• Disclaimer: Hello Guest, Doberman Chat Forums presents the opinions and material on these pages as a service to its membership and to the general public but does not endorse those materials, nor does it guarantee the accuracy of any opinions or information contained therein. The opinions expressed in the materials are strictly the opinion of the writer and do not represent the opinion of, nor are they endorsed by, Doberman Chat Forums. Health and medical articles are intended as an aid to those seeking health information and are not intended to replace the informed opinion of a qualified Veterinarian.”

newbie prong collar questions

Day 2 went even better. The links that you recommended were very helpful @NikiL02. I removed 2 more links and took the rubber caps off. I took Luna for a walk on the beach where she can be very excitable because she loves the waves and she did very well. I actually didn't need to do very many corrections while she was heeling and she did great when I gave her some freedom on the leash.

I think I can actually take out another link. I left her very wide flat collar on and that prevented the prong coming down too far but I think removing another link may help it stay put better.

Here's a pic on the beach today (with cameos from my son and my ex). :)

beach.webp
 
Kris was the first dog I have ever used both a prong and e-collar on. I started using the prong on her when she was just over a year old and it was really icy out. She is four in December and I have not used it for the last few years. I still put the e-collar on her whenever I have her off-leash but have not had to use it for a long time now, just like it on for back-up if we run into deer in the fields. Our area is over-run with deer and she chases them out of my field so can't blame her for thinking she can always chase them. Never had a problem calling her back so far.
 
I only used mine for their crazy barking at nothing, jumping up on me and going after the cat. My commands were 'Quiet' for barking, 'Off' for jumping and 'Leave it' for the cat. I have never cranked it up on them. Just a short nip with the barking while I said quiet and used the hand signal for quiet. Now all I have to do is say quiet and they respond.
I use the tone and vibrate to get their attention and say come and I reward them with praise and sometimes a treat.
I don't like giving too many treats especially when animated praise does the trick. I work them everyday, multiple times a day for short periods and always end training with something they do well so that it ends on a positive note.
There have been several times that both them and I were getting frustrated so I just ended the session with a positive and put them up until I could be calm.

They really pick up on my energy so I have to do deep, slow breathing before I take them out to train or walk. My trainer keeps emphasizing me being calm and assertive, especially with Bogie because he is showing signs of wanting to protect me and that is not good.
I have to train myself before I train them. Lol
But I am working hard on it. :-)
 
Day 2 went even better. The links that you recommended were very helpful @NikiL02. I removed 2 more links and took the rubber caps off. I took Luna for a walk on the beach where she can be very excitable because she loves the waves and she did very well. I actually didn't need to do very many corrections while she was heeling and she did great when I gave her some freedom on the leash.

I think I can actually take out another link. I left her very wide flat collar on and that prevented the prong coming down too far but I think removing another link may help it stay put better.

Here's a pic on the beach today (with cameos from my son and my ex). :)

View attachment 66911

Good-looking crew! I freaking love when they tilt their heads. It's like "What are you even talking about?"
 
Day 2 went even better. The links that you recommended were very helpful @NikiL02. I removed 2 more links and took the rubber caps off. I took Luna for a walk on the beach where she can be very excitable because she loves the waves and she did very well. I actually didn't need to do very many corrections while she was heeling and she did great when I gave her some freedom on the leash.

I think I can actually take out another link. I left her very wide flat collar on and that prevented the prong coming down too far but I think removing another link may help it stay put better.

Here's a pic on the beach today (with cameos from my son and my ex). :)

View attachment 66911

She looks great. I'm glad those links helped!
 
This is what has me on the fence with prongs. I've always gotten the same result with a choker. I have "handled" a lot of dogs over the years and with a little training never had a puller, except the GSD who we had to train to get to the front for showing.

Everything is in how you use it, but a quick pop with a choker, timed right has always got the job done. I understand the prong users say they can't cause damage and don't cause the pain a choker can, but I have no objection to a little pain so long as it is done right. It usually is a good deterrent.

Anything in the wrong hands can be brutal, even the softest snaffle.

The choke chain though is a different beast. It's still centralizing the first "hit" from the pop. They also can actually choke a dog, whereas a prong can only go so tight before it just can't go anymore. It'll make them yelp, but most often they don't have any lasting marks and can chances of a dog dying from them would be a freak accident. The pressure is universal around the neck and never centralized in one spot. That's why they're also known as pinch collars.
 
The choke chain though is a different beast. It's still centralizing the first "hit" from the pop. They also can actually choke a dog, whereas a prong can only go so tight before it just can't go anymore. It'll make them yelp, but most often they don't have any lasting marks and can chances of a dog dying from them would be a freak accident. The pressure is universal around the neck and never centralized in one spot. That's why they're also known as pinch collars.
I have nothing against prongs, if they work for people that's fine with me. I have never seen a dog choke on a choke collar either. While it is possible, to me chokers have the same rules: don't leave on when not working, don't tie them with it, don't pull and not release. Same "pop" but to me it is still "less correction". I'm a horse trainer, I have no issues with correction/ a little discomfort to correct a behavior (not the same thing as teaching something new to the animal), so I'm not at all against a prong, I just don't know if I will get one for Neegan.
 
Sore biceps tendons got me to start wrapping a long leash around my waist for walks. This was a couple Dobes ago.

I will really have to use a prong this winter and see if keeping it high up on the neck will help. I've had my guys just totally defeat the collar and pull just like normal with a prong collar on.

SO not looking forward to another winter of tension and stress over being pulled off my feet on slippery sidewalks. At least my leg is back to healthy this year.
 
Sore biceps tendons got me to start wrapping a long leash around my waist for walks. This was a couple Dobes ago.

I will really have to use a prong this winter and see if keeping it high up on the neck will help. I've had my guys just totally defeat the collar and pull just like normal with a prong collar on.

SO not looking forward to another winter of tension and stress over being pulled off my feet on slippery sidewalks. At least my leg is back to healthy this year.
Don't let him pull. You have to make the correction before he gets to the pulling stage. Snap the lead when he gets in front of you by a few inches. Drogon's prey drive will drive him right through a prong collar but when I'm able to snap / pop it then he responds.
 
@PandoraB Is the prong collar not a Sprenger? that's all we used and I've been told (but never took a look for myself) that the rubber caps on the end of 'other' prong collars are there because their ends might not be as smooth so it's to 'protect' the skin. Again, just what I've been told. Make sure to check there are no jagged edges under those rubber bits! Happy training!
 
@PandoraB Have you guys had an opportunity to try it out again? The thread kind of turned into a choke v. prong deal for a bit, so I just wanted to check in and see how it was going.
I asked a out E Collars a couple of weeks ago, and it turned into a prong debate too, so I just started googling info. since I already knew I was using the prong!!
Did ya take the caps off? A link out? Is she responsive?
 
@bomary she did great with the caps off (did you see the pic I posted above?). I am optimistic that this will be a great training tool with how quickly she has responded in just 2 sessions. I may take her out with it on for Halloween tonight but I'm not sure yet. I think I'm going to do the corrections sooner too based on @Drogon's comments above.

@LifeofRubie I'm not sure what brand the collar is. A friend lent it to me to try. I am likely going to buy my own and was thinking about getting the hot pink one at PetSmart in the smaller links. The one I'm currently using is way too big (I've already taken out 4 links and I think I will be taking out another before the next session).
 
@PandoraB I know the color is tempting but I think the Sprenger does make one of the best prong collars out there. They're very high quality and smooth to use (I did try a petsmart one once and it was clunky and caught on itself with defeats the purpose!). Rubie is 10 months old, 50lbs (just a petite little thing!) and we still use the 2.25mm. Glad to hear she is responding well to it, either way :)

We're working on weaning Rubie OFF her prong collar, now. It's basically like starting all over :wideyed:
 
Don't let him pull. You have to make the correction before he gets to the pulling stage. Snap the lead when he gets in front of you by a few inches. Drogon's prey drive will drive him right through a prong collar but when I'm able to snap / pop it then he responds.
Yeah, I'm gonna try that again.
 
Don't forget to try fast, normal, slow. Do stand and sit stays while you walk around them. I am very firm about leading with my left leg and saying "heel" when I move forward. (on the other hand I lead with my right leg when I make them stay.) You will need to correct quickly when they're out front, and while a dog should walk your speed, sometimes it's easiest if you can find a speed where they either walk or trot lightly. If you are between this, you're making it hard for them to get it right because they have to speed up then slow down.
 
@PandoraB go with the recommendations from @LifeofRubie. I bought the same brand, Sprenger in stainless steel and size, 2.25 (small) after much research and recommendations from other Dobie owners. The quality is much better than the ones you'll find a t Petsmart; the ends of the Sprenger are smoother and will not hurt your pup. I bought mine from Amazon with 4-6 extra links, needed them for size as my boy got older. He's 100lbs and the small size works well on him- I've been told that the smaller ones are more effective because more points are actually on their neck and it's true. @NikiL02 's advice is excellent, I do the same about leading with the left leg so they see when give the command and soon you won't even need to say anything. And good point @NikiL02 about finding the right speed- either walk or jog.
 
@PandoraB I wanted to add (although some have already said it), remove the rubber caps (if it comes with them, mine didn't)- defeats the purpose. And make sure you keep up high on her neck, right behind the ears and tight enough that it doesn't slide down. I rigged mine so it's connected to his flat collar as backup in case the prongs come apart- which has happened twice in a year. hope that helps
 

Back
Top