My Grim, Fearful Prediction

Actually, Hallmark actively makes new movies all the time. Do you get the Hallmark Channel? Sheesh, after, I think Halloween or thereabouts, they have their "Countdown To Christmas" and show all Christmas movies all the time. Of course only a handful of them are new, but the others are just a few years old or less.

Fairly predictable movies, even a bit cheesy sometimes, but I've come to enjoy my wife's and my time watching them.
I suppose if ya have to watch a chick channel hallmark is better than Lifetime.. Whats with all the lifetime Movies being about killing your spouse? This must be some deep rooted fantasy hard coded in womens minds. :)
 
I think that depends on where you live. I haven't seen an uncropped Boxer in a long time. Danes I'd guess about 50%.
That is very interesting. Hmm. Regional differences. Surprising to hear.

As it happens, I saw three Danes yesterday (not together). All uncropped of course.

Dobermans around here are more plentiful than maybe anywhere I've lived, but there are still not many. I do wonder if it's the German heritage in the Cincinnati area.
 
I suppose if ya have to watch a chick channel hallmark is better than Lifetime.. Whats with all the lifetime Movies being about killing your spouse? This must be some deep rooted fantasy hard coded in womens minds. :)
Oh yeah, we don't watch Lifetime. It does seem to be about angry, abused women.
 
Actually, Hallmark actively makes new movies all the time. Do you get the Hallmark Channel? Sheesh, after, I think Halloween or thereabouts, they have their "Countdown To Christmas" and show all Christmas movies all the time. Of course only a handful of them are new, but the others are just a few years old or less.

Fairly predictable movies, even a bit cheesy sometimes, but I've come to enjoy my wife's and my time watching them.
I do have it but I rarely watch it. It's one of my 'pre sets' so I will check it out once in a while to see what's on and the ones I've seen always seem 'old' ....and yes, cheesy. :rolleyes: Even for this woman! I haven't watch more than a few minutes of any of them in a long time.
 
I suppose if ya have to watch a chick channel hallmark is better than Lifetime.. Whats with all the lifetime Movies being about killing your spouse? This must be some deep rooted fantasy hard coded in womens minds. :)
:p I used to watch those too but haven't in long time. Our son used to say they always have the same people in them, that they are always predictable and, in his words, 'stupid'. :spit: Always gave me a chuckle!
 
I do have it but I rarely watch it. It's one of my 'pre sets' so I will check it out once in a while to see what's on and the ones I've seen always seem 'old' ....and yes, cheesy. :rolleyes: Even for this woman! I haven't watch more than a few minutes of any of them in a long time.
Yeah, check it out. Most of them are really not bad. Some are good!

I basically do not watch movies (like mainstream ones) because all of them seem to have a message they're trying to push, and they must also include what is currently politically correct. Where, in the '90s many movies had to have at least one scene where breasts made an appearance (not that that had to do with PC), now you must have at least one bit of homosexual content and it actually seems more popular to have male nudity now than female.

You don't deal with all this with Hallmark movies.
 
Cropping falls out of favor, which makes the breed feel more accessible to the general public. Poor breeding practices abound. Shelter Dobes are plenty.

The breed may wind up increasingly in the hands of those looking for a sweet, goofy, fashionable pet. A trendy pet whether these folks realize it or not.
Just in the last few days, we've had a couple of people (both young people) join in and express that they don't see why cropping is necessary, and that they like the sweet, adorable look of a Doberman with floppy ears.
 
This a very American centric debate. I think it's the opposite in the rest of the world. A cropped dog is usually from a breeder who is looking to sell to people for vanity reasons. Just my two cents worth. I admire all dobies. I prefer mine natural. I prefer mine rescued, if I had tons of cash though I would look into the best euro working lines which *gasp* are natural for the most part. I don't see why I should be crucified for that
 
Just in the last few days, we've had a couple of people (both young people) join in and express that they don't see why cropping is necessary, and that they like the sweet, adorable look of a Doberman with floppy ears.
I know it was said in one of these threads before, maybe even this one? I haven't gone back to the beginning.

Oppression leads to conditioning which leads to mindset which leads to normal.

Do the math. ;)
 
This a very American centric debate. I think it's the opposite in the rest of the world. A cropped dog is usually from a breeder who is looking to sell to people for vanity reasons. Just my two cents worth. I admire all dobies. I prefer mine natural. I prefer mine rescued, if I had tons of cash though I would look into the best euro working lines which *gasp* are natural for the most part. I don't see why I should be crucified for that
I don't want to make you feel that way, Kashi.

It is just a giant shame that animal "rights" and political correctness (not talking about you individually here, Kashi) have stripped the breed of an important part of what it is – and this is right in the part of the world where the breed was conceived, born and developed.

Further, there is a big difference between someone like you who understands a lot about dogs and our breed, and (I'm pretty sure) appreciates and wants their Dobe to be protective and to be able to do what it was designed for; and a person who has become interested in Dobes because they are pretty and they love their cute cuddly, floppy eared look. I think a lot of people – more and more is what I predict – will be drawn to our breed and it will become trendier and trendier as more and more of them are just sweet ineffectual goofy, floppy eared dogs. The Veimaraner, Visla, Boxer and Great Dane are currently trendy pets for the younger, hipper set to own. Three of those are as high energy as the Doberman, and one of them is a giant. Why and how can they be so popular if they are a major challenge to live with? Think it can't happen to the Doberman because of its reputation and the legends surrounding the breed? I think it can as things head in what I see as the current direction.

That's all this thread is about.
 
This a very American centric debate. I think it's the opposite in the rest of the world. A cropped dog is usually from a breeder who is looking to sell to people for vanity reasons. Just my two cents worth. I admire all dobies. I prefer mine natural. I prefer mine rescued, if I had tons of cash though I would look into the best euro working lines which *gasp* are natural for the most part. I don't see why I should be crucified for that
If you live in a country that hasn't banned it, you can get a dobe from the 'best euro working lines' and still have him/her cropped.
 
This a very American centric debate. I think it's the opposite in the rest of the world. A cropped dog is usually from a breeder who is looking to sell to people for vanity reasons. Just my two cents worth. I admire all dobies. I prefer mine natural. I prefer mine rescued, if I had tons of cash though I would look into the best euro working lines which *gasp* are natural for the most part. I don't see why I should be crucified for that



First I don't think a breeders that sell cropped and docked dogs are doing it for vanity reasons. I think they are supporting the standard. They see the standard as what you are trying to achieve when breeding dogs. A template of sorts.
All that is stated here is individual opinions on a specific topic. Everyone is entitled to their own opinion. Because someone else opinion is different than yours does not mean they are crucifing you.
 
It's illegal to dock tails and ears of any dog over here in the UK unless the dog is a working breed for hunting for example, therefore the breeder has a gun and gun licence which allows them to be certified to dock the tails. However because it's illegal here doesn't mean any breeds are actually being bred in any different way to suit the lifestyle of humans. The long lines of Dobes are well documented and cared for here by breeders who are responsible and have years of excellence and work, much like many other breeds I'm supposing. The more I read on here the more I feel scare mongered in a way. It seems the Dobes over in the states have a difficult argument surrounding them like what is being discussed here and the breeding of them and such. American version and EU version also is an argument. Judging by that image I found on here, the American version is slinky and athletic compared to the EU version. You also don't find Dobermans in rescue centres in the UK very easily at all. 98 in 100 chance to be frank. We are looking at getting a Dobe pup simply because we already have a 15month old pup and they would grow together. Previously we looked at rescuing and in 6 months we found 1 in a rescue centre. And 4 available in a Doberman specific rescue centre. However, all were given up because the owners said they were 'too much to handle' because of work or whatever. Only 2 couldn't live with other dogs.
I think because this forum is mostly USA orientated actually I'm going to leave the forum. I only joined the other day and had some positive advice which I thank you for. I've only seen one positive post about the breed and that was in regards to their valiant efforts in the war. Dobes are stunning dogs but I'm feeling my passion for getting one to join my family tainted by these actually quite highly negative 'discussions' that are coming across taking the wind out my sails.
I thank you all for your time and I can't wait for the day when we find our 4 legged Dobe and good luck to the Dobe breed in the states because clearly there's some work to do for them XXX
 
It's illegal to dock tails and ears of any dog over here in the UK unless the dog is a working breed for hunting for example, therefore the breeder has a gun and gun licence which allows them to be certified to dock the tails. However because it's illegal here doesn't mean any breeds are actually being bred in any different way to suit the lifestyle of humans. The long lines of Dobes are well documented and cared for here by breeders who are responsible and have years of excellence and work, much like many other breeds I'm supposing. The more I read on here the more I feel scare mongered in a way. It seems the Dobes over in the states have a difficult argument surrounding them like what is being discussed here and the breeding of them and such. American version and EU version also is an argument. Judging by that image I found on here, the American version is slinky and athletic compared to the EU version. You also don't find Dobermans in rescue centres in the UK very easily at all. 98 in 100 chance to be frank. We are looking at getting a Dobe pup simply because we already have a 15month old pup and they would grow together. Previously we looked at rescuing and in 6 months we found 1 in a rescue centre. And 4 available in a Doberman specific rescue centre. However, all were given up because the owners said they were 'too much to handle' because of work or whatever. Only 2 couldn't live with other dogs.
I think because this forum is mostly USA orientated actually I'm going to leave the forum. I only joined the other day and had some positive advice which I thank you for. I've only seen one positive post about the breed and that was in regards to their valiant efforts in the war. Dobes are stunning dogs but I'm feeling my passion for getting one to join my family tainted by these actually quite highly negative 'discussions' that are coming across taking the wind out my sails.
I thank you all for your time and I can't wait for the day when we find our 4 legged Dobe and good luck to the Dobe breed in the states because clearly there's some work to do for them XXX
'Cause clearly there is no work that needs to be done for Dobes in the U.K.
 
I appreciate the breed standard. Had I had a show dog that I spent 3k on, yes I would have had the ears cropped without a doubt. I sometimes wish I had cropped Nero's ears but too late now! We like dobes for the personality and the body shape, the ears for us were an afterthought. Yes I understand breed standard and would adhere to the letter if conformation was my thing or even protection because I see the advantages of cropped ears for that line of work. I wouldnt have a non-docked dobe though. Having been around dogs with thin tails I know how easily damaged they are. Hubs and I mainly looked at dog breeds who had docked tails strangely.

Ive seen mostly uncropped boxers and danes but lots of cropped terriers and a few dobes where ive lived over the years. In fact I cant remember meeting even one cropped dane...

As to timing of a dog, my mother is visiting soon and without a doubt she would have dropped 2 dogs in our laps without regard for our wishes because she thinks I need a dog. She means well.... lol but Im glad the decision was ours alone. Im glad we went with a dobe over other breeds. I just hope we can be the best owners we can be.

As to UK vs USA dobes, well lots of people import either way. If you think something is cruel then dont do it. A discussion on the merits of cropping and docking is simply that, a discussion. Both sides will feel strongly and thus logic MUST come into play. Nothing is perfect. Life would be boring if it was.
 
when we started looking I was really set on getting a cropped Dobie for the above reason, where we live is beautiful but the people are not, Ive definitively had my fair share of close calls.

One night I was talking with my fella and said I want to be able to walk around where I live and not have to worry so much as I normally do as to ''I need to avoid here, here and here'' On one day My partner was at work and I was doing projects from home, and caught a guy snooping through our window, that only solidified my claim to my partner for us to Get a dog when we can.

So we looked around and Came across the Doberman, Proud, fierce loyalty along with one of the best intelligence out there! What more could you ask in a companion?! And the cropping would only solidify the points of such a Dog, if you look through a window with such a dog like that, you are going to stay well away from it!

Though Unfortunately cropping and docking is Illegal in the United kingdom the only way we could get such a Dog is importing, and thats always a risky things to do.

Though I highly feel your concern....I certainly would not want the Dobies amazing factors to be washed away by irresponsible breeders...
 
It's illegal to dock tails and ears of any dog over here in the UK unless the dog is a working breed for hunting for example, therefore the breeder has a gun and gun licence which allows them to be certified to dock the tails. However because it's illegal here doesn't mean any breeds are actually being bred in any different way to suit the lifestyle of humans. The long lines of Dobes are well documented and cared for here by breeders who are responsible and have years of excellence and work, much like many other breeds I'm supposing. The more I read on here the more I feel scare mongered in a way. It seems the Dobes over in the states have a difficult argument surrounding them like what is being discussed here and the breeding of them and such. American version and EU version also is an argument. Judging by that image I found on here, the American version is slinky and athletic compared to the EU version. You also don't find Dobermans in rescue centres in the UK very easily at all. 98 in 100 chance to be frank. We are looking at getting a Dobe pup simply because we already have a 15month old pup and they would grow together. Previously we looked at rescuing and in 6 months we found 1 in a rescue centre. And 4 available in a Doberman specific rescue centre. However, all were given up because the owners said they were 'too much to handle' because of work or whatever. Only 2 couldn't live with other dogs.
I think because this forum is mostly USA orientated actually I'm going to leave the forum. I only joined the other day and had some positive advice which I thank you for. I've only seen one positive post about the breed and that was in regards to their valiant efforts in the war. Dobes are stunning dogs but I'm feeling my passion for getting one to join my family tainted by these actually quite highly negative 'discussions' that are coming across taking the wind out my sails.
I thank you all for your time and I can't wait for the day when we find our 4 legged Dobe and good luck to the Dobe breed in the states because clearly there's some work to do for them XXX
That's quite a post to dissect.
I find it interesting you've been here 3 days and have come to those conclusions of over 6 years worth of content on this forum?
I'm sorry you feel this way, perhaps it's a cultural barrier? I only say that because I see US referenced several times and in your words and because it's USA oriented you're going to leave?
Wow. Ok then.

Have you by chance looked at many South American examples of this breed?
They're quite striking and offer a unique mix of Europe and American characteristics.

Oh, and "working breed". Yeah, Dobermans are a working breed.
So it sounds as though in the UK if I wanted a docked Doberman I would have to get a gun license, train my Doberman to retrieve bird and I'm in like flint for docking?


But this isn't allowed?

image.webp


I hope you can see past the rough edges we Americans have and continue to use the site for the resources it contains.
A ton of content on nutrition, training, health issues and or remedy, etc not to mention the stories of personal triumph.

You're entitled to your opinions as much as everyone is entitled to theirs.
You may not agree with mine nor do I agree with all of yours but I'm not leaving because of it, I see no reason you should?

Oh and by the way, Rocky says hi. :)
image.webp
 
It's illegal to dock tails and ears of any dog over here in the UK unless the dog is a working breed for hunting for example, therefore the breeder has a gun and gun licence which allows them to be certified to dock the tails. However because it's illegal here doesn't mean any breeds are actually being bred in any different way to suit the lifestyle of humans. The long lines of Dobes are well documented and cared for here by breeders who are responsible and have years of excellence and work, much like many other breeds I'm supposing. The more I read on here the more I feel scare mongered in a way. It seems the Dobes over in the states have a difficult argument surrounding them like what is being discussed here and the breeding of them and such. American version and EU version also is an argument. Judging by that image I found on here, the American version is slinky and athletic compared to the EU version. You also don't find Dobermans in rescue centres in the UK very easily at all. 98 in 100 chance to be frank. We are looking at getting a Dobe pup simply because we already have a 15month old pup and they would grow together. Previously we looked at rescuing and in 6 months we found 1 in a rescue centre. And 4 available in a Doberman specific rescue centre. However, all were given up because the owners said they were 'too much to handle' because of work or whatever. Only 2 couldn't live with other dogs.
I think because this forum is mostly USA orientated actually I'm going to leave the forum. I only joined the other day and had some positive advice which I thank you for. I've only seen one positive post about the breed and that was in regards to their valiant efforts in the war. Dobes are stunning dogs but I'm feeling my passion for getting one to join my family tainted by these actually quite highly negative 'discussions' that are coming across taking the wind out my sails.
I thank you all for your time and I can't wait for the day when we find our 4 legged Dobe and good luck to the Dobe breed in the states because clearly there's some work to do for them XXX
I hope you'll reconsider and remain. We have UK members who are quite active. Cropping is just one of those subjects that people have strong feelings about. Personally I just would like to see people have the choice.
In the US we have too many breeders which is why we end up with Doberman specific rescues. I'm sure you can imagine how difficult it is for us Doberman lovers to see so many end up in rescues. Many of the low cost low quality breeders in the US used to skip the cropping simply because of the cost involved. This is part of the reason why many in the US have an association with low quality and non-cropped ears.
There's only a few topics were people have such strong feelings and I hope it doesn't make you want to leave. There are many people here with decades of experience with Dobermans who are giving away their time to help others simply because of their love of Dobermans.
 
It's illegal to dock tails and ears of any dog over here in the UK unless the dog is a working breed for hunting for example, therefore the breeder has a gun and gun licence which allows them to be certified to dock the tails. However because it's illegal here doesn't mean any breeds are actually being bred in any different way to suit the lifestyle of humans. The long lines of Dobes are well documented and cared for here by breeders who are responsible and have years of excellence and work, much like many other breeds I'm supposing. The more I read on here the more I feel scare mongered in a way. It seems the Dobes over in the states have a difficult argument surrounding them like what is being discussed here and the breeding of them and such. American version and EU version also is an argument. Judging by that image I found on here, the American version is slinky and athletic compared to the EU version. You also don't find Dobermans in rescue centres in the UK very easily at all. 98 in 100 chance to be frank. We are looking at getting a Dobe pup simply because we already have a 15month old pup and they would grow together. Previously we looked at rescuing and in 6 months we found 1 in a rescue centre. And 4 available in a Doberman specific rescue centre. However, all were given up because the owners said they were 'too much to handle' because of work or whatever. Only 2 couldn't live with other dogs.
I think because this forum is mostly USA orientated actually I'm going to leave the forum. I only joined the other day and had some positive advice which I thank you for. I've only seen one positive post about the breed and that was in regards to their valiant efforts in the war. Dobes are stunning dogs but I'm feeling my passion for getting one to join my family tainted by these actually quite highly negative 'discussions' that are coming across taking the wind out my sails.
I thank you all for your time and I can't wait for the day when we find our 4 legged Dobe and good luck to the Dobe breed in the states because clearly there's some work to do for them XXX




Have I missed something? :scratch:

We are all here for the love of the breed, to learn, to encourage and help others in need of some much needed advice and guidance. As an active UK member, I can't recommend this site highly enough. It's a pleasure to be part of such an amazing, friendly group of Doberman lovers from all across the globe. I myself having a floppy eared, long tailed dobe has NEVER felt judged or put down in anyway, shape or form.

It's a shame after such a short period of time on DCF you feel the need to leave. I just don't understand.

ersonally I just would like to see people have the choice.

Absolutely, 100% agree!!
 

Back
Top