My Grim, Fearful Prediction

^^Amen.

Respect! Don't place guilt or judgement on others for their choices. If you dont want to crop the ears thats fine, just dont tell me its wrong. It’s really that simple.

One thing I admire about this wonderful forum, I’ve had both cropped and “natural” and NEVER have I felt judged by members. We are all here for the same reason, the love of the Dobermanns.

I’ll respect your right to choose if you respect mine! :)

Sorry, if you think my distaste for cropping ears is a reflection on you, it just might be. But what I am hearing is that you want me to not state my opinion because it might call into question something you've done?

Interesting case of reverse 'political correctness'.
 
But what I am hearing is that you want me to not state my opinion because it might call into question something you've done?



Not exactly. I'm not speaking for @Viemarangelrock as she can add her own thoughts. If you look through this forum you'll see this topic comes up ALL the time. Gets old, especially when the folks with the loudest voices opposing c/d have no experience or even know much about it. Yes there are horror stories about the procedures but they are rare. It is those stories that are shouted from rooftops by the AR groups to support their agenda. That for me is where the problem is. I don't care if someone chooses to leave their dog natural. I do prefer the look of a c/d Doberman for myself. I have never found what the AR groups say to be true when it comes to c/d.
They say: it's cruel
I say: I have seen puppies running around playing after the procedure as well as have had pups come right to me and lick my face while posting.

I find most AR groups offensive because they are hypocritical for the most part. Don't c/d but do spay as soon as 8 weeks. Now that's cruel.
 
Sorry, if you think my distaste for cropping ears is a reflection on you, it just might be. But what I am hearing is that you want me to not state my opinion because it might call into question something you've done?

Interesting case of reverse 'political correctness'.

You can state what you like, I’m all ears! ;) I’ve already stated that I respect your decision to keep your dobes ears floppy. That’s your choice. So please, instead of going around in circles why don’t you introduce yourself? Post pictures of your dobes and experience of the breed.
 
You can state what you like, I’m all ears! ;) I’ve already stated that I respect your decision to keep your dobes ears floppy. That’s your choice. So please, instead of going around in circles why don’t you introduce yourself? Post pictures of your dobes and experience of the breed.

This is a picture of my 2nd dobie. She died last year at age 11. My first dobie was about 30 years ago. My current dobie is 15 months. So I've had dobies for about 25-30 years. I also have a Beagle and I've had Irish Setters before my first dobie.

My problem with this forum is the people who say a dobie's ears should be cropped. Hard for me to see how my dobie in the picture would be improved by cropped ears.

So why? Because you 'like' it that way? What if people thought the dog would look better with 3 legs. Would that be OK?
 

Attachments

  • dog2.webp
    dog2.webp
    107.3 KB · Views: 10
This is a picture of my 2nd dobie. She died last year at age 11. My first dobie was about 30 years ago. My current dobie is 15 months. So I've had dobies for about 25-30 years. I also have a Beagle and I've had Irish Setters before my first dobie.

My problem with this forum is the people who say a dobie's ears should be cropped. Hard for me to see how my dobie in the picture would be improved by cropped ears.

So why? Because you 'like' it that way? What if people thought the dog would look better with 3 legs. Would that be OK?

Because that is what the founder of the breed wanted. He didn't want to sacrifice what he had in temperament, so cropping was decided to be done instead of introducing the gene for upright ears. Because cropping and docking can be done humanely with little pain, people continue to crop to adhere to the breed standard.

Have all your dogs kept their dew claws or reproductive parts? It's no different. Unlike those two however, ear cropping is a choice that doesn't effect their well being what so ever. Dews do serve a purpose, yet some remove them. Reproductive parts also serve a purpose in growth yet some remove those too before they served their purpose. Yet we don't judge here nor try to start fights. It's your choice for whatever you believe in is the best for your dog.
 
Nice looking Dobermann, @Jim Buono!

We have friendly, civil energy on the forum it would be best to maintain it. I can see you have a problem with owners cropping their Dobermanns ears. You’ve aired your distaste, your opinions and we’ve listened. Our opinions differ, but I can live with that.

The cropped/docked Dobermann is iconic of the breed. The original creator intended the breed to be C/D.

Ear cropping is a less invasive surgical procedure than spaying or neutering, which owners do all the time without a second thought. Spaying/neutering is accepted socially even though it can cause problems also, and is not medically necessary.
 
This is a picture of my 2nd dobie. She died last year at age 11. My first dobie was about 30 years ago. My current dobie is 15 months. So I've had dobies for about 25-30 years. I also have a Beagle and I've had Irish Setters before my first dobie.

My problem with this forum is the people who say a dobie's ears should be cropped. Hard for me to see how my dobie in the picture would be improved by cropped ears.

So why? Because you 'like' it that way? What if people thought the dog would look better with 3 legs. Would that be OK?
She was a beautiful girl, I am sorry for your loss. I lost my last girl at 11yrs. Adopted a Beagle who is now 14yrs. and have 2yr old littermates.
Even had an Irish Setter back in the early 70’s. She was a loving beautiful dog but was EXTREMELY destructive!
I bought my first red boy in the 70’s.:welcome:
To DCF from Florida
 
also have a Beagle
Does your Beagle rule the dobie?
When I first brought my pups home my beagle became instant Mom to the twins and has remained that way until recently when she developed diabetes and went blind. She sure helped me raise them. :-)
 
ars. Would you consider cropping your kid's ears to make them more attractive?
Ears? No.
But, you have heard of a procedure called circumcision, haven’t you? ;)

Welcome aboard, Buono!
This is a topic that swirls around a few times per year, C/D.
No point in arguing,it will get you no where quick around here.
There is no right or wrong answer.
Only opinions.
The site has a lot to offer, stick around and see.
 
Because that is what the founder of the breed wanted. He didn't want to sacrifice what he had in temperament, so cropping was decided to be done instead of introducing the gene for upright ears. Because cropping and docking can be done humanely with little pain, people continue to crop to adhere to the breed standard.

Have all your dogs kept their dew claws or reproductive parts? It's no different. Unlike those two however, ear cropping is a choice that doesn't effect their well being what so ever. Dews do serve a purpose, yet some remove them. Reproductive parts also serve a purpose in growth yet some remove those too before they served their purpose. Yet we don't judge here nor try to start fights. It's your choice for whatever you believe in is the best for your dog.

Do you adhere to all things people from the 19th century wanted? And please realize a breed standard wasn't handed down to Moses.

What's the point of a forum if people can't state their opinions because it might sound 'judgy'? If you have an opinion, back it up and move along. People are free to express different opinions, take issue with your reasons for your position and that is the essence of conversation.

If you simply want everyone to have the same opinion and pat each other on the back for your wonderful insight, it seems you've come to the right place.
 
She was a beautiful girl, I am sorry for your loss. I lost my last girl at 11yrs. Adopted a Beagle who is now 14yrs. and have 2yr old littermates.
Even had an Irish Setter back in the early 70’s. She was a loving beautiful dog but was EXTREMELY destructive!
I bought my first red boy in the 70’s.:welcome:
To DCF from Florida

Yes, Irish Setters are easily bored and can be destructive. Mine developed a taste for electrical cords and no amount pepper spray would deter them.

My first dobie was a black and tan male, then my baby girl, now another girl.
 
Does your Beagle rule the dobie?
When I first brought my pups home my beagle became instant Mom to the twins and has remained that way until recently when she developed diabetes and went blind. She sure helped me raise them. :)

Not really, he was a rescue and now he's 11 or 12. She pests him mercilessly, at times. The first time they were in the same room together she went after him and he bit through her ear. Now she's a little cautious about pushing him too far, but she still gets him going at times. She can be a real brat.

This dobie has been a challenge in that I rescued her at 9 months from a college student who kept her in a cage all day with pee pads and no water. No time and no money for medical care. As my wife and I are both retired, we've plenty of time during the day to help this dog adjust. Everything is new and startling to her and she has lots of energy, never walks when she can run and wants to run all day.
 
What's the point of a forum if people can't state their opinions because it might sound 'judgy'? If you have an opinion, back it up and move along. People are free to express different opinions, take issue with your reasons for your position and that is the essence of conversation.

If you simply want everyone to have the same opinion and pat each other on the back for your wonderful insight, it seems you've come to the right place.
No. You have this place all wrong. Doberman Chat Forum is the only place on the internet in my (granted, limited) experience that is mostly free from vitriol and unnecessary hostility.
 
What's the point of a forum if people can't state their opinions because it might sound 'judgy'? If you have an opinion, back it up and move along. People are free to express different opinions, take issue with your reasons for your position and that is the essence of conversation.

Exactly this and I believe it is what people have been trying to say to you. Glad we are on the same page.
 
What's the point of a forum if people can't state their opinions because it might sound 'judgy'? If you have an opinion, back it up and move along. People are free to express different opinions, take issue with your reasons for your position and that is the essence of conversation.

If you simply want everyone to have the same opinion and pat each other on the back for your wonderful insight, it seems you've come to the right place




With all due respect, I don't see where anyone is saying you can't have your own opinion. In fact everyone has stated they are fine with your natural dobe. It's you that keeps pushing it. Time to move on, we ALL understand your are opposed to c/d. Time to agree to disagree.
We do have other threads you should have a look at. I think you will find we have a very friendly forum full of excellent owners that go above and beyond for the care of their dogs.
Maybe start here https://doberman-chat.com/forums/introduce-yourself.80/
We want to know more about you and your dogs.
 

Back
Top