Your opinion on ear cropping tail docking?

Pro crop & dock

Tail: an undocked Doberman tail is highly prone to injury and sometime to the degree of needing to be amputated.

Ears: breed standard (typically cropped)

Some like a tail, I love a nub!
Some like floppy, I like cropped.
 
Their little nubs are just the best!

I've experienced the fluffy long tail of a larger Golden/Lab type dog and he used to wipe everything off the coffee table everytime he was happy - which was a lot! So his people stopped using the table instead of fixing the problem with training. Another is a pit boxer dog with a long skinny tail and it was like being whipped! Don't know if Dobe tails would have a whip effect but their tails seem pretty thick that I would not want to find out the hard way.

Plus, it's the classic look!
 
Welcome!

The lack of responses thus far is probably due to the fact that this is a real powder-keg issue. Shouldn't be, but it is.

I am hardcore pro-cropping & docking. I used to be more live-and-let-live, but when I started to really think about it more, I developed a firm stance.

C & D is not just cosmetic as you will often hear. It is not just tradition. It is not just the standard.

It's those things, along with some real physical reasons. This breed was designed to be cropped and docked. I think that people who want this breed should C & D. There are plenty of breeds that are not C & D, so if it bothers you, (I don't mean specifically you, Janiethedob) you should invest in one of those other breeds.
 
For me the tail is a must. My first two dobes were rescues and had floppy ears that laid nicely. They were cute. Rubie I got as a puppy from a breeder so hers are cropped. If done right and posted correctly, they are just a phenomenal sight. She still gets confused for other breeds as often as my two floppies did, though.

As @Oh Little Oji said, Dobermans were bred as protection dogs so the C&D does serve a purpose: less to grab onto to get a dog off of you. Since they serve a purpose for what the breed was designed to do, they've made it into the breed standard.
 
I'm pro dock/crop. I don't know why, but I'm having difficulty picturing dobies without it. All the pictures here of undocked/uncropped dobies just look foreign to me. Just as the converse (dogs normally undocked/uncropped but are) would look just as foreign. I know it doesn't make sense, but I'll try to explain it.

I guess it comes down to all those childhood "brain imprints" you get as to what looks attractive and what doesn't. You know... Back on the playgrounds of elementary school, you were scoping out the other kids during recess and deciding for yourself who was "hot" and who was "not..." long before you even knew what do do with them... :eek: :D I call it "Aesthetic attraction." Things that are much more "eye candy" than "libido candy." You carry these brain imprints, pretty much, for the rest of your life.

Dobies that are undocked/uncropped just look different. I suppose if I had been raised all around dobies that were undocked/uncropped, I'd feel different. Like I say.... brain imprints... That said, I do know that part of the logic for docking/cropping dobies was to facilitate their work as guard/police dogs. Just as long hair should be tied/bunn'ed up when in uniform (to prevent a BG from pulling it and disabling you), I liked that dobies with docked/cropped features having less of a risk of the long tail or ears being a problem.
 
Definitely pro both. I hugely regret not getting my mixed boys ears done.

I live with a lab ... His tail is like a damn baseball bat. And I really don't think you can train some of the issues tails present away. As I don't think dogs are always even aware if what their tails are doing. We don't have a coffee table, for good reason lol I'd be ok with never having a tailed large breed again.

Ears. Sigh. After dealing with ear injuries and infections that could have been mostly prevented with cropping, I don't think I'll ever own a flop again.

As for the "cosmetic" side - I think a lot of people forget that since the breed is c/d more often than not, most breeders can't and don't breed for healthy, natural tails and ears, let alone uniform and consistent ones.
 
I am pro crop/dock but it is what I like and how the breed was designed. I still love the breed and have some that train with me that still have ears and tails. I personally think they would look better cropped and docked but if you are planning on taking a dog to the world championship you will have to deal with it. Also importing an older puppy from a country that has banned c/d is beyond your control.
 
There are plenty of breeds that are not C & D, so if it bothers you, (I don't mean specifically you, Janiethedob) you should invest in one of those other breeds.

Tad I'm just picking you out of the responses because for your interesting points, I know that many others agree with you but for the sake of quoting! :D

I am pro C&D, fully prefer the look and agree with all the reasons why, however I don't happen to think it should be mandatory to do anymore unless the dog is actively used for that purpose. This is JMHO and I have a more moderate stance on it. I FULLY respect others don't agree!! :thumbsup2: :thumbsup2::thumbsup2:

This is where I differ more strongly... Dobes are not just their cropped ears and docked tails... if a person wants a Dobermann for everything thing that the breed inherently encompasses (i.e. Temperament, intelligence, loyalty etc etc) but doesn't want to C&D, there is no reason why they should have to choose another breed purely for the superficial reason of C&D. They should be able to have the dog they want. They should have the right to choose. As far as docking.. that is a bit trickier as it's done soon after birth..but they can always import from a Banned country... and I happen to think that @Viemarangelrock 's Kobe and @Judith 's Bella &Buddy are three of the most stunning Dobes I've ever seen! For the sake of discussion, should they not have gotten Dobes just because they did not get one from USA, Serbia or another place that its still legal? Whether or not they prefer C&D?)
I think we can all agree that the Dobermann is a truly unique breed so to say (paraphrase) "if you don't want a C&D Dobe, get a different breed" i don't find quite fair. Other non-C&D breeds may not fit the Dobermann's shoes.

To be clear: I support and prefer C&D myself, fully respect everyone's opinions, and understand that it is a slippery slope with BYB and Mills etc but I just don't agree with that one statement. :anonymous :
 
I love the nub, just love it. All my previous Dobes were rescues, all docked, 2 came cropped, 2 did not. I love cropped ears, but am pro-choice. I really wanted my current girl's ears done, but live in a country where I have seen very few nice crops and couldn't locate a vet I was comfortable with doing it. For me, better down ears than a botched job. And to me she is still 100% Doberman.
 
Well, I will be the odd one out. I won't deny that a cropped and docked dog is a sight to behold. That being said, I believe if they were meant to be that way they would be born like that. There is nothing inherently wrong with their ears and tails that call for amputation. I understand the reasoning behind for protection uses, but let's be honest most owners do not use them extensively for this purpose. Tails serve a great purpose in communicating with other dogs. My boy is a mix but even if he wasn't, and I had the option, I would prefer a natural dog.
 
Tad I'm just picking you out of the responses because for your interesting points, I know that many others agree with you but for the sake of quoting! :D

I am pro C&D, fully prefer the look and agree with all the reasons why, however I don't happen to think it should be mandatory to do anymore unless the dog is actively used for that purpose. This is JMHO and I have a more moderate stance on it. I FULLY respect others don't agree!! :thumbsup2: :thumbsup2::thumbsup2:

This is where I differ more strongly... Dobes are not just their cropped ears and docked tails... if a person wants a Dobermann for everything thing that the breed inherently encompasses (i.e. Temperament, intelligence, loyalty etc etc) but doesn't want to C&D, there is no reason why they should have to choose another breed purely for the superficial reason of C&D. They should be able to have the dog they want. They should have the right to choose. As far as docking.. that is a bit trickier as it's done soon after birth..but they can always import from a Banned country... and I happen to think that @Viemarangelrock 's Kobe and @Judith 's Bella &Buddy are three of the most stunning Dobes I've ever seen! For the sake of discussion, should they not have gotten Dobes just because they did get one from USA, Serbia or another place that its still legal? Whether or not they prefer C&D?)
I think we can all agree that the Dobermann is a truly unique breed so to say (paraphrase) "if you don't want a C&D Dobe, get a different breed" i don't find quite fair. Other non-C&D breeds may not fit the Dobermann's shoes.

To be clear: I support and prefer C&D myself, fully respect everyone's opinions, and understand that it is a slippery slope with BYB and Mills etc but I just don't agree with that one statement. :anonymous :
Good points tactfully presented.

I suppose it depends on if the Doberman really possesses those unique qualities that cannot be found in another breed of similar size and physical makeup. For example, is the Doberman really smarter than the GSP? Is it really more loyal? I can cede that the Doberman may have more alertness and watchfulness than most other breeds.

As for people in countries where C&D is banned, my answer is simple: It should not be banned!
 
Well, I will be the odd one out. I won't deny that a cropped and docked dog is a sight to behold. That being said, I believe if they were meant to be that way they would be born like that. There is nothing inherently wrong with their ears and tails that call for amputation. I understand the reasoning behind for protection uses, but let's be honest most owners do not use them extensively for this purpose. Tails serve a great purpose in communicating with other dogs. My boy is a mix but even if he wasn't, and I had the option, I would prefer a natural dog.
We can't say what is meant to be, as this breed did not occur naturally. It was designed and brought to fruition by mankind. Something that I did not know prior to hearing it here on this forum is that the very early Dobermann did have prick ears without cropping; but as other additions were made in the development of the breed, flopped ears began to show up.

The reason for C&D does not have to do with anything being physically defective from a health perspective with the ears & tails.

If we say that not many people really use the breed for protection so C&D isn't necessary, then do we say we should start breeding out the mental and physical qualities that enable protection work? I think most peoples' answer would be "No, I still want my Doberman to be able to protect, I just don't like cropping and docking." In other words, they want the Doberman, they just want it the way they want it. We are not talking, here, about a car on which you choose options.
 
My point was that there is nothing health wise that merits the amputations, simply that it is a cosmetic procedure. It is for appearance. GSDs that are the most commonly used breed in protection and police work are left unaltered.
 
My point was that there is nothing health wise that merits the amputations, simply that it is a cosmetic procedure. It is for appearance. GSDs that are the most commonly used breed in protection and police work are left unaltered.
Yeah, I know.

I disagree, though, that it is just cosmetic and for appearance – as I indicated above.

Sure, no doubt the GSD excels, overall, at protection/police/military work. Maybe the Doberman needs all the help it can get though. When I think ultimate protection dog, unfortunately, I do not think Doberman.

Part of the reason for C&D is appearance, yes. It is to provide the look of a higher level of alertness, intimidation and ferocity. Note, of course, that the GSD already has ears that stick up, so they have that advantage (both in appearance and in reduced liability in a struggle).
 
The GSD ears are naturally erect, but they are not small. They also have quite the tail. I am curious, the Doberman is docked to better insure his protection capabilities in the event a foe snatches the tail, correct? Why is this not a practice amongst other breeds such as the GSD that rank highly in this purpose?
 
The GSD ears are naturally erect, but they are not small. They also have quite the tail. I am curious, the Doberman is docked to better insure his protection capabilities in the event a foe snatches the tail, correct? Why is this not a practice amongst other breeds such as the GSD that rank highly in this purpose?
Probably the quickest answer is that it is not because it is not. The GSD was not originated to be a protection dog (to my knowledge). It's not named the German Bodyguard. I suspect it was used for herding purposes. It would be unheard of for an established breed to, on a large scale, start having its tail docked. Further, I don't know how the GSD would respond physically to having its tail docked. It has quite a substantial tail as you pointed out. I imagine that plays in harmony with the rest of the body to help it move the way it needs to. Yes, some say that a Doberman with its tail can turn and move better on the field. Maybe it's true. The GSD is a more substantial dog usually, and it's longer-in-body. Removing the tail, I think, might not work well with the breed. It has worked well with the Doberman, and it does provide benefits in protection capability.

The ears: The GSD's are longer (in some cases) and wider. They provide the alert appearance and some of the intimidation factor – though I submit that the crop of a Dobe is more intimidating. I think that a GSD's prick ears still provide some deterrence from being grabbed by a human hand or another dog's teeth. Here again, though, the large-scale cropping of GSD ears has never happened and it won't be. It's a different dog than the Doberman. What the GSD possesses and brings to the table works. We could get into why it works, but I don't think it negates the pro C&D argument in Dobes to say: Look, this other breed is not C&D and it outperforms the Doberman in protection.
 
Probably the quickest answer is that it is not because it is not. The GSD was not originated to be a protection dog (to my knowledge). It's not named the German Bodyguard. I suspect it was used for herding purposes. It would be unheard of for an established breed to, on a large scale, start having its tail docked. Further, I don't know how the GSD would respond physically to having its tail docked. It has quite a substantial tail as you pointed out. I imagine that plays in harmony with the rest of the body to help it move the way it needs to. Yes, some say that a Doberman with its tail can turn and move better on the field. Maybe it's true. The GSD is a more substantial dog usually, and it's longer-in-body. Removing the tail, I think, might not work well with the breed. It has worked well with the Doberman, and it does provide benefits in protection capability.

The ears: The GSD's are longer (in some cases) and wider. They provide the alert appearance and some of the intimidation factor – though I submit that the crop of a Dobe is more intimidating. I think that a GSD's prick ears still provide some deterrence from being grabbed by a human hand or another dog's teeth. Here again, though, the large-scale cropping of GSD ears has never happened and it won't be. It's a different dog than the Doberman. What the GSD possesses and brings to the table works. We could get into why it works, but I don't think it negates the pro C&D argument in Dobes to say: Look, this other breed is not C&D and it outperforms the Doberman in protection.
Very good points!!
 
I used to be more live-and-let-live, but when I started to really think about it more, I developed a firm stance.


You kind of have to. There is such a strong movement to stop it. You don't stand up, you lose your right.


I am also very pro c/d. Maybe it's the imprint thing @DD4MSpock was talking about, IDK.
Are natural dobes beautiful? YES! But for me there is nothing to compare to seeing a c/d dobie on alert. Just takes my breath away.

For me, better down ears than a botched job.


Very true and the big reason I believe a breeder should take care of the c/d. A responsible breeder will know a good crop vet.


As for the pain and suffering the AR groups like to scream, I call BS! I have seen a litter get their ears cropped and stayed with them a couple of days. I saw no signs of pain ever. They were ready (and did) to play with litter mates as soon as we got home from the vet.
 

Back
Top