• Disclaimer: Hello Guest, Doberman Chat Forums presents the opinions and material on these pages as a service to its membership and to the general public but does not endorse those materials, nor does it guarantee the accuracy of any opinions or information contained therein. The opinions expressed in the materials are strictly the opinion of the writer and do not represent the opinion of, nor are they endorsed by, Doberman Chat Forums. Health and medical articles are intended as an aid to those seeking health information and are not intended to replace the informed opinion of a qualified Veterinarian.”

How would you define a 'sharp' dog?

How would you define a 'sharp' dog?


  • Total voters
    16
While I think your accomplishments with Hope are fantastic, I just didn't read anything which would indicate that she is a sharp dog. A dog that is assertive or dominant is not necessarily sharp.
I think my point was that I prevented her from becoming overly assertive...good or bad I wanted her to be trustworthy
 
I got that bit and I'm not trying to be rude, but I just don't see how it ties into the discussion about sharpness?
 
I think my point was that I prevented her from becoming overly assertive...good or bad I wanted her to be trustworthy
While I think your accomplishments with Hope are fantastic, I just didn't read anything which would indicate that she is a sharp dog. A dog that is assertive or dominant is not necessarily sharp.

Also, my male is what I would call sharp, and has shown very assertive behavior. But again I have been trying to prevent him from being overly assertive, so I don't have to be overly concerned with taking him places...
 
I got that bit and I'm not trying to be rude, but I just don't see how it ties into the discussion about sharpness?
Well when the issue of sharpness in Dobes come up I always think about her and how she could have become a very aggressive dog if someone hadn't intervened...
 
Okay, I see where you are coming from now... I think. And yes, certain individual dogs do need experienced owners.

But I would say sharpness is more comparable to drive, in that it's an inherent instinct in some dogs - you can't train it out and it's not the result of something like insufficient training i.e. dominance aggression coming from a dog believing that it is alpha and that its owner is trying to challenge its position.

You can mask some of the dog's initial reactions such as growling or barking, but then you run the risk of your dog taking that as a cue to go straight to the next level which can translate as biting without warning. You were discussing dominance, but dominance is associated with status. A dog doesn't have to be dominant over its handler (or other dogs) to be sharp.
 
Okay, I see where you are coming from now... I think. And yes, certain individual dogs do need experienced owners.

But I would say sharpness is more comparable to drive, in that it's an inherent instinct in some dogs - you can't train it out and it's not the result of something like insufficient training i.e. dominance aggression coming from a dog believing that it is alpha and that its owner is trying to challenge its position.

You can mask some of the dog's initial reactions such as growling or barking, but then you run the risk of your dog taking that as a cue to go straight to the next level which can translate as biting without warning. You were discussing dominance, but dominance is associated with status. A dog doesn't have to be dominant over its handler (or other dogs) to be sharp.
Well I wasn't going to say anything in the conversation because I don't like arguing (I'm sensitive and get my feelings hurt easily). But I had never heard of or been around a puppy like Hope before...so I just thought I would share about how she changed...
 
Hey, you should never feel unwelcome to participate in a discussion! I just thought I was missing something in what you were saying and so that's why I asked - I wasn't trying to pick on you. It is sometimes hard to tell what kind of tone someone is writing in when it's just snippets on a forum, so if I sounded rude I wasn't trying to be.
 
Im not sure why someone would want a dog so.sharp it attacks.without any warning or provocation?
 
Im not sure why someone would want a dog so.sharp it attacks.without any warning or provocation?

Any dog can attack without any warning or provocation, doesn't have to be a sharp dog, the news is full of dogs that have savagely bitten toddlers without warning and it's usually the reliable quiet family dog that's the culprit. The advantage of having a sharp dog is when you participate in dog sports or you work one professionally or you want a dog for protection. If you don't want or need a sharp dog then simply don't buy one that through it's breeding will probably be sharp. Usually a person who deliberately buys a sharp dog does so because they want one for a reason and are aware of the risks and the added responsibility (unless they are some chav from a council estate that wants to look big to his mates).

My Eva has not laid a tooth on anyone because all I have to do is see the world through her eyes and see the triggers before she does. You have to know what the dog regards as a threat so you can behave responsibly and safely among pedestrians or other people. Although she is a sharp dog she doesn't fly off the handle at the drop of a hat as much as she used to, as she has grown and I have come to know what makes her tick combined with training and socialization she has calmed down a lot so much more reliable. Also when she does have a problem with someone she sees there are always signs, stiffness, tail very erect, hackles up and of course low growling quickly escalating to very vocal growling so there are warnings unless she sees the threat as being so close she feels she needs to act immediately and that's where my vigilance comes in.
 
The ideal dog will be sharp shy. The sharp shy dog has the capacity for aggression but is slightly more reserved than a sharp dog. Proper training methods will go a long way in determining the point at which aggression erupts and the point at which it subsides and so much is left to this process.
Do not assume from this that I believe a dog should be unsteady or some how soft until trained, this is far from the truth. A sharp shy dog will indeed bite you even before training, it is simply that training brings out the sharpness and inhibit the shyness to a point you feel comfortable with the overall results. A good test will include some exposure to a wide variety of sights and sounds that frequently occur while on duty.

Full article from the United States Police Canine Association :

Testing Dogs A Perspective on Selection :: United States Police Canine Association

Whilst I don't necessarily agree,they must be doing something right :D; pretty interesting viewpoint nonetheless.
 
If you are ready to work your dog and you have a training experience in Sch or PP then a sharp dog may be your choice. I would say Jess or Marco as pet owners may think about...

Sorry I didn't understand this bold bit :oops:

A sharp dog is not easy to manage. Trainers and working dog breeders are capable to do it. It's a risky undertaking for most pet owners. You and Jess may be able to do it as you are working in Sch field....but most of us are not. I wanted to warn people a sharp dog was not for everyone.
 
I also agree that the defense drive is not like it should be. We have clearly lost focus of that, and you can see it in so many dogs.

We have a lot of dogs that will bark up a storm but when push comes to shove won't act on it.

I would have loved to see some of the Dobermans from the early 70s as it seems that was the end of their prime.
My first one was from this group. Tasha SR was not reactive in any sense of the word. She had a deep throated growl that if you weren't listening for you wouldn't hear it. She never did more than the growl unless Daddy released her, which I saw my mother do one time.

Daddy trained her with the breeder he got her from, that's the way they did it back then. She guarded his truck (tools in the back of the truck). If you came to close she would give a warning growl to walk away. No one to knowledge ever got to close. The time my mother released her there was a guy in the car stealing the CB raidio. It was late at night and Tasha was asleep by the front door. Daddy was away on a job and had left Tasha home with us. Mom heard her growl and got up to come look to see what she was growling about and she saw the light on in the car. She opened the door and released Tash. The guy had already seen the light and was running, she got a good piece of him as he jumped over a large fence that separated the neighborhood and came back to the house with part of his clothes in her mouth. She could be crazy loud but whenever she was serious she got quiet and focused and growled deep and ominous. She was an amazing animal.
 
Most people in the neighborehood avoid my dogs. If you (Ataro) met me with my dogs you might post another thread about aggressive dogs in Canada :) Gino growls to establish his dominance and Asha is always an alpha.... but they are not sharp dogs. I saw sharp dogs in the Schutzhund field.... that's too much to handle for me.
 
I don't see why you are trying to compare dominance or high drive to sharpness. Yes, Ashra is high drive and very dominant, and may turn out to be dog aggressive as she matures. However, Ashra is a sharp dog (medium sharp), according to the the Marko's definition and reacts to stimuli in the same manner as Eva. That is to say, she quickly engages perceived threats with aggression, and does not just alert by barking.

What I count as indicators of her sharpness:
- She will lunge into attack at perceived threats, such as someone suddenly crashing into a pile of leaves behind us or otherwise appearing suddenly in an isolated area such as a lonely street. e.g. I have had to react quickly and pull her off a guy who stepped out from behind a car in the middle of the night when I was out with her on her last toilet break.
- She sees people who are nervous around her or otherwise acting "strange" as threats, and she will growl and lunge at them if they come within a certain distance.
- She will lunge, growl and bark at people she feels are hostile, such as helpers hiding behind the blinds in Schutzhund (she has never been trained to do this, or in any formal protection work).
- She will follow guests around inside the house growling at them the entire time they if she doesn't feel that they are truly friendly (this has happened twice), the same goes for taxi drivers.
 
She behaves like a Doberman :) and exactly like my dogs except of growling at people I invite to my house. They stop acting if I greet and talk to people. My friends are their friends.
 
Exactly, like a Dobermann. And what does the FCI standard say about correct temperament? Medium sharp ;). If your dogs act the same way, then they are medium sharp.

As for visitors, I was not talking about my friends, but rather people who are my flatmate's guests, friends of friends or others such as the landlord.
 
I just don't think I could have a sharp doberman as several people have mentioned in this thread. My dogs are protective at home when they feel the need to alert me to something. The people that come into my house are friends and family and the dogs are introduced to them and dont growl or lunge at anybody under my roof. It will absolutely never happen.
Ataro I could never have Ataro in my live. I take my dogs everywhere with me and I would absolutely forbid one of my dogs lunging at a stranger or biting a person. When you have Dobermans working I thought they worked on field with trainers then that sharpness is left at the training field.
Is Ashra going in to conformation or are you going to work with her in the clubs. I think it would be difficult if Ataro is shy or medium sharp and try to show in conformation. I certainly would like to hear of people that have done both with their dogs. What titles have you got with Ashra and is your puppy starting to train. I don't have the knowledge in working that several of you enjoy. Always love to hear about it and have learned a few things in the threads being posted.

My dogs are Dobermans that I can take anywhere and have control of them. I guess my dogs aren't sharp but boy do I love them and they are healthy happy dogs
 
Michele, are you referring to my temperament or Ashra's as being sharp? You seem to be unclear about that in your post.:p

Ashra is not shy (in fact, she is very confident - maybe even cocky at times) and I have not had any problems with her at shows or in crowds in public, apart from specific situations as I have described above. I think you may have the wrong idea of sharpness and seem to equate it with instability and/or shyness. That is not the case as we live in the city, ride buses, the subway etc. with absolutely no problems. Ashra loves children, and is even tolerant of drunk people, who we often meet on public transport, coming up to her. But of course, since she was very young I have taken her everywhere with me and socialized her extensively and I also know her behaviour and her triggers. She is not a liability and I don't hesitate to take her anywhere with me, but as Marko also stated above, I would not readily put her in the hands of inexperienced people or just anyone.

As you know, I show Ashra (we are going to a show next week, actually) and I would like to title her in Schutzhund. I started taking her to a Schutzhund club last year, but they are currently on a winter break. There are age restrictions on Schutzhund titles, so it is impossible for her to have any (she is just old enough for the BH as of two days ago) titles, apart from the fact that she has just started out as there was no opportunity to train in Mexico. To get the first Schutzhund title, you are looking at a time frame of at least a year or so in training.

As for the puppy, I am not training her beyond basics such as sit, wait and good manners etc. as I am looking for a new home for her. In regards to this discussion though, the puppy is not sharp at all (still doesn't alert at 3 months old), she is not confident or stable so she wouldn't be suitable for showing, and she has very little prey or play drive... there is nothing that indicates that she would be suitable for working, either. I'm sure once she finds a new home, in optimally a rural or semi-rural area, she will enjoy living the rest of her life as a beloved house pet.
 

Back
Top