We have bern choker collars my whole life, i see little point of those flat collars past puppydom. People think regular chokers are cruel.
I compare it to bits in horses= even the gentlest bit in the wrong hands can do damage. I've seen people whose dogs pull on a flat collar to the point it is hacking and choking. I always think "why not teach it to walk with a choker?" But they think the flat collars are more humane. Swift quick correction and release is the key, and it doesn't matter what kind of collar it is if it isn't tight it won't hurt them... And if they pull on it well, it might bite a bit.
I can't say I've ever used a prong collar, but I'm not against them IF the owner knows how to use them. I'm guessing the pet smart people have too often see idiot owners with a prong collar that is constantly engaged and owners like the collar because it looks "bad ass".... It's more about the image than training for many many people.
Do what you know to do, do it just and fairly, and don't try to please the world, it isn't possible. Please yourself and Jax.
I am interested, however, in why so many dobes are trained with prongs? Are they that hard headed? We always took the " use the least amount of force necessary to achieve results so you still have something to use if they blow past that" method... Again similar to horses, ride on the softest bit that still works... But, I will say being able to wear a curb properly is usually a sign of higher training, so is the prong like an advanced curb? (Horse and Doberman people help.me out, you will get where I'm coming from. Not to hijack the thread)