• Disclaimer: Hello Guest, Doberman Chat Forums presents the opinions and material on these pages as a service to its membership and to the general public but does not endorse those materials, nor does it guarantee the accuracy of any opinions or information contained therein. The opinions expressed in the materials are strictly the opinion of the writer and do not represent the opinion of, nor are they endorsed by, Doberman Chat Forums. Health and medical articles are intended as an aid to those seeking health information and are not intended to replace the informed opinion of a qualified Veterinarian.”

His recall...my fear!!

bomary

Hot Topics Subscriber
I am scared to death of E collars...just like I was scared of ear posting...just like I was scared of a prong.
Well...Jax's recall is shitful (my word for pitiful!). I know he knows what I'm talking about, and it's fine on a long training lead, but without a lead, he just stares at me like, "You can't make me!" The last two days, he hasn't even wanted to come back in the house after playing, and in the past he has beaten (is that right??!!) me to the door. (I think this little deal has to do with the weather being nice and not blistering hot.)
Anyway, I sent a text to my trainer last night, and she said she can work with me using the collar. She said we can work with one that she has, and if it works for Jax she will order me the same one.
I know she will do a great job of assessing whether or not this is what we need at this time, but I just wanted to get your opinions. He's just a bit over 1 year, and I think he's pretty sensitive. I just get so scared of hurting him, but I am more scared of putting him in danger because of his recall (lack thereof). I had that bad dream and this is constantly on my mind. Right now, the only place he is off lead away from home is the baseball field.
Thoughts?
 
There is an ecollar made by Ecollar technologies that is a PAGER ONLY collar with NO stim, just different levels of vibration. If he is sensitive, then this may be all you need. I usually use vibrate (pager) or VERY low stim on my Ecollar Tech Mini Educator (lite version of working collar and it is more than enough for my dogs) on about 4-10 occasionally using boost in high drive like bite work. Usually the page will do, however. It's more on how you are taught to use it and how to communicate that this collar is a PROMPT not a punishment, that will ease your nerves as well as make for a happy obedient dog.

PG-300 Pager Only One Dog Communicator
 
Is your fear that you are going to hurt him with the collar? Understandable because the e collar can be your worst nightmare if not used correctly.
Deep breath and remember you have a trainer that will teach you what you need to know. IMHO, recall, and a couple of other commands (sit, down) are essential. Having the commands down solid can save your dogs life. Let's Jax got away from you, a solid recall is important because he could be headed for a dangerous place like the street. Maybe you didn't notice he wondered off. Now he is across the street and maybe calling him is not the best choice. Sit or down till you get to him would be very important.
I would rather my dog suffer, (and they don't really suffer), when you have to hit the button, but that couple of seconds of being, at best uncomfortable could save his life.
 
What Silent Dobe said.

I could only add to look around and see what's out there.
I'm sure the unit she linked is a good one.
We have a cheaper one my wife got from Amazon. It doesn't appear to be a high quality unit, but I've not used any other for direct comparison.
One thing I do like about our unit is its 3 function.
Obviously the "shock" feature. And yes it does! Ours has the ability to adjust the intensity of the shock. Even level one bit the shit out of me, I didn't want to find out what 100 was like but stepped it up to 40ish to make sure I was going the right way. Yup. Stronger bite.
So we leave it on one.

It has a vibrate feature that is also adjustable in intensity from 1-100. It works sometimes but..

The collar also has a tone feature. A simple beep that lasts 1.5-2.5 seconds. This is the feature I use the most often.
The vibrate is cool but with Rocky his movement and sometimes agitation with the fence leaves the vibrate ineffective at grabbing his attention. Same as my voice, sorta hard to hear me when he's barking his fool head off.
So the tone whispers in his ear so to speak and says "that dude that feeds you wants you to stop that, you should listen or at least shut up and look at him for what's next" . It's the most effective in the yard and so far off lead out there. He tends to ignore verbal off lead. The collar reminds him that while I can't run and catch him I can still reach out and touch him so to speak.

When looking at units pay attention to their effective range, that could be important.

And on topic I guess. I know I shared before but here it is again.
My friends out Denver way picked up a Rottweiler no one could train. My friend figured out quick he wasn't an ill minding dog or a deviant, he was just deaf. The E collar was instrumental in turning that dogs life around. They lived on a fenced acre, the vibrate feature of the collar made it so they could "call" him to look their way. From there sign and hand commands. He's an awesome dog today.
Don't be afraid of the collar. It's a tool, like any other tool if used properly is very helpful. If used improperly can be damaging.
 
The E collar fear is of hurting him, but I should add that I suspect I coddle my boy too much. He is my first "baby," and I worry about EVERY tiny thing.
I do agree, though, that recall is a must. Hell, I had a dream about his prong becoming disconnected while walking, and it put the fear of God in me.
I know that my trainer will show me exactly how to use the collar; it just makes me nervous because of the stories I've heard about it "ruining" dogs. However, I was also worried that I was cruel if I used a prong, and after being shown how to use it, I know that it is perfectly okay.
Since my first post, we have walked up to the baseball field. When I was ready to go, he wasn't. Every time I said "come," he looked at me and started my direction and then hauled ass. This lasted about 45 freaking minutes. Then, one of the grounds keepers came up on his gigantic mower. For an additional 30 minutes, he tried to help me. Meanwhile, I was texting my Mother (who works at the school) and her coworker (whose life revolves around dogs.) The guy finally asked if I thought Jax would come to me out of fear if he began to mow. I was desperate and said maybe we should give it a try. Well....Jax just ran along with the mower.
Finally, my Mom's coworker came up; I laid on the ground (she said it would probably work) in front of her, and it did work.
During all of this, I sustained a broken finger (got caught in collar) and a pretty big chip in a front tooth (butted heads.)
I've been disappointed, annoyed, etc. with him before, but NEVER like this, and this is brand new behavior. Ugh. (Of course I have never yelled or even lightly spanked him, but this seriously is the first time I've been completely aggravated and at my wit's end.
We did have a blast before all this happened, and after I get it uploaded, I am going to post a little video fail...I ended up on my ass!
 
Sounds like no more off lead time for Jax until you get this figured out. I would go back to basics. Put him on a leash and stay close, maybe 5 ft. or so. Call him. If he comes big reward....make that huge. As he gets it, move further away. Don't forget correction (given that he understands what you want) if he is not listening. He'll learn that coming when called us a good thing.

If he pulls the not coming stunt again, don't chase, try running away from him. I bet he will come then.:) It's usually a reason to like prey drive.
 
WARNING...this video contains foul language including "s**t" and GD (I know...I'm sorry, but I fell...face first...on rocks!)
When I say the "S word," I am already heading to the ground with no hope of catching myself!!
The one time I actually had my phone with me!
Y'all, I suck at adding photos, and this is my first video (on both you have to click to see them)...Anybody know what I'm doing wrong?
 
Sounds like no more off lead time for Jax until you get this figured out. I would go back to basics. Put him on a leash and stay close, maybe 5 ft. or so. Call him. If he comes big reward....make that huge. As he gets it, move further away. Don't forget correction (given that he understands what you want) if he is not listening. He'll learn that coming when called us a good thing.

If he pulls the not coming stunt again, don't chase, try running away from him. I bet he will come then.:) It's usually a reason to like prey drive.

Yeah, there will definitely be no baseball field for a while! Ugh. On a positive note, he is worn out and snoring on the couch!
 
Yeah, there will definitely be no baseball field for a while! Ugh. On a positive note, he is worn out and snoring on the couch!
Sooner you get back to working it the better I think.
And I agree with @GennyB about trying turning away/walking or running away. It may work. It worked for Daisy but not so much for Rocky.

I also believe that at his age part of this is his Doberteen phase. He's testing you. This is one if the most important times in his development where your leadership needs to be solid understood.Once it's established you'll find he will cooperate much better and will become again eager to learn rather than rebel.
 
The prong should be higher up on his neck, right behind the ears.
My previous Dobe came fron DRU at 1 1/2 years, timid, knew nothing. We did a lot of obedience training that he aced but I too got tried of the long lead while hiking. My trainer introduced us to the e-collar just for recall and it was a godsend. Ended up with a 100% reliable recall, even if we ran into deer. It also seemed to give him a real boost self confidence as well, sort of a "well, see what a good boy I am!"
But as others have said, a professional trainer should teach you how to use it, not youtube :-)4
 
The prong should be higher up on his neck, right behind the ears.
My previous Dobe came fron DRU at 1 1/2 years, timid, knew nothing. We did a lot of obedience training that he aced but I too got tried of the long lead while hiking. My trainer introduced us to the e-collar just for recall and it was a godsend. Ended up with a 100% reliable recall, even if we ran into deer. It also seemed to give him a real boost self confidence as well, sort of a "well, see what a good boy I am!"
But as others have said, a professional trainer should teach you how to use it, not youtube :)4

Thanks! I'll look into getting a trainer and stay off YouTube!!:thumbsup2:
 
OK, I didn't read all the responses but I will say a few things.

An adjustable ecollar that your trainer helps you adjust will not hurt him. It isn't like you're going to go to the strongest shock and zap him. You start at the lowest setting and then work your way up to where your dog is just uncomfortable from it.

I've used two, one beeped first, as a warning; the other just went right for a shock. The one I borrowed from my neighbor who uses it to "force fetch" his labs (which is sad and I don't like the practice). The other is one my parents own for their Dutch draught that gets a little too strong sometimes (that has the warning beep).

I've seen these collars being missused, but I do think they are very effective when used properly. Dogs are smart and know they're far enough away that you can't correct them. "A poor set of legs let a butt take a whopping". Lol

That all said, I only used my neighbors on my GSD because he loved playing with the chickens... And they died. He didn't try to kill them, he sat on them, ran circles, grabbed them, etc. I hit hin with the top setting while yelling NO, (he was a LONG way away). He jumped up 3 feet in the air, and took off for the back of the property. He never bothered a chicken for the next two years, and then he needed a refresher. That is extreme, but the chickens lives matter too.

Now, I once had a Brittany o worked obedience with. He had the worst off lead recall. We were at a class, out in the open, and he ran straight to me then swerved and bolted off into tinbuck two. We didn't have shock collars (or fancy fenced in facilities back then). He spent a ton of time on lead, with a longer and longer lead, and I did get him broke and his CD title without a shock collar.

Either way it can be done, I think the ecollar would be less labor intensive.
 
An adjustable ecollar that your trainer helps you adjust will not hurt him. It isn't like you're going to go to the strongest shock and zap him. You start at the lowest setting and then work your way up to where your dog is just uncomfortable from it.
That's exactly right. We start out at a low setting and just go high enough to get their attention and make them rethink not listening. Any modern collar will not let you zap them enough to physically hurt them and even if you use the continuous mode, it won't go for more than something like 3 or 5 seconds. We usually just have to use the "nick", which is just that, a momentary nick that lets them know you're there.

There were 2 times I hit Albert harder because he was bolting out to the road as a big piece of equipment was coming by. I figure that couple seconds of a zap is better than a dead dog hit by tons of speeding steel. He hasn't tried that little trick since then because he associates going that far down the driveway with a little unpleasantness.
After losing Boris when he bolted down the driveway and was killed instantly by a car, I'm not going to take any chances again.
 
The E collar fear is of hurting him, but I should add that I suspect I coddle my boy too much. He is my first "baby," and I worry about EVERY tiny thing.
I do agree, though, that recall is a must. Hell, I had a dream about his prong becoming disconnected while walking, and it put the fear of God in me.
I know that my trainer will show me exactly how to use the collar; it just makes me nervous because of the stories I've heard about it "ruining" dogs. However, I was also worried that I was cruel if I used a prong, and after being shown how to use it, I know that it is perfectly okay.
Since my first post, we have walked up to the baseball field. When I was ready to go, he wasn't. Every time I said "come," he looked at me and started my direction and then hauled ass. This lasted about 45 freaking minutes. Then, one of the grounds keepers came up on his gigantic mower. For an additional 30 minutes, he tried to help me. Meanwhile, I was texting my Mother (who works at the school) and her coworker (whose life revolves around dogs.) The guy finally asked if I thought Jax would come to me out of fear if he began to mow. I was desperate and said maybe we should give it a try. Well....Jax just ran along with the mower.
Finally, my Mom's coworker came up; I laid on the ground (she said it would probably work) in front of her, and it did work.
During all of this, I sustained a broken finger (got caught in collar) and a pretty big chip in a front tooth (butted heads.)
I've been disappointed, annoyed, etc. with him before, but NEVER like this, and this is brand new behavior. Ugh. (Of course I have never yelled or even lightly spanked him, but this seriously is the first time I've been completely aggravated and at my wit's end.
We did have a blast before all this happened, and after I get it uploaded, I am going to post a little video fail...I ended up on my ass!
How frustrating! He's obviously not ready for that sort of freedom. And don't worry about causing him pain with an e-collar. The level of stim needed is really low. My e-collar goes from 0-129, and Han's working level is 60 on nick only. He never gets continuous stim. I've shocked myself on the highest level on my palm, and while it's unpleasant, I wouldn't call it painful. The e-collar is a great tool when it is introduced to the dog properly. By properly, I mean in a way that makes the dog realize that it is just like any other correction and that not complying is not an option- a way that turns the e-collar into an invisible leash.
 
That's exactly right. We start out at a low setting and just go high enough to get their attention and make them rethink not listening. Any modern collar will not let you zap them enough to physically hurt them and even if you use the continuous mode, it won't go for more than something like 3 or 5 seconds. We usually just have to use the "nick", which is just that, a momentary nick that lets them know you're there.

There were 2 times I hit Albert harder because he was bolting out to the road as a big piece of equipment was coming by. I figure that couple seconds of a zap is better than a dead dog hit by tons of speeding steel. He hasn't tried that little trick since then because he associates going that far down the driveway with a little unpleasantness.
After losing Boris when he bolted down the driveway and was killed instantly by a car, I'm not going to take any chances again.

Good Lord, Jan, I had no idea that was how Boris was taken from you. I am so sorry (I know it's a long while ago, but it still just gave me chills and broke my heart.)
That is exactly how I feel about not taking chances (If we could, Jax and I would live in a bubble!) Lately, I've been overly worried when we walk (I know...he realizes that, and this recent worry was freaking brought on by a dang dream!), and we are waiting for his fur saver to get here to use with his prong. I hate how "paranoid" I am, but I just can't imagine if something happened as a result of my lack of knowledge or caution.
This behavior just truly is BRAND NEW (started two days ago), and I am flipping out. I've cried off and on today since we got home...I feel like a total jackass and I'm honestly embarrassed (I hesitated to even post this); I feel like I'm doing everything wrong. DANG.
We are going to work with our trainer tomorrow. (She is getting up early for us because she has to get to a horse event). She knows how I am, and I am sure she will put my mind at ease and get us on the right track.
It also makes me sad because going to the baseball field is one of his favorite things to do.
 
I hate how "paranoid" I am, but I just can't imagine if something happened as a result of my lack of knowledge or caution.
This behavior just truly is BRAND NEW (started two days ago), and I am flipping out. I've cried off and on today since we got home...I feel like a total jackass and I'm honestly embarrassed (I hesitated to even post this); I feel like I'm doing everything wrong. DANG.
No you are doing things right and you just want the best for him. Don't ever feel embarrassed for caring about your baby.
 
I'll just agree with what most everyone else has already said. Many ecollars have different settings for 1) sound 2) vibrate and 3) muscle stimulation (TS). The TS is the same thing a chiropractor sometimes uses for muscle stimulation around the spine. When set at the correct level it doesn't hurt at all. It is uncomfortable but there's no pain. I remember my leg flopping around when I wasn't moving it at the chiropractor. Very strange and uncomfortable feeling but it didn't hurt.

I had a professional trainer train him (and me) on the ecollar. I very seldom need to use it anymore. We hike for a couple of hours every day for 5-10 miles. He's off lead for much of it. There's wildlife all over and their droppings. Sometimes I still have to use the vibrate when he's about to eat some droppings. Along part of our hike there's barbed wire running along side the path just a few feet away. Just a day or two ago Drogon nearly went into the barbed wire but I hit the TS button and he stopped in his tracks, turned and came running to me. Sure he was uncomfortable for a second or two but much better than him accidentally jumping onto rusty barbed wire.

I also agree that your prong collar is too low. Drogon's slips down as well but I have to adjust it back to the top if I want to give him a proper correction. It should ride just under his ears and 'chin'.
 
This is SOOO stupid, but sometimes I let what strangers in public say get to me...the stupid PetSmart trainer started my doubts about the prong, and then just random people tell me how "cruel" it is. I have a hard time keeping it where it needs to be regardless, and I do often stop and move it up, but...sometimes people say, "That collar is too small," or "Why do you have that so tight/high?," and I start second-guessing myself. My trainer tells me all the time where it needs to be and shows me, etc. Intellectually I know it, and I totally trust her, but...for whatever reason, I let JQP make me doubt my judgment. Screw'em!...I'm getting it where I know it needs to be, and I know it will be more effective.
I posted that video just because I thought it was hilarious that I fell, but I definitely wish I hadn't!! I feel bad about the recall deal, and now I feel like a dumbass about the prong!!
I have a Keeper Collar that would help me avoid the jackass comments about my "cruelty," but I think I ordered the wrong leash attachment. I need to take a close up pic of it so y'all can tell me what the hell it is and how I need to get it fixed. They seem like a great company, and the woman in charge even sent a note in the mail thanking me for ordering it and telling me to call if I had questions. I just don't really know what my question is!! You guys, I know I sound like an idiot sometimes, but I really do want to get everything "right."
Thanks so much for all the help!
Jax likely appreciates it more than I do!!...poor guy!
 

Back
Top