/D has led to many younger vets not learning the procedure in school and others deciding to no longer do them because of AR pressure.

My vet stated; “Until the law forbids me from cropping and docking, I will continue to do them to prevent people from doing them themselves without proper anesthesia and care.
Because that is what will happen and already has happened with the Pit type bully breeds.

It’s a choice, one that we should have without being made to feel like we are cruel for doing so.

More attention should be paid to health and training than whether they are C/D.
I agree with my vet that until it becomes illegal, I will have a choice and will make the choice that is best for my dog and myself.
 
That's VERY true. Every breed is Chuck full BYB pooling to make a quick buck. Really sad when it comes to the dobie. They are a breed riddled with serious health problems. Breeding should be left to the knowledgeable that are interested in the betterment of the breed.





,



Hmm.....interesting. I know very few that will well pups left natural. The ones I do know breed working lines that may compete internationally. Sad to me so many countries have bought into the AR whacko agenda.








I do have a friend who altered her son's ears. He was born with very large ears that stuck out. After years of being bullied (absolutely tormented) by other kids she opted to have it fixed.

I'll bet your friend asked her son if he wanted his ears fixed. When your dog tells you he wants his ears cropped, then its OK to do it.








Einstein I'm not, but I am smart enough to know when a dog is in pain. Like I said earlier I have seen the procedure performed. I watched as the pups ran around and played with each other shortly afterwards. I am on my 4th cropped dobe and have yet to deal with an infection or any problems. Again, a crop performed and cared for properly should heal just fine with no problems.

You are smart enough to know when your dog is in pain? No, you're not. I've seen dogs with broken backs acting normal.


You wish to leave your dogs natural, I'm fine with that. Everyone should be free to make whatever decision that works for them. I am a very responsible owner that researches my decisions. I am also tiring quickly of people that jump on board with the AR movement and not know what they are talking about judging me. I'm done with rehashing the same old thing. Time to move on to much more important things. Dobermans have much bigger problems than the look of their ears.
 

Back
Top