• Disclaimer: Hello Guest, Doberman Chat Forums presents the opinions and material on these pages as a service to its membership and to the general public but does not endorse those materials, nor does it guarantee the accuracy of any opinions or information contained therein. The opinions expressed in the materials are strictly the opinion of the writer and do not represent the opinion of, nor are they endorsed by, Doberman Chat Forums. Health and medical articles are intended as an aid to those seeking health information and are not intended to replace the informed opinion of a qualified Veterinarian.”

How would you define a 'sharp' dog?

How would you define a 'sharp' dog?


  • Total voters
    16
I see that there are many different definitions of what people call sharp in a dog. When I hear the word sharp used, to me it means, on the ball or showing intellegence. So a sharp dog must show the ability to carry out its handlers wishes with no hesitation or fear while showing complete confidence in its work, alert and ready at all times.
I agree 100%!!!
 
As Armin points out Sharpness is more closely associate with defense drives in a dog. When the Dobermans were first created they were describes as very "sharp" and often were handler aggressive. They took no guff and could be dangerous to handle even for their owners. It is one reason they got the reputation of the "Devil Dogs" during WW II.

Part of the doberman temperament is trainability (pack drive) , intelligent ( part of the character, alert (prey drive) but those things really are not part of the defence drives of the dog directly so don't relate to "sharpness" as used in this context. When a dog displays sharpness it comes from the defence and fight drive not the prey drive.

You can say the dogs are Sharp meaning they are sharp in appearance but that is a totally different context from the sharpness they they used to be known for.
 
Many working dogs both for sport or for real world applications are considered sharp. By this I mean, that many dogs used in these avenues are sharp dogs, they are dogs that have high aggression drives when they encounter a perceived threat, and they will engage this threat without hesitation and with certainty. They are dogs that are very confident in themselves and are as some would call it, have a hair trigger when it comes to threat aggression. I personally like these dogs for sport and for patrol applications. BUT, they can sometimes be a bit hard to live with.

Just my take on sharpness.
 
MODS, when I created the poll I meant to have it so we could see who ticked what, thought I did, any chance of a quick edit?
 
Many working dogs both for sport or for real world applications are considered sharp. By this I mean, that many dogs used in these avenues are sharp dogs, they are dogs that have high aggression drives when they encounter a perceived threat, and they will engage this threat without hesitation and with certainty. They are dogs that are very confident in themselves and are as some would call it, have a hair trigger when it comes to threat aggression. I personally like these dogs for sport and for patrol applications. BUT, they can sometimes be a bit hard to live with.

Just my take on sharpness.
:thumbsup::ty:

A sharp dog is not the best pet.
If dogs with a high fight drive are not trained properly and they are not involved in any work they may become a disaster for families. The bitter truth is.... they are being rehomed more often than other dogs.
 
Many working dogs both for sport or for real world applications are considered sharp. By this I mean, that many dogs used in these avenues are sharp dogs, they are dogs that have high aggression drives when they encounter a perceived threat, and they will engage this threat without hesitation and with certainty. They are dogs that are very confident in themselves and are as some would call it, have a hair trigger when it comes to threat aggression. I personally like these dogs for sport and for patrol applications. BUT, they can sometimes be a bit hard to live with.

Just my take on sharpness.

OK so using the last input from Dale as an example I think we are starting to see a general consensus as to the overall definition of 'sharpness' in a dog, which I would say mostly agrees with No2 in the poll. Sharpness in a nutshell is confident instant defensive aggression towards a perceived threat, it is not a reaction born out of fear, that would be a fear biter as D4E pointed out.

Now onto the next question. DV, Dale have touched on it, Ataro has given her view on it. Sharpness is desirable in a working (Police, security, PP, Military) or sport dog (Schutzhund, FR, MR, PSA etc) but what about a dog that is a pet? If not, why not?
 
I think your last question pretty much answers how/why the Dobe's image did a 180 once they started to gain popularity. I think that it is a shame that many are no longer sharp (as stated to be correct temperament in the standard), and as much as people harp on about how Dobes are not for everyone, I think it's safe to say that today a lot of Dobes sadly just fit the generic category of "loyal and energetic large dog" with the added bonus of a short coat and relatively little shedding.
 
a sharp dog is absolutely not good as a regular pet. They can quickly become a disaster or even a danger in a strictly pet home. These dogs need a channel for their aggression, IE patrol work, Detection/Patrol work, Schutzhund, PP, or other working dog avenue. As a pet they can actually become a danger in their homes as this aggression and sharpness can be hard to control without the proper training and guidance.
 
a sharp dog is absolutely not good as a regular pet. They can quickly become a disaster or even a danger in a strictly pet home.

Whilst what you say above is absolutely correct, a bold temperament is the standard. The meaning of "bold" is certainly subjective (a sharp dog can be, or is indeed "bold") but at the end of the day if you want your dog to be child/stranger proof why would you want a "pet" Dobe ? Because they looked cool in Magnum etc and you can get one just like that as a pet with less drive than a golden retriever ?

Not meaning to sound controversial, but there are people working hard to get working/ PP/ Schutzhund accreditation from the same breed as this :

dobe.jpg


No wonder everyone keeps talking about that elusive great Dobe of yesteryears :confused:
 
There is a huge gap between a sharp working dog and a protective family pet. Definitely I prefer a pet with a good drive. It helps in OB training. It is more fun to own such a dog and play fetch and tug games.
However it's not fun to see dog fights or watch family members especially children being hurt by a dog.

Dobs4ever would agree that not every puppy bred from the working lines becomes a working dog. There are always puppies that go to pet homes.

If you are ready to work your dog and you have a training experience in Sch or PP then a sharp dog may be your choice. I would say Jess or Marco as pet owners may think about...
If you are a beginner it would be much better to have a dog with a high drive that may not get SchIII but will help you to get a good experience.
If you are a pet owner get a nice friendly fun dog.
 
a sharp dog is absolutely not good as a regular pet. They can quickly become a disaster or even a danger in a strictly pet home. These dogs need a channel for their aggression, IE patrol work, Detection/Patrol work, Schutzhund, PP, or other working dog avenue. As a pet they can actually become a danger in their homes as this aggression and sharpness can be hard to control without the proper training and guidance.

I think Dales post is spot on but you need to read the subtleties in his post which I have bolded for emphasis that to me make all the difference to understanding what Dale said. A truly sharp dog IS a liability and does needs an outlet. Old fragile Granny Smith, young heads in the clouds 14 year old Samantha or Mr/Mrs Average with 2.4 kids working too many hours, too tired, too much to do not enough time to devote to training and working a sharp dog are all tragic accidents waiting to happen with a sharp working type dog in the household.

Take my two dogs as an example. Ozzy my Dobe, he's not really sharp but as a young dog he still needs training and lots of exercise, at least an hour a day. He doesn't react to everything that comes around the corner, watchful, alert, yes, and will bark/growl but he's not wanting to rip everything apart. I can walk him and let him run in the knowledge that I have only to keep a watchful eye out for any loose dogs that may run up to him, people unless they are really weird or threatening are not a problem.

Eva my young Rottie on the other hand IS sharp, she like any other dog also needs exercise and training but I have to keep a constant vigil out for people or dogs as she easily spins up into full on action girl. She's not one for just barking like Ozzy, she will if she's loose want to run up and confront the perceived threat head on. She keeps me on my toes and there is no relaxing with her unless I'm in a secluded area where I can see anything coming from a long distance away. She is not a dog for anyone who just wants a pet, she needs constant attention or something will happen. I won't let anyone walk her but me or my wife not even my 22 year daughter as there is too much risk. Eva loves working, that's where she shines, her eyes light up when a ball or a tug comes out and she does everything at 100 mph. Although I make her out to be a huge liability she's really loyal and loving, wherever I am in the house even if she's asleep, if she hears me get up and go into another room she will get up off her comfy bed, find me and lay down at my feet on a cold wood floor. I love her the way she is, I wouldn't have her any other way, when I bought her I knew that she would probably turn out this way as this is her breeding. Outside in crowds she's fine, keep her moving and there's no problem it's more when I'm out on a dark street late at night with no-one around or when I'm in a secluded countryside area and someone comes out of the bushes or suddenly comes around a street corner, that's when I keep an extra extra eye out.
 
A bit unrelated, but would Eva act that sharp and protective regardless of who is on the other end of the leash?
 
I once gave my flatmate permission to walk Ashra in the evening around the block with an ex-girlfriend of his and his son, when his son asked if she could come along. I knew where they were going however, and that the chances of meeting another dog were slim to none. He said she was okay, and well behaved (even though I saw her pulling and going in circles both on the way out and on the way back). Most people walking with me get fed up and give the leash back after Ashra shows them absolutely no respect by running circles, pulling and what not.

I don't know if she would act as protectively or protectively at all, were they walking her alone. But I do know she would push them and lunge at other dogs if she felt like it, just because she doesn't feel obliged to obey a stranger (or even a friend), and that's why I don't generally let people walk her. I have the same experience with Ashra as you do with Eva if walking alone (day or night), and even with guests who I have not personally let in the door and welcomed myself. However, at this point I don't feel that she is a liability at all; she will stop her attack reliably on command and her recall is solid. We take public transport, taxis, go through crowds and busy places etc. and she has never reacted inappropriately.

I think that if your dog respects you and is well trained, sharpness should not be a negative factor. It's when people inexperienced with aggression, dominance and/or dogs and dog body language in general have such a dog that it becomes a problem. In this case, I'd have to say sammy's argument holds a lot of truth. If you want a friendly pet dog, why would you want a Dobe? If you rescue a Dobe and it has such a temperament, I say power to you and enjoy your pet. However, breeding for this kind of friendly temperament? The standard states correct temperament is bold and medium sharp, but it seems quite a lot of breeders are breeding for the "market".

I have visited several breeders and met their dogs, and some of their dogs have come up to me super friendly and wanting to lick my face. All I could think of at the time was "Have we met before?! Why is this Dobe being so friendly?" None of my dogs (non-Dobes included) were ever that friendly upon first meeting strange adults (some of them really love children, though). I would expect a Dobe to be calm, stable, and that it comes to sniff and perhaps allows itself to be stroked, but giving kisses to someone they have just met for the first time? I personally would not want my dog to act that way, with the exception of if it was still a puppy.
 
Whilst what you say above is absolutely correct, a bold temperament is the standard. The meaning of "bold" is certainly subjective (a sharp dog can be, or is indeed "bold") but at the end of the day if you want your dog to be child/stranger proof why would you want a "pet" Dobe ? Because they looked cool in Magnum etc and you can get one just like that as a pet with less drive than a golden retriever ?

Not meaning to sound controversial, but there are people working hard to get working/ PP/ Schutzhund accreditation from the same breed as tT



dobe.jpg


No wonder everyone keeps talking about that elusive great Dobe of yesteryears :confused:


There is a huge difference in a sharp dog and a dog that is bold. Bold temperament is not the same as sharpness. Bold is a dog that when pushed will stand its ground and give warning barks or growls, and will engage when forced to engage. A sharp dog is a dog that will attack a threat, and go in head on quickly and suddenly without much warning or provocation. so while a sharp dog is always bold, a bold dog is rarely sharp.
 
I do think a dog's temperament is moldable to certain point. For example when I got Hope as a 8 wk old puppy she was odd, very odd. She had NO fear. She would look people in the eye. She did't show normal puppy behavior but acted like an calm, perceptive adult dog. The only time you saw the puppy come out was when she play with other dogs. She didnt' care for people and gave you a look like don't touch me when you would pet her. I never had to teach her not to play bite, jump, or not do normal wild puppy behavior because she never tried to. She tried to avoid people and was just serious all the time. She was supposed to be my obedience dog...I was devasted and I didn't know what to do with her. So what I did was separated her from other dogs, forced her to sit on my lap and spent lots and lots of time bonding with her. I worked for my dad on his farm so I was with her all day and night. I started obedience training and tried to curb any dominance she displayed (as a puppy it as passive aggressive dominace she never bit or growled because she as still a young puppy at this time). She has always been naturally dominat over all dogs...Eventually she bonded with me and saw me as her alpha. When that happened at about 6 months or so she would do anything to please me and wanted to always be with me. She tolerated other people petting her but didn't enjoy it and didn't seek them out. She would stare people down but not go up to them unless I made her. Which I did, so she learned to be tolerant. Eventually she saw that having other people pet her pleased me, so she would do it on her own. She earned her CD at 11 months of age, her CDX at 23 months of age. I also showed in 4-H at 9 and 10 months where she had nearly perfect scores. She was always consistent and very obedient and rarely made a serious mistake (she never NQed while showing her in obedience). She was always serious and VERY focused. I never had to teach her focus...I did have to teach her to be more lightheared and playful with she learned over time. Eventually she got to the point where she was friendly to other people. And then as the years passed she is now extremely friendly to everyone everywhere and wants attention and petting from everyone. Her personality totally changed. I have no doubt she could been a night mare is someone didn't notice her sharp, dominant. assertive personality so early on. She even became a therapy dog and is even very trustworthy with children. She is 11 years old now. Anyway, I do think socialization and training especially early on can affect her personality greatly.
 
While I think your accomplishments with Hope are fantastic, I just didn't read anything which would indicate that she is a sharp dog. A dog that is assertive or dominant is not necessarily sharp.
 

Back
Top