Your opinion on ear cropping tail docking?

Thanks. I probably will resist the urge to head over to the political forum. I don't do well with emotionally charged anti intellectual do gooders and social justice warriors. Panties (especially when worn by boys) tend to get all knotted up, their feelings get hurt and their limited lives get disoriented when their touchy feely world views are assaulted.
You sound perfect when I go on vacation and need help moderating that section:D

Forward me an Email address to begin the process. :D
 
Well I clicked on the "don't cause psychological suffering" link out of curiosity and saw that it was Becker. I've read it before. Unfortunate that it was her since she has done some excellent work on vaccination, raw diet and spay/neuter. But on this one she becomes another emotionally charged girl using the typical emotionally charged arguments. <yawn>
 
I love the C/D look and hope to own a cropped & docked doberman sometime in the future. As it's banned in my country I'll either go through the import route or through a European rescue organisation.

I'm open minded about both sides and all I'll say is, no matter whether you have a dobe cropped and docked or natural as long as you love them with all your might, protect them with the last breath in your body that is all that counts.

I will learn to grow a thick skin in a country that has banned C/D, I will be judged a plenty. But that is MY CHOICE and I will deal with any negativity as and when. I respect peoples opinions but will not stand to be bashed, end of.
 
Crop-n-dock.

My son has autism and doesn't like people approaching his dog to pet it or otherwise. When he had a chocolate lab adults and children always approached. Also, I want the dog to look as intimidating as possible because I want my wife (who is practically a super model if I don't say so myself) to be able to walk wherever and be safe.

That said, our young Ruger will not be cropped. Here in Northern California they want a TON of money to do it and we simply can't afford it. Plus there's the extra hassle. So we'll get him the crazy, scariest, psycho-dog, spiky collar we can find and mix human body parts into his food. Muuuuuuuaaahhhhhaaaaaa (scary laugh). :-)
 
Crop-n-dock.

My son has autism and doesn't like people approaching his dog to pet it or otherwise. When he had a chocolate lab adults and children always approached. Also, I want the dog to look as intimidating as possible because I want my wife (who is practically a super model if I don't say so myself) to be able to walk wherever and be safe.

That said, our young Ruger will not be cropped. Here in Northern California they want a TON of money to do it and we simply can't afford it. Plus there's the extra hassle. So we'll get him the crazy, scariest, psycho-dog, spiky collar we can find and mix human body parts into his food. Muuuuuuuaaahhhhhaaaaaa (scary laugh). :)
For maximum effect in intimidating looks.
How much is a ton of money? And, how old is the dog again?
A ton of money is subjective, and don't recall if you've posted how much they want?
Was it way out of line compared to what others here have paid?
 
Crop-n-dock.

My son has autism and doesn't like people approaching his dog to pet it or otherwise. When he had a chocolate lab adults and children always approached. Also, I want the dog to look as intimidating as possible because I want my wife (who is practically a super model if I don't say so myself) to be able to walk wherever and be safe.

That said, our young Ruger will not be cropped. Here in Northern California they want a TON of money to do it and we simply can't afford it. Plus there's the extra hassle. So we'll get him the crazy, scariest, psycho-dog, spiky collar we can find and mix human body parts into his food. Muuuuuuuaaahhhhhaaaaaa (scary laugh). :)
You might consider working on teaching things that lend themselves to Ruger being able to alert on your command, alert on a person you indicate, bark on command, bare his teeth on command and so forth. This is all assuming you will not do any actual protection training with him.
 
My opinion: They're dogs, not people. They're here to serve us whether that be protection, affection, or whatever. I've noticed most anti-croppers will happily take a male dog's balls off but find it cruel to trim a bit off the ears. I find that to be a quite funny contradiction! :) People will enlarge breasts, inject into the lips, and lipo their booties & hips, and everyone's OK with that. Haha!

How much is a ton of money? And, how old is the dog again?
I was quoted $800. Ruger is 12 weeks as of Sept 11, 2017.
 
My opinion: They're dogs, not people. They're here to serve us whether that be protection, affection, or whatever. I've noticed most anti-croppers will happily take a male dog's balls off but find it cruel to trim a bit off the ears. I find that to be a quite funny contradiction! :) People will enlarge breasts, inject into the lips, and lipo their booties & hips, and everyone's OK with that. Haha!


I was quoted $800. Ruger is 12 weeks as of Sept 11, 2017.
It's about too late now anyway. I'm not sure but the price doesn't sound drastically out of line?

...and, in your list of human surgical alterations you forgot circumcizing baby boys. ;)
Not to mention all those weird things the put in ear lobes today, or tongue studs, tattoos, and that metal shit they wear in their faces.:rolleyes:

Yep. Those are the people that should be telling me how to live my life and what decisions are right or wrong, lol
 
"Janie... Red/Rust female. Three years old, spayed. Tail and ears are intact!"

ROTFLOL. Why no exclamation point after spayed?

"If a dog is meant to have standing ears, they'll stand naturally. Just like GSD, Chihuahaus, ect."

Evidently they weren't meant to have reproductive organs right? Contradiction much?
it actually wasn't my choice to get her spayed... and I actually hate spay/neutering dogs. But almost every vet won't do any type of surgical procedure without spay/neutering the animal. Also, its proven to help the animal in the long run if they're fixed... but I'm not trying defending .
 
My opinion: They're dogs, not people. They're here to serve us whether that be protection, affection, or whatever. I've noticed most anti-croppers will happily take a male dog's balls off but find it cruel to trim a bit off the ears. I find that to be a quite funny contradiction! :) People will enlarge breasts, inject into the lips, and lipo their booties & hips, and everyone's OK with that. Haha!


I was quoted $800. Ruger is 12 weeks as of Sept 11, 2017.
I'm comepletely not okay with people doing that to themselves... but the way I look at it is, it's THEIR body, not the dogs.
 
"Also, its proven to help the animal in the long run if they're fixed... but I'm not trying defending"

I don't know who and where you've been reading but that is pure foolishness. Neutering and spaying have nothing but negative effects on the health of dogs.

Health Issues Linked to Spaying and Neutering Dogs

Maybe not pure foolishness. Like C/D it is a controversial topic for many.

Benefits and Risks of Neutering, An Evidence Update: Effects of Neutering on Longevity and Cause of Death in Dogs | The SkeptVet
 

I've seen that article and I'm non-plussed. Typical defensive reaction of an industry whose practice is being challenged though this one does its best to stay unbiased. Nevertheless the number of qualifications in it must be noted. There is a great deal of money at stake here.
 

Studies are great! But also have to take in consideration what Crap diets was each dog fed, How many were over vaccinated or not, How many Pesticides were put on or given internally for Flea, Ticks and Heartworm?
All these can affect a dogs health. How many Endocrine issues were caused by Spay/Neuter?
 
I have never heard of that before. Are you saying that if a dog needs a surgical procedure, let's say for a blockage, a vet won't do it if the dog is intact. That's insanity!
No that's not what I'm saying... I'm saying that, while the dog is under, they fix it. I.e- One of my dogs needed a hurnia repair. The vet said that he is going to spay her while he's fixing the hurnia.
 
I'm comepletely not okay with people doing that to themselves... but the way I look at it is, it's THEIR body, not the dogs.
I hear ya. I was generalizing. :-)

I've seen that article and I'm non-plussed. Typical defensive reaction of an industry whose practice is being challenged though this one does its best to stay unbiased. Nevertheless the number of qualifications in it must be noted. There is a great deal of money at stake here.
And there are a lot of variables in play too. It's my opinion that it's also important to know who paid for any study. Interpreting the results of studies has been made intentionally difficult, but whoever is funding said study wants to make a point and they want the results they're paying for.
 

Back
Top