• Disclaimer: Hello Guest, Doberman Chat Forums presents the opinions and material on these pages as a service to its membership and to the general public but does not endorse those materials, nor does it guarantee the accuracy of any opinions or information contained therein. The opinions expressed in the materials are strictly the opinion of the writer and do not represent the opinion of, nor are they endorsed by, Doberman Chat Forums. Health and medical articles are intended as an aid to those seeking health information and are not intended to replace the informed opinion of a qualified Veterinarian.”

"Working" American Line breeder?

That sounds more like his hips, but hard to tell without seeing it. Have his hips been XRayed?

No Archer. I have never thought to get them x-rayed. Is it worth it? He doesn't do well at the vets and they make him wear a muzzle when they work on him due to an "incident" when he got neutered which I think is a load of horse[emoji90] but I digress. That's another story.

If something was discovered, would there be any benefit to putting him through it? He doesn't wobble when he trots or runs, only when he is walking. See attached video. It is mostly his right leg.



Sent from my iPhone using Doberman Chat
 
No Archer. I have never thought to get them x-rayed. Is it worth it? He doesn't do well at the vets and they make him wear a muzzle when they work on him due to an "incident" when he got neutered which I think is a load of horse[emoji90] but I digress. That's another story.

If something was discovered, would there be any benefit to putting him through it? He doesn't wobble when he trots or runs, only when he is walking. See attached video. It is mostly his right leg.



Sent from my iPhone using Doberman Chat
Oh, I see that.

I remember with my first Dobe I asked a vet during a visit (I used to come prepared with a list of questions :)) why when my boy stepped with a rear leg it seemed to move outward slightly every time. The vet didn't have any answer but wasn't worried. That boy lived to 8 1/2 years and showed no mobility problems whatsoever – very active and strong 'til the end.
 
That's good to know! I always worried that he could end up becoming crippled in his older age. I'm hoping to have him around for a very long time [emoji1317]

I did the same until I realized that asking Doberman specific questions wasn't worth it because they just didn't see enough of them to be able to answer the really specific questions. They don't even do holter monitoring [emoji33]


Sent from my iPhone using Doberman Chat
 
I'm not on here often, so I know this is a bit late. My puppy is American show lines...she has a lot of drive and is training in agility, and another sibling is training in ring sport and her trainer says she has plenty of drive. I think you just have to look for what you want in the lines and in the puppies.

You might be interested in some of the upcoming breedings of a dog like Ricky Bobby, for example: Litter Announcements
 
@MeadowCat this is fantastic information! This is the first American breeder that I've seen that does schutzund. She doesn't mention if she mixes other lines in with her dobes, but awesome start. This is exactly what I have been looking for .

And are you the same meadowcat that makes the Doberman jackets?
 
@MeadowCat this is fantastic information! This is the first American breeder that I've seen that does schutzund. She doesn't mention if she mixes other lines in with her dobes, but awesome start. This is exactly what I have been looking for .

And are you the same meadowcat that makes the Doberman jackets?

Yes, I am :)
 
I'm not on here often, so I know this is a bit late. My puppy is American show lines...she has a lot of drive and is training in agility, and another sibling is training in ring sport and her trainer says she has plenty of drive. I think you just have to look for what you want in the lines and in the puppies.

You might be interested in some of the upcoming breedings of a dog like Ricky Bobby, for example: Litter Announcements
Those do seem like nice Dobes for sure! I imagine they are considerably more expensive than most good breeders though. I don't know of course because that sort of thing is not talked about but I assume so.
 
Those do seem like nice Dobes for sure! I imagine they are considerably more expensive than most good breeders though. I don't know of course because that sort of thing is not talked about but I assume so.

I doubt it. I'm sure they are right in line with what most good breeders charge.
 
Okay, so right at $2500?

Not all breeders charge the same amount. You'll see that those are breedings of Whitney's male, so each breeding would be a different breeder's bitch. I can't say what each of those breeders charge - I have no personal experience with them. I just doubt they'd be out of line with the range of pricing that is typical of good breeders, that's all.
 
Not all breeders charge the same amount. You'll see that those are breedings of Whitney's male, so each breeding would be a different breeder's bitch. I can't say what each of those breeders charge - I have no personal experience with them. I just doubt they'd be out of line with the range of pricing that is typical of good breeders, that's all.
Ah. I assumed that for a Dobe out of such a famous name would bring a bunch more money than the going rate.
 
Hi, and welcome! :)

I like your question, and it wasn't what I'd call long-winded at all. You'll see that this reply is actually longer than your question :D I hope you stick with me.

I have repeated it a few times: People do seem to lump Euro and working together, and seem to assume that North American means conformation or just whatever. I say there has to be more to the picture.

Agreed that unless your Dobe is from working lines the likelihood is low that it will have what it takes to work in protection-oriented sports. To me, that's a shame, but it's what the breed has become.

At any rate: If you are talking about an American-line Dobe that has the type of looks you find in the conformation ring, I am not aware of a breeder that is producing Dobes with that appearance and conformation that also has strong working (protection-oriented) titles in its lineage. Not that I am anywhere near an expert on the breeders in this country.

I have heard of ADAMAS and came close (I thought) to getting a pup that was from them on one side of parentage. They have a reputation of having Dobes in agility and having good working ability; but for me that does not translate into having what it takes to do protection work. Drive to excel in the agility ring does not mean having a full-mouth bite and fight drive and hardness.

So, I am curious to see what you think of this: What I have found is that there is in this country a type of Doberman that may have Euro in its lines – or in the case of my current Dobe, is all-Euro – but does not look like that type of Euro Dobermann that is pronounced in size and is quite heavy-boned and blocky with exaggerated forechest and a really large head. No, this type of Doberman actually is sort of the opposite, and is built for speed, agility and all-out performance on the field. Unfortunately, to me, many of them do not look good and are too small, narrow and unsubstantial, and usually have a croup that is too rounded and a somewhat roached back (think greyhound-like). I don't want to name breeder names after the negative things I just said, but I'll show you a pic of my Euro, working-line Doberman male from a breeder here in the States:

Below: At about 20 months.
View attachment 64442
Below: At about 19 months.View attachment 64443
I have seen Euros that have the type of arch in the back. It is not what I prefer, but that doesn't seem to affect their working ability! Actually, my biggest question regarding the NA and SA Dobes is that does that more refined neck affect their ability in bite work? Sometimes I fear it's going to snap under the force they could put into a bite. But of course, I'm biased toward the SA Dobe! Having lived my entire life in South America, and with the intention of moving to Brazil...my sentiments lie here!
 
I have seen Euros that have the type of arch in the back. It is not what I prefer, but that doesn't seem to affect their working ability! Actually, my biggest question regarding the NA and SA Dobes is that does that more refined neck affect their ability in bite work? Sometimes I fear it's going to snap under the force they could put into a bite. But of course, I'm biased toward the SA Dobe! Having lived my entire life in South America, and with the intention of moving to Brazil...my sentiments lie here!
Good question on the neck. Frankly, a Dobe that's not from proven working lines probably won't hit a sleeve all that hard, or hold on to it. What's more, I have a theory that working Dobes tend to be less injury-prone.
 
Good question on the neck. Frankly, a Dobe that's not from proven working lines probably won't hit a sleeve all that hard, or hold on to it. What's more, I have a theory that working Dobes tend to be less injury-prone.
I suspect you're right about being less injury-prone, simply because they have been bred and raised to handle harsher treatment and conditions. Although I love the refined look of the SA and NA Doberman, my goal is a working dog, so I will probably end up with a Euro(from working lines of course).
 

Back
Top