F
FredC
The debate on whether or not to crop a Doberman's ears is a big one. Those who oppose it usually strongly oppose it as an alternation that is against nature. Those who agree with cropping do so with the argument that this breed has been known for its cropped ears for over a century.

So, the question is:
Should you crop your Doberman's ears?
Before you make a decision, be sure to understand the facts and not the hype.
Is it Legal?
Is it legal to crop a Doberman's ears?
Which countries allow cropping and which consider it an actual crime?
Cropping is legal in:
Cropping is not legal in:
What Exactly is Cropping?
When a Doberman has their ears cropped, in countries in which it is legal, it is considered to be cosmetic surgery.
When does a Doberman have their ears cropped?
The general rule is to do so when the Doberman puppy is 10 - 12 weeks old.
The dog is sedated during the surgery. The animal surgeon will mark the area of where the ear will be cut. Just as the name suggests, part of the ear is surgically removed. It is then stitched in such a way so that the ears edges heal with minimal scarring, It is the act of cutting the ear that causes many people opt out of this procedure. However, it must be noted that the dog will not experience pain during the surgery.
A dog will have discomfort for up to 2 weeks afterwards while the ears heal. Small paper cups are usually placed on the ears to protect them in this sensitive stage. An owner is given disinfectant from the veterinarian to carefully apply to the healing ears up to twice per day.
When an owner decides to have their Doberman's ears cropped they must make a commitment to following the very precise aftercare that is needed; if not, scarring will occur. It should also be noted that not all cropped ears will stand up.
Why Do People Crop Doberman's Ears?
In many countries, the Doberman is known for having cropped ears, something that has been done since the breed was introduced and owners feel that they should maintain the breed standard.
Some believe that long, floppy ears can trap moisture which can lead to ear mites and yeast infections. However, this can also happen with erect ears.
In countries such as the U.S. where cropping is legal, it used to be the norm for breeders to have a pup's ears cropped at a young age, before having the puppy go to his new home. However, recent trends have some breeders keeping ears natural. A large number of owners choose this and those that do not can opt to have the procedure done to their Doberman once they obtain the puppy.
We urge anyone who is considering to have this done to their dog to choose an experienced veterinarian, as a bad cropping can lead to infection and aesthetic issues such as too much of the bell being removed, etc. which once done, is a life long feature that can ruin the dog's appearance. Please check with a veterinarian to see if he or she has experience not only with cropping but specifically with the Doberman breed since each breed (that does traditionally have the ears clipped) has different shaping and size.
Some refer to this clipping as a "show crop" and by that, it is meant that per AKC conformation standards, the Doberman's ears should not be an outstanding feature or focal point. Rather, the size, set and shape should flatter the facial features, adding balance and lending to the overall appearance of the head.
A couple of issues that can occur are often due to the thickness of the ear leather. Doberman ears with very thick leather may be too heavy too stand and a good veterinarian will be able to let an owner know in advance. In some cases, not wanting to take off too much of the bell, a vet will err on the side of caution, which can lead to needing a 2nd cropping down the road to gain the desired appearance.
The price to have this done runs between $300 and $600, and additional costs may be checkups to see how the ears are healing, etc. In some locations, the cost for this procedure is tiered based on the dog's weight.
Do Doberman Ears Need to be Cropped to Enter Dog Shows?
The answer is no. While some may say that the Doberman standard is cropped ears, just about every recognized dog club, including the AKC accepts Doberman with or without cropped ears.
Should you Have Your Doberman's Ears Cropped?
This is most certainly a personal decision. Cropping is not clinically proven to reduce ear infections or reduce the chance of a dog getting ear mites. Dog shows allow Doberman with their normal floppy ears. The only valid reason an owner would have is that they prefer their dog to look a certain way. It is a myth that puppies do not feel pain...there are nerve endings in the ears. Is that worth the discomfort that a Doberman puppy will need to endure? While we must stay neutral on this subject, we suggest that an owner carefully think about this issue before deciding.
Taping Doberman Ears
Even with cropping, precise symmetrical ears does not always happen. It is common for 1 ear to stand more erect than another...or even both may not stand as one desired. The experience of the veterinarian has a part in this...But also the muscles at the base of the ear, if not strong enough, simply will not hold them up as one may have wished. When this happens, one wonders if taping Doberman ears is a method that truly works. The answer is: Most times. You will have the best chance of success if it is:
To be a great Doberman owner, one must have clear, easy-to-understand Doberman information on every subject. Trainers, Behaviorists, Breeders and other Pros do not give out information that you need to know. We have this information for you ...Click here to learn about our new-endevor.
--------------
Source: Unknown
--------------

So, the question is:
Should you crop your Doberman's ears?
Before you make a decision, be sure to understand the facts and not the hype.
Is it Legal?
Is it legal to crop a Doberman's ears?
Which countries allow cropping and which consider it an actual crime?
Cropping is legal in:
- Argentina
- The United States
- Canada
- India
- Mexico
- Russia
Cropping is not legal in:
- Australia
- France
- Ireland
- Italy
- New Zealand
- Netherlands
- South Africa
- Sweden
- The UK
What Exactly is Cropping?
When a Doberman has their ears cropped, in countries in which it is legal, it is considered to be cosmetic surgery.
When does a Doberman have their ears cropped?
The general rule is to do so when the Doberman puppy is 10 - 12 weeks old.
The dog is sedated during the surgery. The animal surgeon will mark the area of where the ear will be cut. Just as the name suggests, part of the ear is surgically removed. It is then stitched in such a way so that the ears edges heal with minimal scarring, It is the act of cutting the ear that causes many people opt out of this procedure. However, it must be noted that the dog will not experience pain during the surgery.
A dog will have discomfort for up to 2 weeks afterwards while the ears heal. Small paper cups are usually placed on the ears to protect them in this sensitive stage. An owner is given disinfectant from the veterinarian to carefully apply to the healing ears up to twice per day.
When an owner decides to have their Doberman's ears cropped they must make a commitment to following the very precise aftercare that is needed; if not, scarring will occur. It should also be noted that not all cropped ears will stand up.
Why Do People Crop Doberman's Ears?
In many countries, the Doberman is known for having cropped ears, something that has been done since the breed was introduced and owners feel that they should maintain the breed standard.
Some believe that long, floppy ears can trap moisture which can lead to ear mites and yeast infections. However, this can also happen with erect ears.
In countries such as the U.S. where cropping is legal, it used to be the norm for breeders to have a pup's ears cropped at a young age, before having the puppy go to his new home. However, recent trends have some breeders keeping ears natural. A large number of owners choose this and those that do not can opt to have the procedure done to their Doberman once they obtain the puppy.
We urge anyone who is considering to have this done to their dog to choose an experienced veterinarian, as a bad cropping can lead to infection and aesthetic issues such as too much of the bell being removed, etc. which once done, is a life long feature that can ruin the dog's appearance. Please check with a veterinarian to see if he or she has experience not only with cropping but specifically with the Doberman breed since each breed (that does traditionally have the ears clipped) has different shaping and size.
Some refer to this clipping as a "show crop" and by that, it is meant that per AKC conformation standards, the Doberman's ears should not be an outstanding feature or focal point. Rather, the size, set and shape should flatter the facial features, adding balance and lending to the overall appearance of the head.
A couple of issues that can occur are often due to the thickness of the ear leather. Doberman ears with very thick leather may be too heavy too stand and a good veterinarian will be able to let an owner know in advance. In some cases, not wanting to take off too much of the bell, a vet will err on the side of caution, which can lead to needing a 2nd cropping down the road to gain the desired appearance.
The price to have this done runs between $300 and $600, and additional costs may be checkups to see how the ears are healing, etc. In some locations, the cost for this procedure is tiered based on the dog's weight.
Do Doberman Ears Need to be Cropped to Enter Dog Shows?
The answer is no. While some may say that the Doberman standard is cropped ears, just about every recognized dog club, including the AKC accepts Doberman with or without cropped ears.
Should you Have Your Doberman's Ears Cropped?
This is most certainly a personal decision. Cropping is not clinically proven to reduce ear infections or reduce the chance of a dog getting ear mites. Dog shows allow Doberman with their normal floppy ears. The only valid reason an owner would have is that they prefer their dog to look a certain way. It is a myth that puppies do not feel pain...there are nerve endings in the ears. Is that worth the discomfort that a Doberman puppy will need to endure? While we must stay neutral on this subject, we suggest that an owner carefully think about this issue before deciding.
Taping Doberman Ears
Even with cropping, precise symmetrical ears does not always happen. It is common for 1 ear to stand more erect than another...or even both may not stand as one desired. The experience of the veterinarian has a part in this...But also the muscles at the base of the ear, if not strong enough, simply will not hold them up as one may have wished. When this happens, one wonders if taping Doberman ears is a method that truly works. The answer is: Most times. You will have the best chance of success if it is:
- Done early
- Done with consistency
To be a great Doberman owner, one must have clear, easy-to-understand Doberman information on every subject. Trainers, Behaviorists, Breeders and other Pros do not give out information that you need to know. We have this information for you ...Click here to learn about our new-endevor.
--------------
Source: Unknown
--------------
Cropping and Docking information article - A Critique
Countries allowing cropping was misstated; add the following countries:
Belarus
Bosnia & Herzegovina
Bulgaria Hungary
Macedonia
Malta
Moldavia
Phillipines
Romania
Russia
San Marino
Serbia
Ukraine
_______________________________________________________________
A cup method of posting was referred to and 2 weeks of pain and prescription meds, when actually:
There are multiple ways to “post” ears, cups are but one method. My vet simply recommended an over-the-counter ointment applied as needed. And the 2 weeks is more correctly the period in which the ears ARE COMPLETELY HEALED!
_______________________________________________________________
Ear mites and yeast infections attributed to erect ears - to which I say:
I can quote several prominent veterinarians, two of whom TAUGHT CANINE ANATOMY at veterinarian schools around the U.S. and they will directly refute the above statement.
_______________________________________________________________
The author claims there is a trend of uncropped Dobes ...
THERE IS NO TREND; it is but one or two people out of some two thousand owners in the Doberman Pinscher Club of America alone - who do not crop not to mention thousands of others who own and enjoy their c/d Doberman Pinschers.
_______________________________________________________________
Again the author misstates the "AKC conformation standards"
The inaccuracies are mounting up as it is the DPCA standard that describes the Doberman Pinscher. It is the Parent Clubs who own their breed’s standard, not the A.K.C..
Respected Judge Robert Vandiver who is a member of the Judges Education Committee says that uncropped ears violate the standard in three ways,
1. They are not cropped,
2. They are not erect, and
3. They violate the outline and look of eagles requirements
_________________________________________________________________
The author tries to make a case for a 2nd cropping ...
This happens with the frequency of Halley’s Comet and could be better described as “almost never”. After nearly 50 years in Dobermans I have NOT experienced, much less heard of it ever happening.
__________________________________________________________________
The article states that absence of pain is a myth..
Again - I can quote several prominent veterinarians, two of whom TAUGHT canine anatomy at veterinarian schools around the U.S. and they will directly refute the above statement.
__________________________________________________________________
A cropped and docked Doberman Pinscher never fails to take my breath away - if you don't want a cropped and docked breed - change your choice, not my breed.
Last edited by a moderator:







