@
VonDoom - I clearly said in every post that having intact males, even in a home which is 100% different from a kennel situation, is not for the average pet owner. I've said countless times that you have to remove the fuel to remove the fire. Should you have dogs trained well enough that they will respond to your commands regardless of the situation? Absolutely. That is what training is supposed to be-not a maybe if my dog feels like obeying my command right now type of thing.
Yes breeders will advise you from their experience which is from a breeding kennel, not a home. They also desire to have absolutely zero male returns and there's nothing wrong with that. Breeders aren't full experts in dog behavior and training just like dog behavior experts aren't breeding experts. They know some about each other's business but being the best in the world in one area doesn't magically impart the full knowledge and experience it takes to be an expert in the other area.
The question was posed by an average pet owner seeking to get one Doberman to go with her otherwise social and well behaved dog. Energy, personality and age close to their existing dog are important for a happy home. I've seen many people pick a pup well suited to the family situation, flip them over and go for the second best suited pup because of gender.
I understand this is true for your situation because you are the leader and do all the same things every time your dog is involved. That doesn't make it true for everyone. How do you explain dog behavior experts and trainers who stop dog on dog aggression every day of the year and with every breed on earth including dobermans? There are thousands of people out there who do this but they are experts in behavior, training and can work specifically with all the causes of dog aggression. That level of skill doesn't happen overnight or with a few dogs in your home. You're a novice if you've only worked with dozens of dogs and approach expert after a few hundred. If these experts weren't successful in retraining the owners and then the dogs, this specialty of dog training and behavior wouldn't have grown as it has. If what they do is so impossible, why haven't they been profiled as frauds time after time?
If male Dobermans, pits, etc were all so impossible to control; they would all be banned at doggie daycare, dog walkers, dog parks, dog beaches, etc across the nation. That hasn't happened because dog behavior can be controlled. If Dobermans were so specifically bred for same sex aggression (which is impossible), they would have to be separated at birth or littermates would kill each other until it was down to a male and a female left.
If you can verbally correct your dog and they fully respond, they're fully trained. If you have to physically restrain or remove your dog because they ignore you, they aren't fully trained. That is one part of the problem.
Part 2 is you can't train aggression away per se, but you have to evaluate the dog's reasons for the particular aggression (owner weakness/fear is usually #1 if the animals are s/n) and work on those issues. Correct the things that allow the aggressions to spark and you remove the aggression. Dogs are social animals. They will correct other dogs if they aren't calm and confident because the pack normal state is calm and mellow. They don't like nervous, bouncing off the walls energy chaos. Neither do we, so we correct our kids when it happens just as dogs will correct other dogs.
It's why some people's dogs are repeatedly nipped/attacked. Their dog is the trigger. Remove the fuel and fix their nervous or super excited energy (or whatever else might be the cause) before introducing them to other dogs and you remove the problem. It's something owners who have repeated dog park problems find hard to accept because the other dog owner is legally responsible for the bills. What good is having the bill paid when you will do everything the same next time? Doing the same thing repeatedly but expecting a different outcome is the definition of insanity.
I thought I was an expert after working in shelters for a few years and saving a few hundred dogs from euthanasia through training. A few hundred dogs is a lot of dogs. 2 rescue groups also sought my expertise to help them set up training programs. I took 2 pits out of euthanasia who were impeccable in my home for a week or so. Took them out one night for quick pee in the yard on the lead because I just moved and hadn't had time to fix the fence yet. They started fighting and I had no clue what happened. I held onto the leads with one hand and clawed through snow with the other to open the dog kennel and dragged them inside. I staggered around the corner to get something to help me break them up and they went silent. I came back to look thinking to myself they can't both be dead... and they both looked at me like "where did you go?" Then they licked each others wounds.
I could easily have said pits are aggressive and fight like everyone says and built them separate cages for life or had them euthanized. I had to accept I was the cause/trigger of the fight because there was no intruder, no loud noise, nothing else in the yard but me and the dogs and they stopped fighting to moment I was gone. They were perfectly behaved before they got used to my routine/leadership, so I had to be the weak link. That was a really hard truth to accept.
Even with all the training work I'd done successfully; I didn't have the behavior expertise to see the signals that preceded that fight. For some stupid reason it was embarrassing asking trainers and behavior experts for help because many people called me a behavior and training expert. That was stupid ego. I would never have grown as a leader or trainer if I didn't seek help whenever I hit a stumbling block or if I didn't follow their suggestions no matter how small they were or if I thought it couldn't possibly work.