Your opinion on ear cropping tail docking?

That makes sense Tad, I know Brinks inherited the shepherd tail and I couldn't imagine him without it. It is thick, long, and low set. Dogs definitely use their tails as a sort of counter balance. I did want to point out though that you stated a breed that has never traditionally been altered is unheard of to begin. Do you think that has most to do with practicality and functionality rather than say... what people are "used" to?

If you are a bad guy and you have an 80 lbs dog snarling ready to rip off your face, he's probably not checking to see what style ears he has :D.

Even though I personally don't particularly agree with cosmetic surgeries, I'm not out at rallies or condoning anyone here for feeling differently.
 
I did want to point out though that you stated a breed that has never traditionally been altered is unheard of to begin. Do you think that has most to do with practicality and functionality rather than say... what people are "used" to?
I was saying that it has to do with the fact that is just would not fly to start docking a breed that has never been docked.

At the same time though I also acknowledge, and have alluded to, the notion that the GSD might be better off with its tail.

I just want to take a moment at this point to say I really appreciate our DCF family. This brief debate has been enjoyable and I hope I did not offend or put off anyone.

I don't put myself up as the authority. I'm just expressing what is correct in this one man's mind. Certainly not going to say point blank to anyone "Hey, you shouldn't own a Doberman." Who am I to say that? I just have a strong, idealistic opinion on this and present it.
 
My view is pretty simple. I wouldn't want someone telling me what I should do with my dog so I don't tell anyone what they should do with their dog. I prefer the classic look of cropped and docked. I'm certain the raised ears gives a better ability to hear. Beyond that the benefits become subjective and even vets debate them. If you don't want to or can't have your Dobe cropped and docked, no big deal to me. I don't like the look but it took me a while to get used to Rots with tails too so maybe it will grow on me in time. Since it hasn't grown on me yet, if I couldn't get a cropped and docked Dobermann, I'd probably get a different breed today. Probably a Mal
 
Thinking about other breeds that are altered, dobermans, boxers, giant schnauzer, those breeds strike me as 'people protection' type dogs where as, as someone mentioned, GSDs were originally bred as herders/shepherds, as the name implies. I do believe that the GSD working so closely with their people to protect animals is certainly part of what has instilled great loyalty and fearlessness in them that makes them good as police dogs, now. Other breeds that often get cropped, great danes, cane corso's, were bred as hunting dogs for dangerous game so perhaps the practice of cropping was to keep their ears safe (this reasoning made possible by the power of google and minor knowledge on dog breed history so sorry for any mis-information!).

I do agree that C&D should be done by people who KNOW what they're doing and that flopped is a better alternative to a botched job. Like many things, if made illegal, folks will find a way to get what they want which could translate to more 'botched' jobs, I would think.
 
I prefer crop/dock on breeds that have it in their standard, especially dobermans. I'm not against those that choose not and I'd rather someone not if they don't have an artistic cropping vet or the patience to carry through posting the entire time.

However, having owned floppy ears, dews, and tails in other breeds...I've never experienced constant ear infections or ripped dews or tail issues. I'm not saying they don't happen but I think a lot of it comes down to environment, genetics, and personal management. What is the dog eating, are they getting their ears cleaned and dried out after getting wet? Ears cleaned at all? Long haired breed having the hair thinned out inside the ears? Dews hanging low or nice and tight on the leg? Large dog in a small space?

Imo, don't remove it unless it becomes an issue. Just like my opinion on spay/neuter, or handling any other body injury. I'm not going to remove their legs cause they could possibly injure them or their other nails cause they could rip those out too! Deal with it like any other injury and take precautions to avoid an injury from occuring.
 
I guess it comes down to all those childhood "brain imprints" you get as to what looks attractive and what doesn't.
Totally agree with this concept and glad you mentioned it here as I don't recall it being mentioned in old threads on this very topic. I'm sure there's some formal psychological term for this.
 
I don't happen to think it should be mandatory to do anymore unless the dog is actively used for that purpose.
You raise a good point. To me it seems that Dobermans don't do protection "work" the way they were originally intended. Most of them are pets. Scary looking pets that serve as a visual deterrent ;) Makes me think of "Labrador in a Doberman suit". The look is fierce and that's usually what a lot of people are attracted to initially.
 
Thinking about other breeds that are altered, dobermans, boxers, giant schnauzer, those breeds strike me as 'people protection' type dogs
There is a list on this forum of all dogs that are C/D and it is huge and was very surprising to me. I can't find it now but on some dogs, I bet ppl just never notice. I never noticed these things in other dogs until Kaiser came along.
 
I disagree that it's purely cosmetic, especially when it comes to ears. Floppy ears are simply more prone to infections due to trapping moisture in and more prone to injury.

I'm beyond dilligent about ear cleaning and yet, my lab gets ear infections rather often. Because we also work the dogs beyond what most "pet" people do, we've also dealt with ear tears which are nasty, borderline impossible to heal and just an all around pain in the ass. My lab tore his ear running through brush, it took six MONTHS to fully heal. Why? Because every single time he shook his head, it opened back up. It got to the point that the only option was to bandage and wrap his ear to his head, which exacerbated the infections issue. If I could crop him, I would in a heart beat. Kaizer has also torn his ear open, though I dunno how, possibly just wrestling with the lab and there again, a rather superficial wound took months to heal.

Maybe we just have bad luck, I dunno. But I never had these issues with my prick eared dogs. Ever.

On a side note - and this is NOT directed at anyone here - I find it interesting that many of those who are against C/D fully support early spay/neuter. Seems odd to me when they argue that c/d is a cosmetic surgery with no benefits but yet are totally ok with surgery to desex despite the fact that we know that early desexing leads to a miriad of issues and imo, is usually used as a lazy way out of having to be a dilligent and responsible owner.

Lastly - I agree that the biggest difference with GSD in regards to c/d is that unlike the Dobermann, they were not bred specifically for personal protection. Many protection and game/hunting breeds are cropped and/or docked. Hunting dogs are notorious for tail injuries and flop ears would be an inherent risk as other animals would grab them. Traditionally, most of these breeds had very, very short crops, some are left with basically no ears at all. It's only been more recently that the longer crops have become popular as they are usually seen as more attractive, particularly in the show world. Even the traditional dobermann crop was quite short and you will still see this done in dogs who are primarily working (think "military crop" for instance).
 
Well to me it's like this, I am in the UK so no crop/dock great I love natural, if I was in the US I would still choose natural, IF by some chance I could only own a Doberman that was docked cropped I would still have a Doberman, I am faithful to the breed, it's not fair saying if we want to keep a dog natural we should pick another breed as we could say the same to you , Dobermans are unique and irreplaceable, no other breed comes close, lets face it these dogs are dying younger and younger just enjoy them and worry about the things that are killing them at 2,3 4 years old.
Thanks @Prushanks that was a wonderful thing you said about my kids, I have to admit I think Bella was the most beautiful Doberman ever, and everyday people admired her, I miss her very very much :(:(bellaface.webp
 
Well to me it's like this, I am in the UK so no crop/dock great I love natural, if I was in the US I would still choose natural, IF by some chance I could only own a Doberman that was docked cropped I would still have a Doberman, I am faithful to the breed, it's not fair saying if we want to keep a dog natural we should pick another breed as we could say the same to you , Dobermans are unique and irreplaceable, no other breed comes close, lets face it these dogs are dying younger and younger just enjoy them and worry about the things that are killing them at 2,3 4 years old.
Thanks @Prushanks that was a wonderful thing you said about my kids, I have to admit I think Bella was the most beautiful Doberman ever, and everyday people admired her, I miss her very very much :(:(View attachment 75717

I believe you can still import into the UK a C/D Dobermann for a Working Dog!
 
A few of you have said that you'd rather have others leave their Doberman uncropped than have them wind up with a bad crop or botched job. I will assume you group cropped-but-flopped in this thinking as well.

It raises the curiosity in me: Can you explain why you want others to not have bad, botched or flopped crops?

For darned sure I do not want a bad crop or a crop-flop! In fact it's one of the biggest stressors on me with owning a Doberman – the worry about one of the ears not standing, or with winding up with a bad crop job.

But why do you care what others wind up with?
 
Perhaps she meant as if you do not want to keep a dog natural you should pick another breed. I'm not saying that literally, just that the term could go both ways.

I have had natural dogs with flop ears my entire life without any ear infections. Maybe it comes down to mostly genetics?

I understand that traditionally, a GSD was originally a herding breed and not for protection, although they excel at it. I suppose my point was if a dog was serving the exact same purpose, why would one be altered to be further suited but not another? Because of tradition, and what people are accustomed to?
 
Perhaps she meant as if you do not want to keep a dog natural you should pick another breed. I'm not saying that literally, just that the term could go both ways.
I figure that's what she meant. There's just no sense in that notion.
 
Likewise is there much sense in saying that if you do not care to adhere to the accustomed norm you should also choose another breed, despite being fully qualified otherwise?
 
Likewise is there much sense in saying that if you do not care to adhere to the accustomed norm you should also choose another breed, despite being fully qualified otherwise?
No. I am saying that the notion that [If you want a cropped dog maybe you should choose a breed other than the Doberman] does not make sense.

It does make sense (though I have indicated that I would probably not tell this to anyone in particular) to say that [If you want a floppy eared dog maybe you should choose a breed other than a Doberman].

See? I am saying that it does not make sense to simply flip the statement. It does not stand to reason.
 
I do not think she meant that if you want a cropped dog to choose another breed, as that does not make sense as you said. Without human intervention, and in quite a few countries, a Doberman IS a flop eared breed.
 

Back
Top