• Disclaimer: Hello Guest, Doberman Chat Forums presents the opinions and material on these pages as a service to its membership and to the general public but does not endorse those materials, nor does it guarantee the accuracy of any opinions or information contained therein. The opinions expressed in the materials are strictly the opinion of the writer and do not represent the opinion of, nor are they endorsed by, Doberman Chat Forums. Health and medical articles are intended as an aid to those seeking health information and are not intended to replace the informed opinion of a qualified Veterinarian.”

His recall...my fear!!

I have a very finely-honed skill for overreacting, panicking, jumping to conclusions, and going straight to worst-case scenarios. I think I might be losing sight of realistic short-term goals in my pursuit of the long-term ones.
We will reassess and see where we are.
Jax is NEVER off lead anywhere that isn't enclosed, and at this time, I don't see any need for him to be. The main reason this even got on my mind is because for 2 days in a row (seriously, just yesterday and the day before) he didn't act the way he usually does regarding "come." Plus...in the event that something happened (lead getting away from my hand, prong detachment), I want to at least have some hope that he'll do what I need him to do to be safe.
 
If Jax isn't 100% (or as close to it as dogly possible) on recall, I think you're always at risk. That's the great thing about the e collar, IMO. If they do get away from you, you always have a "hand" on them to lead back your way.

I'm a big proponent of the e collar. But an even bigger proponent of using tools you're comfortable with. Because if you don't have the confidence, the dogs will sense it and take over as alpha.

A great example of this was last night. I was walking Kai in the neighborhood (very low crime rate and a very safe area) and we saw a trio of teenage boys on the street. It was dark, and I was very wary of what they were doing, because I didn't recognize any of them. Kai was on the leash (she's always got a leash on, but I will let her "free" to sniff around) beside me. She sensed my tension and as we passed them, she was very tense with her hair raised. And they were across the street on the other sidewalk.

Take your time, determine what works best for you and Jax, and then go down that path.
 
choke vs prong... I don't like choke collars personally. They single target an area on the neck, even though they're around the whole neck and eventually will provide pressure all the way around, they still start in an area and progress outward from there. When a dog pulls it's the trachea that takes the brunt of the force. A prong or a martingale encircles the neck and provides equal pressure around it. I much prefer a prong. The problem is when either collar is overused. I hate seeing dogs with injuries due to either collar, but probably a prong even more. Or when the dog is pulling against the prong. At that point put on a front clip harness and/or halti and go get some training classes. (It's generally a pit type that doing this, so I'm not worried about their neck like I've learned we have to worry about dobermans with.)
 
I have a very finely-honed skill for overreacting, panicking, jumping to conclusions, and going straight to worst-case scenarios. I think I might be losing sight of realistic short-term goals in my pursuit of the long-term ones.
We will reassess and see where we are.
Jax is NEVER off lead anywhere that isn't enclosed, and at this time, I don't see any need for him to be. The main reason this even got on my mind is because for 2 days in a row (seriously, just yesterday and the day before) he didn't act the way he usually does regarding "come." Plus...in the event that something happened (lead getting away from my hand, prong detachment), I want to at least have some hope that he'll do what I need him to do to be safe.

If you're really concerned about about him getting away from you, keep the flat collar on, keep an extra lead on it and attach it with a carbiner to a belt or have it around your waist. Sure it can be dangerous if he's pulling, but you'll stay attached to him. (You gotta stay on yer feet tho. ;) ) Have you ever taken some martial arts classes or something that would help you learn to not panic and stay calm during an emergency?

Hands-Free Leashes: The Best Ones and How to Use Them Safely
 
I think I am just terrible at expressing myself today/last night. I am not neurotic in all aspects of life...yoga instructor 7 years, flight attendant six, high school teacher now 13...all of those require the ability to stay fairly calm and 'even.' However, my nieces and Jax are the only "babies" whose well-being I've ever been solely responsible for. Jax has never been close to getting away from me; I just want to prevent it, and a bad dream got that "heavy" on my mind. I have the fur saver en route. I don't really feel like I completely suck with the prong. Maybe it's too low in that vid, but again, that vid had nothing to do with my questions. It was a failed attempt at humor. Now that I think about it, during those moments, we weren't even "training," I was letting him explore en route to where we walk/train and then to the baseball field.
Regardless....I trust that my trainer will take a close look at us with the prong and then decide if we need to work on that or if he is indeed ready to try an e collar. The only reason I started this thread was to get opinions on e collars and their safety...obviously I didn't ask my questions well!! (I guess I just kind of wanted to know how many people use them here and in what situations). I probably should have just messaged a few people with my questions...I definitely didn't expect this to be 3 pages about prongs!
 
Lol ok to answer your actual question like anything else if used properly it is completely safe. You will not hurt your dog if you go slow. Start low stim and you can gradually adjust to what is required during any situation. The different levels are there for a reason, some dogs need it bumped up to a higher level if there is a ton of distractions, or if their prey drive kicks in. Most will use a leash or long to get the dog to understand that the when the stim goes off the dog should return to you when called and will gently pull the leash to help the dog figure it out. After the dog understand stim means return to person the leash is phased out.
 
Thank you OH SO much for that! It is exactly what my trainer explained to me, but I like to check in with my "Dobe fam" before embarking on new things!

I have also written down several of the brands, etc. that y'all suggested and am ready with my questions, etc. Cheri (our trainer) loves that I have a thousand questions and specific needs, etc. because it annoys the hell out of her when people come in wanting a "quick fix" and absolutes. She definitely will take plenty of time to help me get it all figured out.

Oh...I did call her early this morning and tell her that she need not worry about trying to work us in right this instant (before she leaves town for a horse show!!), and that despite my panic/urgency of last night, I think we'll be okay!!

Thanks again everybody! I am calm, cool, and collected...as is Jax on my lap!
 
Absofreakinglutely! He's amped up because the nieces are here...it's their "birthday weekend!" They are better quarterbacks than I, so his catch rate is far higher when they come over!
Hahahahaha it's my day off and I really don't want to get up and out lol plus I have dog snuggles lol !!!! Which is making it next to impossible to get up and moving !!
 

Back
Top