Lizzard
Hot Topics Subscriber
I think most people on this board can agree with the following statement:
This statement is confusing:
I will try to say it one more time. It is not about cropping and docking ONLY. I am not against some leaving their dogs uncropped and docked. I am 100% solidly for following the standard and NOT LOOSING the right to crop and dock.
This statement is confusing:
If any of you can guarantee me that by you leaving your dogs uncropped we will NOT LOOSE our right to crop [\quote]
Regardless of what we do with our dogs, we can't guarantee the preservation or loss of the right. Think about it - continuing to crop dogs does not necessarily guarantee, one way or another, that the right to crop would remain, does it? Whether we keep that right [and this applies to any right] is more up to how passionate the people are and how willing they are to fight the courts/AR groups/etc. Not cropping the dog does not guarantee, one way or another, that we would lose or keep the right; nor would cropping the dogs guarantee, one way or another, that we would lose or keep the right.
No more purebred dogs? :confused2: Like Swift and DV, I fail to see how the "purebred" is gone if you don't crop the ears. Whether a dog gets their ears cropped, they are still from a line of DOBERMANS - you are not breeding in or breeding out a cropped ear. The cropped ear is a cosmetic change made to the dog after birth so that it conforms to the standard. But it does not mean that without the crop, the dog is not purebred and that the purebred goes away. How do you make that conclusion? Am I missing something?Once that standard is chopped away there are no more purebred dogs.![]()


They don't tell you that!