• Disclaimer: Hello Guest, Doberman Chat Forums presents the opinions and material on these pages as a service to its membership and to the general public but does not endorse those materials, nor does it guarantee the accuracy of any opinions or information contained therein. The opinions expressed in the materials are strictly the opinion of the writer and do not represent the opinion of, nor are they endorsed by, Doberman Chat Forums. Health and medical articles are intended as an aid to those seeking health information and are not intended to replace the informed opinion of a qualified Veterinarian.”

Doberman Ear Crop Information

  • Thread starter Thread starter FredC
  • Start date Start date

I read in a reliable source (cant recall which but it was a Doberman book) that the original line Louis bred had pricked ears. They were bred out when they introduced a certain breed into the line to breed out the original temperment that Dobermann didn't like. For the life of me I can't recall what breed that was.
My thinking is that by cropping they are trying to carry on what they couldn't figure out how to breed back in genetically
 
My thinking is that by cropping they are trying to carry on what they couldn't figure out how to breed back in genetically
My thinking is they didn't care that they lost the prick ear because cropping wasnt such a hot button topic.. lol in other words PETA hadn't formed yet. Considering the procedure was likely done at the breeders even if a vet did it however not likely, it certainly wasn't considered an art form yet. ;) All of those early crops were hideous by today's standards.
 
My thinking is they didn't care that they lost the prick ear because cropping wasnt such a hot button topic.. lol in other words PETA hadn't formed yet. Considering the procedure was likely done at the breeders even if a vet did it however not likely, it certainly wasn't considered an art form yet. ;) All of those early crops were hideous by today's standards.
PETA would not have survived back then.Refer back to Archer post about "sissification",she termed it nicer than I do;)
I believe there was also a much greater sense of "mind your own damn business" going on as well,combined with the very real repercussions if one didn't.
 
Does anyone know of black-colored medical tape that can be used for ear taping? I would like to get away from the bright white stuff this time around.

To me, it's not a great look to start with – walking down the street with the get-up on the head. I figure why does it have to be bright white?
 
Does anyone know of black-colored medical tape that can be used for ear taping? I would like to get away from the bright white stuff this time around.

To me, it's not a great look to start with – walking down the street with the get-up on the head. I figure why does it have to be bright white?
I may be wrong but my thought is white is used so any bleeding/seepage can easily be detected.
 
Does anyone know of black-colored medical tape that can be used for ear taping? I would like to get away from the bright white stuff this time around.

To me, it's not a great look to start with – walking down the street with the get-up on the head. I figure why does it have to be bright white?
I haven't seen any other color of the medical tape you put around the ears, but the black gorilla tape works great for wrapping it around the post before you insert it in the ear. It really strengthens the backer rod too. This isn't the solid black, but you can see it helps make it blend better.
Headshot panting sized Aug 17 14.webp
 
Once the ears are healed and you are just posting, (like in the picture with the gorilla tape) I don't see why you couldn't use the colored athletic tape instead of the white. It doesn't stretch and comes in a rainbow of colors. Anyone know of a reason I'm not thinking of?
 
I don't see why you couldn't use the colored athletic tape instead of the white. It doesn't stretch and comes in a rainbow of colors. Anyone know of a reason I'm not thinking of?
I was thinking that would probably work after they're healed too. I can't see a reason why not either.
 
I appreciate this thread. I've always loved Dobes (and dogs in general) but have always wondered at the reasons behind cropping. I get the docking reasons. I personally have never been a fan of cropping or docking. However in most things, I appreciate people having a right to choose. I have really enjoyed reading this thread. I've wanted to ask but figured it was a hot button topic and didn't want to cause any drama.

(And no worries I am not an A/R nutball. :-) I grew up hunting, fishing and rodeoing/ranching and while opportunity doesn't often allow me to do those same things I enjoy and miss them. :-)
 
PS... I would own a dobe either way. We have always gotten dogs through some manner of rescue and crop/dock wouldn't matter to me. I just personally would not likely have the surgery done.
 
These are all some very good arguments for and against cropping! I do have a question though as the original post did not say how the ears are cropped. I was doing some research on cropping in my state and learned that one of the vets here uses a laser to cut. Is this the usual way it is done now? I like the idea of using a laser to do it for sure, but I wasn't clear on if that's a common method. Also, here is my two cents worth on why I chose the cropped look. Before we bought our house, it had been broken in to twice, with the previous owners being home and tied up in the basement during one of the incidents (nobody was hurt). My husband may also be starting a new job that requires him to be out of town often. I have other means of protection but no "deterrent". I would have gone with a German Shepard but the coat is just too thick for the summers here and I intend to train my future doberman to be a service dog. A doberman with cropped ears is more intimidating, and I am relying on that factor. As a doberman person, you may be able to tell that the big friendly looking dog with floppy ears is a doberman, but to most of the general population, we see a hound, until you tell us otherwise. It is absolutely about the look for me, but it isn't because I think they look better with cropped ears, but I do want that working dog association as soon as you see him. People take a Doberman with cropped ears a little more seriously that natural. I need him to be taken seriously.

Edit: I feel like I over explained a lot lol
 
These are all some very good arguments for and against cropping! I do have a question though as the original post did not say how the ears are cropped. I was doing some research on cropping in my state and learned that one of the vets here uses a laser to cut. Is this the usual way it is done now? I like the idea of using a laser to do it for sure, but I wasn't clear on if that's a common method. Also, here is my two cents worth on why I chose the cropped look. Before we bought our house, it had been broken in to twice, with the previous owners being home and tied up in the basement during one of the incidents (nobody was hurt). My husband may also be starting a new job that requires him to be out of town often. I have other means of protection but no "deterrent". I would have gone with a German Shepard but the coat is just too thick for the summers here and I intend to train my future doberman to be a service dog. A doberman with cropped ears is more intimidating, and I am relying on that factor. As a doberman person, you may be able to tell that the big friendly looking dog with floppy ears is a doberman, but to most of the general population, we see a hound, until you tell us otherwise. It is absolutely about the look for me, but it isn't because I think they look better with cropped ears, but I do want that working dog association as soon as you see him. People take a Doberman with cropped ears a little more seriously that natural. I need him to be taken seriously.

Edit: I feel like I over explained a lot lol
No, that was great. Makes sense and I agree.

That was my main argument for cropping – a more intimidating look. I have other reasons as well, so I reject the notion that so many espouse that it is "purely cosmetic."

You and I are in a similar situation. While I'm a male, and it sounds like you're a female, you have "other means of protection" and I don't. My wife forbids firearms. So for us, it's just this little old middle-aged man left to defend our home and family. Deterrent is good.
 
Thanks! I really tried to explain the way I feel about it. I think whichever choice a person make is just fine. I just have a reason that I feel is very valid for cropping. It's taken me awhile to get my words right because a few of my friends, that I have mentioned getting the crop done to, simply said, "I think ear cropping is barbaric." in response. It took me some time to feel confident enough to defend my choice. Researching until I blue in the face has really helped. I am nervous about the after care though. I want to be sure that my future dog is in as little pain or no pain as possible, and the cuts heal properly. And yes, I am female and a small one at that. I also hope to start boxing classes soon. I want every chance, and to maximize each chance I have at defending myself, as well as get my confidence and peace of mind back. When you lose those two things, you live in fear constantly and I want to be myself again. Regardless of dog breed, they are amazing companions and truly man's best friend.
 
I think cropping should be a personal decision of the dog owner.

- Cropped dogs definitely make better protection animals. If just the look of a cropped dog is enough to stop a potential problem perfect. Any time a problem can be solved without even needing to have a conflict you've won.

- If you think Dobermans are great family animals (they are) natural ears are a great way to avoid problems. (Like neighbors viewing your dog as a potential threat to their children/family.)
 
Thanks! I really tried to explain the way I feel about it. I think whichever choice a person make is just fine. I just have a reason that I feel is very valid for cropping. It's taken me awhile to get my words right because a few of my friends, that I have mentioned getting the crop done to, simply said, "I think ear cropping is barbaric." in response. It took me some time to feel confident enough to defend my choice. Researching until I blue in the face has really helped. I am nervous about the after care though. I want to be sure that my future dog is in as little pain or no pain as possible, and the cuts heal properly. And yes, I am female and a small one at that. I also hope to start boxing classes soon. I want every chance, and to maximize each chance I have at defending myself, as well as get my confidence and peace of mind back. When you lose those two things, you live in fear constantly and I want to be myself again. Regardless of dog breed, they are amazing companions and truly man's best friend.
It's clear you want the best for your future dog. Not that I'm an expert, but as for pain from cropping, obviously there will be some. How much I don't know, but I know dogs are tough animals and Dobermans certainly should be. The breed has been getting its ears cropped since its inception and I wouldn't consider all of the people who have had cropped Dobermans through history to be barbarians. Now, this laser cropping I've not heard of. I wonder if the pain is less? Regardless, I would think that any significant pain would only last a few days. Maybe those more experienced could weigh in.

As for boxing class: That's a good idea not only in terms of self defense, but in stress relief and exercise! I tell you, you only have to punch a bag or some pads for like 30 seconds before you're starting to get pretty darn tired. With kicking it's even more so.

I trained MMA for 5 1/2 years and it has brought me a good level of confidence that I didn't have even after training karate in the past. So much more practical in terms of self defense. The ability to control your opponent on the ground and gain the upper hand is quite necessary. Of course for self defense they experts say you don't want it to go to the ground, but you don't want to be helpless if it does (which it often does). And knowing how to choke someone with their own shirt without tearing it is just pretty cool.

Maybe the best idea would be a good quality self-defense class. Our instructor added in practical self defense with the MMA so that was cool. "Stun and Run" he liked to say. Stop your attacker and get the heck out of there as fast as possible.

So anyway, that's my 20 cents. :nerd:
 
I can't speak to the laser cropping, but I did some research on laser declawing on cats. (:ot:, but falls into the same controversy. Mine have full claws and I've got the scars to prove it, but it can be a last ditch save for a serious behavioral issue.) What I learned was that there is less tissue trauma and the healing is faster with the laser cuts. It is more precise and leaves very clean edges. The laser cauterizes so there is less bleeding, scabs etc. which means less chances of infection. I could see it being the same for cropping as there would be less physical pressure used to remove the excess ear leather.
 
It took me some time to feel confident enough to defend my choice. Researching until I blue in the face has really helped. I am nervous about the after care though. I want to be sure that my future dog is in as little pain or no pain as possible, and the cuts heal properly.
This is a minor surgery compared to spaying or neutering (also very minor) and the aftercare is very easy providing you let the edges heal before posting them. :) Many vets don't do a good job at posting and we have some good threads going in the puppy section going to help people step by step with the process.
 
I did see the posting section, thank you! I intend to utilize it as often as I can. Cutting with lasers made sense to me, with the healing process too. As for the boxing, I've entertained the idea going further and doing the MMA style fighting. I watched a video of a man who defended his co-worker with MMA techniques and I was thoroughly impressed. He was of course, a champion in his country so he made it look so easy. Anyway, I don't want to go off topic too much here, so if you want to talk more about the MMA stuff, (and I'd love to) send me a private message.
 

Back
Top