• Disclaimer: Hello Guest, Doberman Chat Forums presents the opinions and material on these pages as a service to its membership and to the general public but does not endorse those materials, nor does it guarantee the accuracy of any opinions or information contained therein. The opinions expressed in the materials are strictly the opinion of the writer and do not represent the opinion of, nor are they endorsed by, Doberman Chat Forums. Health and medical articles are intended as an aid to those seeking health information and are not intended to replace the informed opinion of a qualified Veterinarian.”

His recall...my fear!!

There are 3 types of people who have dogs. 1) never use a prong, it's cruel and horrible 2) they over use the prong (re: dog pulling on a prong) 3) they use the prong correctly and appropriately (or at least want to)

Do you use a large link prong or small link prong? A small link allows you to adjust better to make sure it stays up. Ignore the people who accuse of it being cruel (keeper collar is cool and I will get one) and the others you can inform them of proper fit and location and why.
 
Or... 4) don't know or care what a prong (or even what attempting to train a dog) is.
When we go to the trainer tomorrow, I'll just focus on proper prong use and go back to square 1.
Thanks everybody for your responses. Evidently recall is the least of our worries.
 
We have bern choker collars my whole life, i see little point of those flat collars past puppydom. People think regular chokers are cruel.

I compare it to bits in horses= even the gentlest bit in the wrong hands can do damage. I've seen people whose dogs pull on a flat collar to the point it is hacking and choking. I always think "why not teach it to walk with a choker?" But they think the flat collars are more humane. Swift quick correction and release is the key, and it doesn't matter what kind of collar it is if it isn't tight it won't hurt them... And if they pull on it well, it might bite a bit.

I can't say I've ever used a prong collar, but I'm not against them IF the owner knows how to use them. I'm guessing the pet smart people have too often see idiot owners with a prong collar that is constantly engaged and owners like the collar because it looks "bad ass".... It's more about the image than training for many many people.


Do what you know to do, do it just and fairly, and don't try to please the world, it isn't possible. Please yourself and Jax. :)

I am interested, however, in why so many dobes are trained with prongs? Are they that hard headed? We always took the " use the least amount of force necessary to achieve results so you still have something to use if they blow past that" method... Again similar to horses, ride on the softest bit that still works... But, I will say being able to wear a curb properly is usually a sign of higher training, so is the prong like an advanced curb? (Horse and Doberman people help.me out, you will get where I'm coming from. Not to hijack the thread)
 
We have bern choker collars my whole life, i see little point of those flat collars past puppydom. People think regular chokers are cruel.

I compare it to bits in horses= even the gentlest bit in the wrong hands can do damage. I've seen people whose dogs pull on a flat collar to the point it is hacking and choking. I always think "why not teach it to walk with a choker?" But they think the flat collars are more humane. Swift quick correction and release is the key, and it doesn't matter what kind of collar it is if it isn't tight it won't hurt them... And if they pull on it well, it might bite a bit.

I can't say I've ever used a prong collar, but I'm not against them IF the owner knows how to use them. I'm guessing the pet smart people have too often see idiot owners with a prong collar that is constantly engaged and owners like the collar because it looks "bad ass".... It's more about the image than training for many many people.


Do what you know to do, do it just and fairly, and don't try to please the world, it isn't possible. Please yourself and Jax. :)

I am interested, however, in why so many dobes are trained with prongs? Are they that hard headed? We always took the " use the least amount of force necessary to achieve results so you still have something to use if they blow past that" method... Again similar to horses, ride on the softest bit that still works... But, I will say being able to wear a curb properly is usually a sign of higher training, so is the prong like an advanced curb? (Horse and Doberman people help.me out, you will get where I'm coming from. Not to hijack the thread)
I don't recall the name of the condition but there is something to do with the Doberman neck, a regular choke collar is discouraged. Something about it causing injury.

And I can only speak from my limited experience with the breed but both of mine will pull, hard. Last time I had Daisy at the vet with a flat collar the gal took her to weigh, that gal and Daisy probably weighed within a few pounds of each other. The gal looked like the wind sock at the airport blowing in the wind behind her. :dobe: But she was very stubborn, she'd pull the prong too unless I corrected her and readjust. Rocky does better.
For a dog with strong prey drive it helps for that surprise burst from a rabbit or what have you.
I could walk them both by myself, arthritis in the hands and all.
 
I don't "know" anything for certain about anything regarding collars, but these are some of the things I read before using a prong:

This is from: http://www.dru.org/prongcollar.htmr
"The prong collar works on the concept that evenly applied pressure is gentler and more effective on a dog's neck than the quick jerk and impact of a choke chain or the steady, relentless pressure of a flat collar. While a professional trainer can make a choke chain correction look fast and flawless, it is very difficult for most pet dog owners to master the timing and the release of the correction. Also, even a perfectly executed choke chain correction is a repeated impact on a single spot on a dog's neck. The current trend of the "head halter" system is equally flawed. In an earlier edition of this article, I referred to it as a good choice for dogs with structural problems. In the past few years I have spoken with veterinarians, trainers and owners who took issue with that recommendation based on the potential insult to the soft tissue of the dog's upper neck and the often careless way in which the headcollar is used by people who are assured that it is "humane" and cannot harm their dog. Like every other training tool, it also has its place. However, for a breed already beset with potential spinal and structural problems such as the Doberman, I find myself recommending it less and less. The self-limiting tightening action of the prong collar also makes it a safer bet for strong-pulling dogs. A prong collar can only be pulled so tight, unlike the choke or slip collar, which has unlimited closing capacity and in careless or abusive hands, can cut a dog's air entirely."

I think that "atlantoaxial subluxation" might be what @Gelcoater is referring to. The examples of dogs prone to having this include Danes and Dobes. Atlantoaxial subluxation - Dog
I've read about both of these in other places (because I know the internet is not always trustworthy), but I just wanted to add this info. here.
 
I just remembered that I started this thread about off-leash recall! Now, I am hijacking my own thread with prong collar "conversation" that has been covered a thousand times here and a million other places!! Ugh...why did I contribute to this??
 
I just remembered that I started this thread about off-leash recall! Now, I am hijacking my own thread with prong collar "conversation" that has been covered a thousand times here and a million other places!! Ugh...why did I contribute to this??
Shall I add you to the list of potential members to raffle off the Threadcrappers title to? :eek::bag:
 
I'll just add my choker/prong 2 cents quickly lol :2cents:threadjacked:

My parents always and only used a choker. That's what I started with mischa once she was about 6 months old. Hated it. It was NOTHING like I remembered Gretchen being on leash! She didn't care, she pulled to the point of hacking and gagging herself. I know how to put it on properly (you can put it on "backwards" and it won't loosen when you release pressure like it should... can be very dangerous for a dog) but it just didn't seem to work well for us this time. After my research, and talking to @AresMyDobie I finally sacked it up and got the prong. I LOVE it. I love the fact it can only get so tight, whereas the choker can keep getting tighter and tighter and tighter to the point of literally choking the dog. I also learned here about the dangers of chokers and the possibility of trauma to the trachea. So, thanks to this forum, after 30 years, I switched from choker to prong and will never go back! I still have the choker, but it hangs on a hook, and only because it was Gretchen's collar. The prong you can just give a nice quick pop to get her attention, and I know I'm not risking any damage like you can with the choker getting too tight when you "pop" it.
 
I'll just add my choker/prong 2 cents quickly lol :2cents:threadjacked:

My parents always and only used a choker. That's what I started with mischa once she was about 6 months old. Hated it. It was NOTHING like I remembered Gretchen being on leash! She didn't care, she pulled to the point of hacking and gagging herself. I know how to put it on properly (you can put it on "backwards" and it won't loosen when you release pressure like it should... can be very dangerous for a dog) but it just didn't seem to work well for us this time. After my research, and talking to @AresMyDobie I finally sacked it up and got the prong. I LOVE it. I love the fact it can only get so tight, whereas the choker can keep getting tighter and tighter and tighter to the point of literally choking the dog. I also learned here about the dangers of chokers and the possibility of trauma to the trachea. So, thanks to this forum, after 30 years, I switched from choker to prong and will never go back! I still have the choker, but it hangs on a hook, and only because it was Gretchen's collar. The prong you can just give a nice quick pop to get her attention, and I know I'm not risking any damage like you can with the choker getting too tight when you "pop" it.

You can add up to ten bucks worth, and then you're cut off, and you don't even have to do it quickly!! Hijacking is a pastime of mine, and I'm very proud to be a big part of hijacking my own thread!! I really am glad to read up on prong collars and why we are using them!!...I need to brush up on everything, and I will get right on it!...Then, six months will pass, and I'll need more reminders.
Also...It's precious that you have Gretchen's collar hanging up!! Really...very sweet and meaningful.
 
I'll just add my choker/prong 2 cents quickly lol :2cents:threadjacked:

My parents always and only used a choker. That's what I started with mischa once she was about 6 months old. Hated it. It was NOTHING like I remembered Gretchen being on leash! She didn't care, she pulled to the point of hacking and gagging herself. I know how to put it on properly (you can put it on "backwards" and it won't loosen when you release pressure like it should... can be very dangerous for a dog) but it just didn't seem to work well for us this time. After my research, and talking to @AresMyDobie I finally sacked it up and got the prong. I LOVE it. I love the fact it can only get so tight, whereas the choker can keep getting tighter and tighter and tighter to the point of literally choking the dog. I also learned here about the dangers of chokers and the possibility of trauma to the trachea. So, thanks to this forum, after 30 years, I switched from choker to prong and will never go back! I still have the choker, but it hangs on a hook, and only because it was Gretchen's collar. The prong you can just give a nice quick pop to get her attention, and I know I'm not risking any damage like you can with the choker getting too tight when you "pop" it.




I have a choke collar. It's never been on a neck. Drake had this horrible habit of biting his leash. I tried everything to stop it. One day I saw a choke collar at the store and enter great idea! I use the choke as an extension if his leash. He bit down on that metal exactly once. ;)
 
I posted that video just because I thought it was hilarious that I fell, but I definitely wish I hadn't!! I feel bad about the recall deal, and now I feel like a dumbass about the prong!!
The prong is and easy fix, but I'd just like you to know that reliable recall is (in my opinion) a very advanced level of training that requires the dog to block out distractions and focus strictly on the handler. Even then, a dog is never 100%. That's where the e-collar comes in as an "emergency brake". Jax is how old again? If I remember correctly, he's too young to really expect a solid recall from. Before Hans was e-collar trained, I'd take him to tennis courts and baseball fields for training sessions. We hiked too but only in areas where we wouldn't encounter any vehicles or other people with dogs. So please don't feel bad his recall. He's still immature and not trained yet. You (plural) will get there :)
 
If you get an e collar, get a dogtra model (I have the 2300 NPT two dog model). And then go to loucastle.com/recall and follow Lou's methods. Super simple, no pain involved for the dog, and I have a 7 year old mutt that is now perfect on loose leash and will come when I call her. My 7 month old dobe is great as well. She was trained by a trainer, and we don't even shock her -just the page function. Not sure how he got her trained to just the page, but I know when I have to shock her (on level 13 out of 127), it gets her moving quick.

The e collar is a great tool - just like most others like the prong and choke. Use them correctly, and you won't hurt anyone.

As an FYI, I've shocked myself with the dogtra on level 40. It's a lot like a tens unit used in physical therapy. Highest I've hit the dogs so far was 22 - there were rabbits involved, and their prey drive was kicking in. Kept them from chasing and they returned quickly.
 

Back
Top