I once gave my flatmate permission to walk Ashra in the evening around the block with an ex-girlfriend of his and his son, when his son asked if she could come along. I knew where they were going however, and that the chances of meeting another dog were slim to none. He said she was okay, and well behaved (even though I saw her pulling and going in circles both on the way out and on the way back). Most people walking with me get fed up and give the leash back after Ashra shows them absolutely no respect by running circles, pulling and what not.
I don't know if she would act as protectively or protectively at all, were they walking her alone. But I do know she would push them and lunge at other dogs if she felt like it, just because she doesn't feel obliged to obey a stranger (or even a friend), and that's why I don't generally let people walk her. I have the same experience with Ashra as you do with Eva if walking alone (day or night), and even with guests who I have not personally let in the door and welcomed myself. However, at this point I don't feel that she is a liability at all; she will stop her attack reliably on command and her recall is solid. We take public transport, taxis, go through crowds and busy places etc. and she has never reacted inappropriately.
I think that if your dog respects you and is well trained, sharpness should not be a negative factor. It's when people inexperienced with aggression, dominance and/or dogs and dog body language in general have such a dog that it becomes a problem. In this case, I'd have to say sammy's argument holds a lot of truth. If you want a friendly pet dog, why would you want a Dobe? If you rescue a Dobe and it has such a temperament, I say power to you and enjoy your pet. However, breeding for this kind of friendly temperament? The standard states correct temperament is bold and medium sharp, but it seems quite a lot of breeders are breeding for the "market".
I have visited several breeders and met their dogs, and some of their dogs have come up to me super friendly and wanting to lick my face. All I could think of at the time was "Have we met before?! Why is this Dobe being so friendly?" None of my dogs (non-Dobes included) were ever that friendly upon first meeting strange adults (some of them really love children, though). I would expect a Dobe to be calm, stable, and that it comes to sniff and perhaps allows itself to be stroked, but giving kisses to someone they have just met for the first time? I personally would not want my dog to act that way, with the exception of if it was still a puppy.