strykerdobe
Hot Topics Subscriber
Proper fitting and use are the most important as with any type (E Collars, Chokers and others) of collars.



Day 2 went even better. The links that you recommended were very helpful @NikiL02. I removed 2 more links and took the rubber caps off. I took Luna for a walk on the beach where she can be very excitable because she loves the waves and she did very well. I actually didn't need to do very many corrections while she was heeling and she did great when I gave her some freedom on the leash.
I think I can actually take out another link. I left her very wide flat collar on and that prevented the prong coming down too far but I think removing another link may help it stay put better.
Here's a pic on the beach today (with cameos from my son and my ex).
View attachment 66911
Day 2 went even better. The links that you recommended were very helpful @NikiL02. I removed 2 more links and took the rubber caps off. I took Luna for a walk on the beach where she can be very excitable because she loves the waves and she did very well. I actually didn't need to do very many corrections while she was heeling and she did great when I gave her some freedom on the leash.
I think I can actually take out another link. I left her very wide flat collar on and that prevented the prong coming down too far but I think removing another link may help it stay put better.
Here's a pic on the beach today (with cameos from my son and my ex).
View attachment 66911
This is what has me on the fence with prongs. I've always gotten the same result with a choker. I have "handled" a lot of dogs over the years and with a little training never had a puller, except the GSD who we had to train to get to the front for showing.
Everything is in how you use it, but a quick pop with a choker, timed right has always got the job done. I understand the prong users say they can't cause damage and don't cause the pain a choker can, but I have no objection to a little pain so long as it is done right. It usually is a good deterrent.
Anything in the wrong hands can be brutal, even the softest snaffle.
I have nothing against prongs, if they work for people that's fine with me. I have never seen a dog choke on a choke collar either. While it is possible, to me chokers have the same rules: don't leave on when not working, don't tie them with it, don't pull and not release. Same "pop" but to me it is still "less correction". I'm a horse trainer, I have no issues with correction/ a little discomfort to correct a behavior (not the same thing as teaching something new to the animal), so I'm not at all against a prong, I just don't know if I will get one for Neegan.The choke chain though is a different beast. It's still centralizing the first "hit" from the pop. They also can actually choke a dog, whereas a prong can only go so tight before it just can't go anymore. It'll make them yelp, but most often they don't have any lasting marks and can chances of a dog dying from them would be a freak accident. The pressure is universal around the neck and never centralized in one spot. That's why they're also known as pinch collars.
Don't let him pull. You have to make the correction before he gets to the pulling stage. Snap the lead when he gets in front of you by a few inches. Drogon's prey drive will drive him right through a prong collar but when I'm able to snap / pop it then he responds.Sore biceps tendons got me to start wrapping a long leash around my waist for walks. This was a couple Dobes ago.
I will really have to use a prong this winter and see if keeping it high up on the neck will help. I've had my guys just totally defeat the collar and pull just like normal with a prong collar on.
SO not looking forward to another winter of tension and stress over being pulled off my feet on slippery sidewalks. At least my leg is back to healthy this year.

Yeah, I'm gonna try that again.Don't let him pull. You have to make the correction before he gets to the pulling stage. Snap the lead when he gets in front of you by a few inches. Drogon's prey drive will drive him right through a prong collar but when I'm able to snap / pop it then he responds.