• Disclaimer: Hello Guest, Doberman Chat Forums presents the opinions and material on these pages as a service to its membership and to the general public but does not endorse those materials, nor does it guarantee the accuracy of any opinions or information contained therein. The opinions expressed in the materials are strictly the opinion of the writer and do not represent the opinion of, nor are they endorsed by, Doberman Chat Forums. Health and medical articles are intended as an aid to those seeking health information and are not intended to replace the informed opinion of a qualified Veterinarian.”

Doberman Ear Crop Information

  • Thread starter Thread starter FredC
  • Start date Start date

i would speculate that the dog introduced later,losing the prick ears had far less to do with form and more to do with temperament/sharpness.
i dont have the time to search out the source, And i really do not recall many specifics. :(
 
It truly is cosmetic when it comes down it.

There is plenty of medical data to support the advantages of cropping - the AR groups just choose to ignore it. There are no flopped earred dogs in nature - all are pricked so they must have great value or we would see both in nature so the cropped ear is really more natural.

Why are some people soooo against cropped ears, but you don't hear as much "hype" when it comes to docking?
Because they are uneducated as to the benefits for a dog bred for protection. They are not knowledgeable as to the importance of breed type to maintain a breed as it was originally. And sorry but the undone ear and tail make the doberman more closely resemble the hound group than the working group

I understand the argument in today's society is that its just not necessary anymore, but i take offence to that statement because no one knows for what purpose we intend for our own dogs.

IF a dog is bred for working and temperament is important then cropping is just was important part of a standard as any other part. Every single standard describes the correct ear so ears must be important not to mention the ability to pin point the sound is increased in a cropped ear. Is someone is hiding and going to sneak up on you this is critical. Why have a dog bred for protection if you do not want to be protected?
 
I'd like to point out that cropped or not, Doberman will act exactly the same.

Natural = More friendly looking / approachable
Cropped = More aggressive looking / not approachable

Again Cropped or Natural it doesn't matter. The dog will act exactly the same.
 
Not for long - soft look and I guarantee you soon the AR groups will have everyone calling for a softer temperament.
 
I'd like to point out that cropped or not, Doberman will act exactly the same.

Natural = More friendly looking / approachable
Cropped = More aggressive looking / not approachable

Again Cropped or Natural it doesn't matter. The dog will act exactly the same.
I "almost" agree with all of this.
Act the same?=no question,act the same.
Now,on approachability...many factors at play here.
Some people are going to be afraid regardless and that's their issue to deal with.
Some,I would imagine you and I would be on the same page here,see a Doberman and want to say hi regardless of cropped or not.i know I do anyways.
At the same time,under the right circumstance like a dirtbag lurking outside your window,cropped or not when our dogs "spring" into alert/time to kick ass mode,said dirtbag will not want anything to do with them cropped or not.
That goes back to your first point,cropped or not the ears don't make the dog.
 
See my Signature... (Quoted in case i change it down the road)
The Dobermann "By its Presence Alone it Defends."
I've always assumed that quote was intended specifically for the Cropped and Docked Variety.
 
I Now,on approachability...many factors at play here.
Some people are going to be afraid regardless and that's their issue to deal with.
Some,I would imagine you and I would be on the same page here,see a Doberman and want to say hi regardless of cropped or not.i know I do anyways.


I find a big factor is color. I am on my third Doberman (all c\d) and in my experience color has been the biggest factor. Greta has always been the one that people would approach first with no hesitation. I have had people come up and start loving on her and then say 'What kind of dog is she?' When I say Doberman they back drop their hands and back away. Chaos, my red male, was somewhat approachable as far as other people were concerned. Some just didn't recognize him as a Doberman because of his color. Now with Drake being black, I find people grabbing their children and turning in another direction.
So IMHO, the biggest problem is the same as it has always been... prejudice and lack of education.


People can call me whatever they want, but I believe in the standard. Just like when you make clothes, engine parts or wherever, you must have pattern or template to ensure consistent results. So something to think about while deciding what side you are on is the old saying "united we stand, divided we fall'
 
I find a big factor is color. I am on my third Doberman (all c\d) and in my experience color has been the biggest factor. Greta has always been the one that people would approach first with no hesitation. I have had people come up and start loving on her and then say 'What kind of dog is she?'
That is very true and we run into the same thing with both of ours as well. People will back away or cover their dogs with big black Albert, but with Della being red and smaller they always come right up to her and want to pet her.
 
I find a big factor is color. I am on my third Doberman (all c\d) and in my experience color has been the biggest factor. Greta has always been the one that people would approach first with no hesitation. I have had people come up and start loving on her and then say 'What kind of dog is she?' When I say Doberman they back drop their hands and back away. Chaos, my red male, was somewhat approachable as far as other people were concerned. Some just didn't recognize him as a Doberman because of his color. Now with Drake being black, I find people grabbing their children and turning in another direction.
So IMHO, the biggest problem is the same as it has always been... prejudice and lack of education.


People can call me whatever they want, but I believe in the standard. Just like when you make clothes, engine parts or wherever, you must have pattern or template to ensure consistent results. So something to think about while deciding what side you are on is the old saying "united we stand, divided we fall'
Agreed! Any deviation from
That pattern and the standard starts to crumble.

I too, experience issues with people being less intimated by my dogs due to their color. I have (I hope at least) opened the eyes of one lady who was all about Archer at first, backing off after she asked what breed he was. When we had talked for a while she admitted she was concerned at first after learning "what" he was, but said the concern left once she saw how sweet he is :) i told her rather gently and in an indirect way that most Dobies are like my Archer.
 
A natural Doberman is like a Camaro without the scoops and spoiler.. Sorry but i like the scoop and spoiler.. And even though they make the car look cool they also provide function.. A docked tail for example can save you hundreds in spilled drinks alone. :) Tell me where in this Super Big Gulp society that, that is not a desirable function?
 
I don't get offended by anything someone believes or wants to do to their own dog as long as the dog is happy healthy and well taken care of. I have literally heard from three different vets and read accredited resources that it is purely cosmetic. But what do I know, if it helps in whomever's case then great! I don't know why Mr. Doberman would breed them to be the ultimate guard and sport dog with floppy ears if it was of such grave importance? Along with the breeders of pits, boxers, viszlas hounds, weimaraners, etc... I want to crop my dogs ears, so I guess I will see for myself
The "purely cosmetic" claim is very common, and I'm not surprised a lot of vets think that. Vets can be wrong. Recently I had a vet (not knowing I am a Doberman guy) go on a little tirade against Schutzhund and those who participate in it. He said all that shouting at the dogs in a foreign language makes then a nervous wreck. Said a bunch of other stuff too. He otherwise sounded like a good, accomplished veterinarian.

So anyway, I guess we all have our opinions. I can think of many ways in which cropping is useful and beneficial. Oh yeah, I listed some of them in this thread :)
 
At some point before the Doberman was a recognized breed it did have natural prick ears however somewhere along the lines another breed was introduced into the gene pool and the prick ears were lost..

However to answer your question specifically.. 100 years ago Mr Doberman could easily C/D his own dogs with no questions asked.. A vet wast even required.. Breeders did this on their own regularly.. So i'm thinking considering the ease of availability less importance was put on ears when designing a new breed and purpose.
I had not heard that the earliest incarnations of the Dobermann had prick ears!
 
With our Pitt/Am. Bulldog, I got tired of waiting for her tail to clear doorways so I could shut the door as she sauntered in or out.
 
A docked tail for example can save you hundreds in spilled drinks alone. :) Tell me where in this Super Big Gulp society that, that is not a desirable function?
:D
The dock pays for itself!!

Actually,in another one if these conversations we had some time ago I brought up this very point about spilt drinks/clearing the coffee table with the tail.
One of our resident(at the time) anti c/d members Ataro brought up a good point I could not much argue.
A non docked Dobe's tail is curled,not as much but similar to an Akita.
Maybe it's from lack of personal exposure to an undocked Dob but I haven't seen one with a tail down or any pics of one?
Personally I don't miss the tail,never been thwacked by a nub,never worried about doors etc and no burglar could ever get ahold of Daisy's nub I don't think before she could take the hand off;)
 

Back
Top