BASIC OR CORE VACCINES (Parvo, Distemper, Parainfluenza, Adenovirus, and Coronavirus): In a perfect world, all animals would be titer tested before CORE revaccination. The problem is cost - titer testing, depending on how many diseases you are titering for can be cost prohibitive. Even when just doing the "core vaccines" you are often looking at well in excess of $500. The efficacy of vaccines in dogs, as in humans, is in large part, predicated on the concept of herd immunity. As long as the majority are protected via vaccine, there is less disease around to affect those who CANNOT be vaccinated due to health, allergy or other conditions.
HERD IMMUNITY: this is the basis of all vaccination protocols. Assuming upwards of 70% of the population that can contract any virus has immunity, the remaining 30% have transferred immunity, essentially, as the virus cannot travel, replicate and infect efficiently as there are too few vectors (bodies) to spread the disease and become an epidemic. This basic principal is how we "eradicated" Polio...it is still out there, but the population was so extensively and for so long protected by vaccination induced immunity that it has basically been eradicated from all first and second world countries. Obviously herd immunity is not 100%, but it goes a long way in preventing deadly outbreaks and epidemics, resulting instead with "pockets" of disease outbreaks in areas of low herd immunity, that can usually be contained.
WHAT IS A VACCINE: this may be obvious to most, but very few actually fully understand what a vaccine is. In most cases vaccinations are manufactured from a portion of the actual virus, and could be from dead vaccines, modified live or live viral culture. Science takes a tiny portion of the actual virus cell, a portion that does not cause any negative reaction, and uses that to irritate the immune system, this ensures the body actually recognizes the virus, and begins to create antibodies against the virus. This is sort of like learning to ride a bike, once the skill is obtained, the memory remains, and even after 20yrs, you not only recognize a bike, but you can quickly remember how to ride it, and your skill level will, in minutes, return to that of 20 years ago. Vaccinations teach the body what viruses are dangerous, so that they can immediately mount a defense if any portion of the virus is ever detected, stopping it in its tracks before it takes root, and/or becomes acute. To be clear, you CANNOT contract the virus or disease FROM the vaccine - when this occurs it is because the virus was ALREADY in the animals system, and is strictly coincidental.
PUPPY VACCINATIONS: it is protocol to give three puppy vaccines, boostering every three to four weeks. Studies have shown that maternal antibodies begin to decline IN MOST DOGS (60+%) around 6-8 wks. But that is only most dogs - some maintain these antibodies longer, essentially making the initial vaccination(s) useless. This is why it is boostered every three to four weeks until 16 weeks when the majority (90+%) have lost all the maternal antibodies and maternally transferred immunity, allowing the vaccination(s) to do their job.
One may ask, then why not wait until 16 weeks, the problem is, babies, be they human or canine are far more susceptible to contraction of the diseases we commonly vaccinate for, and suffer far more serious complications from the contraction of the diseases than adult dogs. A pup with Parvo or Distemper is looking at an extremely expensive vet bill, that may or may not actually save the dogs life, and even if the dog recovers, there is always the issue of long term health issues associated with the contraction of each specific disease.
ANNUAL VACCINATIONS: These are, in most cases, a thing of the past. As mentioned by others, the new standards of once every three years after the triple puppy vaccinations (8, 12 and 16 wks) has proven safe and effective, and is the current recommendation. Thanks to titer testing, this timeline is continuing to be looked at and may well increase once actual "average immunity" is fully explored.
VACCINATION CONCERNS: The concerns regarding vaccine reaction (FYI a documented vaccine reaction must be reported to the vaccine manufacturer and in most cases means your dog will get the majority of it's vet needs paid by them for life!!) whether autoimmune, tumor or otherwise are extraordinarily rare. I only know one vet (out of dozens) who have dealt with the vaccine site tumor issue, it is very rare, and again, why vaccines are now given in the rear leg or tail rather than between the shoulder blades.
All medical procedures carry risk, but is the microscopic risk of autoimmune or tumor worth the very common contraction of parvo, distemper etc. worth it??? The core vaccines protect against the most commonly contracted and dangerous viruses.
For the maintenance of herd immunity (if 70% of the "herd" is vaccinated, the likely hood of an outbreak is drastically reduced), and the low cost versus rare chance of negative reaction, I believe for most folks vaccination every three years is safe, cost effective, and assuming there are no contraindications, the right thing to do.
If cost is no object then by all means, forgo the regular vaccinations every three years and titer annually, but if that is not an annual, financial option, go ahead and at least do your core vaccinations.
Rabies: unless you live on an island, in the middle of an ocean, with no wildlife or bats, this is potentially a risk.
The big issue with rabies is the lack of treatment, the ease of spread and the contraction or transmission to humans. This is NOT a disease that can be tested for confirmation of contraction or a disease that can be treated once contracted, for animals AND HUMANS, it is fatal, period. The only option is preventative vaccination or post-exposure vaccination. To be clear, there is absolutely no option of treatment, once the disease has been contracted, the only outcome is death.
So yes, there are regulations about rabies vaccinations, because the best defense is a strong herd immunity, this keeps outbreaks small, and they burn out quickly, meaning the unvaccinated humans are at minimal risk.
Bordatella (kennel cough): IMO this is a bit of a scam, as it is generally not overly effective, and commonly only valid for six months, but, most kennels, daycares etc. require it.
Leptospirosis: a common add-on that I would highly recommend if you own hunting dogs, or go out in the bush, have a high rodent population or have wildlife commonly visiting your property. In some breeds it is contra-indicated, and in most cases, in an urban environment the risk is minimal. This is one to research and determine your animals and your environments level of risk.
Monthly flea and tick treatments: this is something that is completely dependent on your area, your dogs likelihood of being off your property, and again the cost of treating the side effects of flea/tick infestation. What if your dog is allergic to fleas, or gets Tapeworm from ingesting a flea; are you in an area where tick borne diseases are common; your financial cost and treatment (curing the issue) risks/side effects may well be greater than the risk or cost of flea meds.
***FYI regular, blue, Dawn dishsoap kills fleas almost instantly, but do follow up with a conditioner as it will strip your dogs coat.
Heartworm Preventative: this can be another cash grab, or it can be a life and cost saving blessing. Again, this depends on where you live, the likely hood of contraction (I believe this is primarily mosquito borne, but we do not have it where I live - doesn't stop vets from recommending preventatives though!!), and the cost both physically and financially if contracted and treatment must be sought. It may also be something that could or should be used seasonally or when traveling where mosquito's are active and discontinued in the colder months when there are no mosquito's.
Beyond the "core vaccines" of Parvo, Distemper, Parainfluenza, Adenovirus, and Coronavirus all other vaccinations, flea, tick, heartworm etc. must be evaluated on a case by case basis, individually based on each animals health, risk factors, location, travel, environment, vector species, and general risk of contraction to determine if preventative action could, or should be taken. In a perfect world we would not need any of these, but depending on your dog, location, climate, local regs, and general risk factors all may be necessary or most may be a cash grab, a risk not worth taking, and money ill spent.
There is no "right" answer to the question of vaccinate or not, preventatives or not. Each owner, financial ability, animal, location and risk factors are different. Speak with your vet, local rescues (trust me, we don't waste money on treatments that are not worthwhile in our location), and honestly assess your dogs risk factors.
Be honest with yourself on the costs of treatment, financially, emotionally, and physically, whether pet insurance is an option, and if so, what are their requirements...in a perfect world, money would be no object, but we do not live in that world...at the end of the day, for most, vaccinations every three years are safe, cheap, and excellent insurance from physical and financial hardship.