My Grim, Fearful Prediction

You can tell whoever wrote that knows nothing about the purebred dog fancy and what it is about. I doubt they even know there is a standard and that "white" is a non allowed color. For me it is one of AKC's biggest hyprocrisies. They are for breed quality clears state that you are not to breed know defects yet allow a mutant gene that is known to be harmful all along promoting a million dollar health foundation to eliminate defects. Now go figure that one out.
Yep.
That's why I posted it.
Really points out how depending on where you read what,very different things can be said.
In fact it is not a choice per the standard - Ears normally cropped and carried erect - the uncropped ear will not stand erect -
Not to be nitpicky here,but that says "Normally".
Normally doesn't mean always.
 
I did not get Kris cropped, she was docked before I got her and still has her front dew claws. I like the looks of a cropped Doberman but as there is no Vet in our area that does cropping and also the closest ones will not even dock or remove dew claws.
As she was already 11 weeks old, I just left her ears. She is spayed and I wanted to do Agility and Obedience with her and I really like the temperament and looks of them even with their ears. I have not had anyone ask what breed she is even with her ears.
There are two Dobermans that come to the Agility practices and they are both cropped but the ears were not looked after so they do not stand and I certainly do not like the look of them, would rather see entire ears than that.
 
You're not giving dog owners enough credit. People know that a cropped dog looks more imposing than a non cropped dog. Just like they know that a Doberman will be more protective than a Lab.

Then why hide the fact it is a doberman??? Leaving it uncropped is hiding behind a false wall of feel good it won't bite right up til the time someone gets hurt then we all get blamed and the breed suffers. Now those with a more lab like temperament probably won't bite but they are not bred to standard cropped or not.

She is spayed and I wanted to do Agility and Obedience with her and I really like the temperament and looks of them even with their ears.

Cariboo - how exciting. Can't want for all your fun stories as you train and run!!! Any and all training really expands ones knowledge of just how fantastic this breed is.
 
It still remains a choice! You choose to follow the standard without exception, and others choose to allow for the exception...it's all a choice. You may feel that it is not a choice in your world of DPCA and UDC, but pet owners are not in that world and they have a choice in C/D, unless it is already done for them. And we will continue to see more of this every day.

I personally choose to C/D my dogs...It is what I desire in the breed. But not everyone has this desire, and that is their choice. I see the writing on the wall and the DPCA and UDC are not going to keep a C/D ban from progressing forward forever. And I feel that your hard core position on C/D not being a choice will be detrimental in the long run. I will be pro-choice in this matter, as without unification in this area it will be lost one day. If it remains either/or then one will loose, and take a guess who that will be. I do not want to loose my CHOICE to C/D my dogs! I am sure there are many Europeans that would like a choice in this matter, but that has been taken away from them. What a shame!!!

@Dobs4ever How in the world is making enemies out of your opposition help your position in any way?
How does your position stop this train from rolling?

The problem is--is that we are not living in the past, in the way that things "were" done. And the way things were done did not necessarily mean good responsible breeding took place. Many a Champion standard bread dog has died early from some dreaded disease. The standard alone does not make for quality breeding....the integrity of the breeder does.

I really hope that my children and grandchildren have the "choice" to C/D in their day.
 
Yep.
That's why I posted it.
Really points out how depending on where you read what,very different things can be said.
Not to be nitpicky here,but that says "Normally".
Normally doesn't mean always.
I thought we went over the word "normally" before and it was determined that it meant a normal crop- not a pit bull crop or anything weird for the breed...
 
I thought we went over the word "normally" before and it was determined that it meant a normal crop- not a pit bull crop or anything weird for the breed...
That could be,maybe I missed it.
However,that in itself is subject to interpretation.Why is it that every other aspect of "the standard" is so well defined yet the length or style of crop is left to interpretation?
If we look at crops from the 20s,30's,40's even into the 60's we see either a very short military or medium crop yet today they're mile high show style crops.
Not sure what word to use for that situation?hypocritical doesn't really fit,imprecise doesn't either.I dunno.
 
I thought we went over the word "normally" before and it was determined that it meant a normal crop- not a pit bull crop or anything weird for the breed...

Yes, that is exactly what it means. It probably should be written "should have a normal crop." From the DPCA website....

The DOBERMAN **STANDARD** asks for “ears normally cropped and carried erect”. This simply implies that the ears are cropped in a normal manner. Responsible breeders have the ear-cropping surgery done and healed before they leave the breeders home.

but yes, even then that is left up to interpretation. This can also be found on the website under Ears....which I'm sure judges can and do use.

There are a variety of lengths and shapes of cropped ears. The cropped ear should be in balance with the head and body. Ear cropping is an art and each cropper has their own style.
 
Ok well I have an natural dobe granted i am not in the states and not to blow my own horn or anything but i am the only person in the whole town to to do any work with my dog. I had a guy come up to me clapping and cheering whilst I was working Layla in the park saying its so amazing to see somebody work with their dog and its the first time he's ever seen it in Walvis Bay. I do obedience, tracking and agility with her. I have to say I don't understand the debate as I am not American but I got a dobermann and I knew that i wanted to do "work" with her. My vet told me that she thinks I would make a great trainer and that I should start training as nobody does it here. So I think I am going to start. In the meantime I am working harder and harder on making Layla the poster child for my training enterprise ;). I think cropped or uncropped they are gorgeous. I love the head and the heart of the dobermann more then anything else. I think its unfair to paint a natural dobe in that light. Boarder Collies are not cropped and docked doesn't mean that they don't dominate at agility etc.
 
Please show me where anyone is asking for the standard to be opened? You are seriously so blinded by fear that you can't even see that we are agreeing with you on the standard.. this is what frustrates so many people here..
She said that she wonders why any breeder would sell uncropped/undocked Dobermans when the standard states that they must be cropped and docked. I think maybe @Dobs4ever feels this allowing for choice will add momentum to the forces seeking to change the standard?
 
She said that she wonders why any breeder would sell uncropped/undocked Dobermans when the standard states that they must be cropped and docked. I think maybe @Dobs4ever feels this allowing for choice will add momentum to the forces seeking to change the standard?

I agree 100% unfortunately for @Dobs4ever marketplaces are defined by supply and demand and people like choice. I'm all for cropped and docked dogs but I'm also all for natural and docked dogs. This is just like the split between conformation and protection dog people. Different strokes for different folks.
 
I agree 100% unfortunately for @Dobs4ever marketplaces are defined by supply and demand and people like choice. I'm all for cropped and docked dogs but I'm also all for natural and docked dogs. This is just like the split between conformation and show dog people. Different strokes for different folks.
Hmmm. So above all, give the people what they want. Maybe it's like how the purists felt about the first Porsche SUV or Porsche 4-door. Of course I believe a noble breed being preserved is more important than any automobile.
 
Maybe the reason why were losing all our freedoms as Americans is because we don't value them?
 
I think you missed what I was saying. I was hinting that beating the drum for only C+D will not work in a free marketplace. Eventually someone is going to provide what consumers are requesting.

A better tactic would be to embrace everyone that shares your core beliefs even though you don't agree with everything they believe. This way at a minimum you have a larger group to push agendas.
 
Again we have another thread that has gone way off topic and turned into another crop/dock debate. I have question for those of us who live where c/d is still allowed. What or why would you choose an uncropped or un docked dog when purchasing your next puppy? This is assuming you are planning on buying from a breeder and not getting a dog from a rescue.


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk
 
I have to ask the people for choice when have you ever seen a country faced with the issue of whether to ban c/d ever left with a choice? It is a very passionate subject that becomes all or nothing. The people that are for choice cave when given an ultimatum.
 
What or why would you choose an uncropped or un docked dog when purchasing your next puppy?
All three of my Dobermans have been purchased already c/d. I never gave it a moments thought. It's how I thought it should be. :) It's the standard of the Doberman that I grew up with and all I've ever known. :dobe: That and dew claws removed. :paw:
 
Again we have another thread that has gone way off topic and turned into another crop/dock debate. I have question for those of us who live where c/d is still allowed. What or why would you choose an uncropped or un docked dog when purchasing your next puppy? This is assuming you are planning on buying from a breeder and not getting a dog from a rescue.


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk
I was born in the USA Im not sure what oppressive country you live in. The United States of America may be an oppressive country today but it wasn't Always that way. I personally value my freedoms slightly more than I value a dog's standard. I think some of you people need to realize that every dog on this planet isn't some working utility to be used like a slave some dogs don't need to go through unnecessary cosmetic procedures some dogs have no business being put under and most dogs today are just pets. Sorry but in this day and age I don't need a pitbull that can take down a bulll in an arena. Does anyone really? Boy if we had to exterminate every dog on this planet that doesn't have a job in the 21st-century we wouldn't have too many purebred dogs in the first place. I think the dog show purest need to remember that without their pet people they wouldn't be breeding in the first place because they would have anybody to buy their dogs from them. It does shock me though how easily so many of you will dismiss your God-given freedoms as American citizens to do if you will with your dog apparently cutting parts off of them is okay but leaving them in tact is to turn them into a Frankenstein. this is a country where you're damned if you do and you're damned if you don't Most people are aware of this and gave up trying to please anybody a long time ago. Show me where I am breaking any laws. And Susan you can call me a flip-floper all day long if people were not allowed to have opinions or change their minds than evolution would not be possible. give me a break. Sadly today I'm too busy fighting the pro C/D groups to for my right to choose to have anything left for those on the other side of the no choice group. But since my opinion means nothing to certain people here why should there opinion mean anything to me? Fortunately I don't think you guys will have to put up with my obviously unpopular position for much longer.
 
@Dobs4ever How in the world is making enemies out of your opposition help your position in any way?
How does your position stop this train from rolling?

I find this thinking amusing and confusing. Let’s see if I have it right - Because of my stand to support 100% the standard that has been the benchmark for the Doberman for 100% it makes enemies. BUT if I would just accept the change and the desecration of our breed I could be politically correct and have more friends. First I am not sure that is the kind of friends I want or need. I have friends and heaven knows we do not agree on everything but I respect them and their position and yes we argue about it but then we lay down the arms and we remain friends because the friendship means more than a political stand. I don’t feel it makes them a monster. In fact we enjoy the debate and at times we both have learned from each other.

Are we saying we can only like people who agree with us??? What kind of person would I be if I just give up to make everyone else happy??? A COWARD….now that is not admirable to me. If I am the only one who is on this side I would not change my position because I have clearly seen where “choice” has taken a large part of the world. It has taken it to a ban. If anyone could guarantee that choice would not force a change which leads to a ban I would have no problem with anyone’s choice because who truly revere and love this breed would always strive to follow the standard which describes the most magnificent dog ever. BUT choice is an AR agenda and for that reason “choice” is not their ultimate goal – BAN of c/d and soon to follow ban of purebred dogs is their goal.

My children used to tell me everyone is doing it so why can’t we. I told them were I everyone else’s mother they would not be doing it either. I did not change my standard of raising my children based on what everyone else was doing. I wanted my children to grow up responsible adults with common sense and good morals. Then my daughter had friends who got pregnant in HS and two years later she said I guess I was right. REALLY!!

So because you(the global you) feel my position will not stop the train I should give in??

Fact is there may be NO position that will stop this train from rolling, but we clearly have the examples of where "choice" led countries on the c/d issue. IF it could be guarantee that "choice" would NOT lead to "change" and then the ban I would have no problem with choice. But choice becomes common and then acceptable and normal and then ban. If it was not driven by the AR activities we would not have to be concerned about the ultimate goal behind the move.

I find it amusing that I stand for the standard - which is the guidelines we are suppose to follow now and I paid to join an exclusive club that set that standard which was accepted by AKC and I am the one that is wrong. My mind does not grasp that thinking. Even you said I hope HOPE I always have the choice which indicates that you already accept the changing of the standard if and when it happens. I prefer to fight to keep it from changing even though it might be a loosing battle I believe it is the right side of the battle. I want to know I did my best to fight a change that is not in the best interest of our Dobermans. To do less would go against all that I believe. I do not hate those who oppose my position - I know who the enemy is - the AR whackos - not my fellow doberman lovers who have been blinded to the ultimate goal of the AR whackos. Fortunately DPCA is standing tall and standing strong to protect and preserve our breed and not allow the whackos to run over us. I am proud to be a member of this elite group that stand for our dobermans. Why aren't you a member???

Von: you do not have to fight for choice - you already have it and will always have it right up til they take your right and ban it. It is the c/d that is at risk and if you want choice to continue then we must preserve my right to c/d or the risk is you will also loose your right to choice when it is banned.
 
for what it's worth Susan you're the one who changed my mind on the subject. So yes you may call me a flip-flopper all you like. Lol bet you wouldn't call someone who changed their mind to agree with you a flip flopper.
 

Back
Top