Thoughts on neutering?

Was said as a question not a statement so I can’t answer that for you. Referring to the option of vasectomy because it keeps the Hormones rather then a neutering, who knows I’m sure there some people out there that might have had to get it done before the 18 months due to reasons.
Most people who do it earlier just don’t know any better because the usual spay/neuter age pushed by vets is 6 months.
 
Most people who do it earlier just don’t know any better because the usual spay/neuter age pushed by vets is 6 months.
Yeah aha I know with my cats they were always pushy about it (even tho they are indoor cats only) both my cats are spayed/neutered now but every vet I visited up until the time it happened were very pushy.
 
Was said as a question not a statement so I can’t answer that for you. Referring to the option of vasectomy because it keeps the Hormones rather then a neutering, who knows I’m sure there some people out there that might have had to get it done before the 18 months due to reasons.


I'm always curious why people think they need or have to alter their dog. It's like they think it's a law or something.
I currently have an intact pair, that's right, a male and female. :shock: People think I'm nuts but it's actually very doable. We've never had any puppies, not even close.
IMHO, I wouldn't consider altering a male before 3 and a female before 2 if at all.
People are under this misconception that altering will change behavior, but the reality is training changes behavior. Of course this limits breeders for me because reputable breeders have it in their contract that you must alter by a certain age.
One of the few reasons I would consider it is health. If there is a history of cancer in the pedigree, that might a deciding factor for me. Otherwise I think recent studies prove that leaving a dog intact is a much healthier option.
 
My best friend who is a vet tech keeps telling us we need to neuter now or before a year. We are only at 9.5 months and plan on waiting until at least 18 months if we can get away with it.

We lose our amazing dog walker soon to a job in Boston soon and are struggling to find a new one in our area. Right now doggy day cares aren't even an option, even though they stress me out, since he isn't neutered.

After reading this thread I think we will stick to our guns on waiting until he's at least 18 months!
 
I'm always curious why people think they need or have to alter their dog. It's like they think it's a law or something.
I currently have an intact pair, that's right, a male and female. :shock: People think I'm nuts but it's actually very doable. We've never had any puppies, not even close.
IMHO, I wouldn't consider altering a male before 3 and a female before 2 if at all.
People are under this misconception that altering will change behavior, but the reality is training changes behavior. Of course this limits breeders for me because reputable breeders have it in their contract that you must alter by a certain age.
One of the few reasons I would consider it is health. If there is a history of cancer in the pedigree, that might a deciding factor for me. Otherwise I think recent studies prove that leaving a dog intact is a much healthier option.
Language is indicative of priorities and values in a society. It's "hit by a car" not by a driver. It's "fixed" not altered.
 
I almost purchased breeding rights just so I can keep my guy intact for his health. However, price was kind of steep. Ill be neutering him as close to his 2yr birthday as possible. Vet told me to do it at 6mths because the recovery was worse for an older dog. I told her that my rescue was 2 when he was neutered and we worked through it just fine. Then she tried throwing the whole, "he will be less agressive if you do it early." Just a load of BS.
 
My vet knows what I do with dogs and my intentions with tank, he told me he wouldn't want to consider neutering him till at least a year so that he gets all his big boy hormones and builds those muscles.
 
I almost purchased breeding rights just so I can keep my guy intact for his health. However, price was kind of steep. Ill be neutering him as close to his 2yr birthday as possible. Vet told me to do it at 6mths because the recovery was worse for an older dog. I told her that my rescue was 2 when he was neutered and we worked through it just fine. Then she tried throwing the whole, "he will be less agressive if you do it early." Just a load of BS.
We have heard the aggressive piece too. We have seen no signs of this from our boy yet and from what I've gathered on her it doesn't seem that others have experienced it either ?

Where does that theory even come from?
 
I was told that since I have a household of females to have Ragnar neutered before 6months or he will become aggressive and start humping. I was warned multiple times- better get him neutered.....

I did not see anything of the such.

Glad I stuck with it and waited until 18months.
 
We have heard the aggressive piece too. We have seen no signs of this from our boy yet and from what I've gathered on her it doesn't seem that others have experienced it either ?

Where does that theory even come from?
I’ve mentioned a few times all the idiotic stuff I hear on the Doberman group on FB, and this is one of the main ones that gets tossed around a lot. People really do believe aggression/humping/marking is caused by testicles lol. Many of the people with multiple Dobermans of the same sex also attribute peace in the household (no same sex aggression) to the neutering. When hundreds of comments are saying the same thing, I guess it’s hard to believe otherwise.
 
I can tell you that all the Dobies I've had as a kid were intact, and stayed that way. And we had no issues with them, whatsoever.

I'm opposed to spaying/neutering without a specific and urgent medical need. I won't do it for "population control" reasons as is proffered by the "pro-spay/neuter" vets. And I won't patronize a vet that has a "spay/neuter for all" policy for any animal that comes through the door (think Animal Planet's "Dr. Jeff - Rocky Mountain Vet" show).

That said, I do understand that there may be some benefit to spay females you don't intend to breed for various hormonal reasons. It may help prevent (or retard) certain issues. But not until they're sufficiently mature, anatomically/physiologically.
 
I personally don't support fixing, but I understand sometimes it needs to be done (*Cough* backyard breeders and irresponsible owners *cough*)

Very informative video:
 
Rex is 10 months, but I’m waiting until 18-24 months for neuter. I have a breeders contract & want that full look to him. Also my best friend has an intact female who Rex is around all the time & we don’t want puppies!
My vet actually refuses to do before 18 months because the bones won’t fully develop.
 
My current breeder has in our contract that I must notify them before I choose to neuter, and that they reserve the right to collect semen prior to such procedure.

I do find working breeders far easier to deal with than confo. breeders. No offense to anyone, but it's like they're more common sense, down to earth people.
 

Back
Top