Second Dog

There are some members on here that have pulled it off, like Max Hawk and a couple others........However why would you risk it ? I know my breeder wouldn't of sold me a puppy if it was same sex so I can assume most reputable breeders would not unless they really, really knew you could pull it off.


Max Hawk comes instantly to mind too. Her two males live together beautifully and have done so for years. If I had a choice I would certainly chose a female.
 
I had a puppy person contact me wanting a female puppy when they also had a young female boxer. I told them I would only sell them a male puppy which wasn't available in this litter. They travelled to my home and visited the puppies and met Juno, nice people but bitches together can be worse than males. I think it depends on the temperament of the puppies as well as their new home and the dog experience the new owners have. If you can eliminate possible problems at the beginning it helps.
 
Correct me if I'm wrong Max is a stay at home dobe mama........ Not everyone has the luxury of staying home raising Dobermans, if there was a way I would do it, trust me........... What I mean in all this is, she has the patience, the time, the training required to pull this off. Her two aren't left alone for hours on end like mine, or most for that matter. Again I really wanted two males, I really, really did. I didn't want to have to worry about having an accidental liter, or having blood on my floor when that time came. But, again, I was told by so, so many people that it just wasn't going to happen. I then realized, Hmmmmmm must be a solid reason for this craziness. Then a friend of mine adopted another male dog in his home, not a Doberman, but big enough to worry about. His two males fight like mortal enemies. He has to seperate them in kennels when he's at work, and he tells me that it's very hard on him to not be able to trust them. He's gone thru 2 trainers that I know of and each of them said " Why did you get a second male " ?

But to those of you that have all day to spend with them, monitoring them, training them, and raising them correctly, I say try to pull it off for whatever the reasons bringing you to get two males. I could understand liter mates, I could understand helping another male dog out in a jamb, but wanting one, after all the negatives I hear, why the risk ? Still goes without saying " Where the hell are you going to find a breeder willing to listen to your reasoning " ?
 
Who are these experts you claim to quote? You have zero experience in male Dobermans with other males in a home setting (not in a breeding kennel and not with unaltered dogs)but you will fight to the death over it. I have had this situation in my home since before I even went to kindergarten. You fight with you assume... and every expert... but you have absolutely zero experience. My experience isn't just in my home but with hundreds of adopters I've worked with and I've only worked with the ones who needed training help.

Again, if the deadly male Doberman were the apocalyptic creature you claim all these nebulous experts agree on, why are there no male Doberman bans at doggie daycare, dog walkers, dog parks, dog beaches, apartments, condos, etc? Why are there no bans if the male Doberman is so uncontrollable with any other males?

Millions of people have male Dobermans with other males but you imply 2 or 3 people can pull this miracle off. Millions of people do it without effort or issue. Just basic training and confident leadership.

"...same-sex pairs can do just fine with supervision and common sense on the part of the owner." from New England Doberman rescue.

"A dog aggressive female will follow through on her threat with less display and more sincerity than many male dogs." - same group and exactly how I described the female Doberman we got that successfully and eventually inseparably got along with our male Doberman Max.

You fight over this like average adopters fight that females are more better with families. Some are and some aren't. The females that aren't give less warning and follow through on their posturing far quicker than males do. I've seen people bit by their own female dog brush it off because they firmly believe females are more gentle. They won't give up that belief even when they needed stitches because all the experts told them so...

You can start trying to find an expert to quote but compare apples with apples. Don't bring in quotes pertaining to breeding kennels or unaltered males in the home. if you want to advise people on something you have zero experience in, at least do some research and find info on neutered males in a home setting first.

Here's an average video of 2 males Dobermans meeting for the first time. Average slight posturing easing into play. Decent redirection by the owner when they seem to get too excited.
View: http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=EYSseVFJN5Q
There are numerous other videos showing the same thing-average dog owners with male Doberman and other males. No panic, no cages, no one needs to be physically restrained because they are reasonably trained. Not even perfectly trained but reasonably trained. They posture a bit and greet, then move into play. This IS the norm for neutered males Dobermans in homes with confident leaders and decent training.

I completely understand that the last things breeders want back in their kennels are males they will not breed. Good breeders care about the dogs they produce but it is a business and multiple males around breeding females and intact males is difficult. Neutered males in a home setting when properly trained and exercised are a complete non-issue.
 
Who are these experts you claim to quote? You have zero experience in male Dobermans with other males in a home setting (not in a breeding kennel and not with unaltered dogs)but you will fight to the death over it. I have had this situation in my home since before I even went to kindergarten. You fight with you assume... and every expert... but you have absolutely zero experience. My experience isn't just in my home but with hundreds of adopters I've worked with and I've only worked with the ones who needed training help.

Again, if the deadly male Doberman were the apocalyptic creature you claim all these nebulous experts agree on, why are there no male Doberman bans at doggie daycare, dog walkers, dog parks, dog beaches, apartments, condos, etc? Why are there no bans if the male Doberman is so uncontrollable with any other males?

Millions of people have male Dobermans with other males but you imply 2 or 3 people can pull this miracle off. Millions of people do it without effort or issue. Just basic training and confident leadership.

"...same-sex pairs can do just fine with supervision and common sense on the part of the owner." from New England Doberman rescue.

"A dog aggressive female will follow through on her threat with less display and more sincerity than many male dogs." - same group and exactly how I described the female Doberman we got that successfully and eventually inseparably got along with our male Doberman Max.

You fight over this like average adopters fight that females are more better with families. Some are and some aren't. The females that aren't give less warning and follow through on their posturing far quicker than males do. I've seen people bit by their own female dog brush it off because they firmly believe females are more gentle. They won't give up that belief even when they needed stitches because all the experts told them so...

You can start trying to find an expert to quote but compare apples with apples. Don't bring in quotes pertaining to breeding kennels or unaltered males in the home. if you want to advise people on something you have zero experience in, at least do some research and find info on neutered males in a home setting first.

Here's an average video of 2 males Dobermans meeting for the first time. Average slight posturing easing into play. Decent redirection by the owner when they seem to get too excited.
View: http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=EYSseVFJN5Q
There are numerous other videos showing the same thing-average dog owners with male Doberman and other males. No panic, no cages, no one needs to be physically restrained because they are reasonably trained. Not even perfectly trained but reasonably trained. They posture a bit and greet, then move into play. This IS the norm for neutered males Dobermans in homes with confident leaders and decent training.

I completely understand that the last things breeders want back in their kennels are males they will not breed. Good breeders care about the dogs they produce but it is a business and multiple males around breeding females and intact males is difficult. Neutered males in a home setting when properly trained and exercised are a complete non-issue.
Edited myself,for the purpose of self preservation on DCF.:)
 
I remember having conversations like this on another Doberman Site. The reason I moved to this site is the respectful tact that came into play when people posted threads. No one lashed out here, but yet here's a member that's had Doberman's her entire life, and just now is coming on to this site, seems a tad strange. Members on here try to prove their point in a respectful way, not irritate long standing members who enjoy coming here to help.

Assuming only by your one picture you've posted you don't own a lawn mower so I won't start a " Here's how to cut the grass " thread and argue with you. Being your lab is a bit on the heavy side, I won't start to educate you on proper diets for dogs, and last but not least your yard needs to be a bit bigger for the fact Dobermans need plenty of room to run and get the proper exercise, just sayin...........but being an expert you probably already knew that......right ?

I have an idea to make your voice heard on male on male homes. Adopt 10 male in-tact Dobermans and youtube your experiences, document every instance, every fight, every kiss of affection for a year. Tell us how many arguments they've had, then tell us your an expert and can viably argue your point on why this member should get another male for his/her home.

Until then, I will stand firmly by saying " I'm no expert but my opinions and experiences count for something ". We've all been able to voice our opinions and I'm sure the feedback has been informative, but confusing in the last few columns for this original poster. Hopefully Malania is able to make his/her own assumptions on whether to get another male.
 
I don't wish to turn this into a harsh thread either. I hope that we can continue to give our opinions and experiences in a polite manner like we have. :) :ty:
Honestly, I am surprised and don't understand people arguing so hard based on something they have never experienced.
There are many facets of life were actually personal experience is not always needed to form an opinion. For me, it's usually when someone I trust gives me information on something I know little about, I listen. I may go around and ask questions of other people I trust too and if they each say the same thing, I may follow that advice. If, after much research, I find I still would like to try and experience it myself (whatever it is) I at least go in being armed with some information and the experiences of others.

I agree that if I haven't personally experienced something maybe I shouldn't even be commenting on it. But that's all I was doing....commenting. Giving my opinion. And I said that in my post. It's just MHO. It's not experience. It's not the law. It's nothing except what I have heard ( a LOT!). I wasn't "arguing so hard'', against it. I actually think there are times it can be done! There might be some males that get along beautifully. There might be people who are experienced trainers who know how to make it work. Experienced breeders and show people, who know how to make it work. But then there's the average Joe, who doesn't. And I think there are more 'average Joes'' in the world then trainers, breeders and show people. :)

And I think if you have to ask, then you may fall into the 'average Joe' and should at the very least be warned that it doesn't always work. That sometimes you end up with a problem you didn't foresee and now you have a lifetime of crate and rotate. That is something I, the average Joe, would not like to end up with. Even with not experiencing it. I've heard enough about it not working that I choose not to do it. I'm just not that set on having two males.

I have to agree with Stephen here. Some temperaments make it work out, but for so many experienced breeders to not recommend it, I would leave owning same sex of the doberman breed to the experienced or dedicated only. Things don't always work out that way but if you have the choice (and me knowing no background on the experience of the prospective owner) I will always recommend to avoid the possibility of having to live a life of crate and rotate.


If you have your heart set on two males, go for it......but train, train and train, then be ready to break up fights and battles as their hormones rage as it's recommended to keep them in tact for 24 months. Again, why risk it ?
Both posts are my thoughts exactly. First off, when a good breeder recommends something to me, I listen. Again, I may still ask around, not taking one person's opinion as word, but I think a breeder telling me something should be thought long and hard about. Why would they say that? Why would't they just sell me ANYthing? Why would they care as long as money has changed hands? Because they care about their puppers! lol And obviously they have seen more than the average Joe and know the average Joe might, might not be able to handle the possible special needs of same sex dogs.

So, like Stephen says, go for it, if it's what you want. Just be ready and informed.
 
I don't wish to turn this into a harsh thread either. I hope that we can continue to give our opinions and experiences in a polite manner like we have. :) :ty:

There are many facets of life were actually personal experience is not always needed to form an opinion. For me, it's usually when someone I trust gives me information on something I know little about, I listen. I may go around and ask questions of other people I trust too and if they each say the same thing, I may follow that advice. If, after much research, I find I still would like to try and experience it myself (whatever it is) I at least go in being armed with some information and the experiences of others.

I agree that if I haven't personally experienced something maybe I shouldn't even be commenting on it. But that's all I was doing....commenting. Giving my opinion. And I said that in my post. It's just MHO. It's not experience. It's not the law. It's nothing except what I have heard ( a LOT!). I wasn't "arguing so hard'', against it. I actually think there are times it can be done! There might be some males that get along beautifully. There might be people who are experienced trainers who know how to make it work. Experienced breeders and show people, who know how to make it work. But then there's the average Joe, who doesn't. And I think there are more 'average Joes'' in the world then trainers, breeders and show people. :)

And I think if you have to ask, then you may fall into the 'average Joe' and should at the very least be warned that it doesn't always work. That sometimes you end up with a problem you didn't foresee and now you have a lifetime of crate and rotate. That is something I, the average Joe, would not like to end up with. Even with not experiencing it. I've heard enough about it not working that I choose not to do it. I'm just not that set on having two males.





Both posts are my thoughts exactly. First off, when a good breeder recommends something to me, I listen. Again, I may still ask around, not taking one person's opinion as word, but I think a breeder telling me something should be thought long and hard about. Why would they say that? Why would't they just sell me ANYthing? Why would they care as long as money has changed hands? Because they care about their puppers! lol And obviously they have seen more than the average Joe and know the average Joe might, might not be able to handle the possible special needs of same sex dogs.

So, like Stephen says, go for it, if it's what you want. Just be ready and informed.



With all this said I'm sure this thread has run it's course before it get's anymore out of hand. I do apologize for being a tad too harsh, but just wanted to point out the information I've had in my experiences. It seems to be the trend that males and males aren't purposely placed together without the proper supervision and experiences. Again It can be done, has been done, etc, but at what costs ?
 
Now the 2 males I have are lab and Doberman but I've had mostly males including multiple Dobermans and pits at the same time. You say you won't assume, then state "all the experts..."
So are you recommending that the OP get two intact males and simply train the aggression away? If so that doesntr seem practical.. Awesome that you have pulled this off but its fair to say not everyone is Cesar Millan or Victoria Stilwell.. Giving advice on a forum that invites a dangerous situation for the OP or their family is not only irresponsible but potentially extremely dangerous.. In these situations that we do not have all the fact its important to exercise caution..
 
So are you recommending that the OP get two intact males and simply train the aggression away? If so that doesntr seem practical.. Awesome that you have pulled this off but its fair to say not everyone is Cesar Millan or Victoria Stilwell.. Giving advice on a forum that invites a dangerous situation for the OP or their family is not only irresponsible but potentially extremely dangerous.. In these situations that we do not have all the fact its important to exercise caution..
Precisely! When we went to get our second Dobe I talked to a lot of experienced Dobe folks, my breeder of choice, and Schutzhund folks on what to do. The sport folks all talked about how males were their preference for training but they and all the other experienced Dobe folks warned me of the same-sex aggression. I've also personally seen this exhibited in the male we already had. Because of the advice I had received I decided that it was not worth it to me to even take that risk. What folks don't realize is that most of the time once that line has been crossed and a fight has occurred you cannot repair that relationship to what it was. There will always be a higher risk of a fight than before. And yes that is my personal experience. As I mentioned, our male has shown some same-sex aggression. Back when we used to frequent dog parks he had one incident with a male and after that any time that male came around Spock would start posturing. Thankfully that is as far as it ever got since we know how to read our dogs and removed him from the situation before he could do more. That means if it happens in your home the only thing you can do is prevent them from being together again by either crating and rotating for the rest of their lives or rehoming one. Neither of those seemed worth it to me so we went for an opposite sex pair instead. Any two dogs can piss each other off but it is a known fact that Dobes have a tendency towards same sex aggression so why take that chance if you don't have to?
 
@VonDoom - I clearly said in every post that having intact males, even in a home which is 100% different from a kennel situation, is not for the average pet owner. I've said countless times that you have to remove the fuel to remove the fire. Should you have dogs trained well enough that they will respond to your commands regardless of the situation? Absolutely. That is what training is supposed to be-not a maybe if my dog feels like obeying my command right now type of thing.

Yes breeders will advise you from their experience which is from a breeding kennel, not a home. They also desire to have absolutely zero male returns and there's nothing wrong with that. Breeders aren't full experts in dog behavior and training just like dog behavior experts aren't breeding experts. They know some about each other's business but being the best in the world in one area doesn't magically impart the full knowledge and experience it takes to be an expert in the other area.

The question was posed by an average pet owner seeking to get one Doberman to go with her otherwise social and well behaved dog. Energy, personality and age close to their existing dog are important for a happy home. I've seen many people pick a pup well suited to the family situation, flip them over and go for the second best suited pup because of gender.


What folks don't realize is that most of the time once that line has been crossed and a fight has occurred you cannot repair that relationship to what it was. There will always be a higher risk of a fight than before.

I understand this is true for your situation because you are the leader and do all the same things every time your dog is involved. That doesn't make it true for everyone. How do you explain dog behavior experts and trainers who stop dog on dog aggression every day of the year and with every breed on earth including dobermans? There are thousands of people out there who do this but they are experts in behavior, training and can work specifically with all the causes of dog aggression. That level of skill doesn't happen overnight or with a few dogs in your home. You're a novice if you've only worked with dozens of dogs and approach expert after a few hundred. If these experts weren't successful in retraining the owners and then the dogs, this specialty of dog training and behavior wouldn't have grown as it has. If what they do is so impossible, why haven't they been profiled as frauds time after time?

If male Dobermans, pits, etc were all so impossible to control; they would all be banned at doggie daycare, dog walkers, dog parks, dog beaches, etc across the nation. That hasn't happened because dog behavior can be controlled. If Dobermans were so specifically bred for same sex aggression (which is impossible), they would have to be separated at birth or littermates would kill each other until it was down to a male and a female left.

If you can verbally correct your dog and they fully respond, they're fully trained. If you have to physically restrain or remove your dog because they ignore you, they aren't fully trained. That is one part of the problem.

Part 2 is you can't train aggression away per se, but you have to evaluate the dog's reasons for the particular aggression (owner weakness/fear is usually #1 if the animals are s/n) and work on those issues. Correct the things that allow the aggressions to spark and you remove the aggression. Dogs are social animals. They will correct other dogs if they aren't calm and confident because the pack normal state is calm and mellow. They don't like nervous, bouncing off the walls energy chaos. Neither do we, so we correct our kids when it happens just as dogs will correct other dogs.

It's why some people's dogs are repeatedly nipped/attacked. Their dog is the trigger. Remove the fuel and fix their nervous or super excited energy (or whatever else might be the cause) before introducing them to other dogs and you remove the problem. It's something owners who have repeated dog park problems find hard to accept because the other dog owner is legally responsible for the bills. What good is having the bill paid when you will do everything the same next time? Doing the same thing repeatedly but expecting a different outcome is the definition of insanity.

I thought I was an expert after working in shelters for a few years and saving a few hundred dogs from euthanasia through training. A few hundred dogs is a lot of dogs. 2 rescue groups also sought my expertise to help them set up training programs. I took 2 pits out of euthanasia who were impeccable in my home for a week or so. Took them out one night for quick pee in the yard on the lead because I just moved and hadn't had time to fix the fence yet. They started fighting and I had no clue what happened. I held onto the leads with one hand and clawed through snow with the other to open the dog kennel and dragged them inside. I staggered around the corner to get something to help me break them up and they went silent. I came back to look thinking to myself they can't both be dead... and they both looked at me like "where did you go?" Then they licked each others wounds.

I could easily have said pits are aggressive and fight like everyone says and built them separate cages for life or had them euthanized. I had to accept I was the cause/trigger of the fight because there was no intruder, no loud noise, nothing else in the yard but me and the dogs and they stopped fighting to moment I was gone. They were perfectly behaved before they got used to my routine/leadership, so I had to be the weak link. That was a really hard truth to accept.

Even with all the training work I'd done successfully; I didn't have the behavior expertise to see the signals that preceded that fight. For some stupid reason it was embarrassing asking trainers and behavior experts for help because many people called me a behavior and training expert. That was stupid ego. I would never have grown as a leader or trainer if I didn't seek help whenever I hit a stumbling block or if I didn't follow their suggestions no matter how small they were or if I thought it couldn't possibly work.
 
I understand this is true for your situation because you are the leader and do all the same things every time your dog is involved. That doesn't make it true for everyone. How do you explain dog behavior experts and trainers who stop dog on dog aggression every day of the year and with every breed on earth including dobermans? There are thousands of people out there who do this but they are experts in behavior, training and can work specifically with all the causes of dog aggression. That level of skill doesn't happen overnight or with a few dogs in your home. You're a novice if you've only worked with dozens of dogs and approach expert after a few hundred. If these experts weren't successful in retraining the owners and then the dogs, this specialty of dog training and behavior wouldn't have grown as it has. If what they do is so impossible, why haven't they been profiled as frauds time after time?
You are actually proving my point here. You are speaking of experts and yet giving this advice to someone that you know nothing about. This person could be a great dog handler with natural ability to read dogs. But it is far more likely that they are the average pet owner who cannot read their dog and would not know how to stop a fight or prevent one. THAT alone is why we are all warning them about same-sex aggression. I would actually argue that the dog behavior experts aren't actually training the aggression out but rather teaching coping and prevention methods.

If male Dobermans, pits, etc were all so impossible to control; they would all be banned at doggie daycare, dog walkers, dog parks, dog beaches, etc across the nation. That hasn't happened because dog behavior can be controlled. If Dobermans were so specifically bred for same sex aggression (which is impossible), they would have to be separated at birth or littermates would kill each other until it was down to a male and a female left.
Like I stated in the other thread, no one else is talking in generalities. However, like it or not Dobes are prone to same-sex aggression. Sorry but that is the truth. And that is same-sex meaning males to males AND females to females. Also, these aggression issues typically don't crop up until the dogs reach sexual maturity so typically no earlier than about 9 months but far more likely around 2 or 3 years old. That is why littermates don't turn on each other. They have no reason to do so.

If you can verbally correct your dog and they fully respond, they're fully trained. If you have to physically restrain or remove your dog because they ignore you, they aren't fully trained. That is one part of the problem.
I disagree on this one, too. Some dogs get so focused and so in the "red zone" that no matter how loud you yell you cannot break their focus. That is not a sign of a lack of training but rather situational.

Part 2 is you can't train aggression away per se, but you have to evaluate the dog's reasons for the particular aggression (owner weakness/fear is usually #1 if the animals are s/n) and work on those issues. Correct the things that allow the aggressions to spark and you remove the aggression.
Absolutely, but this doesn't justify telling a new owner this is a safe situation. When these situations occur it is often that they only way to prevent the reasons for aggression are to separate the dogs permanently. Really, what life is it to crate and rotate for the next 10+ years? Why suggest taking that risk? Because in these situations, it is often the presence of the other dog alone is the trigger or it can be a resource guarding issue over something like the owner themselves where the dogs can never be together around each other and the owner.
 
@VonDoom - I clearly said in every post that having intact males, even in a home which is 100% different from a kennel situation, is not for the average pet owner. I've said countless times that you have to remove the fuel to remove the fire. Should you have dogs trained well enough that they will respond to your commands regardless of the situation? Absolutely. That is what training is supposed to be-not a maybe if my dog feels like obeying my command right now type of thing.

Yes breeders will advise you from their experience which is from a breeding kennel, not a home. They also desire to have absolutely zero male returns and there's nothing wrong with that. Breeders aren't full experts in dog behavior and training just like dog behavior experts aren't breeding experts. They know some about each other's business but being the best in the world in one area doesn't magically impart the full knowledge and experience it takes to be an expert in the other area.

The question was posed by an average pet owner seeking to get one Doberman to go with her otherwise social and well behaved dog. Energy, personality and age close to their existing dog are important for a happy home. I've seen many people pick a pup well suited to the family situation, flip them over and go for the second best suited pup because of gender.




I understand this is true for your situation because you are the leader and do all the same things every time your dog is involved. That doesn't make it true for everyone. How do you explain dog behavior experts and trainers who stop dog on dog aggression every day of the year and with every breed on earth including dobermans? There are thousands of people out there who do this but they are experts in behavior, training and can work specifically with all the causes of dog aggression. That level of skill doesn't happen overnight or with a few dogs in your home. You're a novice if you've only worked with dozens of dogs and approach expert after a few hundred. If these experts weren't successful in retraining the owners and then the dogs, this specialty of dog training and behavior wouldn't have grown as it has. If what they do is so impossible, why haven't they been profiled as frauds time after time?

If male Dobermans, pits, etc were all so impossible to control; they would all be banned at doggie daycare, dog walkers, dog parks, dog beaches, etc across the nation. That hasn't happened because dog behavior can be controlled. If Dobermans were so specifically bred for same sex aggression (which is impossible), they would have to be separated at birth or littermates would kill each other until it was down to a male and a female left.

If you can verbally correct your dog and they fully respond, they're fully trained. If you have to physically restrain or remove your dog because they ignore you, they aren't fully trained. That is one part of the problem.

Part 2 is you can't train aggression away per se, but you have to evaluate the dog's reasons for the particular aggression (owner weakness/fear is usually #1 if the animals are s/n) and work on those issues. Correct the things that allow the aggressions to spark and you remove the aggression. Dogs are social animals. They will correct other dogs if they aren't calm and confident because the pack normal state is calm and mellow. They don't like nervous, bouncing off the walls energy chaos. Neither do we, so we correct our kids when it happens just as dogs will correct other dogs.

It's why some people's dogs are repeatedly nipped/attacked. Their dog is the trigger. Remove the fuel and fix their nervous or super excited energy (or whatever else might be the cause) before introducing them to other dogs and you remove the problem. It's something owners who have repeated dog park problems find hard to accept because the other dog owner is legally responsible for the bills. What good is having the bill paid when you will do everything the same next time? Doing the same thing repeatedly but expecting a different outcome is the definition of insanity.

I thought I was an expert after working in shelters for a few years and saving a few hundred dogs from euthanasia through training. A few hundred dogs is a lot of dogs. 2 rescue groups also sought my expertise to help them set up training programs. I took 2 pits out of euthanasia who were impeccable in my home for a week or so. Took them out one night for quick pee in the yard on the lead because I just moved and hadn't had time to fix the fence yet. They started fighting and I had no clue what happened. I held onto the leads with one hand and clawed through snow with the other to open the dog kennel and dragged them inside. I staggered around the corner to get something to help me break them up and they went silent. I came back to look thinking to myself they can't both be dead... and they both looked at me like "where did you go?" Then they licked each others wounds.

I could easily have said pits are aggressive and fight like everyone says and built them separate cages for life or had them euthanized. I had to accept I was the cause/trigger of the fight because there was no intruder, no loud noise, nothing else in the yard but me and the dogs and they stopped fighting to moment I was gone. They were perfectly behaved before they got used to my routine/leadership, so I had to be the weak link. That was a really hard truth to accept.

Even with all the training work I'd done successfully; I didn't have the behavior expertise to see the signals that preceded that fight. For some stupid reason it was embarrassing asking trainers and behavior experts for help because many people called me a behavior and training expert. That was stupid ego. I would never have grown as a leader or trainer if I didn't seek help whenever I hit a stumbling block or if I didn't follow their suggestions no matter how small they were or if I thought it couldn't possibly work.
Im not argueing for or against your point.. Frankly i agree with you to a point.. Ive seen some pretty amazing people work Magic on dogs, i firmly believe under the proper leadership and guidance same sex aggression can be curbed.. My point is/these people are one in a million.. So i don't believe for even a second its something the average owner should even bother to attempt..

I frankly gave up on getting my bitches to get along not because i thought it was impossible but because it wasnt worth the risk to their health to me.. At some point one of those fights was going to cause serious injury and if it happened to be an off week and i didnt have the money for the Vet i would have been S.O.L.. At the end of the day i just decided it wasnt worth it to me..
 
You create the outcome with every dog your bring into your home, regardless of their age, background, temperament, breeding lines or sex. You love them, exercise them and instill discipline and training. The calm, well disciplined and adjusted dogs live together, walk down the street or go to the dog park without other dogs going crazy, barking/fencing or having fights begin.

I'm sorry -- and please don't take this as an attack or anything -- but that is complete bull. Bring home a neurologically challenged Chihuahua and turn it into a healthy, happy, well adjusted member of your pack. Get a severely DA pitbull to be friends with multiple other dogs in your household, and don't forget the rotating fosters. Rehabilitate an intensely HA AmBull or GSD. Make an undersocialized puppy mill mutt be not afraid of its own shadow.Curb a working line, unstable border collie's obsession with BALL. Once you've done these things, then talk to me and tell me you create the outcome no matter what. And while you're at it, give me your credentials so I can look you up, verify your info, and pass your name onto people in your area who might need help.

You also keep saying that it's impossible to breed for behavior. Please, please explain to me the Russian fox experiment if this is true. Or why retrievers retrieve but sighthounds don't. Why certain lines of pitbulls are incredibly DA. Why the hardcore military working dogs are often HA. Why the Guide Dogs for the Blind line of Labrador that they have bred exclusively for the past more than fifty years is about 70% likely to make it through training whereas the donated dogs of the same breed are less than 30%. Explain it to me. I am not being sarcastic or rude; my mind is open.

Another thing I'd like to address is your statement that if Dobes were SSA, we'd see them being banned. Well, the fact is, they are banned in many places. There are many, many places that include them on their BSL lists, and most insurances won't insure them. I have yet to find a doggie daycare in my area that will take them, and in the place that I used to live, which was a much larger city, at least half of them wouldn't take Dobes or pits. I couldn't find a dog walker for Soren, whereas I had people practically lining up around the block to walk my lab Drake. I've had trouble with some groomers in the past, as well. Perhaps it's not as prevalent in your area or maybe you're just not looking in the right spots, but I guarantee you it is there. Dobes are banned in a lot of places.


To the OP, I will second (third? fourth? fifteenth?) the advice to not get a male. In addition to some Dobes being same sex aggressive, you need to consider the breed you already have. While my experience has primarily been with the Giant Schnauzer, their smaller constituents are often likely to display the same characteristics as them -- one of which is, you guessed it, same sex aggression. I don't know how prevalent it is in the minis, but I do know it is there. That would be enough for me to not want to bring in another male without good reason.

However, if you are absolutely convinced that you want a male, I would advise you to not get a puppy. Instead, get an older dog, around the 3 year mark. You should also be prepared to do a trial period, during which you would give your current dog time to get to know the new guy and vice versa. While this won't absolutely guarantee that there won't be problems in the future, it would give you a good idea. But you should definitely have a trainer who is experienced with aggression on call, as well as the number of a veterinary behaviorist should things come to that (I would be happy to refer you to one in your area). Remember that even if you think they're getting along great to never leave them alone unsupervised, even for a few minutes. That's all it takes for the unthinkable to happen, and while we would hope that it never would, I cannot imagine a worse feeling than knowing you could have prevent your precious one from getting hurt or killed.
 
So are you recommending that the OP get two intact males and simply train the aggression away? If so that doesntr seem practical.. Awesome that you have pulled this off but its fair to say not everyone is Cesar Millan or Victoria Stilwell.. Giving advice on a forum that invites a dangerous situation for the OP or their family is not only irresponsible but potentially extremely dangerous.. In these situations that we do not have all the fact its important to exercise caution..

Im not argueing for or against your point.. Frankly i agree with you to a point.. Ive seen some pretty amazing people work Magic on dogs, i firmly believe under the proper leadership and guidance same sex aggression can be curbed.. My point is/these people are one in a million.. So i don't believe for even a second its something the average owner should even bother to attempt..

Exactly!

Dayham! You said in a couple of paragraphs, what I was trying to make a point on in three pages! LOL! ;)
 
I'm sorry -- and please don't take this as an attack or anything -- but that is complete bull. Bring home a neurologically challenged Chihuahua and turn it into a healthy, happy, well adjusted member of your pack. Get a severely DA pitbull to be friends with multiple other dogs in your household, and don't forget the rotating fosters. Rehabilitate an intensely HA AmBull or GSD. Make an undersocialized puppy mill mutt be not afraid of its own shadow.Curb a working line, unstable border collie's obsession with BALL. Once you've done these things, then talk to me and tell me you create the outcome no matter what. And while you're at it, give me your credentials so I can look you up, verify your info, and pass your name onto people in your area who might need help.

You also keep saying that it's impossible to breed for behavior. Please, please explain to me the Russian fox experiment if this is true. Or why retrievers retrieve but sighthounds don't. Why certain lines of pitbulls are incredibly DA. Why the hardcore military working dogs are often HA. Why the Guide Dogs for the Blind line of Labrador that they have bred exclusively for the past more than fifty years is about 70% likely to make it through training whereas the donated dogs of the same breed are less than 30%. Explain it to me. I am not being sarcastic or rude; my mind is open.

Another thing I'd like to address is your statement that if Dobes were SSA, we'd see them being banned. Well, the fact is, they are banned in many places. There are many, many places that include them on their BSL lists, and most insurances won't insure them. I have yet to find a doggie daycare in my area that will take them, and in the place that I used to live, which was a much larger city, at least half of them wouldn't take Dobes or pits. I couldn't find a dog walker for Soren, whereas I had people practically lining up around the block to walk my lab Drake. I've had trouble with some groomers in the past, as well. Perhaps it's not as prevalent in your area or maybe you're just not looking in the right spots, but I guarantee you it is there. Dobes are banned in a lot of places.


To the OP, I will second (third? fourth? fifteenth?) the advice to not get a male. In addition to some Dobes being same sex aggressive, you need to consider the breed you already have. While my experience has primarily been with the Giant Schnauzer, their smaller constituents are often likely to display the same characteristics as them -- one of which is, you guessed it, same sex aggression. I don't know how prevalent it is in the minis, but I do know it is there. That would be enough for me to not want to bring in another male without good reason.

However, if you are absolutely convinced that you want a male, I would advise you to not get a puppy. Instead, get an older dog, around the 3 year mark. You should also be prepared to do a trial period, during which you would give your current dog time to get to know the new guy and vice versa. While this won't absolutely guarantee that there won't be problems in the future, it would give you a good idea. But you should definitely have a trainer who is experienced with aggression on call, as well as the number of a veterinary behaviorist should things come to that (I would be happy to refer you to one in your area). Remember that even if you think they're getting along great to never leave them alone unsupervised, even for a few minutes. That's all it takes for the unthinkable to happen, and while we would hope that it never would, I cannot imagine a worse feeling than knowing you could have prevent your precious one from getting hurt or killed.



Perfectly stated.
 

Back
Top