• Disclaimer: Hello Guest, Doberman Chat Forums presents the opinions and material on these pages as a service to its membership and to the general public but does not endorse those materials, nor does it guarantee the accuracy of any opinions or information contained therein. The opinions expressed in the materials are strictly the opinion of the writer and do not represent the opinion of, nor are they endorsed by, Doberman Chat Forums. Health and medical articles are intended as an aid to those seeking health information and are not intended to replace the informed opinion of a qualified Veterinarian.”

"Working" American Line breeder?

CrazyDobieLady

Active Member
Hey all,

This is going to be a rather long winded post, so I apologize in advance, and for those who stuck with me thank you for any help you are able to give.

I have 2 American dobies currently. A male I got as a puppy at a wee 8 weeks and a female I rescued last year from DRU (one of my all time favorite dobie rescues). The male is 3 and the female is 4. The male's lineage is probably from what most people may say is a BYOB breeder, for the simple fact that at that time, she was not showing her dogs in confirmation. She however, in my opinion, did everything right: Health testing, single litters, family raised, etc. and he turned out to be a great dog who just got his CGC and am prepping to compete in rally. Does he look perfect? Nope. Not when standing next to a show quality pooch. Is he super smart? You bet. But his drive is lacking. My rescue female is awesome, smart, not so crazy about obedience, but loves agility. Again not a crazy level of drive.

Which brings me to my question. I love the look of American Dobermans vs the Euro but really want something like the drive that I see in GSDs to get into protection work in the future. I've never seen a Euro dobie work so I can't say anything about their drive. The biggest issue I am finding is that the only breeders that have a history of protection or schuzund training are euro lines. Am I crazy? I am not looking for an American/Euro cross, but true American line with good drive. All I keep reading is that Euro is for working and American is for confirmation. Is this true? Does anyone know of any breeders?

Thank you!
 
I have a European Doberman that does train in schutzhund. He's highly driven and needs an enormous amount of physical and mental exercise. I'm sure there are high drive American lines, but I'm not an expert. All I know is I have a high drive dog and it's not easy. Relax is not something he's is known for and he takes a lot of time, dedication and exercise. Not once a week it's everyday.
 
Hi! Thanks for the quick reply. Trust me, my male's drive is practically not existent and he doesn't have the right tempermant [emoji24]. I work with a trainer who competes and has helped me train Stryker for the last 2 years. He is great at standard obedience and will do well in rally, but for what I would like to do in the future I need a different kind of dog. I've started looking at dutchies but my heart will always be with dobies.


Sent from my iPhone using Doberman Chat
 
Hi! Thanks for the quick reply. Trust me, my male's drive is practically not existent and he doesn't have the right tempermant [emoji24]. I work with a trainer who competes and has helped me train Stryker for the last 2 years. He is great at standard obedience and will do well in rally, but for what I would like to do in the future I need a different kind of dog. I've started looking at dutchies but my heart will always be with dobies.


Sent from my iPhone using Doberman Chat
Awwwww well I can say that I think both NA and EU are beautiful. Have you ever looked into SA dobes ? They are gorgeous and might just be exactly what you are looking for :)
Would love to see pics of your pups :)
Here's my monster lol he's a 1 1/2 :)
image.webp I don't think you would disappointed in a euro but then again that's the look I prefer and there are some awesome folks here to help you :)
@Archer knows her stuff :) I'm sure she will chime in here shortly :)
 
Hi and welcome. I have three Dobermans. One is NA bred for conformation, one is NA/EU bred for performance and the other is NA/SA bred for conformation and performance. All three of mine have high drive and intelligence and excell in multiple venues.

Imho either NA or EU can achieve what you desire. I wouldn't say one is better than the other in certain venues. I have seen NA bred dogs excell at IPO and performance. That being said, Most EU dogs don't do well in the NA conformation ring as the "type" is different between the countries. We do breed a more refined Doberman in NA. Personally, I prefer the look of the NA bred lines.

If you are looking for a NA line with good drive for performance, look into ADAMAS Dobermans. They are typically multi venue higher drive dogs. I have known of a few who have gone on to do IPO out of these lines, but it is not common. Typically these are agility/confo/obedience dogs. If you truly want a NA bred from an IPO line to just do protection work, I fall short on offering suggestions for a breeder as IPO is a dying sport here and not one I compete in. Hopefully someone else can offer a good suggestion.
 
Hi, and welcome! :)

I like your question, and it wasn't what I'd call long-winded at all. You'll see that this reply is actually longer than your question :D I hope you stick with me.

I have repeated it a few times: People do seem to lump Euro and working together, and seem to assume that North American means conformation or just whatever. I say there has to be more to the picture.

Agreed that unless your Dobe is from working lines the likelihood is low that it will have what it takes to work in protection-oriented sports. To me, that's a shame, but it's what the breed has become.

At any rate: If you are talking about an American-line Dobe that has the type of looks you find in the conformation ring, I am not aware of a breeder that is producing Dobes with that appearance and conformation that also has strong working (protection-oriented) titles in its lineage. Not that I am anywhere near an expert on the breeders in this country.

I have heard of ADAMAS and came close (I thought) to getting a pup that was from them on one side of parentage. They have a reputation of having Dobes in agility and having good working ability; but for me that does not translate into having what it takes to do protection work. Drive to excel in the agility ring does not mean having a full-mouth bite and fight drive and hardness.

So, I am curious to see what you think of this: What I have found is that there is in this country a type of Doberman that may have Euro in its lines – or in the case of my current Dobe, is all-Euro – but does not look like that type of Euro Dobermann that is pronounced in size and is quite heavy-boned and blocky with exaggerated forechest and a really large head. No, this type of Doberman actually is sort of the opposite, and is built for speed, agility and all-out performance on the field. Unfortunately, to me, many of them do not look good and are too small, narrow and unsubstantial, and usually have a croup that is too rounded and a somewhat roached back (think greyhound-like). I don't want to name breeder names after the negative things I just said, but I'll show you a pic of my Euro, working-line Doberman male from a breeder here in the States:

Below: At about 20 months.
GB21mo2wkLookOutWndw.webp
Below: At about 19 months.GB19mo3halfWkStandProfile.webp
 
I would look into Swift Run Dobermans in KY. I really don't know their lineage but they are certainly working line Dobermans and IMHO don't look like big EU dobes.
 
@ariesmydobe: who/what is SA dobes?

@Archer: Thank you for the suggestion! I don't know for sure that I want to do it. It's interesting and I'd like to try it. I know that I love working obedience


Sent from my iPhone using Doberman Chat
 
Disregard the above dupe post please


@ariesmydobe: who/what is SA dobes?

@Archer: Thank you for the suggestion! I don't know for sure that I want to do it. It's interesting and I'd like to try it. I know that I love working obedience and would have loved to move on to something more with Stryker. If you had asked me 2 years ago I would have had no understanding of temperament and drives beyond the concept that I wanted a sound dog that wasn't going to attack people. When we got Stryker, he was everything we asked for "the goofy, loving dog, that runs into walls." [emoji13] he doesn't run into walls but as he was my first Doberman that I owned it was perfect. He was so easy to train and despite some mistakes I made raising him l, he has turned into a fantastic dog.

@oji: your dobie is beautiful!!! [emoji7] and doesn't look euro at all. His chest doesn't swoop down as much as Stryker's and he doesn't have as pronounced of an uptuck? But I wouldn't have guessed he was euro. As you mention Stryker doesn't have a perfectly straight back either, and you can see a slight arch to it when he stands. His back legs also wobble when he walks which has been a concern of mine. I don't know if that is a result of poor confirmation. If you don't mind, would you PM me the breeder. I'd love to look into it. I always do tons of research before I choose the right breeder for me and having multiple to research is a huge help!

And as requested here are my babies:

Our Rescue Layla:
8203e0843cea4a4e9dd4faaa17d7933e.jpg



Stryker:
0466d0302f7aaee8e2139af571d47a23.jpg


And our honorary dobie Gambit
127ee62002c09ceb1187f07f53c4d632.jpg


Sent from my iPhone using Doberman Chat


Sent from my iPhone using Doberman Chat
 
SA is South American :) Their lines are like NA Dobes, but they have more of a harsher tempermeant. The few I have come in contact with are a handful and were a bit aggressive
 
Disregard the above dupe post please


@ariesmydobe: who/what is SA dobes?

@Archer: Thank you for the suggestion! I don't know for sure that I want to do it. It's interesting and I'd like to try it. I know that I love working obedience and would have loved to move on to something more with Stryker. If you had asked me 2 years ago I would have had no understanding of temperament and drives beyond the concept that I wanted a sound dog that wasn't going to attack people. When we got Stryker, he was everything we asked for "the goofy, loving dog, that runs into walls." [emoji13] he doesn't run into walls but as he was my first Doberman that I owned it was perfect. He was so easy to train and despite some mistakes I made raising him l, he has turned into a fantastic dog.

@oji: your dobie is beautiful!!! [emoji7] and doesn't look euro at all. His chest doesn't swoop down as much as Stryker's and he doesn't have as pronounced of an uptuck? But I wouldn't have guessed he was euro. As you mention Stryker doesn't have a perfectly straight back either, and you can see a slight arch to it when he stands. His back legs also wobble when he walks which has been a concern of mine. I don't know if that is a result of poor confirmation. If you don't mind, would you PM me the breeder. I'd love to look into it. I always do tons of research before I choose the right breeder for me and having multiple to research is a huge help!

And as requested here are my babies:

Our Rescue Layla:
8203e0843cea4a4e9dd4faaa17d7933e.jpg



Stryker:
0466d0302f7aaee8e2139af571d47a23.jpg


And our honorary dobie Gambit
127ee62002c09ceb1187f07f53c4d632.jpg


Sent from my iPhone using Doberman Chat


Sent from my iPhone using Doberman Chat
Beautiful babies :) Stryker's back is secondary to his conformation and is the result of his hip angles being slightly off.
 
Disregard the above dupe post please


@ariesmydobe: who/what is SA dobes?

@Archer: Thank you for the suggestion! I don't know for sure that I want to do it. It's interesting and I'd like to try it. I know that I love working obedience and would have loved to move on to something more with Stryker. If you had asked me 2 years ago I would have had no understanding of temperament and drives beyond the concept that I wanted a sound dog that wasn't going to attack people. When we got Stryker, he was everything we asked for "the goofy, loving dog, that runs into walls." [emoji13] he doesn't run into walls but as he was my first Doberman that I owned it was perfect. He was so easy to train and despite some mistakes I made raising him l, he has turned into a fantastic dog.

@oji: your dobie is beautiful!!! [emoji7] and doesn't look euro at all. His chest doesn't swoop down as much as Stryker's and he doesn't have as pronounced of an uptuck? But I wouldn't have guessed he was euro. As you mention Stryker doesn't have a perfectly straight back either, and you can see a slight arch to it when he stands. His back legs also wobble when he walks which has been a concern of mine. I don't know if that is a result of poor confirmation. If you don't mind, would you PM me the breeder. I'd love to look into it. I always do tons of research before I choose the right breeder for me and having multiple to research is a huge help!

And as requested here are my babies:

Our Rescue Layla:
8203e0843cea4a4e9dd4faaa17d7933e.jpg



Stryker:
0466d0302f7aaee8e2139af571d47a23.jpg


And our honorary dobie Gambit
127ee62002c09ceb1187f07f53c4d632.jpg


Sent from my iPhone using Doberman Chat


Sent from my iPhone using Doberman Chat
You have a Pharaoh Hound as well? Or is that in Ibithan Hound. I am not overly familiar.

Hey, I think Striker's conformation looks good! I am not bothered by that amount of roundness to the back, and it would be less if you had him stacked with his rear legs farther back.

Layla is also good looking! I say you're doing well in the looks department with your crew.
 
@oji: yes! He is a pharaoh hound [emoji16]. And true Stryker is a great looking dog, but after going to confirmation shows and seeing what a "perfect" or "near perfect" Doberman looks like I now see he isn't as "perfect" as I thought. I still think he is perfect regardless [emoji6]. Yes I got lucky with Layla. Only had her for about a year and a half and she really is a great dog!!! There's something about Dobermans I can't get enough of.

And I really want to take a minute and say thanks to everyone on this thread. I've been on some other forums in the past and they haven't been nice like the group of you here. It is much appreciated. I always get worried talking about breeders in an open forum since it can turn negative so quickly.

I have a lot of homework to do!!!!


Sent from my iPhone using Doberman Chat
 
Beautiful babies :) Stryker's back is secondary to his conformation and is the result of his hip angles being slightly off.

@Archer: thanks for that. I wonder if his hips is the cause for him to walk slightly bow legged too [emoji848]. His rear legs wobble slightly when he walks, one worse than the other. I've taken videos of it once I was so concerned he had a neurological issue to show to my vet.


Sent from my iPhone using Doberman Chat
 
@Archer: thanks for that. I wonder if his hips is the cause for him to walk slightly bow legged too [emoji848]. His rear legs wobble slightly when he walks, one worse than the other. I've taken videos of it once I was so concerned he had a neurological issue to show to my vet.


Sent from my iPhone using Doberman Chat
That sounds more like his hips, but hard to tell without seeing it. Have his hips been XRayed?
 

Back
Top