• Disclaimer: Hello Guest, Doberman Chat Forums presents the opinions and material on these pages as a service to its membership and to the general public but does not endorse those materials, nor does it guarantee the accuracy of any opinions or information contained therein. The opinions expressed in the materials are strictly the opinion of the writer and do not represent the opinion of, nor are they endorsed by, Doberman Chat Forums. Health and medical articles are intended as an aid to those seeking health information and are not intended to replace the informed opinion of a qualified Veterinarian.”

Resource guarding owner

I read your post yesterday. The whole time I was thinking, yes! I am no expert. I usually go by my experience, what I've learned. And my gut. And my gut is telling me that no way, No how, would I allow a dog to growl at my family. :tap: I know sometimes people think it's cute or they think it's being protective. But that's an issue that could get out of hand real fast. If my dog growled at my husband, I would never put up with that. And God forbid he growled at one of my children! There would be hell to pay.

Now, I really haven't been in a situation like that to actually tell you what I did. Or what I would do. But that may well be because my demeanor or Pack Leader? never had a dog go beyond that. Reacting like you did sounds almost abusive, but in reality, it may be the right thing to do. It may sound harsh. But you know? It's very similar to letting your children get away with murder and then you wonder why they are the way they are. If you nip something in the bud immediately and set the standard or rules, you won't have a bigger problem down the road.

Now, I wish I was six foot two, 200 lb. and can take my dog to the ground. I don't think I can. LOL. But I get the idea. And I believe in a certain situation, it may be correct. Not everyone will agree with that. I think it's the old adage of having the punishment fit the crime. If you can nip it in the butt right away, you may not have to throw the dog to the ground. And of course, it depends on the temperament of your dog. Buddy has never shown this kind of behavior at all. My first Doberman had much more prey drive and even in a play situation, we would always say he would protect me. He could be very aggressive, but very much under control. (mine) I never had to worry about him growling at somebody else.

You know this kind of reminds me of the Dog Whisperer episode with that little Chihuahua sitting on his mom's lap and barking and nipping at her son! When I watched that I was appalled! Why would she allow that? All it would take was a little bit of Correction on her part to show their dog that this is not allowed! But she just sat there and let the dog do it. Wow.

And here's another thing. I have a friend with a Labrador. One day when I was there, my movements were just too much for the dog, I guess. She jumped up and grabbed my ponytail! :shock: I was aghast! Really? And you allow that? ? They just shrugged and said, she does that and we don't know what to do about it. Um, How about correcting her? I wanted to smack her. The owner, not the dog, LOL.
You don't have to be 6'2" 200+ pounds, believe me; but I get what you're saying. I think about what if I had a 160 lb. South African Boerboel with a neck nearly as thick as my thigh? Probably no "alpha roll" gonna' happen there. Same for when I get to be elderly. So, ideally, there should be a far less physical way to handle this problem. Like you said, though, hopefully it wouldn't become a problem in the first place with good training. My boy, I believe, simply had a problem.
 
Reacting like you did sounds almost abusive, but in reality, it may be the right thing to do. It may sound harsh. But you know? It's very similar to letting your children get away with murder and then you wonder why they are the way they are. If you nip something in the bud immediately and set the standard or rules, you won't have a bigger problem down the road.

Yes ,I am aware some folks may think it is not border line but is flat out abusive... just like some folks think prong collars E collars are abusive too.

My response fair enough your entitled to your opinion.
But I want you to understand is what I know is abusive?
Children that are living in constant fear when they are home ( A place that every child deserves to feel is the safest place on earth) that at any moment a growling snapping Doberman may attack them.
That is psychological & emotional abuse and could cause them fear dogs for the rest of their life.
Ditto for the wife.

I guarantee you this.
If one those children started crying at school or a friends house and a teacher or parent asked whats wrong?
And was told "I am afraid to go home because our Doberman growls and snaps at me and I think he is going to attack me."
And then they reported it to the authorities ..(Which the teacher is obligated to do so by law.)

Child services with charge the parents with child endangerment and emotional abuse.
Animal control would step in and it would be all over for the dog.


My guess is it would be on the local news and it would just confirm in many peoples mind that Dobermans are vicious dogs and something should be done about it. Nobody should be allowed to have those dogs.

Yes serious situations..requires serious responses.

Cheers
MR
 
You don't have to be 6'2" 200+ pounds, believe me; but I get what you're saying. I think about what if I had a 160 lb. South African Boerboel with a neck nearly as thick as my thigh? Probably no "alpha roll" gonna' happen there. Same for when I get to be elderly. So, ideally, there should be a far less physical way to handle this problem. Like you said, though, hopefully it wouldn't become a problem in the first place with good training. My boy, I believe, simply had a problem.

I agree 100% the key is to raise them so this hopefully is never an issue.
But the fact is its pretty natural for a dog at some point to want to try to move up in the pack.
Especially teenagers 7 to 12 months that are testing & pushing all boundaries.

This is a Doberman site not one for South African Boerboels.
Dobes are a medium breed. If your Doberman weighs 160 pounds..never mind not even going to go there LOL.

As far as being elderly and doing this... I am 60 and glad we got Maja now.
At 60 the 1st few months were exhausting...brings back memories of being a sleep deprived parent of a new born. I can't imaging trying to raise another doberman puppy when I am in my 70's.
I know some folks can run marathons at that age... I am not one of them LOL

I think when we reach that age looking at re-homing an already mature doberman will be a better fit.
All of the breeders I know require by contract owners that can't keep their dogs for any reason are required to return the dog to them.. They usally also know other breeders that require it too.
So from time to time due to unforeseen circumstances divorce, job loss or relocation, change in health etc. Nice older dogs with no major problems need new homes.
We almost went that way this time but it didn't happen because the nice dobermans find new homes pretty dang fast.
Also this is my wife's 1st Doberman and we went for the full Dobe puppy experience.

Sorry this thread got so far off topic.
MR
 
the key is to raise them so this hopefully is never an issue.
Just to let people know as this has been mentioned many times to me in the past few weeks my dog as far as I'm concerned was well socialised. He was out in public from I got him. I encouraged anyone who commented on him to pet him when out on walks or in pet shops. Then one day a switch flipped and he dislikes virtually everyone except me/my son.
He's due to see a trainer/behaviour guy next week. He says he should be able to sort it and give me a program to follow.
I'll report back after that visit.
 
Just to let people know as this has been mentioned many times to me in the past few weeks my dog as far as I'm concerned was well socialised. He was out in public from I got him. I encouraged anyone who commented on him to pet him when out on walks or in pet shops. Then one day a switch flipped and he dislikes virtually everyone except me/my son.
He's due to see a trainer/behaviour guy next week. He says he should be able to sort it and give me a program to follow.
I'll report back after that visit.
It is a great misconception that socializing your dog means to have strangers meet and greet your dog. It is really about your dog be comfortable in public with you, while other people and dogs are around. They should be confident and content to be out and playing with you with these distractions. By letting your dogs meet others just feeds into them looking at others as people they need to go meet, same with dogs. If you are a strong leader and make yourself the most important and fun thing where every you, then your dog will ignore others and show no concern.
 
It is a great misconception that socializing your dog means to have strangers meet and greet your dog. It is really about your dog be comfortable in public with you, while other people and dogs are around. They should be confident and content to be out and playing with you with these distractions
I agree! I also feel that way when I'm riding my horse. So many people want to ride up to you and let the horses touch noses. :groan: Not me! I want my horse to pay attention to me. Not greet the other horses.
 
Just to let people know as this has been mentioned many times to me in the past few weeks my dog as far as I'm concerned was well socialised. He was out in public from I got him. I encouraged anyone who commented on him to pet him when out on walks or in pet shops. Then one day a switch flipped and he dislikes virtually everyone except me/my son.
He's due to see a trainer/behaviour guy next week. He says he should be able to sort it and give me a program to follow.
I'll report back after that visit.

Something has caused this change in behavior.
Extreme changes in behavior just don't happen for no reason.
I am sure what ever it is was something you were not aware was happening.
Or you simply didn't understand the seriousness when he first exhibited the aggressive behavior.

In my experience the only time "a switch is flipped" is when a dog has experienced significant trauma
or there is organic medical issue.

Have you talked to your vet about the problem?
Have you contacted the breeder about this problem?
Is there any history of any organic medical issues like a brain or neurological disorders or endocrine system problems like over / under active thyroid that can cause changes in mood & personality in this breeders line?

I wish you all the best in getting this behavior solved.
Hopefully the trainer will figure it out and put an end to it.

If not an unpredictable aggressive and threatening Doberman does not have a bright future.
Society does not have much if any tolerance for unpredictable & threatening dogs of any breed yet alone Dobermans.

Shelters won't place "dangerous" dogs in new homes they euthanize them.
Way too much liability for their workers and the new owners.
They have way to many non aggressive dogs that need homes.

Even most doberman rescue organizations are reluctant to try work with this kind of problem.
Nobody wants to risk being attacked and bit by a Doberman.
Even those of us that love the breed may draw the line at sharing their lives & homes with a dog that might attack unprovoked and without warning.

Please keep us up to date on any progress so we all can learn how to prevent and solve this problem.
MR
 
Well no magic bullet for this dog!! Trainer/behaviourist left me with more questions than answers!!
Most of what he said didn't apply to my case and he suggested his classes/food/neutering/ no sport. He basically said the dog sees himself as high up the pack under me which is what I've read into the situation.
I think I'll continue on my own course of action with my son getting involved with training. I'm slowly coaxing my daughter to feed as Well. Unfortunately wife is anti dog so we'll see how it all pans out.
 
I fully meant it when I hit the "empathetic" button. As I shared, I had a fairly similar unfortunate situation with my previous Doberman. His case was unsolvable, it seemed. I do empathize with you, though, on the wife thing.

I have a pretty great wife, I do, but since she got pregnant with our first child, she no longer had much desire for a dog in her/our lives. She currently does not think we need one or should have one. I feel that my Dobe is part of what keeps our family safe, but wife's response is always the typical "Ah, nothing's going to happen."
 
Sometimes it's for the best to do things on your own by trial & error. There are lots of good threads on training right here on this forum, and even indirectly, lots and lots of training would be helpful. Best of luck, and yes keep us posted.
 
Well no magic bullet for this dog!! Trainer/behaviourist left me with more questions than answers!!
Most of what he said didn't apply to my case and he suggested his classes/food/neutering/ no sport. He basically said the dog sees himself as high up the pack under me which is what I've read into the situation.
I think I'll continue on my own course of action with my son getting involved with training. I'm slowly coaxing my daughter to feed as Well. Unfortunately wife is anti dog so we'll see how it all pans out.

Sorry to hear no easy answer.
Not every trainer is the right fit for every dog or breed they come across.
I would try another trainer/behaviorist nothing wrong with seeking 2nd, 3rd or 4th opinions.
Have you asked the breeder or your vet to suggest trainers?
MR
 
fully meant it when I hit the "empathetic" button
I did too! I totally understand when a new (human) baby arrives. Sometimes the pets are put on the back burner. When I had my first child, I had my Pomeranian, who I loved dearly. But I remember that she got on the back burner at times too. It happens. New babies take up a lot of time. But never did I think that I didn't want her. I wouldn't give her up for the world! And I think it's naive to think that we are all safe. It's great that nothing has happened to her to make her feel insecure. But we shouldn't look through Rose Colored Glasses. Sh*t happens . Your Doberman would probably give his life for your family.
 
Have you asked the breeder or your vet to suggest trainers
He's imported from Russia by myself so the breeder can't help! I'm from a very small country, you could count dog behaviourists on 3 fingers . I used the most recommended one but he did seem a bit taken aback by him(the dog).
I'll work on my own plan. I can read his body language pretty well now and if he begins any aggression I've been giving him a quick command - sit/down or place which seems to be working. He's getting muzzle trained too for when he's in a crowded public place ie shop etc in case of a stranger trying to pet him. Which has happened.
His aggression is on different levels in the house/with family and outside/strangers.
Small growls/the odd snap in house but if a stranger went to pet him he's full on cujo rabid dog. If people ignore him he's no interest.
So it's going to be muzzled in public and I'm working on his house manners. Wish me luck!
 
I did too! I totally understand when a new (human) baby arrives. Sometimes the pets are put on the back burner. When I had my first child, I had my Pomeranian, who I loved dearly. But I remember that she got on the back burner at times too. It happens. New babies take up a lot of time. But never did I think that I didn't want her. I wouldn't give her up for the world! And I think it's naive to think that we are all safe. It's great that nothing has happened to her to make her feel insecure. But we shouldn't look through Rose Colored Glasses. Sh*t happens . Your Doberman would probably give his life for your family.
Oh yes. Thank you. Make no mistake: My wife continued to love her Husky just as much as she had since years earlier. Just for the record: We did not get rid of her! She remained our beloved pet the rest of her life. I know you probably already realize this.

Only thing is, I pretty quickly displaced the Husky girl from the bed once we move in together. Boy, my wife used to really value me!! :rofl:
 
This is a dominance issue. He accepts you as the alpha & pack leader but he is challenging family members and succeeding.
He needs to learn his place in the pack is dead last period & PRONTO! (Ok the cat if you have one can be dead last LOL!)

I am sure there are many here that will disagree with what I am about to post next. So be it.
I am not going to sugar coat this problem. I am not talking about appropriate aggressive & protective behaviors towards strangers or people that are a threat. We are talking about Dobermans not Pugs here. I have a N.A x Euro cross because I think most NA breeders and the AKC have lost sight of the fact that Dobermans were bred to be protection dogs.

If you want take the lovey dovey warm & fuzzy training approach to dangerous behavior thats your call and when somebody gets hurt and animal control officers come for your dog thats on you.
I believe in positive reinforcement & positive training methods as much as anybody.
But this is serious business for all involved. It's dangerous for both the family and the dog .
Dogs that hurt innocent & non threatening people end up getting destroyed and their owners sued.

This a behavior I simply do not tolerate.
Showing any form of aggressive behavior towards me or any family members is at the top of my list of things I don't ever let my dog do.
I don't care if it's a baby, small child or my great-grandmother.
I never let any of my dogs get away with threatening any family member, not even once.

I make no apologies for my "No one.. yet alone my dog threatens me or my family ever!!" position on this. Man or beast no different in my book. I love & protect my family and my dogs are family to me.

If they do I respond in such a way that they will never do it again.
It will be immediate & a very unpleasant lesson..as it should be.

I am a big guy 6'2" 250#s
On the very rare occasions my dogs have tried this in the past
(After 40+ years & 6 dobes of my own and fostering
more dobe rescues than I can name .)
It has happened only 3 times... 2 were males around 8 & 10 moths old and a 15 month old bitch that we fostering for a rescue.

(Note) If you are not 100% confident in your role as alpha & pack leader call in a professional that is. If the dog does not respect you as alpha you will get hurt.

I handled it this way...
I grabbed them by the scruff of their neck (Just like an alpha wolf does) pinned them on the ground. Grabbed them by their throat and made myself as big and scary as I possibly could.
I looked them directly in the eye and literally growled at them as loud as I could.
When I let them go I chased them off into their safe space AKA their crate. And gave them time to reflect on what just took place. After they processed what just took place all of them came to me exibiting very submissive behavior. I petted them and the lesson was over and done.
It was not an experience that they ever wished to repeat and they never did.

My actions were proportionate and age appropriate.
I don't respond to a 8 month old doberteen the same way I would to a full grown dog.
And yes there were some pretty over the top theatrics involved.
Just like when I am playing with a small puppy and they get a bit too rough and bite a little too hard.
I will yipe, yelp ,cry and "act" like they really hurt me. They always respond with a "I am sorry behavior" Give me kisses and then play gentle.

As I stated in the beginning this is a dominance problem in your pack/family and I am not going to sugar coat it.
You as pack leader let a member of the pack bully & threaten another member of the pack.
That was a failure of you as alpha and pack leader. It is your resposnability to protect everyone in your pack/family.
Learn from it.

I will close with this..
If one of your children pulled a knife or weapon on another family member and threatened them with serious injury would you allow it?
Or would you take action the moment it happened and make it crystal clear that that is never ok and will never will be allowed...EVER!
Would you allow somebody else's dog threaten your family members?
If not, why are you letting your family dog do it?

I know my post won't be popular or agreed with by many here and that fine.
It's not politically correct in this age of micro aggression & safe spaces.
I don't tolerate canine terrorist or 4 legged wrecking balls in my pack/family.
And for the life of me I don't understand why anybody does.

Be a loving but firm leader and your dog will trust, follow and love you for life.

Good luck!

MR

PS For those reading this that think I am some big ogar that likes to be mean to my dog to prove what a tough guy I am. Here is a photo of Maja and me in my bed taking a nap after a trip to the park. As you can tell she doesn't love or trust me. LOL!
View attachment 105066
Late post here, but we are having similar dominance issues with our dobie and your method makes good sense to me but he is now 3 years old and 90 lbs. I am worried that my husband and I could not safely grab and pin him down. Do you think we would get similar results implementing this without actually touching him? Just getting big, growling and running him off? We need to fix this before it gets worse. Do you think there's still hope of correcting these behaviors at his age? Thanks!!
 
I am sure this is not what is happening here, but earlier in the thread "Rage" was mentioned. I have unfortunatley had a Doberman with what the vet called "Sudden Rage Syndrome". It used to be called Spaniel Rage, but they are seeing it in many other breeds now. Shows up between 6 months and 2 years. Our boy was 2 years old, had obedience titles, well socialized everywhere, then started the "dead stare" and would attack without provocation. It happened over a period of months.....We were making excused for his behavior (He was attacking dog friends he would be walking with when they would look at him too long) Heartbreaking to say the least...and I almost had my face ripped off because I was staring at him (thinking he was having a heart issue because he was just standing staring at me). Moments before he had been dropping a ball in my lap (like a lab) and wanting to play. Did some damage to my face, and we had to put him down. That was years ago, and have had 4 other dobermans since....our family members think we are insane, but nobody understands what Doberman addiction is! ;)
 

Back
Top