Well I wasn't going to say anything in the conversation because I don't like arguing (I'm sensitive and get my feelings hurt easily). But I had never heard of or been around a puppy like Hope before...so I just thought I would share about how she changed...

Well when the issue of sharpness in Dobes come up I always think about her and how she could have become a very aggressive dog if someone hadn't intervened...
sharp shy dog has the capacity for aggression
Poppy you did a good job and you should be proud but I will say this about the true word "Sharpness" as defined by the working dog folks. You will not train a sharp dog thorugh normal techniques. They wouldl rather eat you alive than comply. So it takes a very masterful Schutzhund trainer and most of them don't even want to handle one.
There is no shyness in a sharp dog - Fear and aggression are not the same drives and reactions. A dog that bites out of fear is not sharp they are scared and only defend themselves when cornered or scared. Their first reaction is more often flight. A sharp dog does not flee ever.
A sharp dog (a true sharp dog as defined by working dog people never bites out of fear. They bite because you crossed their line and they set the rules. If you try to correct them they would jusat as soon eat you too.
Ashra may be dominant but she is not sharp as per the discussion she may be medium sharp as describes in the FCI standard - A true sharp dog in the situations you have described would disable you first for trying to holding her back and second kill the other dog for invading their planet.
It is why the early Dobermans had to first have a lot of the sharpness bred out as few could handle them. They did not care who you were they did not want to be messed with and there was NO FEAR.
Temperament from the DPCA web site: TEMPERAMENT
Energetic, watchful, determined alert, fearless, loyal and obedient. The judge shall dismiss from the ring any shy or vicious Doberman.
Shyness: A dog shall be judged fundamentally shy if, refusing to stand for examination, it shrinks away from the judge; if it fears an approach from the rear; if it shies at sudden and unusual noises to a marked degree.
Viciousness: A dog that attacks or attempts to attack either the judge or its handier, is definitely vicious. An aggressive or belligerent attitude towards other dogs shall not be deemed viciousness.
FCI Temperaments: BEHAVIOUR AND TEMPERAMENT: The disposition of the Dohermann is friendly and calm; very devoted to the family, it loves children. Medium temperament and medium sharpness (alertness) is desired. A medium threshold of irritation is required with a good contact to the owner. The Dobermann enjoys working, and shall have good working ability, courage and hardness. The particular values of self confidence and intrepidness are required, and also adaptability and attention to fit the social environment.
As you can see shyness is no part of the Sharpness described in the correct temperament except as a disqualifying factor. a dog can't be displaying sharp shyness as the two are opposed. I only post this for educational purposes not to argue but to help in understanding our Doberman correctly. As Marko stated we can all learn from the discussion and that is what I hope is happening.
It was very early intervention before she had the chance to act aggressively. Do you think an 8 wks old puppy would be acting overly aggressive already if they were actually 'sharp'. So basically, a truly sharp dog would not be something to be desired because if they were willing to even bite their own trainer, it seems like the dog would be nearly impossible to work with...trying to figure this out???
It always sounds like they were orignally more like working wth a tiger or a lion...wow that seems pretty extreme...I kinda figured that is why they decided to change the breed to become softer...Even a more assertive Doberman can be hard to have in public, since people tend to expect all dogs to act like friendly Golden retreivers...Poppy I have seen and watched on very sharp dog work. The handler trainer was bit several times while trying to work with the dog and always knew if they stepped over th eline that they would be bitten. It is why breeders had to work with temperament to make it more suitable for the world we live in. While trying to breed out sharpness some went too far and we lost some of the hardness, fearlessnessalertness etc. There was no prescription that said measure this dose and the breeding will correct sharpness but not take out the defense drive, dominance, fearlessness, alertness etc. It is a pig in the poke.
Yes a 8 week old puppy will show tendencacies toward sharpness. But all the socialization and training in the world will not change the final outcome if the dog is truly sharp as we are discussing sharp as it applies in the working dog world. Sharpness is a hardwired set of genetics that all the training in the world will not eliminate. If that makes sense. The dog will continue to progress into a sharper attitude and training will not resolve it. Cross the line and you will be taught a valuable lesson about how these dogs are dogs not humans and we do not totally understand their innermost thought processes.
Then to make it really hard all these drives, instincts, and character interact and melt together to create the final dog who is usually mature mentally at 2 years of age. I would not want one and would not want to work with one.
It always sounds like they were orignally more like working wth a tiger or a lion...wow that seems pretty extreme...I kinda figured that is why they decided to change the breed to become softer...Even a more assertive Doberman can be hard to have in public, since people tend to expect all dogs to act like friendly Golden retreivers...
I will agree with several on here who are also experienced with these types of dogs. I have seen nothing at all in your descriptions of Ashra that would indicate her as a sharp dog. I would classify her as more of an assertive dog. This to me is a better dog for an experienced working breed pet owner, who wants a dog that is loving and loyal, yet also protective and semi defensive. But this is not sharpness.Hmm, so I guess I should give Ashra back then?![]()
actually this type of dog is not why breeds get a bad name, they get a bad name because inexperienced handlers and owners take dogs that are like this, or dogs they make aggressive and put them in situations that create bad behaviors. You absolutely can not blame the dog, you must blame the people. Dogs are instinctual animals, people are cognitive reasoning animals. People must understand what dog fits them and what dog doesnt. These types of dogs are for experienced working dog profesionals, Schutzhund competitors, police and military applications, Personal Protection applications and other working venues. and when used in these venues by experienced handlers and trainers, then these dogs are actually much safer and more in control, than your average chihahua or terrier.Sounds dangerous to me. And people wonder how certain breeds get bad names?
actually this type of dog is not why breeds get a bad name, they get a bad name because inexperienced handlers and owners take dogs that are like this, or dogs they make aggressive and put them in situations that create bad behaviors. You absolutely can not blame the dog, you must blame the people.
actually this type of dog is not why breeds get a bad name, they get a bad name because inexperienced handlers and owners take dogs that are like this, or dogs they make aggressive and put them in situations that create bad behaviors. You absolutely can not blame the dog, you must blame the people. Dogs are instinctual animals, people are cognitive reasoning animals. People must understand what dog fits them and what dog doesnt. These types of dogs are for experienced working dog profesionals, Schutzhund competitors, police and military applications, Personal Protection applications and other working venues. and when used in these venues by experienced handlers and trainers, then these dogs are actually much safer and more in control, than your average chihahua or terrier.
Besides you have to understand that dog breeds are created by people to fill a certain role. And as D4E has explained, the doberman was created as a loyal personal protection dog. they were created to be a sharp dog that would react quickly to any threat. but over the years, this was bred out of many of the dogs seen today, because people wanted them as pets, not as a working dog, and this is why you get pet home dobermans. Yet there are still those out there, that are bred for the working sports etc, and these are the dogs that have much more of their original veracity still intact, and is why they should only be owned and handled by experienced handlers and trainers.
Now as for a confident and assertive dog, that is a dog that is more on the lines with being a bit defensive of their space and their areas and their people. They dont easily make friends, they are a bit aloof and they usually dont like other dogs around, or strangers. They will stand their ground and be defensive, but they sit back and assess the situation more first versus a sharp dog takes the threat immediately and reacts offensively to it.
Just some thoughts.
I do agree with all of that, but I have to wonder why someone would want a dog so sharp it has the capability of attacking the handler/owner. If the standard calls for medium sharpness shouldn't that be the breeding aim? Not a dog so sharp it's a liability in the wrong hands?
so Marko, what do you think of his working in the videos. Just curious as to your thoughts on him.

do agree with all of that, but I have to wonder why someone would want a dog so sharp it has the capability of attacking the handler/owner. If the standard calls for medium sharpness shouldn't that be the breeding aim? Not a dog so sharp it's a liability in the wrong hands?